ABSTRACT

This volume of primary source material examine the thoughts and ideas behind music in Britian during the ninteenth century. Sources explore music critics, listening to music, music education, and philosophy. The collection of materials are accompanied by an introduction by Rosemary Golding, as well as headnotes contextualising the pieces. This collection will be of great value to students and scholars.

chapter |24 pages

Introduction

part 1|139 pages

Music Criticism

chapter 1|11 pages

Anon. [Richard Mackenzie Bacon], ‘Plan of the Work’ and ‘First Lines of Vocal Criticism’

In The Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review vol. 1 no. 1 (January 1818), pp. 1–10 and 72–75

chapter 2|6 pages

Adelos, ‘Amateur Criticism’

In The Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review vol. 6 no. 22 (April 1824), pp. 171–177

chapter 3|14 pages

Charles Kensington Salaman, ‘On Musical Criticism’

In Proceedings of the Musical Association 2nd session (1875–1876), pp. 1–15

chapter 4|15 pages

Edmund Gurney, ‘Musical Criticism’

In The Power of Sound (London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1880), Chapter 23 pp. 524–539

chapter 5|16 pages

John Stainer, ‘The Principles of Musical Criticism’

In Proceedings of the Royal Musical Association 7th session (1880–1881), pp. 35–52

chapter 6|12 pages

Frederick J. Crowest, ‘Musical Criticism’

In Phases of Musical England (London: Remington, 1881), Chapter 1 pp. 1–30

chapter 7|6 pages

C.V. Stanford, ‘Some Aspects of Musical Criticism in England’

In Fortnightly Review vol. 55 no. 330 (June 1894), pp. 826–831

chapter 8|27 pages

John F. Runciman, ‘Musical Criticism and the Critics’, and ‘The Gentle Art of Musical Criticism’

In The Fortnightly Review vol. 56 no. 332 (August 1894), pp. 170–183; and The New Review vol. 12 (1895), pp. 612–624

chapter 9|9 pages

Ernest Newman, ‘Introduction’ in Gluck and the Opera: A Study in Musical History

(London: Bertram Dobell, 1895), pp. 1–15

chapter 10|6 pages

Edward Baughan, ‘The Futility of Criticism’

In Monthly Musical Record vol. 27 no. 323 (November 1897), pp. 241–243

chapter 11|7 pages

Hermann Klein, Thirty Years of Musical Life in London, 1870–1900

(New York: Century, 1903), Chapter 3 pp. 42–58

chapter 12|8 pages

Henry Davison, Music during the Victorian Era. From Mendelssohn to Wagner: Memoirs of J.W. Davison

(London: Reeves, 1912), Chapter 6 pp. 68–76

part 2|92 pages

Listening to Music

chapter 13|12 pages

W.H. [William Henry], ‘Cursory Remarks on Music, Especially on the Sources of the Pleasure Which It Communicates’

In Edinburgh Monthly Magazine vol. 1 no. 4 (July–August 1817), pp. 343–347 and 459–462

chapter 14|5 pages

William Crotch, ‘On the Present State of the Public Taste of this Nation’

In Substance of Several Courses of Lectures on Music (London, Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, and Green, 1831), Chapter 6 pp. 148–158

chapter 15|6 pages

William Gardiner, ‘On the Faculties of the Ear’

In The Music of Nature (London: Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green, and Longman, 1832), Chapter 1 pp. 2–11

chapter 16|3 pages

Charles H. Purday, ‘Letter to the Editor’

In The Musical World vol. 3 no. 38 (2 December 1836), p. 191

chapter 17|4 pages

Vernon, ‘The Influence of Music on the Public’

In The Musical Times and Singing Class Circular vol. 5 no. 100 (1 September 1852), pp. 59–60

chapter 18|9 pages

M. [J.B. Macdonnell], ‘Classical Music and British Musical Taste’

In Macmillan's Magazine vol. 1 no. 5 (March 1860), pp. 383–389

chapter 19|5 pages

H.R. Haweis, ‘The Listener’ And ‘Planes of Emotion’

In Music and Morals (London: Strahan & Co., 1871), Chapter 8 pp. 94–97 and 97–100

chapter 20|8 pages

Edmund Gurney, ‘The Two Ways of Hearing Music’

In The Power of Sound (London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1880), Chapter 13 pp. 104–111

chapter 21|9 pages

John Stainer, Music in Its Relation to the Intellect and the Emotions

(London: Novello & Co., 1892), pp. 49–64

chapter 22|12 pages

W.H. Hadow, ‘Faculties of Appreciation’

