ABSTRACT

Socrates: Tat2 Ho8ab P 6oCo 6. " o Gag Yalo dCal Fa "shsF gh F6sh Fsl o7 530 )Cal GagC 6al o st 0 A6ohgh7

Socr aot tai 1a YC.Fohb )Cal 0 Ase.gCghi dCal F6o dohFs".8 ad 2 hY8oAsghb Socrates: 3 at4 F Fo88 l o F6o 0 Ase.gCs.th 6a8e . YatFohF daC rhapsodes st

6ataC ad F6o Dae7 Socr 5 6oG YoCF. st8G ea2 5 6oG ea sF daC o" oCG haCF ad AaoFCG . te l ghsYb Socrates: 6o . 88G2 3 se Gag otFoC F6o YatFohF7 2 te 6ac ese sF Da daC Gag7 Socr ) sChF ACs7 oi 1a YC.Foh2 P o Y.CCsoe sF addb p Socrates: 56 .F4h Daae Fa 6o. Cb P o8i 8oF4h hoo F6. F co cst F6o D.l oh . F

2F6 othi to: Fb Socr P o488 ea sFi 1a YC.Fohi Dae cs8stDb Socrates: 8ag 4taci Tati l. tG Fsl oh T4"o ot" soe Gag C6.Ahaeoh GagC

ACadohsatb ,6 GhsY.88Gi sF sh . 8c.Gh dsFFstD daC Gag st GagC ACadohhsat Fa po eCohhoe gA Fa 8aa4 . h po.gFsdg8 . h Gag Y. t9 . te . F F6o h.l o Fsl o sF sh toYoh.CG daC Gag Fa po . F caC4 csF6 AaoFh: l.tG dsto atohi . te csF6 HaloC .p a"o . 88i c6 a4h F6o pohF AaoF . te F6o l ahF es"sto: .t e Gag 6. " o Y Fa 8o. Ct 6sh F6agD6Fi taF ;ghF 6sh " oChoh2 Sac F6. F sh haloF6stD Fa ot" G2 T l o.t i ta ato cag8e o"oC DoF Fa po . Daae C6. Ahaeo sd 6o eset4F gteoChF.te c6 .F sh l o.tF pG F6o AaoFb 2 C6.Ahaeo l ghF Yal o Fa ACohotF F6o AaoF4h F6agD6F Fa 6sh .gesotYo9 . te 6o Y.t4F ea F6.F po.gFsdg88G gt8ohh 6o 4tach c6 .F F6o AaoF l o. thb 1a F6sh . 88 eohoC"oh Fa po ot" soeb

Socr 56 .F4h FCgoi 1 aYC.Fohb 2 te F6.F4h F6o A.CF ad lG ACadohhsat F6.F Faa4 F6o l ahF caC4b T F6st4 T hAo.4 l aCo po.gFsdg88G F6.t .t Gato o8ho .p agF Hal oC9 tosF6oC <o FCaeaCgh ad r.lAh.Ygh taC 1FohslpCaFgh ad 56.hah taC e =8 .gYat taC . tGato o8ho A.hF aC ACohotF Yag8e adoC . h l .t G po.gFsdg8 F6agD6Fh .p agF HaloC . h T Y. tb

Socrates: 56. F4h Daae Fa 6o. Ci Tatb 1gCo8G Gag cat4F poDCgeDo l o . eolathFC.Fsat7

Socr 6o. 88Gi 1a YC.Fohi sF4h caCF6 6o.CstD 6ac co88 T4 " o DaF HaloC eCohhoe gAb T F6st4 T4 l caCF6G Fa po YCactoe pG F6o 1a th ad HaloC5 csF6 . Da8eot YCactb

n3

531 Socrates: 6 o.88Gi T h6.88 l .4 o Fslo Fa 6o.C F6.F 8.FoCb Sac T4e ;ghF 8s4o . t .thcoC Fa F6sh> 2Co Gag ha cateoCdg88G Y o"oC .p agF HaloC .8ato: aC . 8ha .pagF Hohsae . te 2CY 6s8aY6gh7

Io n : N o, tab ?t8G .p agF HaloCb 56 . F4h Da e otagD6i I F6st4b Socrates: Is F6oCo .t G hgp;oYF at c6sY6 HaloC . te Hohsae paF6 h.G

