ABSTRACT
INTERVENINGMONTHSMILLIONSOFPEOPLEHAVELOSTTHEIRJOBSANDHOMES,EHMAN "ROTHERSHASCOLLAPSEDANDWASBROKENUP#HRYSLER'-AND)CELANDHAVEBEEN BANKRUPTEDANDAREALLBEINGDEEPLYREINVENTED!)'2OYAL"ANKOF3COTLANDAND MANYOTHERlNANCIALINSTITUTIONSHAVEBEENBAILEDOUTANDNATIONALIZEDMANY OFTHEWORLDSSTOCKMARKETSHAVELOSTHALFTHEIRVALUEBUTARERECOVERINGGROUND ANDTHEEXPOSURESOFGOVERNMENTSANDCENTRALBANKSHAVECLIMBEDTOTHETENSOF TRILLIONSOFDOLLARS#LIMATECHANGECONTINUESRELATIVELYUNCHECKEDASTHEWORLD PREPARESFORTHE#OPENHAGENCONFERENCE)NRECOGNITIONOFTHESEDRAMATICRECENT EVENTSWEHAVEADDEDTOOURREPERTOIREANEWCHAPTER#HAPTERONTHElNANCIAL CRISIS7ElNDTHATTHECRISISCORROBORATESMUCHOFOURARGUMENTINTHElRST EDITIONOFTHEBOOKWHICHWEHAVEKEPTLARGELYINTACT 0OSSIBLEFUTURESOVERTHENEXTlVETOTENYEARSASSEENBYACORPORATEEXECUTIVE
AGOVERNMENTPLANNERORANON GOVERNMENTALORGANIZATION.'/ MANAGING
DIRECTORINCONTINUETOHOLDBOTHGREATPROMISEASWELLASGREATRISKS-OST DECISION MAKERSWOULDACKNOWLEDGETHATCOMPLEXITYINTHEGENERALCONTEXTOF THEIRORGANIZATIONSAPPEARSTOBEINCREASINGSEE#HAPTER -OSTWOULDALSO RECOGNIZETHATFAILURETOEFFECTIVELYADDRESSTHISCONTEXTUALCOMPLEXITYCANBE EXPENSIVE4HEDESTRUCTIVEEVENCATASTROPHICCONSEQUENCESOFTHESEFAILURESHAVE BEENWELLEXAMINEDINTHELITERATURESONPUBLICPOLICYANDCORPORATESTRATEGY4WO EXAMPLESPOINTTHISOUTSHARPLY&IRSTTHE3TERNREPORTCOMMISSIONEDBYTHE5+ GOVERNMENTANDISSUEDIN/CTOBEREXAMINEDTHEREALCOSTOFCLIMATECHANGE OUTTOCONCLUDINGTHATITWOULDLEADTOTHEBIGGESTEVER RECORDEDECONOMIC MELTDOWNIFITWASNOTAVERTED3TERN 3ECOND.OBEL0RIZEWINNER*OSEPH 3TIGLITZTOGETHERWITHACOLLEAGUEHASCALCULATEDTHATTHEFAILURESOFTHE"USH ADMINISTRATIONTOCOMPREHENDTHECOMPLEXITIESOF)RAQHAVELEDTOACOSTOVERRUN OFTHEWARFROMTHEADMINISTRATIONSORIGINALESTIMATEOFBILLIONTOWELLOVER TRILLION3TIGLITZAND"ILME -ORERECENTLYINTHE53THEBILLION EXPOSURECALLEDTHE4OXIC!SSET2ELIEF0ROGRAMOFHASBALLOONEDTOOVER TRILLIONANDTHEREISEXPOSUREOFGOVERNMENTSWORLDWIDEINTERMSOF@BAILOUTS STIMULUSPROGRAMMESlSCALEASINGETC 7HILEWEEXPRESSALLTHESESITUATIONSASTHREATSEVERYCHANGECONSTITUTESAN
OPPORTUNITYFORGROWTHANDDEVELOPMENT&OREXAMPLETHEINCREASINGUSEOF TECHNOLOGYINSOCIETYSTIMULATESINTERCONNECTIONSANDTHUSGREATERCOMPLEXITY EGHOUSEHOLDSSPENDMOREONTELECOMMUNICATIONSANDMOREPEOPLETRAVELAND TRAVELMOREnBETWEENANDTHEAVERAGEANNUALDISTANCETRAVELLEDBY "RITONSGREWPERCENT !SASSETSINTHEWORLDBECOMEMORELIQUIDWITHRAPIDLY DEVELOPINGTECHNOLOGY.ORMANN THEYCANBELINKEDTOEACHOTHERINMORE WAYSANDTHEINCREASINGLYRICHCONNECTIONSPATTERNCANPRODUCEUNFORESEEABLE SURPRISES&OREXAMPLEECONOMICGROWTHANDGLOBALIZATIONINCREASEOURAWARENESS OFOVERALLCONSTRAINTSAFFECTINGACTIVITIESWHICHWECONSIDEREDUNRELATEDUPTO NOW-ANYOFTHEMHAVEDESTRUCTIVEUNINTENDEDCONSEQUENCES 4HISBOOKISABOUTHOWTHREATSCANCONVERTINTOOPPORTUNITIESnANDHOW
INCREASINGTHREATSCANTURNINTOINCREASINGOPPORTUNITIES)NORDERTOTHINKIN THESETERMSWENEEDTOLOOKINTOTHEFUTURE&ORREASONSTHATWILLBECOMECLEARWE CONSIDERTHEFUTURETHROUGHTHESPECTACLESOFTHESCENARIOAPPROACH7HILEWEDO THATWEREmECTONOURPRACTICEINTHELIGHTOFTHEPERSPECTIVEOFFEREDBYASCHOOLOF THOUGHTINTHESOCIALANDORGANIZATIONALSCIENCESCALLEDSOCIALECOLOGYINPARTICULAR ITSDESCRIPTIONOFTHE@TURBULENTENVIRONMENT7EWILLSHOWHOWSCENARIOSAND SOCIALECOLOGYINFORMEACHOTHERALLOWINGUSnASMANAGERSCONSULTANTSAND SCHOLARSnTOBECOMEMOREEFFECTIVEANDSUCCESSFULNAVIGATORSINANINCREASINGLY TURBULENTWORLD
