ABSTRACT

This volume explores the possibilities of cognate music theory, a concept introduced by musicologist John Walter Hill to describe culturally and historically situated music theory.

Cognate music theories offer a new way of thinking about music theory, music history, and the relationship between insider and outsider perspectives when researchers mediate between their own historical and cultural position, and that of the originators of the music they are studying. With contributions from noted scholars of musicology, music theory, and ethnomusicology, this volume develops a variety of approaches using the cognate music theory framework and shows how this concept enables more nuanced and critical analyses of music in historical context.

Addressing topics in music from the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries, this volume will be relevant to musicologists, music theorists, and all researchers interested in reflecting critically on what it means to construct a theory of music.

Chapter 9 of this book is freely available as a downloadable Open Access PDF at https://www.taylorfrancis.com under a Creative Commons [Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (CC-BY-NC-ND)] 4.0 license.

chapter 1|14 pages

Musicology beyond historicism

Epistemological implications and scope of John Walter Hill's cognate music theory

part I|31 pages

Framing concepts

chapter 2|19 pages

Cognate music theory

chapter 3|10 pages

Insiders and outsiders

Revisiting Indigenous musical thought

part IV|63 pages

Timbre, color, and temperament

chapter 10|24 pages

“Quegli strumenti, che erano più atti a far proporzionata accompagnatura al balletto a cavallo”

Envisioning a cognate theory of instrumental timbre in early modern Florence 1

chapter 11|16 pages

“Énergie des modes”

Tuning and temperament in seventeenth-century France

chapter 12|21 pages

“Il cembalo de' colori, e la musica degli occhi”

Francesco Algarotti and a cognate concept of music in the age of the Enlightenment *