F6o h.lo F6stDh7 Socr 8o hi T F6st4 hab 2 Da e l . tGb Socrates: 5 6oti at F6aho hgp;oYFhi cag8e Gag o:A8.st HaloC4h " oCho

poFFoC .t e laCo po.gFsdg88G F6. t Hohsae4h7 p Io n : 8ghF F6o h.lo 1aYC.Fohi at F6aho hgp;oYFhi .tGc. Gi c6oCo F6oG h.G

F6o h.lo F6stDhb Socrates: 2t e 6ac .p agF F6o hgp;oYFh at c6sY6 F6oG ea taF h.G F6o

h.lo F6stDh7 3 s"st.Fsati daC o:. l A8ob HaloC h.Gh haloF6stD .p agF sF . te ha eaoh Hohsaeb

Soc r 0 oCF. st8Gb Socrates: P o8b 5 .4o .88 F6o A8.Yoh c6 oCo F6aho Fca AaoFh hAo.4 ad

es"st.Fsati paF6 c6oCo F6oG . DCoo .t e c6oCo F6oG eat4F> c6 a cag8e o:A8.st F6aho poFFoC .t e l aCo po.gFsdg88Gi Gagi aC ato ad F6o es"stoCh sd 6o4h Daae7

Socr ? to ad F6o es"stoChb Socrates : 1g AAaho you coCo . es"stoC> sd Gag coCo Co.88G .p8o Fa o:A8.st

F6o A8.Yoh c6 oCo F6o Fca AaoFh .DCo i cag8et4F Gag .8ha 4tac 6ac Fa o:A8.st F6o A8.Yoh c6oCo F6oG esh.DCo7

Io n : 56. F4h Y8o. Cb c Socrates : 56ot c6. F st F6o caC8e sh sF F6.F Gag4Co Y8o"oC .pagF st HaloC

pgF taF st Hohsae .t e F6o aF6oC AaoFh7 3 aoh HaloC hAo.4 ad .tG hgp;oYFh F6.F esddoC dCal F6aho ad all F6o aF6oC AaoFh7 3 aoht4F 6o l.s t8G Da F6CagD6 F.8oh ad c. Ci .t e ad 6ac AoaA8o eo.8 csF6 o.Y6 aF6oC st haYsoFG:Daae AoaA8o .t e p. ei aCest.CG da84h . te YC.dFhlot7 2t e ad F6o Daehi 6ac they eo.8 csF6 o.Y6 aF6oC .te csF6 l ot7 2t e eaoht4F 6o CoYagtF c6. F 6.AAoth

e st 6o."ot .t e st 6o88i . te Fo88 ad F6o psCF6h ad Daeh . te 6oCaoh7 56aho . Co F6o hgp;oYFh ad HaloC4h AaoFCG@l. 4stDi . Cot4F F6oG7

Soc r 56. F4h FCgoi 1 aYC.Fohb Socrates: 2te 6ac .pagF F6o aF6oC AaoFh7 3 se F6oG cCsFo at F6o

h.l o hgp; oYFh7 Soc r 8 ohi pgF 1aYC.Fohi F6oG eset4F ea sF F6o c.G HaloC eseb Socrates: Haci F6ot7 Pa Cho7 Soc r < gY6 c aChob Socrates : 2t e HaloC eaoh sF poFoC7 Socr Really poFFoCb Socrates : Po88 taci Tati eo.C 6o.CFi c6ot . tglpoC ad AoaA8o . Co

eshYghhstD .CsF6loFsYi .t e ato ad F6ol hAo.4h pohFi T hgAAaho someone cs88 o 4tac 6ac Fa AsY4 agF F6o Da e hAo.4 oCb

Soc r 8 ohb Socrates : P s88 sF po F6o h.lo AoChat c6a Y.t AsY4 agF F6o p.e hAo.4oChi

aC haloato o8ho7

Socr 5 6o h. l oi ad YagChob Socrates: 2t e F6. F cs88 po haloato c6a 6. h l .hFoCoe .CsF6loFsYi

CsD6F7 Socr 8o hb So crates: P o8b 1g AAaho . tglp oC ad AoaA8o . Co eshYgh stD 6o.8F6G

tgFCsFsati . te ato ad F6ol hAo.4 h pohFb Ps88 ato AoChat 4tac F6.F F6o pohF hAo.4 oC hAo. 4h pohFi . te .taF6oC F6.F . t stdoCsaC hAo.4oC hAo.4h caCho7 ? C cs8 F6o h.l o l. t 4tac paF67