3CENARIOSAREDESCRIPTIONSOFPLAUSIBLEFUTURECONTEXTSINWHICHWEMIGHTlND OURSELVES3CENARIOSARETYPICALLYPRESENTEDASASMALLSETOFSTORIESABOUTHOWOUR SURROUNDINGENVIRONMENTMIGHTHAVEEVOLVEDINTOTHEFUTURE4HEYAREPRODUCED BYCAREFULLYANALYSINGANDSTRUCTURINGRELEVANTANDCHALLENGINGPOSSIBILITIESFORA GOODMETHODOLOGICALOVERVIEWSEEVANDER(EIJDEN !VAILABLEDATASUGGESTTHATTHEUSEOFSCENARIOSTOADDRESSCOMPLEXCONDITIONS
HASBEENINCREASING3CENARIOTHINKINGANDPRACTICEHAVEOCCURREDINMILITARY CIRCLESANDPOLICYTHINKTANKSASWELLASINCOMPANIESFORMANYDECADES4HERE AREINDICATIONSTHATITSPRACTICEISSPREADINGSEE&IGURE 4HETHINKINGAND PRACTICEOFSCENARIOSARECHARACTERIZEDBYABROADANDCONFUSINGMIXOFMETHODS ANDPRACTICESWITHLITTLEEXPLANATIONASTOWHYANDHOWTHEY@WORKANDVARIABLE CRITERIAFORSUCCESS)NSPITEOFITSWIDESPREADADOPTIONSCENARIOWORKREMAINS THEORETICALLYUNDERDEVELOPED 2ECOGNIZINGTHENEEDTOCLARIFYTHETHEORETICALUNDERPINNINGSOFSCENARIO
WORKTHETHREEEDITORSOFTHISVOLUMEORGANIZEDTHElRST/XFORD&UTURES&ORUM /&& AT4EMPLETON#OLLEGE/XFORD5NIVERSITYIN/CTOBER4HIS FORUMATTRACTED@FUTURESPRACTITIONERSANDACADEMICRESEARCHERSFORTWODAYSOF DIALOGUEABOUTTHERELEVANCEOFCOMPLEXENVIRONMENTSnASCONCEPTUALIZEDBYTHE lELDOFSOCIALECOLOGYnTOTHEPRACTICEOFSCENARIOS0ARTICIPANTSINCLUDEDMANYOF THESCENARIOPLANNERSWHOHAVESHAPEDTHEPRACTICEOVERTHELASTYEARSASWELL ASACROSS SECTIONOFRESEARCHERSANDCONSULTANTSFROMTHESOCIALECOLOGYSCHOOL7E DESIGNEDTHE/&&ASA@STRATEGICCONVERSATIONSEEVANDER(EIJDEN ANDTHEEVENTDEMONSTRATEDTHATREmECTIVEDIALOGUEBETWEENTHETWOCOMMUNITIES CANBELIVELYMUTUALLYENRICHINGANDRELEVANT4HECHAPTERSINTHISVOLUMEARE DRAWNFROMCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHE/&&THATHAVEBEENEDITEDANDUPDATED(ENCE INANIMPORTANTSENSETHISBOOKCONTINUESTHECONVERSATIONSSTARTEDINTHE/XFORD &UTURES&ORUMANDHASNOILLUSIONSOFENDINGTHEM 4HISBOOKSEEKSTOPROVIDEACADEMICRIGOURANDSCHOLARSHIPTOSCENARIOWORK
3OFARTHElELDHASBEENSUPPORTEDBYPRACTITIONERBOOKSOFVARYINGQUALITY7E AIMTOANCHORSCENARIOTHINKINGMOREROBUSTLYINSOCIALSCIENCEKNOWLEDGEBASED ONBETTERRESEARCHTHATIMPROVESPRACTICE&OREXAMPLEADEBATEWASREPORTEDIN THEJOURNAL/RGANIZATION3TUDIESVOLUMEISSUE AMONG2ICHARD 7HITTINGTON'ERARD(ODGKINSONAND'EORGE7RIGHTASTOWHYASCENARIOS BASED INTERVENTIONBYTHETWOLATTERAUTHORSFAILED4HEYAGREETHATTHEINTERVENTION WAS@PREMATUREINRELATIONTOTHEEMERGINGTURBULENCEINTHECLIENTORGANIZATIONS ENVIRONMENT(OWEVERWHATISSTILLMISSINGISGUIDANCEASTOWHENINTHERISING TURBULENCEITWOULDHAVEBEENADVISABLEFORSCENARIOSTOBEDEPLOYED4HISBOOK AIMSTOCLARIFYSUCHISSUES
)NTHESAGROUPOFSOCIALSCIENTISTSFOCUSEDONORGANIZATIONALRESEARCH THEORIZEDENVIRONMENTALCOMPLEXITYANDUNCERTAINTYINTERMSOFTYPESOFWHAT THEYCALLEDTHEENVIRONMENTS@CAUSALTEXTURE4HEIRDEVELOPMENTOFCAUSALTEXTURE THEORYHENCEFORTH@#44 WASPROVOKEDBYAGROWINGNEEDFORSOCIALSCIENTISTS TOBETTERUNDERSTANDINCREASINGENVIRONMENTALCOMPLEXITYANDUNCERTAINTYAND THEINDETERMINATENATUREOFSUCHENVIRONMENTSTHATMANAGERSWEREBEGINNINGTO EXPERIENCE4HUSASPARTOFTHEIRWORKON#44THEYCOINEDTHETERM@TURBULENCE TOREPRESENTTHEMOSTUNCERTAINENVIRONMENTS4HENEEDTOUNDERSTANDCOMPLEX ENVIRONMENTSHASCERTAINLYNOTABATED 4HISBOOKSUGGESTSTHAT#44PROVIDESAROBUSTCONCEPTUALUNDERPINNINGFOR
HOWSCENARIOPRACTICESHELPTOADDRESSENVIRONMENTALCOMPLEXITY'ROUNDEDIN STATE OF THE ARTEXAMPLESFROMACROSSTHEWORLDTHEBOOKEXAMINESHOW#44 EXPLAINSTHEEFFECTIVENESSANDLIMITATIONSOFSCENARIOPRACTICES )N BROADOUTLINEWE SEE TWOWAYSWHERE SCENARIOSHELP IN COPINGWITH
