ABSTRACT

Contrary to the common belief that peace and democracy go hand in hand after a civil war, Pereira Watts argues they are, in fact, at a crossroads.

Offering an innovative framework based on Philosophical, Actors, and Tactical considerations, Pereira Watts identifies 14 dynamic dilemmas in democratic peacebuilding, with respective trade-offs. She focuses on explaining the contradictions in modern post-conflict recovery, the challenges facing interim governments, and the international community’s role. Based on an analysis of more than 40 countries between 1989 and 2022 and more than 60 UN peace operations, she presents critical issues that commonly need to be addressed in such scenarios: Elections and Political Parties; the Constitution; Checks, Balances and Power-sharing; Transitional Justice; Human Rights, Amnesty, Truth Commissions and War Crimes Tribunals; Disarmament, Demobilization, and Reintegration; and Media Reform and Civil Society. Solving any of these dilemmas leads to others that shape a complex apparatus for restoring peace and installing a new political regime.

An essential resource for decision-takers, policymakers, international analysts and practitioners in the field of peacebuilding that will also be of great value to students of International Relations and Peace Studies as well as anyone interested in peacekeeping, democracy-building, and state-building.

chapter |44 pages

Introduction

part |104 pages

Transitional dilemmas, violent democracies, and the United Nations's statecraft

chapter 1|21 pages

The transition from civil war to hybrid peace

14 dilemmas of peace, democracy, and state-building in post-conflict societies

chapter 2|21 pages

United Nations hybrid liberal peace dilemmas

Contingent sovereignty, responsibility to protect and moral selectiveness

chapter 3|25 pages

From guns to votes to doves

Violent transition with ballots and bullets

part |126 pages

Transitions to political, legal, civil, and social orders

chapter 5|31 pages

From war to peace

When elections and political parties promote democracy?

chapter 6|28 pages

When the pen fails, the sword rules

Constitution building and power-sharing for divided societies

chapter 7|19 pages

No Justice, (no) peace?

Democratic injustice or undemocratic justice in the name of human rights and reconciliation

chapter 8|29 pages

Silencing the guns through DDR and SSR

The securitization of peace or governance of insecure democracy?

chapter 9|17 pages

From war to peace

Voters but not yet citizens

part |8 pages

Conclusion and recommendations

chapter |6 pages

From hybrid democratic peace toward an integrated transition

Conclusion, limitations, and recommendations