Socr ? p"sagh8Gi F6o h.l o l . tb Socrates: P 6a sh 6o7 P6.F ea co Y. 88 6sl 7 Socr 2 eaYFaCb eos:5 31I r 1a i Fa hgl sF gAi F6sh sh c 6. F c o4 Co h.GstD> c 6ot . tgl poC

ad AoaA8o hAo. 4 at F6o h.l o hgp; oYFi sF4 h . 8c. Gh F6o h. l o AoChat c 6a c s88 I3n 4tac 6ac Fa AsY4 agF Daae hAo. 4oCh . te p. e hAo. 4oChb Td 6o eaoht4 F 4tac 6ac Fa AsY4 agF . p. e hAo. 4oCi 6o YoCF. st8G c at4 F 4tac . Daae hAo. 4oC: at F6o h. l o hgp; oYFi . tGc . Gb

Socr 5 6 . F4h hab Socrates: 56 ot sF FgCth agF F6. F F6o h.l o AoChat sh Aca teoCdg88G Y8o"oCA

. pagF paF6 hAo. 4oChb Socr 8 ohb Socrates: Sac you Y8.sl F6.F HaloC . te F6o aF6oC AaoFh B stY8gestD

Hohsae . te 2CY 6s8aY6ghC hAo.4 at F6o h.l o hgp;oYFhi pgF taF oD g.88G co88b He's Daaei .t e F6oG4 Co stdoCsaCb

Socr 8 ohi . te sF4h FCgob Socrates: Sac sd Gag Co.88G ea 4tac c6 a4h hAo.4stD co8i Gag488 4tac p

F6.F F6o stdoCsaC hAo.4oCh . Co hAo.4stD caChob Socr 2 AA. CotF8G hab Socrates: 8 ag4Co hgAoCp2 So sd co h.G F6. F Tat sh oD g.88G Y8o"oC . pagF

HaloC . te F6o aF6oC AaoFhi c o488 l. 4o ta l shF.4ob E oY.gho Gag . DCoo GagCho8d F6. F F6o h.l o AoChat cs88 po . t . eoD g.Fo ;geDo ad . 88 c6a hAo.4 at F6o h.l o hgp;oYFhi . te F6.F .8lahF . 88 F6o AaoFh do FCo.F F6o h.l o hgp;oYFhb

Tat> 5 6ot 6ac st F6o caC8e ea Gag o:A8.st c6. F I eai 1 aYC.Foh7 P 6ot haloato eshYgh oh .taF6oC AaoF T A.G ta .FFotFsati . te T 6. " o ta AacoC c Fa YatFCspgFo .t GF6stD caCF6c6s8o> T hslA8G ea7 o addb E gF 8oF haloato lotFsat HaloC . te CsD6F .c .G T4l cseo .c . 4o . te T4l A.GstD .FFotFsat .t e T 6. "o A8otFG Fa h. Gb

Socrates: That's taF 6. Ce Fa dsDgCo agFi lG dCsoteb 2t Gato Y. t Fo88 F6. F Gag . Co AacoC8oh Fa hAo.4 .p agF HaloC at F6o p.hsh ad 4tac8oeDo aC l . hFoCGb E oY.gho sd GagC .ps8sFG Y. l o pG l .hFoCGi Gag cag8e po .p 8o Fa hAo.4 .p agF .88 F6o aF6oC AaoFh . h co88b raa4i F6oCo sh . t . CF ad AaoFCG . h . c6a8oi sht4 F F6oCo7

Socr 8 ohb Socrates: 2 te tac F.4o F6o c6a8o ad any aF6oC hgp; oYF> cat4F sF 6. " o e

F6o h.l o eshYsA8sto F6CagD6agF7 2t e F6sh Daoh daC o"oCG hgp;oYF F6. F Y. t po l . hFoCoeb 3 a Gag tooe l o Fa Fo88 Gag c6. F T l o.t pG F6shi Tat7

Socr raCei Gohi T eai 1a YC. Fohb T 8a"o Fa 6o.C Gag csho l ot F. 84b

So crates: T csh6 F6. F coCo FCgoi Tatb E gF csho7 1g Co8G ag . Co F6o csho o loti Gag C6.Ahaeoh .t e .YFaChi Gag .te F6o AaoFh c6aho caC4 Gag hstDb

