ABSTRACT
Cause and chance have long been the object of secular controversy concerning both their =HAKL=EGDG?A;9D KL9LMK 9F< L@=AJ JGD= AF L@= N9JAGMK d=D<KG>CFGOD=<?= -=;=FLDQ L@=Q @9N=9?9AF:==F9L L@=;=FLJ=G><=:9L= AF=;GFGEA; L@=GJQ= ? +9KAF=LLA #A;CK _9<=:9L=AFO@A;@9LL=FLAGF@9K>G;MK=<GFL@=L@GM?@LG>L@=KG ;9DD=<&=QF=KA9F =;GFGEAKLK $LL@=J=>GJ=K==EKMK=>MDLG=P9EAF=&=QF=KcGOFNA=OKGF;9MK=9F<;@9F;= $ shall consider mainly A Treatise on Probability9F<L@=HGKALAGF&=QF=KLGGC;GF;=JFAF? ;GFL=EHGJ9JQK;A=F;=HJAF;AH9DDQ;GF;=JFAF?L@=MK=G>L@=;9D;MDMKG>HJG:9:ADALQ KO=K@9DDK==&=QF=KcHGKALAGF@9<LOGE9AF>=9LMJ=K !AJKLL@=>G;MKG>9F9DQKAKG>
L@=HJG:D=EG>;9MK=9F<;@9F;=AKK@A>L=<>JGEL@=d=D<G>=PHD9F9LAGF:QE9L=JA9D9F<H@QKA;9D ;GFF=;LAGFLGL@=KLM<QG>L@==>>=;LAN=HJG;=KK=KG>CFGOAF?9F<:=DA=NAF? .=;GF<@AKL@=GJQ G>HJG:9:ADALQD=<@AELG<=N=DGH9FGJ?9FA;9F9DQKAK:9K=<GFFGF <=EGFKLJ9LAN=DG?A; 9F<GJ<AF9JQ<AK;GMJK=J9L@=JL@9F9F9LGEA;GF=:9K=<GF<=<M;LAN=DG?A;9F<E9L@=E9LA;K &=QF=Kc;G?FALANAKE$K@9DD9J?M=O9K9FLA =EHAJA;AKL #GO=N=JAL<A<FGL;GFKLALML=J9LAGF9D
AKE=AL@=J&=QF=KcNA=OL@GM?@9;G?FALAN=GF=O9KFGL?JGMF<=<AFL@=;=JL9AFLQ G><=<M;LAN=DG?A; /@AKEAPLMJ=G>9FLA =EHAJA;AKE9F<9FLA J9LAGF9DAKEO9KL@=;GJ=G>&=Q F=KcH=;MDA9J=HAKL=EGDG?A;9DHGKALAGF9F<E9C=K&=QF=KcHGKALAGF<A>d;MDLLG<=K;JA:=AFKAEHD= L=JEK &=QF=KLGGJ=B=;L=<HGKALANAKEJ=>MKAF?:GL@ALK=EHAJA;AKL9F<ALKDG?A;AKLN=JKAGFK /@=K=9LLALM<=KO=J=9DKGJ=e=;L=<AF&=QF=Kc=;GFGEA;KKGL@9L@AK;GFLJA:MLAGFKGF
=;GFGEA;E=L@G< L@=GJQ 9F< HGDA;Q 9J= ;@9J9;L=JAK=< :Q 9 K=FK= G> O@9L AK HGKKA:D= J9L@=JL@9FL@9LO@A;@AKF=;=KK9JQ
Cause
/@GM?@L@=;GF;=HLG>;9MK=AK9J=;MJJ=FLAKKM=AFA Treatise on Probability,1 the reader DGGCAF?>GJ9J=9KGF=<<=dFALAGFG>AL@9KLGO9ALMFLAD+9JL$$$ /@=J=@=K@=;9FL9C=<= DA?@LAF9L@J== H9?=)GL==FLALD=<b*FL@=0K=G>L@=/=JE`9MK=ac21$$$^ $F L@AK)GL=&=QF=K=PHD9AF=< L@9L MH LG L@9LHGAFL@=@9<FGL >GMF< ALF=;=KK9JQ LG
;D9JA>QO@9L @= L@GM?@L 9:GML L@= ;GF;=HL G> ;9MK= L@GM?@ @=E9F9?=< LG 9NGA< bL@= E=L9H@QKA;9D<A>d;MDLA=KO@A;@KMJJGMF<L@=LJM=E=9FAF?G>;9MK=c #GO=N=JGFH @=@9<9DJ=9<QFGL=<bH9JLA9DGJHGKKA:D=;9MK=AFNGDN=KA<=9KO@A;@9J=KLADDG:K;MJ=c $FL@=)GL=@=GH=FDQKL9L=<L@9L@=@9<:==FMKAF?L@==PHJ=KKAGFbAF9:JG9<=JK=FK=c
L@9FL@9LAFNGDN=<AFL=;@FA;9D=PHJ=KKAGFKDAC=bKM>d;A=FL;9MK=cGJbF=;=KK9JQ;9MK=c #=
had been referring to causal relations between objects which did not stand strictly in a position of cause and effect, or to probable causes where there was no implication of necessity and where the antecedents would sometimes have led to particular consequences and sometimes not.
