ABSTRACT

This volume includes original essays that examine the underexplored relationship between recognition theory and key developments in critical social epistemology. Its aims are to explore how far certain kinds of epistemic injustice, epistemic oppression, and types of ignorance can be understood as distorted varieties of recognition and to determine whether contemporary work on epistemic injustice and critical social epistemology more generally have significant continuities with theories of recognition in the Frankfurt School tradition. Part I of the book focuses on bringing recognition theory and critical social epistemology into direct conversation. Part II is devoted to analysing a range of case studies that are evocative of contemporary social struggles.

The essays in this volume propose answers to a number of thought-provoking questions at the intersection of these two robust philosophical subfields, such as the following: how well can different types of epistemic injustice be understood as types of recognition abuses? How useful is it to approach different forms of social oppression as recognition injustices and/or as involving epistemic injustice? What limitations do we discover in either or both recognition theory and the ever-expanding literature on epistemic injustice when we put them into conversation with each other? How does the conjunction of these two accounts bear on specific domains, such as questions of silencing?

Epistemic Injustice and the Philosophy of Recognition heralds new directions for future research that will appeal to scholars and students working in critical social epistemology, social and political theory, continental philosophy, and a wide range of critical social theories.

chapter |7 pages

Introduction

Starting the Conversation

part I|207 pages

Recognition Theory and Critical Social Epistemology in Conversation

chapter 1|25 pages

Two Interpretations of Social Disrespect

A Comparison between Epistemic and Moral Recognition

chapter 2|26 pages

A Fourth Order of Recognition?

Accounting for Epistemic Injustice in Recognition Theory

chapter 3|24 pages

Gadamer, Fricker, and Honneth

Testimonial Injustice, Prejudice, and Social Esteem

chapter 4|26 pages

Recognising Disempowerment

Taking the ‘Merely Experienced’ Seriously

chapter 5|24 pages

Gaslighting

Pathologies of Recognition and the Colonisation of Psychic Space

chapter 7|28 pages

Calling Recognition Bluffs

Structural Epistemic Injustice and Administrative Violence

part II|134 pages

Making Sense of Contemporary Social-Epistemic Struggles

chapter 9|37 pages

Commission to Inquire into Ireland's Mother and Baby Homes

An Epistemology of Ignorance

chapter 10|23 pages

Constitutional Law and Epistemic Injustice

Hate Speech, Stereotyping, and Recognition Harm

chapter 12|29 pages

The Problem of Recognition, Erasure, and Epistemic Injustice in Medicine

Harms to Transgender and Gender Non-Binary Patients – Why We Should Be Worried

chapter 13|25 pages

Epistemic Injustice and Misrecognition in the Sphere of Work

The Case of Women in Surgery