In Studies in Modern Music 2nd series (London: Seeley and Co., 1895), Chapter 1 pp. 3–25

chapter 23|17 pages

H. Hayes Newington, ‘Some Mental Aspects of Music’

In Journal of Mental Science vol. 43 no. 183 (October 1897), pp. 704–723

part 3|110 pages

Music Education

chapter 24|5 pages

Anne Gunn, ‘Preface’ in An Introduction to Music

(Edinburgh: C. Stewart & Co, 1803), pp. i–xiii

chapter 25|6 pages

Vetus [Richard Mackenzie Bacon], ‘On the Objects of Musical Education’

In The Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review vol. 1 no. 4 (October 1818), pp. 421–428

chapter 26|5 pages

F.W.H. [F.W. Horncastle], ‘Plan for the Formation of an English Conservatorio’

In The Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review vol. 4 no. 14 (April 1822), pp. 129–133

chapter 27|4 pages

Anon., ‘Musical Tuition’

Letter to the Editor from the Father of a Family in The Quarterly Musical Magazine and Review vol. 6 no. 23 (1824), pp. 306–309

chapter 28|6 pages

Eleanor Geary, Musical Education; with Practical Observations on the Art of Piano-Forte Playing

(London: D'Almaine & Co., 1841), First Part pp. 5–17

chapter 29|9 pages

Olivia Dussek Buckley, Musical Truths; or, an Analysis of Music

(London: published for the author, 1843), pp. 13–30

chapter 30|8 pages

Joseph Mainzer, Music and Education

(London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, 1848), Chapter 10 pp. 88–96

chapter 31|14 pages

John Hullah, Music as an Element of Education

(London: John W. Parker and Son, 1854), pp. 3–30

chapter 33|8 pages

John Evans and W.G. McNaught, ‘Order and Manner of Teaching’

In The School Music Teacher (London: J. Curwen & Sons, 1888), Chapter 9 pp. 255–268

chapter 34|7 pages

Bettina Walker, My Musical Experiences

(London: Richard Bentley and Son, 1890), pp. 15–31

chapter 35|5 pages

C.F. Abdy Williams, ‘Development of the Modern Requirements for Musical Degrees’

In A Short Historical Account of the Degrees in Music at Oxford and Cambridge (London and New York: Novello, Ewer & Co., 1893), Chapter 6 pp. 40–44

chapter 36|5 pages

Anon., ‘Mr. J. Spencer Curwen on the Tonic Sol-Fa Notation’

In Strand Musical Magazine vol. 1 no. 4 (April 1895), pp. 254–255

chapter 37|10 pages

Charles Hallé, ‘The Royal Manchester College of Music’

In Strand Musical Magazine vol. 1 no. 5 (May 1895), pp. 323–329

part 4|132 pages

Theory and Philosophy

chapter 38|8 pages

George Farquhar Graham, ‘Essay’ in An Account of the First Edinburgh Musical Festival

(Edinburgh: James Ballantyne & Co., 1816), pp. 139–142, 147–162

chapter 39|6 pages

William Kitchiner, Observations on Vocal Music

(London: Hurst, Robinson & Co., and Edinburgh: Archibald Constable & Co., 1821), pp. 1–17

chapter 40|12 pages

Anon. [Elizabeth Eastlake], ‘Music’

In The Quarterly Review vol. 83 no. 166 (August 1848), pp. 481–486, 509–515

chapter 41|17 pages

H.S. [Herbert Spencer], ‘The Origin and Function of Music’

In Fraser's Magazine (1857), pp. 396–408

chapter 42|10 pages

Henry Wylde, ‘Music in Its Art-Mission’

In Music in Its Art-Mysteries (London: L. Booth, 1867), Chapter 8 pp. 105–124

chapter 43|6 pages

Henry C. Lunn, ‘Descriptive Music’

In The Musical Times and Singing Class Circular vol. 13 no. 310 (1 December 1868), pp. 599–601

chapter 44|23 pages

Edmund Gurney, ‘On Some Disputed Points in Music’

In Fortnightly Review vol. 20 no. 115 (July 1876), pp. 106–130

chapter 45|11 pages

H.R. Haweis, ‘The Rationale of Music’

In My Musical Life (London: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1884), Book 2 Part 2 pp. 136–159

chapter 46|14 pages

Richard Wallaschek and James McKeen Cattell, ‘On the Origin of Music’

In Mind vol. 16 no. 63 (July 1891), pp. 375–388

chapter 47|10 pages

C. Hubert H. Parry, ‘Preliminaries’ in The Art of Music

(London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner & Co., 1893), Chapter 1 pp. 1–15

chapter 48|10 pages

Ebenezer Prout, ‘The Relation of Musical Theory to Practice’

In The Monthly Musical Record vol. 25 no. 292 (1 April 1895), pp. 73–77

chapter 49|3 pages

Samuel Coleridge Taylor, ‘On Music’

Address to students at Streatham School of Music (November 1905), reprinted in Berwick Sayers, Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, Musician: His Life & Letters (London 1915), pp. 177–179