TURBULENCE&IRSTTHEYHELPSTAKEHOLDERSDEVELOPABETTERSYSTEMICUNDERSTANDING OFTHEIRSURROUNDINGENVIRONMENTANDPROVIDENEWINSIGHTSINTOTHETURBULENT ENVIRONMENTSTHEYINHABIT!CLEARERSEE#HAPTERINTHISVOLUME AWARENESS OFPRE DETERMINEDELEMENTSINTHEENVIRONMENTSEE#HAPTER HELPSMANAGERS ANDOTHERDECISIONMAKERSTOMAKEBETTERSENSEOFTHEIRSUBJECTIVEEXPERIENCE OFTURBULENCE3ODOESAKEENERINSIGHTABOUTPLAUSIBLERATHERTHANPROBABLE FUTURESASILLUSTRATEDINTHENEW#HAPTERONTHElNANCIALCRISIS 3ECOND SCENARIOS HELP IN BUILDING COMMON GROUND AMONG DISPARATE
STAKEHOLDERSINATURBULENTENVIRONMENT)TENABLESTHEMTOFOCUSTHEIRCOLLECTIVE ATTENTIONONASETOFALTERNATIVEFUTURES-ULTIPLEFUTURESPROVIDESPACEFORSURFACING TACITASSUMPTIONSWHICHCANTHENBEDISCUSSEDANDUNDERSTOODSEE#HAPTERS ANDINTHISVOLUME 5NDERSTANDINGEACHOTHERSPERSPECTIVESONHOWTHE lELDTHEYHOLDINCOMMONMAYPLAYOUTINTHEFUTURESEE#HAPTERSAND ALLOWSSTAKEHOLDERSTOCOMETOGETHERTOALIGNANDJOINTLYSTRENGTHENTHEIRCOPING STRATEGY
4HISISNOTANOTHER@SCENARIOSBOOK.ORISITANACADEMICTREATISEONAPARTICULAR MANAGEMENTTHEORYORTRENDINTHESOCIALSCIENCES)NSTEADITLINKSTHEORYAND PRACTICETORENDERTHEORYMORERIGOROUSANDPRACTICEMOREEFFECTIVE 4HISKEYLINKISFORTHOSEWHOWISHTOREmECTONANDADDRESSUNCERTAINTYAND
COMPLEXITYINTHEIRENVIRONMENTINACREATIVEMANNERWITHAFOCUSONTHEFUTURE INORDERTOSERVETHEIRPRESENTCONCERNS4HISINCLUDESBOTHPRACTITIONERSAND SCHOLARS
7ETHINKTHISWORKWILLBEOFINTERESTTOWHAT$ON3CHšN CALLED REmECTIVEPRACTITIONERSINSCENARIOWORKTHOSEWHOUSESCENARIOSINTHEIRMANAGERIAL ORCONSULTINGWORKANDWHOWANTTOKNOWMOREABOUTWHYWHENANDHOWTHEY CANBEMADEMOREEFFECTIVE7EEXPECTTHISBOOKTOBEOFPARTICULARRELEVANCE TO PROFESSIONALS DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY INVOLVEDWITH STRATEGIC PLANNING AND MANAGEMENTINPRIVATEPUBLICAND.'/SECTORSANDWHOCONSIDERTHEMSELVES REFLECTIVE LEARNERS4HISWILL INCLUDE SENIOR GENERALMANAGEMENT EXECUTIVES IN SMALLAND LARGEORGANIZATIONSBUTALSOPROFESSIONALS INVOLVED INSTRATEGIC PLANNINGFORESIGHTSCOUTINGCORPORATEAFFAIRS INTER GOVERNMENTALRELATIONS EXTERNALCOMMUNICATIONSCHANGEMANAGEMENTCORPORATESOCIALRESPONSIBILITY ANDINTERNALCONSULTANCY7EHOPETOPROVIDETHESEREADERSWITHNEWINSIGHTS ABOUTPRACTICALISSUESSUCHASFORGINGCOMMONGROUNDRESPONDINGTODISRUPTION THEROLEANDSCOPEOFFAIRNESSINPLANNINGDIFFERENTUSESOFSCENARIOS@SWARM PLANNINGCLARITYINSCENARIOWORKANDWORKINGWITHPRE DETERMINEDELEMENTS 7ETHINKTHEBOOKWILLALSOAPPEAL TO SCHOLARSWHOWANT TOUNDERSTAND
BETTERHOWMANAGERIALPRACTICERELATESTOTRACKINGHOWUNCERTAINTYANDVOLATILITY IMPACTSBUSINESSESGOVERNMENTALINSTITUTIONSAND.'/S4HESETHEMESMAYBE RELEVANTTOFACULTYANDSTUDENTSINTHElELDSOFSTRATEGYMANAGEMENTSTUDIESAND POLICYSTUDIESASWELLASINSOCIALGEOGRAPHYSOCIOLOGYECONOMICSEDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIPPUBLICADMINISTRATIONEPIDEMIOLOGYCOMMUNITYPSYCHOLOGYAND ENGINEERING4HEBOOKWILLBESPECIlCALLYUSEFULFORFACULTYANDSTUDENTSWITHAN INTERESTINSTRATEGYLEADERSHIPSENSE MAKINGENVIRONMENTALSTUDIESSCANNING FUTURESTUDIESSUSTAINABILITYCORPORATESOCIALRESPONSIBILITYLONG RANGEPLANNING SCENARIOSANDENTREPRENEURSHIP !SPECIALAPPEALOFTHEMATERIALINTHISBOOKISITSGLOBALNATURETHATISSOOFTEN
MISSINGINPOLICYSTUDIESANDSTRATEGICPLANNINGBOOKS4HECHAPTERAUTHORSARE FROM!USTRALIA#ANADA%NGLAND(OLLAND'REECE-EXICO3COTLAND3OUTH !FRICA3WEDENANDTHE53-OREOVERTHECHAPTERSUSEMATERIALFROMDIVERSE CULTURALCONTEXTSRANGINGFROM6ENEZUELAAND)NDIATOTHE5+AND(OLLAND