2 h daC l oi T h.G taF6stD pgF F6o FCgF6i . h Gag4e o:AoYF dCal . t aCest.CG l . tb T l o.ti o"ot F6sh DgohFsat T .h4oe Gag: 8aa4 6ac YallatA8.Yo .t e aCest.CG . l. FFoC sF shb 2tGpa eG Yag8e gteoChF.te c6.F T l o.t F> eat4F Gag gho F6o h.lo eshYsA8sto F6CagD6agF c6 oto"oC Gag l.hFoC F6o c6a8o ad . hgp; oYF7 5 .4o F6sh daC eshYghhsat:A.stFstD sh . hgp;oYF Fapo l.hFoCoe . h . c6a8oi sht4 F sF7

Socr 8o hb Socrates: 2 te F6oCo .Co l.t G A.stFoChi Da e .t e p.e i .t e F6oCo 6. " o

poot l.t G st F6o A. hFb Soc r 0 oCF. st8Gb

533 Socrates: H." o Gag o"oC 4tact .tGato c6a sh Y8o"oC . F h6acstD c6. F4h co88 A.stFoe . te c6. F4h taF st F6o caC4 ad ,a8GDtaFghi pgF c 6a4h AacoC8oh Fa ea F6.F daC aF6oC A.stFoCh7 1alo ato c6a ea7oh ad c6ot F6o caC4 ad aF6oC A.stFoCh s eshA8.Goei . te sh 8ahFi . te 6. h taF6stD Fa YatFCspgFo: pgF c6ot 6o 6. h Fa Ds"o ;geDlotF at ,a8GDtaFgh aC . tG aF6oC A.stFoC B ha 8atD . h sF4h ;ghF one), 6o4h cseo .c .4o .t e 6o4h A.GstD .FFotFsat . te 6o 6.h A8otFG Fa h.G: 6. "o Gag o"oC 4tact .t Gato 8s4o F6.F7

Socr =a ae 8aCe tai ad YagCho taF2 Socrates : P o8b 5.4 o hYg8AFgCob H."o Gag o"oC 4tact .tGato c6a sh

p Y8o"oC .F o:A8.ststD c6sY6 hF.Fgoh . Co co88 l.e o st F6o Y.ho ad 3.o e. 8ghi hat ad <oFsati aC 0 Aosghi hat ad ,.taAoghi aC 56oaeaCgh ad 1.l ahi aC . tG aF6oC single hYg8AFaCi pgF c6a4h 8ahF c6ot 6o4h .la tD F6o ACaegYFh ad aF6oC hYg8AFaChi .t e 6o ea7 oh add .t e 6. h taF6stD Fa h. G7

Socr =aa e 8aCe tab T 6." ot4Fb S o c ra te s : 2t e dgCF6oCi sF sh lG aAstsati Gag4" o to"oC 4tact . tGato

o"oC: taF st d8gFo@A8.GstDi taF st YsF6. C.@A8.GstDi taF st hstDstD Fa F6o YsF6.C.i .t e taF st C6.Ahaes7stD:Gag4" o to"oC 4tact . l.t c6a sh Y8o"oC

c . F o:A8.ststD ?8G lAgh aC 5 6.l GCgh aC ? A6 ogh aC ,6olsghi F6o C6.Ahaeo dCal TF6.Y.i pgF c6a 6. h taF6stD Fa YatFCspgFo .p agF Tati F6o C6.Ahaeo dCal 0A 6ohghi . te Y.ttaF Fo88 c6ot 6o eaoh 6sh caC4 co88 . te c6ot 6o eaoht4F: Gag4" o to"oC 4tact . l.t 8s4o F6. Fb

Socr T 6. "o taF6stD Fa h.G .D.sthF Gag at F6.F AastFi 1a YC.Fohb EgF this T 4tac .p agF lGho8d> T hAo.4 .p agF HaloC laCo po.gFsdg88G F6.t .tGpaeG o8ho . te T 6. " o 8aFh Fa h.G9 .t e o"oCGpaeG h.Gh T ea sF co88b EgF .pagF F6o aF6oC AaoFh T ea taFb Sac ho c6. F F6.F l o. thi

e S o c ra te s : T ea hooi Tati . te T4l DastD Fa .ttagtYo Fa Gag c6.F T F6st4 F6.F shb 2 h T h. se o.C8soCi F6.F4h taF . hgp;oYF Gag4" o l.hFoCoe:hAo.4stD co88 .pagF HaloC9 sF4h . es"sto AacoC F6.F la"oh Gagi . h . A< . DtoFsYA hFato la"oh sCat CstDhb B56 .F4h c6.F 0gCsAseoh Y.88oe sF9 lahF AoaA8o Y.88 sF A HoC.Y8s. tbAC n 56 sh hFato taF at8G Ag8h F6aho CstDhi sd F6oG4Co sCati sF

