ABSTRACT

The Critical Heritage gathers together a large body of critical sources on major figures in literature. Each volume presents contemporary responses to a writer's work, enabling students and researchers to read for themselves, for example, comments on early performances of Shakespeare's plays, or reactions to the first publication of Jane Austen's novels.
The carefully selected sources range from landmark essays in the history of criticism to journalism and contemporary opinion, and little published documentary material such as letters and diaries. Significant pieces of criticism from later periods are also included, in order to demonstrate the fluctuations in an author's reputation.
Each volume contains an introduction to the writer's published works, a selected bibliography, and an index of works, authors and subjects.
The Collected Critical Heritage set will be available as a set of 68 volumes and the series will also be available in mini sets selected by period (in slipcase boxes) and as individual volumes.

chapter |20 pages

Introduction

part |72 pages

The Early Works from Pickwick to Nickleby

chapter |1 pages

From an unsigned review of Sketches by Boz, Metropolitan Magazine

March 1836, xv, 77

chapter |2 pages

From unsigned reviews of Pickwick Papers, Metropolitan Magazine

May 1836 – May 1837

chapter |1 pages

Unsigned review of Pickwick Papers Nos. I – IX, the Athenaeum

3 December 1836, 841–3

chapter |1 pages

Miss Mary Russell Mitford on Pickwick Papers

1837

chapter |1 pages

W. M. Thackeray on Pickwick Papers, in The Paris Sketch Book

1840 (Works, Biographical Edition (1898–9), v, 80)

chapter |2 pages

C. S. Calverley, from ‘An Examination Paper: The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club'

Fly Leaves (Cambridge, 1872), 121–4

chapter |1 pages

‘[Arthur Locker?]' from ‘Charles Dickens' Graphic

18 June 1870, 687

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of Oliver Twist in the Spectator

24 November 1838, xi, 1114–6

chapter |1 pages

Queen Victoria, from her diaries

1838–9

chapter |2 pages

[W. M. Thackeray], from ‘Going to see a man hanged', Fraser's Magazine

August 1840, xxii, 154–5 (Works, iii, 436–7)

chapter |1 pages

From an unsigned article, ‘Literary Recipes', Punch

7 August 1841, i, 39

chapter |4 pages

[John Forster], from an unsigned review of Nicholas Nickleby, Examiner

27 October 1839, 677–8

chapter |3 pages

[Charles Buller], from ‘The Works of Dickens', London and Westminster Review

July 1837, xxix, 194–215

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, ‘Boz and his Nicholas Nickleby', Spectator

31 March 1838, xi, 304

chapter |1 pages

Unsigned notice, ‘Loose Thoughts', Fraser's Magazine

October 1838, xviii, 500

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of Oliver Twist, Literary Gazette

24 November 1838, 741

chapter |5 pages

[Richard Ford], from, an unsigned review, Quarterly Review

June 1839, lxiv, 83–102

chapter |4 pages

From an unsigned notice, ‘Charles Dickens and his Works,' Fraser's Magazine

April 1840, xxi, 381–400

part |28 pages

Master Humphrey's Clock

chapter |2 pages

John Ruskin on The Old Curiosity Shop

1841, 1883

chapter |2 pages

[Thomas Hood], from a review of Barnaby Rudge, Athenaeum

22 January 1842, 77–9

chapter |6 pages

Edgar Allan Poe, from a review in Graham's Magazine

February 1842, xix, 124–9

chapter |3 pages

Dickens's Reception in America

1842

part |26 pages

American Notes and Pictures from Italy

chapter |3 pages

[Samuel Warren], from a review in Blackwood's Magazine

December 1842, lii, 783–801

chapter |5 pages

[James Spedding], from a review in the Edinburgh Review

January 1843, lxxxvi, 497–522

chapter |5 pages

[Cornelius C. Felton], from a review in the North American Review

January 1843, lvi, 212–37

chapter |3 pages

[John Wilson Croker], from an unsigned review, Quarterly Review

March 1843, lxxi, 502–28

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of Pictures from Italy, The Times

