ABSTRACT

The starting point of the dispute between conceptualists and non-conceptualists resides in a number of related ­platitudes—largely shared on both sides—about how concepts are connected with thoughts and beliefs. For conceptualists, the functions concepts play in one's psychology aren't limited to thoughts and beliefs: the realm of the conceptual extends to perception and sensory awareness too. Many arguments take as their explicit target the view that perceptual experiences have a conceptual content (content conceptualism), but end up, if successful at all, discarding at most the view that such experiences are conceptual states (state conceptualism): there is, that is, a recurrent but illegitimate shift between content conceptualism and state conceptualism, the worry goes. Demonstrative concepts have proven a useful tool for conceptualists: one which helps escape a host of related objections about fine-grained experiences, and sheds some light on what concepts might be deployed in experience and how.