ABSTRACT

Following Freud's death in 1939, the radical theories of Melanie Klein were the subject of prolonged controversy and fierce debate within the British Psychoanalytical Society. At the time, individuals fought passionately in support of their positions.

In the midst of, or as a result of, the personal animosities and political manoeuvrings, important intellectual contributions were made, and practical decisions taken, which were to affect the development of psychoanalysis down to the present day.

The Freud-Klein Controversies 1941-45 offers the first complete record of the debate, including all relevant papers and correspondence, based on previously closed archive material which is presented without censorship.

chapter |5 pages

Introduction

part Section One|164 pages

The evolution of controversies in the British Psycho-Analytical Society

part Section Two|274 pages

First Series of Scientific Discussions on Controversial Issues

part Section Three|70 pages

Scientific Controversies and the Training of Candidates

chapter 1|4 pages

Introductory Memorandum by Edward Glover

Chairman of the Training Committee—September 21st, 19421

chapter 2|6 pages

Discussion Memorandum by James Strachey

Member of the Training Committee—February 24th, 1943

chapter 4|9 pages

Memorandum on her technique by Marjorie Brierley

Memo on valid technique for the Training Committee, October 25th, 1943

chapter 5|5 pages

Memorandum by Anna Freud

Statement for the Training Committee dated 29th September 1943, concerning the bearing of the present controversies on the training of Candidates by Anna Freud

chapter 6|3 pages

Memorandum on her technique by Melanie Klein

Melanie Klein—25th October 1943

chapter 7|7 pages

Memorandum on her technique by Ella Freeman Sharpe

Concerning the problem of technique and training by Ella Freeman Sharpe (November 24th 1943)

chapter 8|4 pages

Memorandum on her technique by Sylvia M.Payne

Contribution todiscussion on the fundamentals of techniqueby S.M.Payne (24th November 1943)

chapter 9|6 pages

Draft Report of the Training Committee

Draft report of the Training Committee uponthe effects of current Scientific Controversieson the training of Candidates1

chapter 10|6 pages

Repercussions of the Draft Report of the Training Committee

Comments from Edward Glover and other members of the Training Committee of the draft report on training in the Society

chapter 11|8 pages

Final Report of the Training Committee

The effects of current Scientific Controversies on the Training of Candidates

part Section Four|121 pages

Second Series of Scientific Discussions on Controversial Issues

chapter |2 pages

Editorial comments

chapter 3|17 pages

Eighth Discussion of Scientific Differences

Discussion held on February 16th, 1944—condusion of discussion on Dr P.Heimann's and Dr S.Isaacs' paper on ‘Regression'