1 June 1846

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Gentleman's Magazine

July 1846, n.s. xxvi, 3–21

part |42 pages

The Christmas Books

chapter |2 pages

Lord Jeffrey on A Christmas Carol, in a letter to Dickens

26 December 1843

chapter |2 pages

[W. M. Thackeray], from ‘A Box of Novels', Fraser's Magazine

February 1844, xxix, 166–9

chapter |3 pages

From a review of R. H. Horne's A New Spirit of the Age, Westminster Review

June 1844, xliv, 374–7

chapter |1 pages

From an unsigned review of The Chimes, The Mirror of Literature, Amusement, and Instruction

21 December 1844, n.s. vi, 401–3

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of The Chimes, The Times

25 December 1844, 6

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review of The Chimes, Christian Remembrancer

January 1845, ix, 301–4

chapter |2 pages

[John Forster], from a review of The Chimes, Edinburgh Review

January 1845, lxxxi, 181–9

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review of The Chimes, the Economist

18 January 1845, 53—4

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned article, ‘Boz versus Dickens', Parker's London Magazine

February 1845, i, 122–8

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of The Cricket on the Hearth, Chambers's Edinburgh Journal

17 January 1846, n.s. v, 44–8

chapter |1 pages

From an unsigned review of The Battle of Life, Tait's Edinburgh Magazine

January 1847, xiv, 55–60

part |28 pages

Martin Chuzzlewit

chapter |2 pages

[John Forster], from an unsigned review, Examiner

26 October 1844, 675–7

chapter |5 pages

From an unsigned article, National Review

July 1861, xiii, 134–50

chapter |4 pages

R. H. Horne, from his The New Spirit of the Age

1844, i, 1–76

chapter |2 pages

Thomas Carlyle on Dickens

1844, 1856, 1870, 1880

chapter |2 pages

William Howitt, from ‘Charles Dickens', The People's Journal

3 June 1846, i, 8–12

chapter |4 pages

[W. E. Aytoun], from ‘Advice to an Intending Serialist', Blackwood's Magazine

November 1846, lx, 590–605

part |31 pages

Dombey and Son

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of No. I, the Economist

10 October 1846, 1324–5

chapter |3 pages

Lord Jeffrey, from letters to Dickens

1846–7

chapter |2 pages

From a review (signed ‘H') of Nos. I–VI, Westminster Review

April 1847, xlvii, 5–11

chapter |3 pages

[Charles Kent], from a review in the Sun

13 April 1848

chapter |2 pages

[John Forster], from an unsigned review, Examiner

28 October 1848, 692–3

chapter |2 pages

Harriet Martineau on Dickens

1849, 1855

part |32 pages

David Copperfield

chapter |4 pages

From an unsigned article, ‘Charles Dickens and David Copperfield', Fraser's Magazine

December 1850, xlii, 698–710

chapter |1 pages

Thackeray, in a letter to David Masson.

6(?) May 1851

chapter |3 pages

Matthew Arnold, from ‘The Incompatibles', Nineteenth Century

June 1881, ix, 1034–42

chapter |2 pages

From Thomas Powell, Pictures of the Living Authors of Britain

1851, 175–82

part |34 pages

Bleak House

chapter |1 pages

Henry Crabb Robinson, in his diaries

1852

chapter |2 pages

G. H. Lewes, from an open letter in the Leader

5 February 1853, 137–8

chapter |3 pages

[Henry Fothergill Chorley], from a review in the Athenaeum

17 September 1853, 1087–8

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review, Illustrated London News