e .8ha AgFh AacoC in F6o CstDhi ha F6. F F6oG st FgCt Y.t ea ;ghF c6.F F6o

hFato eaoh: Ag88 aF6oC CstDh:ha F6. F F6oCo4h aloFsloh . "oCG 8atD Y6.st ad sCat AsoYoh . te CstDh 6. tDstD dCal ato .t aF6oCb 2t e F6o AacoC st . 88 ad F6ol eoAoteh at F6sh hFatob Tt F6o h.l o c.Gi F6o <g ho l. 4oh hal o AoaA8o sthAsCoe 6oCho8di . te F6ot F6CagD6 F6aho c6a . Co sthAsCoe . Y6.st ad aF6oC otF6ghs.hFh sh hghAoteoeb 8ag 4taci tato ad F6o oAsY AaoFhi sd F6oG4Co Daei . Co l .hFoCh ad F6osC hgp; oYF9 F6oG . Co sthAsCoei Aah ohhoei .t e F6. F sh 6ac F6oG gFFoC . 88 F6aho po.gFsdg8 Aaol hb 56 o h.l o Daoh daC 8GCsY AaoFh sd F6oG4Co Daae> ;ghF . h F6o 0aCGp.tFoh .Co taF st F6osC sD6F 534 l steh c6ot F6oG e. tYoi 8GCsY AaoFhi Faai . Co taF st F6osC CsD6F lsteh c6ot F6oG l .4 o F6aho po.gFsdg8 8GCsYhi pgF . h haat . h F6oG h.s8 stFa 6.ClatG .te C6GF6l F6oG . Co Aahohhoe pG E .YY6sY dCot7 Gb GghF .h E. YY6gh caCh6sAAoCh3 c6ot F6oG . Co Aahohhoe eC.c 6atoG . te ls84 dCal Cs"oChi pgF taF c6ot F6oG .Co st F6osC CsD6F lsteh: F6o hag8 ad . 8GCsY AaoF eaoh F6sh Faai . h F6oG h.G F6olho8"ohb )aC ad YagCho AaoFh Fo88 gh F6. F F6oG D.F6oC hatDh . F p 6atoG@d8acstD hACstDhi dCal D8. eoh .t e D.Ceoth ad F6o <g hohi .t e F6. F F6oG po.C hatDh Fa gh . h pooh Y.CCG 6atoGi d8GstD 8s4o poohb 2t e c6. F F6oG h.G sh FCgob )aC . AaoF sh .t .sCG F6stDi cstDoe . te 6a8Gi .t e 6o sh taF . p8o Fa l. 4o AaoFCG gtFs8 6o poYaloh sthAsCoe . te Daoh agF ad 6sh l ste . te 6sh stFo88oYF sh ta 8atDoC st 6sl b 2 h 8atD . h . 6gl. t postD 6. h 6sh stFo88oYF st 6sh Aahohhsat 6o cs88 .8c.Gh 8.Y4 F6o AacoC Fa l. 4o AaoFCG aC hstD ACaA6oYGb 56oCodaCo poY.gho sF4h taF pG l.hFoCG F6.F F6oG l.4 o Y Aaol h aC h.G l.t G 8a"o8G F6stDh .pagF F6osC hgp;oYFh B . h Gag ea . pagF HaloCC: pgF poY.gho sF4h pG . es"sto DsdF: o.Y6 AaoF sh . p8o Fa YalAaho po.gFsdg88G at8G F6.F daC c6sY6 F6o < gho 6. h . Caghoe 6sl > ato Y. t ea esF6GC.l phi . taF6oC otYals.i ato Y. t ea e. tYo hatDhi . taF6oCi oAsYhi . te GoF . taF6oCi s.lp sYh9 . te o.Y6 ad F6ol sh caCF68ohh daC F6o aF6oC FGAoh ad AaoFCGb 8ag hooi sF4h taF l.hFoCG F6. F ot.p 8oh F6ol Fa hAo.4 F6aho " oChohi pgF . es"sto AacoCi hstYo sd F6oG 4toc 6ac Fa hAo.4 po.gFsdg88G at ato FGAo ad AaoFCG pG l.hFoCstD F6o hgp;oYFi F6oG Yag8e ea ha daC .88 F6o aF6oCh . 8hab 56. F4h c6G F6o Dae F.4oh F6osC stFo88oYF .c .G dCal F6ol c6ot 6o e ghoh F6ol . h 6sh hoC". tFhi . h 6o eaoh ACaA6oFh . te Dae8G es"stoChi ha F6. F co c6a 6o.C h6ag8e 4tac F6.F they . Co taF F6o atoh c6a hAo.4 F6aho " oChoh F6.F . Co ad hgY6 6sD6 ". 8goi daC F6osC stFo88oYF sh taF st F6ol > F6o Dae 6slho8d sh F6o ato c6a hAo.4 hi . te 6o Ds"oh "asYo F6CagD6 F6ol Fa ghb 56o pohF o"seotYo daC F6sh .YYagtFsh 5Gtt sY6gh dCal 06 .8Yshi c6a to"oC l .e o . Aaol .tGato cag8e F6st4 caCF6 lotFsatstDi except daC F6o AC.sho@hatD o"oCGato hstDhi .8lahF F6o l ahF po.gFsdg8 8GCsY@Aaol F6oCo shi . te hsl A8Gi . h 6o h.Gh 6slho8di A . t st"otFsat ad F6o <gh ohbA Tt F6sh l aCo o F6. t .t GF6stDi F6oti T F6st4i F6o Dae sh h6acstD ghi ha F6.F co h6ag8e po st ta eagpF .p agF sFi F6. F F6oho po.gFsdg8 Aaol h .Co taF 6gl .t i taF o" ot from 6gl. t postDhi pgF . Co es"sto . te dCal Daeh9 F6.F AaoFh . Co taF6stD pgF CoACohotF.Fs"oh ad F6o Daehi Aah ohhoe pG c6ao"oC Aahohhoh F6ol b 5 a

