ABSTRACT

Basic to American political history has been a devotion to grassroots rule and a commitment to local units of government. This belief in government close to the people underlies the proliferation of incorporated municipalities over the past two hundred years. At the beginning of the twenty-first century the Federal Census Bureau reported a total of 19,429 municipalities in the United States, with more than a thousand each in Pennsylvania, Illinois, and Texas. This municipal fecundity is especially evident in metropolitan areas where an array of “heights,” “parks,” “woods,” and “hills” clutter the map and fragment the governance of each region. Los Angeles County alone is home to 88 municipalities with an additional 34 in adjacent Orange County. A multiplicity of municipal governments is one of the inescapable facts of American metropolitan life.

Though Americans have long extolled grassroots government as the essence of democracy, this devotion to local rule has enabled many people to further their own narrow interests, creating a metropolitan checkerboard of privilege. Some have exploited municipal incorporation to dodge taxes and others to escape regulations. A number of municipalities, however, were created to impose regulations that would exclude undesirable people or development. Too often municipal incorporation has proved a means by which Americans could evade their full responsibility for the ills burdening metropolitan areas. Suburban grassroots have grown deep and strong, impervious to concerns about the supposed “greater metropolitan good.”