ABSTRACT

Debunking the Grit Narrative in Higher Education examines pressing structural issues currently impacting African American, Asian American, Pacific Islander, Latinx, and Native American students accessing college and succeeding in U.S. postsecondary environments. Drawing from asset-based work of critical race education scholars such as Yosso, Ladson-Billings, and contributing author Solórzano, the authors interrogate how systems and structures shape definitions of academic merit and grit, how these systems constrain opportunities to attain access and equitable educational outcomes, and challenge widely held beliefs that Students of Color need grit to succeed in college. Dominant narratives of educational success and failure tend to focus mostly on individual student effort. Contributing authors explore the myriad ways that institutional structures can support Students of Color utilizing their strengths through critical perspectives, asset-based, anti-deficit perspectives to access postsecondary environments and experience success. Scholars, scholar-practitioners, students affairs professionals, and educational leaders will benefit from this timely edited book as they work to transform postsecondary institutions into entities that meet the needs of Students and Communities of Color.

chapter 1|8 pages

Introduction

The Problem with Grit

part I|77 pages

Contexts and Foundations

chapter 3|18 pages

Challenging Everyday Structural Racism

A Critical Race Analysis of Grit in STEM

chapter 4|19 pages

The Grit Narrative

Shifting the Gaze and the Danger

chapter 5|17 pages

Sometimes You're Gritty, and Sometimes You're Not

The Racialization of Grit for Asian Americans

part II|71 pages

College Structural Barriers and Research Studies

chapter 6|23 pages

More than Grit

Toward Critical Race College Retention and Persistence for Latina/o/x Students

chapter 7|23 pages

Gritty Enough?

African American Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Student Success Factors

chapter 8|23 pages

Beyond the Bootstraps Mentality

The Fallacy of Grit as a Measure of Success for Black and Latine/x Men in California Community Colleges

part III|89 pages

Educational Practices Supporting Achievement

chapter 9|20 pages

Returning to Campus

Equity-Minded Approaches to Degree Completion

chapter 11|20 pages

Holo i ka ʻAuwai, Flowing with the Power of the Stream

Empowerment-Based Evaluation and Research

chapter 13|8 pages

Conclusion

The Problem with Grit is White Supremacy