535 h6ac that, F6o Dae eo8spoC.Fo8G h.tD F6o lahF po.gFsdg8 8GCsY Aaol F6CagD6 F6o lahF caCF68ohh AaoFb 3 at4 F Gag F6st4 T4l CsD6Fi Tat7

Io n : raCe Gohi I YoCF.st8G eab 1a lo6ac Gag FagY6 lG hag8 csF6 GagC caCehi 1a YC.Fohi . te T ea F6st4 sF4h pG . es"sto DsdF F6.F Da e AaoFh . Co .p 8o Fa ACohotF F6oho Aaol h Fa gh dCal F6o Daehb

Socrates: 2 te Gag C6.Ahaeoh st FgCt ACohotF c6 .F F6o AaoFh h. Gb Io n : 56 .F4 h FCgo Faab Socrates: 1 a Gag FgCt agF Fa po CoACohotF.Fs"oh ad CoACohotF.Fs"ohb Socr H gsFo CsD6Fb

b Socrates: Ha8e ati Tat9 Fo88 l o F6shb 3 at4F 4ooA .t G hoYCoFh dCal me. P6ot Gag CoYsFo oAsY AaoFCG co88 .t e Gag 6. "o F6o lahF hFgttstD oddoYF at GagC hAoYF.FaChi osF6oC c6ot Gag hstD ad ?eGhhogh:6ac 6o 8o.AF stFa F6o eaaCc.Gi 6sh seotFsFG tac ap"sagh Fa F6o hgsFaChi . te 6o AagCoe agF .CCach . F 6sh dooF: aC c6ot Gag hstD ad 2Y 6s88oh Y6.CDstD . F HoYFaCi aC c6ot Gag hstD . AsFsdg8 oAshaeo .p agF 2t eCal.Y6o aC HoYgp. aC , Cs. l i

c . Co Gag . F F6.F Fslo st GagC sD6F lstei aC ea Gag DoF pohseo GagCho8d7 2t e eaoht4F GagC hag8i st sFh otF6ghs.hli po8so"o F6.F sF sh ACohotF . F6o .YFsath Gag eohYCspoi c6oF6oC F6oG4Co st TF6. Y. aC st 5CaG aC c6oCo"oC F6o oAsY .YFg.88G F.4oh A8.Yo7