+EYCONTRIBUTORSTOTHECREATIONOFSOCIALECOLOGYWERE&RED%MERYAND%RIC4RIST 4RAINEDASAPSYCHOANALYST4RISTCO FOUNDEDTHE4AVISTOCK)NSTITUTEIN,ONDON AFTER7ORLD7AR))WHERE LINKSBETWEEN TECHNICAL INNOVATIONSANDPSYCHO SOCIALPOSSIBILITIESWEREEXPLOREDINTHESERVICEOFWORKERSANDMANAGERSINLARGE ORGANIZATIONSSUCHASTHE"RITISH#OAL"OARD &RED%MERYAN!USTRALIANSOCIALSCIENTISTWASINITIALLYASTUDENTOF4RISTBUT
QUICKLYBECAMEACOLLEAGUEANDIN4RISTSVIEWPERSONALINFORMATION ALEADER INMUCHOFTHEIRJOINTINTELLECTUALWORK7HILEOVERTHEIRWORKINGLIVESTHEY
COLLABORATEDWITHMANYOTHERIMPORTANTSOCIALSCIENTISTSANDACTIONRESEARCHERS SUCHAS%INAR4HORSURDINDEVELOPINGINDUSTRIALDEMOCRACYIN.ORWAYAND2USSELL !CKOFFINDEVELOPINGINTERACTIVEPLANNINGINTHE53 THEYCONTINUEDCOLLABORATING TOGETHERFORMANYYEARSDESPITETHEIRRESIDINGONDIFFERENTCONTINENTSFORSEVERAL YEARSATATIME %MERYAND4RISTSORIGINALSTATEMENTIN CONCERNINGTHECAUSALTEXTURES
OFTHEENVIRONMENTMAYBESEENASAHIGH LEVELDESCRIPTIVETHEORYOFENVIRONMENTAL EVOLUTIONÍLA4OYNBEE$ARWINOR-ARX (OWEVERTHEYRECOGNIZEDFROMTHE BEGINNINGTHATITOFFEREDIMPORTANTDIRECTIMPLICATIONSFORPRACTICEINTHEWORLD /THERSINCLUDINGTHEAUTHORSINTHISVOLUMEHAVETAKENUPANDDEVELOPEDTHESE PRACTICALIMPLICATIONS!NEXAMPLEOFTHISISAPLANNINGANDINTERVENTIONMETHOD CALLEDTHESEARCHCONFERENCEWHICH&REDAND-ERRELYN%MERYDESIGNEDINTHE SANDTHENDEVELOPEDOVERTHENEXTYEARS)NTHISVOLUME#HAPTER COMPARESTHEFEATURESOFTHESEARCHCONFERENCEANDTHESCENARIOMETHOD 7EBELIEVETHATREADINGCAUSALTEXTURESASAMACROEVOLUTIONARYTHEORYALONE
WOULDBEINCOMPLETEANDINACCURATEFORSEVERALREASONS&IRST#44ASCRIBESTO @STRATEGICCHOICERATHERTHANDETERMINISMINSOCIALINCLUDINGBUSINESS AFFAIRS THATISACTORSAREABLETOCHOOSEAMONGPOSSIBLERESPONSESTOTHEIRENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONSANDSUCHCHOICESARECONSEQUENTIAL3ECONDASAPARTOFOPEN SYSTEMS THEORYANDSOCIALECOLOGY#44ISUNDERPINNEDBYTHENOTIONTHATSYSTEMSAND THEIRENVIRONMENTSCO EVOLVETHATISACTIONSBYSYSTEMSANDTHEIRMEMBERSCAN HAVETHEEFFECTOFCHANGINGTHEBASICCONTOURSOFENVIRONMENTSSYSTEMSMUST THENADAPTTOTHOSECHANGEDCONTOURS4HIRD#44ISGROUNDEDDEEPLYINHUMAN PRACTICEANDASCRIBESTOADELIBERATELYNORMATIVESTANCETOWARDAN@IMPROVED FUTUREFORHUMANKIND&INALLYTHE@VARIANTONTHEORIGINAL#44ADVANCEDBY -C#ANNAND3ELSKY EXPLICITLYINTRODUCESTHEPERCEPTIONSBYACTORSOFTHEIR ENVIRONMENTASAKEYCONTINGENCYINADAPTATION4HATINTRODUCESTHESUBTLELINK BETWEENTHEOBJECTIVEANDTHEPERCEIVEDENVIRONMENTTHATSCENARIOWORKHELPSTO EXPLOREASPARTOFDEVELOPINGANDSTRENGTHENINGADAPTIVEBEHAVIOUR )NTHEDECADESSINCETHEPUBLICATIONOF%MERYAND4RISTSORIGINALARTICLEIN
RESEARCHONCOMPLEXENVIRONMENTSANDTURBULENCEHAVEINCREASEDINTHE lELDOFORGANIZATIONANDMANAGEMENTSTUDIESASSHOWNIN&IGURE #OINCIDENTALLYFROMONWARDSWHILE%MERYAND4RISTWEREDEVELOPING
CAUSALTEXTURESTHEORYPEOPLELIKE(ERMANN+AHNAND0IERRE7ACKTOOKALEADING ROLEINDEVELOPINGTHEMETHODOFSCENARIOSASANAIDTOSTRATEGICPLANNING4HE LINKSBETWEENTHEIRWORKAREWHATWEEXPLOREDATTHE/&&ANDWHICHTHIS BOOKMAKESAVAILABLEFORAWIDERAUDIENCE7EPROPOSETHAT#44WHICHWE EXPLAININ#HAPTER PROVIDESAUNIQUELYWELL INFORMEDUNDERSTANDINGOF
s WHYSCENARIOPRACTICESAREGROWINGAND s HOWTHEYWORKTOADDRESSTURBULENCE
4HISUNDERSTANDINGOFSCENARIOWORKHASNOTBEENAVAILABLEBEFORE!STHECHAPTERS INTHISBOOKSHOWWHENSCENARIOPRACTITIONERSATTENDTO#44ANDITSIMPLICATIONS THEYCANIMPROVETHEEFFECTIVENESSANDQUALITYOFTHEIRSCENARIOWORK