24 September 1853, 247

chapter |3 pages

George Brimley, from an unsigned review, Spectator

24 September 1853, xxvi, 923–5

chapter |3 pages

Unsigned review, Bentley's Miscellany

October 1853, xxxiv, 372–4

chapter |3 pages

[John Forster ], from an unsigned review, Examiner

8 October 1853, 643–5

chapter |3 pages

[James Augustine Stothert ], from ‘Living Novelists', The Rambler

January 1854, n.s. i, 41–51

chapter |1 pages

John Stuart Mill, from a letter to Harriet Taylor

20 March 1854

part |52 pages

Hard Times

chapter |2 pages

[John Forster], from an unsigned review, the Examiner

9 September 1854, 568–9

chapter |1 pages

[Richard Simpson], from a review in The Rambler

October 1854, n.s. ii, 361–2

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review, Westminster Review

October 1854, n.s. vi, 604–8

chapter |4 pages

From ‘Hard Times (Refinished)', Our Miscellany

(New edn., 1857), 142–56

chapter |1 pages

John Ruskin, in Unto this Last, Cornhill Magazine

August 1860, ii, 159

chapter |5 pages

Edwin P. Whipple, from an essay on Hard Times, in the Atlantic Monthly

March 1877, xxxix, 353–58

chapter |8 pages

Mrs Oliphant, from ‘Charles Dickens', Blackwood's Magazine

April 1855, lxxvii, 451–66

chapter |5 pages

Hippolyte Taine, from his ‘Charles Dickens: son talent et ses œuvres,' Revue des deux Mondes

1 February 1856, 2nde période, i, 618–47

chapter |5 pages

[James Fitzjames Stephen], from ‘Mr Dickens as a Politician', Saturday Review

3 January 1857, iii, 8–9

chapter |2 pages

[William Forsyth], from ‘Literary Style,' Fraser's Magazine

March 1857, lv, 260–3

chapter |2 pages

W. M. Thackeray, from his ‘Charity and Humour'

Works, vii, 724–5

part |45 pages

Little Dorrit

chapter |4 pages

[E. B. Hamley], from ‘Remonstrance with Dickens', Blackwood's Magazine

April 1857, lxxxi, 490–503

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review, the Leader.

27 June 1857, 616–7

chapter |1 pages

Matthew Davenport Hill on Stephen's review

14 August 1857

chapter |3 pages

John Hollingshead, from ‘Mr Dickens and his Critics', The Train

August 1857, iv, 76–9

chapter |4 pages

John Cordy Jeaffreson, from his Novels and Novelists, from Elizabeth to Victoria

1858, ii, 273–4, 318–30

chapter |3 pages

Francis Jacox attacks the Saturday Review, New Monthly Magazine

June 1864, cxxxi, 168–77

chapter |9 pages

[Walter Bagehot], from ‘Charles Dickens', National Review

October 1858, vii, 458–86

part |20 pages

The Weekly Periodicals

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review of A House to Let, Saturday Review

25 December 1858, vi, 644

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of Mrs Lirriper's Lodgings, Saturday Review

12 December 1863, xvi, 759–60

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review of Doctor Marigold's Prescriptions, Saturday Review

16 December 1865, xx, 763–4

chapter |2 pages

[Charles Kent], from an unsigned review of Mugby Junction, Sun

7 December 1866

part |6 pages

A Tale of Two Cities

chapter |2 pages

Dickens on A Tale of Two Cities

1859–60

chapter |2 pages

[John Forster], from an unsigned review, Examiner

10 December 1859, 788–9

part |24 pages

Great Expectations

chapter |2 pages

[Edwin P. Whipple], from a review, Atlantic Monthly

September 1861, viii, 380–2

chapter |3 pages

[E. S. Dallas], from an unsigned review, The Times

17 October 1861, 6

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Dublin University Magazine

December 1861, lviii, 685–93

chapter |2 pages

[John Moore Capes and J. E. E. D. Acton], from a review in the Rambler

January 1862, n.s. vi, 274–6

chapter |3 pages

[Mrs Margaret Oliphant], from ‘Sensational Novels', Blackwood's Magazine

May 1862, xci, 574–80

chapter |2 pages

John Ruskin on Dickens

1863, 1870, 1886

chapter |6 pages

[Justin McCarthy], from ‘Modern Novelists: Charles Dickens', Westminster Review

October 1864, n.s. xxvi, 414–41

part |45 pages

Our Mutual Friend

chapter |4 pages

From an unsigned review, London Review

28 October 1865, 467–8

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review, Saturday Review

11 November 1865, xx, 612–3

chapter |4 pages

[E. S. Dallas], from an unsigned review, The Times

29 November 1865, 6

chapter |4 pages

[Henry James], review in The Nation (New York)