Io n : P6.F . "s"se o:.l A8o Gag4" o Ds"ot l oi 1a YC.Foh2 T c at4F 4ooA hoYCoFh dCal you. rshFoti c6ot I Fo88 . h.e hFaCGi lG oGoh . Co dg88 ad Fo. Ch9 .t e c6ot T Fo88 . hFaCG F6.F4h dCsD6FotstD aC .c dg8i lG 6.sC hF.teh at ote csF6 do.C . te lG 6o.CF ;gl Ahi

d Socrates: Po88i Tati h6ag8e co h.G F6sh l. t sh st 6sh CsD6F lste . F Fsloh 8s4o F6oho> c6ot 6o4h . F dohFs" .8h aC Yo8opC.Fsathi .88 eCohhoe gA st d.tYG Y8aF6ohi csF6 Da8eot YCacthi .t e 6o cooAhi F6agD6 o4h 8ahF tato ad 6sh dstoCG: aC c6ot 6o4h hF.testD .la tD ls88sath ad dCsote8G AoaA8o .t e 6o4h dCsD6Fotoei F6agD6 ta ato sh gteCohhstD 6sl aC eastD 6sl .tG 6. Cl7 Th 6o st 6sh CsD6F lste F6ot7

Io n : raCe tai 1a YC. Fohb SaF . F . 88i Fa Fo88 F6o FCgF6b Socrates: 2t e Gag 4tac F6. F Gag 6."o F6o h.lo odoYFh at lahF ad

GagC hAoYF.FaCh Faai eat4F Gag7 e Ion: I 4tac "oCG co88 F6. F co eab I 8aa4 eact . F F6ol o"oCG Fslo dCal

gA at F6o CahFCgli . te F6oG4Co YCGstD .t e 8aa4stD FoCCsdsoei . te . h F6o hFaCsoh . Co Fa8e F6oG . Co ds88oe csF6 .l .7o l otFb 8ag hoo T lghF 4ooA lG csFh . te A.G Y8aho .FFotFsat Fa F6ol > sd T hF.CF F6ol YCGstDi I cs88 8.gD6 . h T F.4o F6osC l atoGi pgF sd they 8.gD6i T h6.88 YCG .F 6."s tD 8ahF l atoGb

Socrates: 2 te Gag 4tac F6.F F6sh hAoYF.FaC sh F6o 8.hF ad F6o CstDhi eat4F Gag: F6o atoh F6. F T h.se F.4o F6osC AacoC dCal o.Y6 aF6oC pG "sCFgo ad

536 F6o HoC.Y8s.t hFato I F6o l.D toFJ7 5 6o lsee8o CstD sh Gagi F6o C6.Ahaeo aC .YFaCi .t e F6o dsChF ato sh F6o AaoF 6sl ho8db 5 6o Dae Ag8h AoaA8o4h ag8h F6CagD6 . 88 F6oho c6oCo"oC 6o c.t Fhi 8aaAstD F6o AacoC eact dCal ato Fa .t aF6oCb 2te ;ghF . h sd sF 6gtD dCal F6. F hFatoi F6oCo4h .t otaClagh Y6.st ad Y6aC.8 e.t YoCh . te e.t Yo Fo.Y6oCh . te .hhshF.tF Fo.Y6oCh 6.t DstD add FaF6o hseoh ad F6o CstDh F6.F . Co hghAoteoe dCal F6o < ghob ?to AaoF

sh .FF.Y6oe Fa ato < ghoi .taF6oC Fa .taF6oC B co h.G 6o sh A Aah ohhoeiA p . te F6.F4h to. C otagD6i daC 6o sh held). )Cal F6oho dsChF CstDhi dCal F6o AaoFhi they . Co .FF.Y6oe st F6osC FgCt . te sthAsCoei hal o dCal ato AaoFi hal o dCal .t aF6oC> hal o dCal ? CA6oghi hal o dCal <g h.oghi .t e l .t G . Co Aah ohhoe .t e 6o8e dCal Hal oCb 8ag . Co ato ad themi Tati . te Gag . Co Aah ohhoe dCal Hal oCb 2 te c6ot .t Gato hstDh F6o caC4 ad .t aF6oC AaoFi Gag4Co .h8o A .t e Gag4Co 8ahF .p agF c6. F Fa h.G9 pgF c6ot .t G hatD ad F6.F AaoF sh hagteoei Gag . Co sll oes.Fo8G . c. 4oi GagC hag8 sh e. tYstDi c . te Gag 6. " o A8otFG Fa h. Gb 8ag ho sF4h taF poY.gho Gag4Co . l.hFoC ad 4tac8oeDo .pagF HaloC F6. F Gag Y.t h.G c6. F Gag h. Gi pgF poY.gho ad . es"sto DsdFi poY.gho Gag .Co Aahohhoeb 56. F4h 6ac sF sh csF6 F6o 0 aCGp.t@ Fohi c6a 6. " o h6.CA o. Ch at8G daC F6o hAoYsdsY hatD F6. F po8atDh Fa c6.Fo"oC Dae Aah ohhoh F6ol9 F6oG 6. " o A8otFG ad caCeh . te la"olotFh Fa Da csF6 that hatD9 pgF F6oG . Co D gsFo 8ahF sd F6o l ghsY sh esddoCotFb 56 .F4 h 6ac sF sh csF6 Gagi Tat> c6ot .t Gato l otFsath HaloCi Gag 6. " o A8otFG Fa h. Gi pgF sd 6o l otFsath F6o aF6oCh Gag . Co 8ahF9 . te F6o o:A8.t. Fsat ad F6shi daC e c6sY6 Gag .h4 lo: c6 G sF sh F6.F Gag 6. " o A8otFG Fa h.G .p agF HaloC pgF taF . pagF F6o aF6oCh:sh F6. F sF4h taF l. hFoCstD F6o hgp; oYFi pgF . es"sto DsdFi F6.F l .4 oh Gag . cateoCdg8 hstDoC ad HaloC4h AC. shohb