3EVERAL SOURCESOFDATA INDICATE THAT SCENARIOUSEHAS INCREASEDSIGNIlCANTLY PARTICULARLYSINCETHEEVENTSOF3EPTEMBER&IGURESHOWSHOWTHE NUMBEROFSCHOLARLYARTICLESONSCENARIOSPUBLISHEDIN%NGLISHONLY INTHESOCIAL SCIENCESHASSHOTUP7EBELIEVETHISINDICATESTHEINCREASINGINTERESTINANDTHE IMPORTANCEOFSCENARIOPRACTICE &IGUREWASPRODUCEDBYTHE53 BASEDCONSULTANCY"AINANDPUBLISHEDIN
BYTHE(ARVARD"USINESS2EVIEW)TSUGGESTSTHATSCENARIOUSEAMONGTHE PARTIESSURVEYEDHASGONEUPASHASSATISFACTIONWITHTHEAPPROACHnPRESUMABLY AGOODPROXYFORRELEVANCE3IMILARSTATISTICSAREAVAILABLEFROMTHE#ONFERENCE "OARDA53 BASEDASSOCIATIONOFBIGCOMPANIES(OWEVERBOTHSURVEYSARELESS THANRIGOROUSINDElNINGWHAT@SCENARIOUSEACTUALLYENTAILS!STHESEDElNITIONS VARYBETWEENUSERSANDHAVECHANGEDOVERTIMETHElGURESMUSTBETAKENONLYAS ROUGHINDICATORSOFWHATISGOINGON )NASURVEYOFTHELITERATUREONSCENARIOSCOVERINGARTICLESBOOKSAND
CHAPTERSPUBLISHEDBETWEENANDMID,ANG APPLIED-ORGANS FRAMEWORKOFEIGHTMETAPHORSFORCLASSIFYINGSOCIALSCIENCERESEARCHON ORGANIZATIONS3HEFOUNDTHATTHEPATTERNOFSCENARIORESEARCHFOLLOWSROUGHLYTHAT OFRESEARCHONORGANIZATIONSASAWHOLE4HATISAMAJORITYOFTHEPUBLICATIONSFALL
WITHINTHE@-ACHINEAND@/RGANISMMETAPHORSREmECTINGCONCERNWITHHOWTO DOSCENARIOWORKEFlCIENTLYANDHOWTOUSETHEMETHODTOASSISTORGANIZATIONSIN ADDRESSINGENVIRONMENTALUNCERTAINTY.ONEOFTHISHOWEVERHELPSINEXPLAINING THE GROWTH IN SCENARIO USE PARTICULARLY THE EXPLOSIVE GROWTH FOLLOWING 3EPTEMBER 7EPROPOSE THAT SCENARIOUSE AND RELEVANCEHAS INCREASEDBECAUSE
BROUGHTHOMETODECISION MAKERSHOWTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURENOWHASBECOME PARTANDPARCELOFTHElELDTHEYLIVEIN7EEXPECTANOTHERSTEP CHANGEINGROWTH TOEMERGEFROMTHERECENTlNANCIALCRISIS7EPROPOSETHATSINCETHATTIMEITHAS BECOMELEGITIMATEFORSENIORMANAGERSTOEXPRESSTHEIRINABILITYTOCONTROLSOME KEYUNCERTAINTIESINTHEIRCONTEXTS)TISNOWACCEPTEDTHATTHESEUNCERTAINTIES NEEDTOBEADDRESSEDTHROUGHMETHODSTHATACCEPTTHEREALITYANDINEVITABILITYOF SUCHUNCERTAINTIES 7E ALSO CONSIDERWHERE IN THE SAME LIGHT SCENARIOSWOULD NOT BE AN
APPROPRIATEORAHELPFULMETHOD7EWILLCOMETOTHECONCLUSIONSEELASTCHAPTER THATSCENARIOSARENOTHELPFULINENVIRONMENTSWHICHHAVEATEXTURETHATISEITHER MORESTABLETHANATURBULENTENVIRONMENTOREVENMOREUNCERTAINANDCOMPLEX SEE#HAPTER
0ART)SETSTHESCENEFORTHERESTOFTHEBOOK)TREVIEWSTHEINTELLECTUALHISTORIESOF CAUSALTEXTURESTHEORYFOCUSINGONTHETURBULENTlELD@TURBULENCE ANDSCENARIO PRACTICESTOADDRESSCOMPLEXSTRATEGICISSUESINCORPORATEANDPUBLIC SECTORCONTEXTS 4HESEHISTORIESPROVIDETHEFOUNDATIONFORANORIGINALANDRIGOROUSEXPLORATIONOF HOWSCENARIOWORKSUCCEEDSANDFAILSINADDRESSINGTURBULENCELEADINGTOANEW UNDERSTANDINGOFTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHEAPPROACH4HISEXPLORATIONISEMBODIED INTHREEFURTHERCHAPTERSIN0ART)COMPARINGTHECAUSALTEXTURESFRAMEWORKWITH OTHERCONCEPTUALFRAMEWORKSANDMETHODSTHESEARCHCONFERENCEMETHODSOFT SYSTEMSMETHODOLOGYANDTHECOMPLEXITYTHEORYOF)LYA0RIGOGINE )N#HAPTERTHETHREEEDITORSOFTHISVOLUMEREVIEWTHEINTELLECTUALHISTORY
OFTHETWOKEYSTRANDSOFTHEBOOKA THEFRAMEWORKOFENVIRONMENTALCAUSAL TEXTURESANDTURBULENCEDRAWNFROMTHEORIGINALWORKBY%MERYAND4RISTIN THEMIDSANDSUBSEQUENTDEVELOPMENTSUPTOTHEPRESENTDAYANDB THE PRACTICEOFSCENARIOSINTERMSOFACOMPARISONOFANUMBEROFSCHOOLSOFTHOUGHT ANDAMIXOFINSTITUTIONALHOMESANDHOWTHISHASLEDTOALACKOFACOHERENT THEORETICALFRAMEWORK 7ETHENOUTLINETHETWOMAINWAYSWHEREBYSCENARIOS HELPINCOPINGWITHTURBULENCE
&IRSTTHEYHELPSTAKEHOLDERSDEVELOPABETTERSYSTEMICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE ORIGINSOFTURBULENCEINTHEIRCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTLEADINGTOINSIGHTSON THEBALANCEBETWEENPRE DETERMINEDELEMENTSANDIRREDUCIBLEUNCERTAINTIES