21 December 1865, 786–7

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned review, Westminster Review

April 1866, n.s. xxix, 582–5

chapter |2 pages

James Hannay, from his Course of English Literature

1866, 321–3

chapter |7 pages

[Edwin P. Whipple], from ‘The Genius of Dickens', Atlantic Monthly

May 1867, xix, 546–54

chapter |2 pages

‘Mr Dickens's Moral Services to Literature', Spectator

17 April 1869, xlii, 474–5

chapter |7 pages

George Stott, from ‘Charles Dickens', Contemporary Review

January 1869, x, 203–25

part |42 pages

Obituary Tributes, 1870

chapter |3 pages

Thomas Chenery, leading article in The Times

10 June 1870, 9

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned article, ‘The Death of Mr Dickens', Saturday Review

11 June 1870, xxix, 760–1

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned leading-article, Sunday Times

12 June 1870

chapter |1 pages

Unsigned notice, ‘Charles Dickens', British Medical Journal

18 June 1870, i, 636

chapter |4 pages

[R. H. Hutton], from ‘The Genius of Dickens', the Spectator

18 June 1870, xliii, 749–51

chapter |2 pages

A. P. Stanley, from a sermon in Westminster Abbey

19 June 1870 (Sermons on Special Occasions (1882) 127–37)

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned notice, ‘Charles Dickens', Fraser's Magazine

July 1870, n.s. ii, 130–4

chapter |3 pages

Arthur Helps, from ‘In Memoriam', Macmillan's Magazine

July 1870, xxii, 236–40

chapter |3 pages

Alfred Austin, ‘Charles Dickens', Temple Bar

July 1870, xxix, 554–62

chapter |4 pages

A. W. Ward, from Charles Dickens: a Lecture

30 November 1870

part |23 pages

Edwin Drood

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Saturday Review

17 September 1870, xxx, 369

chapter |2 pages

‘H. Lawrenny' [Edith Simcox], from a review in the Academy

22 October 1870, ii, 1–3

chapter |3 pages

An unsigned review in the Spectator

1 October 1870, xliii, 1176–7

chapter |3 pages

From an unsigned article, ‘Dickens', London Quarterly Review

January 1871, xxxv, 265–86

chapter |5 pages

[Mrs Oliphant], from ‘Charles Dickens', Blackwood's Magazine

June 1871, cix, 673–95

part |26 pages

Forster's Life of Dickens

chapter |1 pages

Thomas Carlyle on the Life

1871, 1874

chapter |1 pages

Lord Shaftesbury on Dickens

1871

chapter |7 pages

G. H. Lewes, from a review of Vol. I of Forster's Life, Fortnightly Review

February 1872, xvii, 141–54

chapter |2 pages

[William Dean Howells], from an unsigned review of Vol. II, Atlantic Monthly

February 1873, xxxi, 238–9

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Temple Bar

May 1873, xxxviii, 169–85

chapter |3 pages

[R. H. Hutton], from a review of Vol. III of Forster's Life, the Spectator

7 February 1874, xlvii, 174–6

chapter |2 pages

Wilkie Collins, marginalia in the Life

Pall Mall Gazette, 20 January 1890, 3

part |23 pages

The Letters of Charles Dickens

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Spectator

29 November 1879, lii, 1506–8

chapter |3 pages

‘Matthew Browne' [W. B. Rands], from a review in Contemporary Review

January 1880, xxxvii, 77–85

chapter |2 pages

From an unsigned review, Dublin Review

April 1880, 3rd. series, iii, 409–38

chapter |10 pages

Mowbray Morris, from ‘Charles Dickens', Fortnightly Review

1 December 1882, n.s. xxxii, 762–79