ABSTRACT
Byron, Werner (1822); Edinburgh [Scots] Magazine, 2nd Series, XI (Dec. 1822), 688-694. This unknown reviewer seems to be identical not with “Jonathan Oldmixon” who reviewed The Liberal but with the reviewer of Sardanapalus. For example, on page 694 he quotes (from memory) part of the same speech in Hamlet III.iv that the reviewer of Sardanapalus quoted on p. 112 of that review.