3ECOND SCENARIOS HELP IN BUILDING COMMON GROUND AMONG DISPARATE STAKEHOLDERSBYCREATINGSPACE FORMULTIPLE INTERPRETATIONSANDFOCUSING COLLECTIVEATTENTIONONACONSTRAINEDSETOFALTERNATIVEFUTURES
)NTHENEXTTWOCHAPTERSWEAIMTODEEPENTHISUNDERSTANDINGBYCONTRASTING TURBULENCEANDTHEUSEOFSCENARIOSINITWITHOTHERAPPROACHESDESIGNEDTOASSIST DECISIONMAKERS IN SITUATIONSOFCONSIDERABLEUNCERTAINTY#HAPTER *AIME *IM£NEZ ELABORATESTHEHISTORYOFCAUSALTEXTURESBYCOMPARINGANINTERVENTION METHODNORMALLYASSOCIATEDWITHITTHESEARCHCONFERENCEWITHTHESCENARIO APPROACH4HISHIGHLIGHTSTHESPECIlCATTRIBUTESOFSCENARIOPRACTICE#HAPTER 4RUDI,ANGAND,YNN!LLEN DEMONSTRATESHOWTHESOFTSYSTEMSMETHODOLOGY DEVELOPEDBY0ETER#HECKLANDCANHELPUSUNDERSTANDHOW SCENARIOS FORGE COMMONGROUNDAMONGSTAKEHOLDERSINATURBULENTENVIRONMENT &INALLY#HAPTER-ARY"ERNARD SHOWSHOWTHElELDOFSOCIALECOLOGY
HASMOVEDONSINCE%MERYAND4RISTUNDERTHEINmUENCEOFTHEDEVELOPMENTOF COMPLEXITYTHEORY4HEAUTHORDOESTHISBYCOMPARINGITWITHTHEWORKOF.OBEL 0RIZEWINNER)LYA0RIGOGINEONCOMPLEXITYANDSELF ORGANIZATION4HISCOMPARATIVE ANALYSISPROVIDESAMORECONTEMPORARYTHEORETICALUNDERSTANDINGOFHOWCHANGE OCCURSINTURBULENTENVIRONMENTS #OMINGOUTOF0ART)THEREADERSHOULDHAVEACLEARERIMAGEOFCAUSALTEXTURES
THEORYOF SCENARIOSWORKANDOF THE INTERFACESBETWEENCAUSAL TEXTURESAND SCENARIOSTHATDRIVETHERESTOFTHEBOOK )N0ART))WElNDFOURCASESORSTORIESOFSPECIlCTURBULENTENVIRONMENTSAND
HOWSCENARIOSWEREDEPLOYEDTOADDRESSTHESE4HESECASESILLUSTRATEINPRACTICE THEPRINCIPLESSETOUTIN0ART)ANDPREPARETHEREADERFORNEWCONCEPTUALAND METHODOLOGICALINSIGHTSIN0ART))) 4HECASESIN0ART))HELPTHEREADERTOAPPRECIATETHEDIVERSITYOFCONDITIONS
ANDCONTEXTSINWHICHTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURESARISEASWELLASTHEADAPTABILITY ANDVERSATILITYOFSCENARIOPRACTICESTOADDRESSTHESE/RIGINALLYCAUSALTEXTURE THEORISTSPROPOSEDTHATTURBULENTENVIRONMENTSCOULDBEADDRESSEDEFFECTIVELYBY IDENTIFYINGANDBUILDINGCOMMONGROUNDAMONGSTAKEHOLDERS4HECASESSELECTED ILLUSTRATEHOWTHISISFACILITATEDBYSITUATINGTHESECOMMONGROUNDPOSSIBILITIESIN POSSIBLEFUTURESWITHTHEHELPOFSCENARIOPRACTICES &IRST#HAPTER+EESVANDER(EIJDEN DISCUSSESTHESHIFTFROMA@PLACID
CLUSTERED ENVIRONMENTAL TEXTURE TO A @TURBULENT ENVIRONMENTAL TEXTURE AS )NDIANAGRICULTUREISGRADUALLYOPENEDUPTOTHELOGICSANDTHEPRESSURESOFWORLD MARKETSASPARTOFTHECOUNTRYSECONOMICTAKE OFF.EWDYNAMICINDEPENDENT ANDAUTONOMOUSPROCESSESTAKEONANUNCERTAINLIFEOFTHEIROWN#AUSALTEXTURE THEORYSUGGESTS THATCONTROLOF TURBULENCERESULTING FROMECONOMIC TAKE OFF REQUIRESCOLLABORATIONAMONGSTAKEHOLDERSBASEDONTHEIRSHAREDUNDERSTANDING OFCOMMONGROUNDAMONGTHEM!SCENARIOPROJECTWASAIMEDATCREATINGA @STRATEGICCONVERSATIONAMONGTHERELEVANTACTORSWITHTHEPURPOSEOFDEVELOPING
INSIGHTSINWHATSHAPETHISCOMMONGROUNDMIGHTTAKE4HISPOINTEDTOELEMENTS OFPOSSIBLEFUTURESHAREDIDEALSBEINGIDENTIlEDTHATMIGHTLIMITTHEPOTENTIALLY DESTRUCTIVECONSEQUENCESOFTURBULENTCONDITIONSASAPOWERFULSTEPTOWARDS INCREASINGTHECOUNTRYSADAPTIVECAPACITY #HAPTER2OB2OGGEMA THENEXAMINESHOWINCREASINGENVIRONMENTAL
TURBULENCEHAVELED$UTCHURBANANDREGIONALPLANNERSTOWARDSMETHODSTHAT INCORPORATESCENARIOPRACTICES(EEMPHASIZESTHEROLEOFTHEINDIVIDUALIDEA NEXTTOTHEROLEOFCOMMONGROUNDCOLLABORATIONSINTHESTRUGGLETOADAPTTO TURBULENCEASEXPLAINEDBYCOMPLEXITYTHEORYSEE#HAPTER 4HESEDISTINCT ROLESINADDRESSINGTHECHALLENGESOFMAJORCLIMATECHANGEAREDISCUSSED/NTHE BASISOFTHISTHEAUTHORPROPOSES@SWARMPLANNINGASAPOSSIBLEFUTUREEXTENSION OFSCENARIOPROCESSESWHENDEPLOYEDTOADDRESSTURBULENTSETTINGS #HAPTER.IKLAS!RVIDSSON EXAMINESHOWREGULATIONANDGOVERNANCERELATE