Socr 8 ag4Co . Dae hAo.4oCi 1a YC.Fohb 1F s88i T cag8e po .l .7o e sd Gag Yag8e hAo.4 co88 otagD6 Fa Yat"stYo l o F6. F T .l Aahhohhoe aC YC. 7 oe c6ot T AC.sho HaloCb T eat4F po8so" Gag4e F6st4 ha sd Gag 6o. Ce l o hAo.4 stD at Hal oCb

Socrates: 2 te I Co.88G ea c.t F Fa 6o. C Gagi pgF taF podaCo Gag .t hcoC e l o F6sh> at c6sY6 ad HaloC4h hgp;oYFh ea Gag hAo.4 c o887 T eat4 F hgAAaho Gag hAo.4 co88 at all ad F6ol b

Socr S eai 1a YC.Fohi po8so"o l oi at o"oCG hstD8o ato2 Socrates : 1 gCo8G taF at F6aho hgp;oYFh Gag 6. AAot Fa 4tac taF6stD

. pagFi o"ot sd HaloC eaoh hAo.4 ad F6ol b Socr 2 te F6oho hgp;oYFh HaloC hAo.4h adi pgF T eat4 F 4tac .pagF:

c6. F . Co F6oG7 Socrates: E gF eaoht4F HaloC hAo.4 .p agF ACadohhsat.8 hgp;oYFh st l.t G 537

A8.Yohi .t e h.G . DCo.F eo.87 06 .CsaF eCs"stDi daC o:.l A8oi T4 88 h6ac Gagi sd T Y. t CololpoC F6o 8stohb

Socr S ai T4 88 CoYsFo F6ol b T do Col ol poCb Socrates: 56 ot Fo8 l o c6. F SohFaC h. Gh Fa 6sh hat 2t Fs8aY6ghi c6ot

6o . e" shoh 6sl Fa F.4 o Y.Co . F F6o FgCtstD AahF st F6o 6aCho C.Yo F6oG 6o8e daC ,.FCaY8gh4 dgtoC. 8b

Socr A ro. tiA 6o h.Ghi

Lean yourself over on the smooth-planed chariot Just to the left of the pair. Then the horse on the right: p Goad him, shout him on, easing the reins with your hands. At the post let your horse on the left stick tight to the turn

So you seem to come right to the edge, with the hub Of your welded wheel. But escape cropping the stone .. b1

c Socrates: 56 .F4 h otagD6b P 6a cag8e 4tac poFFoCi Tati c6oF6oC HaloC hAo.4h YaCCoYF8G aC taF st F6oho A.CFsYg8.C "oChoh:. eaYFaC aC . Y6.CsaFoC7

Soc r 2 Y6. CsaFooCi ad YagChob Socrates: Is F6.F poY.gho 6o sh . l.hFoC ad F6.F ACadohhsati aC daC halo

aF6oC Co.hat7 Soc r a on TF4 h poY. gho 6 o4 h . l . hFoC ad sFb Socrates: 56ot Fa o.Y6 ACadohhsat . Dae 6. h DC.tFoe F6o .p s8sFG Fa 4tac

. YoCF.st dgtYFsatb T l o.ti F6o F6stDh t." sD.Fsat Fo.Y6oh gh: co c at4F 8o.Ct F6ol dCal loesYsto . h co88i cs88 co7

Io n : ? d YagCho taFb Socrates : 2t e F6o F6stDh l oesYsto Fo.Y6oh gh co c at4F 8o.Ct dCal .CY6s?