TOADDRESSINGTURBULENCE(EDOESSOEXPLORINGHOWSCENARIOSWEREDEPLOYEDIN DEALINGWITH3WEDISHREGIONALHEALTHCAREANDITSFUTURE4HISCASESUGGESTSTHAT GOVERNANCEORIGINALLYDEVELOPEDFORMOREPREDICTABLEENVIRONMENTSTHANTURBULENT ONESMUSTLIKE2OGGEMASREGIONALPLANNINGBERE THOUGHTANDREDESIGNEDnAND THATFAILINGTODOSOWILLLEADTOUNACCEPTABLECONDITIONS &INALLY#HAPTER-ARTIN4HOMAS HIGHLIGHTSTHELIMITATIONSOFSCENARIOWORK
INEXTREMEENVIRONMENTCAUSALTEXTURESEVENBEYONDWHATISNORMALLYCONSIDERED ASTURBULENCEBASEDONTHEORIGINALTHEORY%XAMPLESARE-C#ANNAND 3ELSKYS @HYPER TURBULENTAND"ABÓROG€LUS @VORTICALENVIRONMENTAL TEXTURES4HOMASUSESTHECASEOF6ENEZUELAINTODEMONSTRATETHECHALLENGES OFFORGINGCOMMONGROUNDINSUCHHIGHLYTURBULENTCONDITIONS(EREmECTSUPON HISORIGINALANALYSISFROMTHEVANTAGEPOINTOFHINDSIGHT ANDCONSIDERSTHE POSSIBILITIESOFUSINGSCENARIOSINCAUSALTEXTURESOTHERTHANTHETURBULENT 0ART)))DISCUSSESKEYISSUESARISINGFROMTHEEXPLORATIONOFTHELINKSBETWEEN
CAUSAL TEXTURES AND SCENARIOS AND REVIEWS IMPLICATIONS FOR SCENARIOPRACTICE METHODS7ESUGGESTTHATTHESEISSUESIMPACTALLSCENARIOWORKANDALLSCENARIO PRACTITIONERS2EALWORLDCASESAREALSOINCLUDEDHEREBUTWEASEDITORSCONCLUDED THATTHEPOWEROFTHESECHAPTERSLAYINTHECONCEPTUALANDMETHODOLOGICALISSUES THEYRAISE #HAPTER*OHN3ELSKYAND*OSEPH-C#ANN STARTSTHISSECTIONBYEXPLORING
THEDISRUPTIVEASPECTOFCHANGEINCONTEXTUALTURBULENCE4HEYEXAMINEKEYFEATURES ANDTYPESOFDISRUPTIVENESSANDFOCUSINONCONTEXTUALDISRUPTIONASKEYTOCOPING WITHTURBULENTCONDITIONS4HEAUTHORSPROPOSEASHIFTINTHINKINGABOUTCHANGE FROMVIEWINGDISRUPTIONASADEVIATIONFROMNORMALCYOREQUILIBRIUMTOVIEWING ITASANORMALCONDITIONOFORGANIZATIONALLIFE4HEYCALLFORA@CONTINUOUSCHANGE MODELSEARCHFOREMERGENCEANDIMPROVIZATIONANDCOLLABORATIONBASEDONA NETWORKEDlELDMODELOFTHEORGANIZATION3ELSKYAND-C#ANNSEEANIMPORTANT ROLEFORSCENARIOSINDEVELOPINGTHEIMPROVIZATIONSKILLSOFTHEORGANIZATION4HEY SUGGESTTHATENVISIONINGTHEPOSSIBILITYOFFUTUREDISRUPTIVECHANGECANGALVANIZE
STAKEHOLDERSTOCREATEFOSTERORSTRENGTHENCOMMONGROUNDASTHEBASISFORAMORE PROSPEROUSFUTURE #HAPTER 2AFAEL2AMIREZ EXAMINESCLARITYANDAESTHETICS IN SCENARIO
PRACTICES(EFOCUSESONHOWATTENDINGTO@CLARITY INTHEPROCESSOFSCENARIO BUILDINGHELPSTOFOSTERTHECREATIONOFCOMMONGROUND#LARITYISANAESTHETIC QUALITYORASPECTOFSCENARIOPRACTICES2AMIREZARGUESTHATAESTHETICJUDGEMENTSIN SCENARIOWORKCOMEPRIORTOFORGINGCOMMONGROUNDANDINDEEDAREANECESSARY PRECONDITIONTOIT(EREPORTSTHERESULTSOFANEXPLORATORYWORKSHOPTOASSESSTHE ROLEOFAESTHETICSINSCENARIOWORK(ECONCLUDESBYSUGGESTINGTHATATTENDING EXPLICITLYTO@CLARITYASANORGANIZINGPRINCIPLEINSCENARIOWORKHELPSTOENGAGE WITHTHEUNCERTAINTYOFTURBULENTCONDITIONS #HAPTER'EORGE"URT USESTHECASEOFASCENARIOPROJECTFORANENGINEERING
ORIGINALEQUIPMENTMANUFACTURERSERVINGTHE5+POWERINDUSTRYTOEXPLORE HOWSCENARIOPRACTICESCANHELPTHEMANAGEMENTTEAMOFSUCHACOMPANYTO UNDERSTANDPOSSIBLEFUTURECONTEXTSOF5+POWERGENERATION(ESHOWSHOWTHE EXISTINGCONTEXTOFDE REGULATIONCARRIESTHESEEDSOFINCREASINGPOWERSHORTAGES ANDBLACKOUTS(EFOCUSESONHOWSCENARIOWORKHELPSTOASSESSTHEPREDETERMINED ELEMENTSINANENVIRONMENTTHATWILLPLAYOUTINALLPLAUSIBLECONDITIONSANDHOW ATTENDINGTOTHISASPECTOFSCENARIOMETHODSENABLESTURBULENCETOBEADDRESSED #HAPTER3HIRIN%LAHI HIGHLIGHTSHOWIMPORTANTITISTOATTENDTOTHEISSUES
OFFAIRNESSANDEQUITYAMONGTHESTAKEHOLDERSESPECIALLYINHIGHLYCOMPLEXINTER ORGANIZATIONALLYSPONSOREDSCENARIOINITIATIVES#OLLABORATIONSUNDERCONDITIONS OFHIGHUNCERTAINTYREQUIREUNDERSTANDINGOFGENERALLYACCEPTEDPRINCIPLESOF FAIRNESSTOGENERATECONlDENCETHATEVENIFTHINGSTURNOUTDIFFERENTLYFROMWHAT ISFORESEEABLEEQUITYAMONGSTAKEHOLDERSWILLBEMAINTAINED3HESUGGESTSTHAT FAILURETOATTENDTOPOWERANDFAIRNESSWILLCOMPROMISETHECOHERENCEOFTHE COLLABORATIONANDTHEREFORETHEEFFECTIVENESSOFSCENARIOPRACTICES 4HElNALCHAPTERIN0ART)))#HAPTER!NDROMACHE!THANASOPOULOU
TAKESTHISASTEPFURTHERBYCOMPARINGTWOCASESTUDIESINTHETOBACCOANDUTILITY INDUSTRIESWHERETOPMANAGEMENTTEAMSESPOUSEDEXPLICITSTRATEGIESON#ORPORATE 3OCIAL2ESPONSIBILITY#32 ANDSTAKEHOLDERRESPONSIVENESS3HESITUATES#32 ASASTABILIZINGMECHANISMTOPRODUCE@COMMONGROUNDAMONGAlRMANDITS VARIOUSSTAKEHOLDERSHELPINGTOADDRESSANDMITIGATEENVIRONMENTALTURBULENCE 7HILENEITHERCOMPANYSTUDIEDACTUALLYUSEDSCENARIOSTHEAUTHORARGUESTHATTHE EFFECTIVENESSOFBOTHCOMPANIES#32STRATEGIESWOULDHAVEBEENSTRENGTHENEDIF SCENARIOSHADBEENDEPLOYEDBYTHESECOMPANIES)NTURNTHISPOINTSTOHOW#32 MAYBESTRENGTHENEDINTHEFUTUREANDHOWSCENARIOPRACTICESMAYBEINFORMED BYA#32AGENDA 0ART)6SUMMARIZESINTWOCHAPTERSBYTHEEDITORSTHETHEMESOFTHEBOOK
SURFACESSEVERALHIDDENTHEMESANDOFFERSSUGGESTIONSFORFUTUREPROSPECTSAND TRAJECTORIESFORRESEARCHONTURBULENCEANDSCENARIOPRACTICE
#HAPTERWITH!NGELA7ILKINSON ISTHENEWCHAPTERONTHERECENTlNANCIAL CRISIS7EHAVEDELIBERATELYPLACEDITHEREFORITBUILDSONINSIGHTSOFTHEPRECEDING ONESANDILLUSTRATESINTERMSOFTHISUNFOLDINGCRISISMANYOFTHEPOINTSMADE WHENRELATINGCAUSALTEXTURESTHEORYANDSCENARIOWORK7EARGUETHATDECISION MAKERSNEEDTOMAKEUSEOFSCENARIOSINORDERTONAVIGATESUCHCRISESEFFECTIVELY 7ETHINKTHEKEYCONTRIBUTIONOFTHISCHAPTERISTOIDENTIFYFORDECISIONMAKERS HELPFULWAYSTOUSESCENARIOSINTHEIRPLANNINGBASEDONPLAUSIBILITIES RATHERTHAN UNHELPFULANDEVENDANGEROUSWAYSTOUSESCENARIOSBASEDONPROBABILITIES &INALLY#HAPTERINCLUDESREmECTIONONISSUESSUCHASTHEPERCEIVEDVS
OBJECTIVENATUREOFTURBULENCETHEWAYINWHICHTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT GAINSSALIENCEOVERTHETRANSACTIONALONEOVERWHELMINGMANAGERSANDOTHER STAKEHOLDERSHOWSCENARIOWORKMAKESSENSEOFSUCHCONDITIONSANDCONTRIBUTES TOACLEARERDElNITIONOFCAUSALTEXTURESTHEORYANDDILEMMASANDCHALLENGESIN FORGINGCOMMONGROUNDANDDEPLOYINGITTOCOPEWITHTURBULENCE 7EENDBYHIGHLIGHTINGSOMEOUTSTANDINGISSUESTHATEITHERAROSEORBECAME
CLARIlEDFROMTHEMATERIALINTHECHAPTERS&OREXAMPLETHEREISTHEQUESTION OFHOWWECANWRITEABOOKABOUTADDRESSINGTURBULENCEWHILEITRESIDESINTHE CONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTWHEREACTORSBYDElNITIONHAVENODIRECT INmUENCE 4HISISTHESOCIALECOLOGYEQUIVALENTOFTHEDESIGNVSEVOLUTIONDILEMMATHATIS CURRENTLYBEINGDEBATEDINBOTHBIOLOGYANDRELIGION)TISAQUESTIONOFLEVELS HOWDOESTHEINDIVIDUALACTORRELATETOEMERGENTOUTCOMESATTHElELDLEVEL -OREGENERALLYHOWAREWETOLINKTHEMACROANDTHEMICROLEVELDESCRIPTIONS OFAPARTICULARlELD/URSOLUTIONISTODRAWONCOMPLEXITYTHEORYWHICHRELATES VERYSMALLmUCTUATIONSTOVERYLARGESTRUCTURALCHANGEWHENTHESYSTEMISATTHE @EDGEOFCHAOSORA@TIPPINGPOINTORIN0RIGOGINESTERMSABIFURCATIONPOINT SEE#HAPTER 4HEPATIENTREADERATTHEENDOFTHISBOOKWILLSEETHATTHISISSUE ISNOTMERELYANABSTRACTCONCEPTUALONEBUTINSTEADONETHATHASIMPORTANT METHODOLOGICALIMPLICATIONSFORSCENARIOPRACTITIONERS ,ETTHECONVERSATIONCONTINUE
