ABSTRACT

This book contains edited versions of thirty British legal cases involving accounting issues decided from 1849-1888. These cases are a valuable source of information about the development of accounting principles and practices in nineteenth-century Great Britain. The thirty cases show that the court decisions involved a rich variety of accounting issues. In some cases courts upset private contractual stipulations regarding accounting and dividend matters. In others, management was held to have used incorrect principles in computing profits. Whether or not a contract or management decision was upset, the courts often discussed at some length the principles that management should apply in the preparation of balance sheets or income statements. It is therefore obvious that in resolving issues of equity among participants in British companies, the courts were applying normative accounting principles.

chapter |4 pages

Burnes v. Pennell

9 English Reports 1181 (1849) House of Lords

chapter |1 pages

Ex Parte Spackman

41 English Reports 1228 (1849) Lord Chancellor — Court of Appeal

chapter |2 pages

Ex Parte Holme

22 L.J.Ch. Lord Chancellor — Court of Appeal

chapter |2 pages

Ex Parte Brockwell

26 L.J.Ch. 855 (1857) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |5 pages

Henry v. The Great Northern Railway Company

4 Kay & John. 1 (1857) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |2 pages

Corry v. The Londonderry and Enniskillen Railway Company

29 Beav. 263 (1860) Master of the Rolls — Chancery

chapter |18 pages

Bale v. Cleland

4 F. & F. 117 (1864) Civil Court

chapter |4 pages

Macdougall v. Jersey Imperial Hotel Co., Limited

2 Hem. & M. 528 (1864) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |2 pages

Binney v. the Ince Hall Coal and Cannel Company

35 L.J. Ch. Vice Chancel 363 (1866) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |11 pages

Bloxam V. Metropolitan Railway Company

L.R. 3 Ch. App. 337 (1868) Lord Chancellor—Court of Appeal

chapter |5 pages

Rishton v. Grissell

L.R. 5 Eq. 326 (1868) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |11 pages

Turquand v. Marshall

L.R. 6 Eq. 112 (1868) Master of the Rolls — Chancery 20 L.T. 766 (1869) Lord Chancellor — Court of Appeal

chapter |11 pages

Stringer's Case

20 L.T. 553 (1869) Vice Chancellor — Chancery L.R. 4 Ch; App. 475 (1869) Lord Justices — Court of Appeal

chapter |11 pages

Rance's Case

L. R. 6 Ch. App. 104 (1870) Lord Justices — Court of Appeal

chapter |6 pages

Mills v. Northern Railway of Buenos Ayres Company

L.R. 5 Ch. App. 621 (1870) Lord Chancellor — Court of Appeal

chapter |2 pages

Salisbury v. Metropolitan Railway Company (1)

20 L.T. 72 (1869) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |2 pages

Salisbury v. Metropolitan Railway Company (2)

22 L. T. 839 (1870) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |3 pages

Bardwell V. Sheffield Waterworks Company

L.R. 14 Eq.517 (1872) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |2 pages

Lord Rokeby v. Elliot

9 L. R. Ch. 685 (1878) Chancery

chapter |3 pages

Davison v. Gillies

16 L.R. Ch. 344, @ 347n. (1879) Master of the Rolls — Chancery

chapter |4 pages

Dent v. the London Tramways Company (Limited)

16 L.R. Ch. 344 (1881) Master of the Rolls — Chancery

chapter |19 pages

City of Glascow Bank v. Mackinnon

9 Court Session Cases, 4th Series, 535 (1882) Court of Sessions, Scot.

chapter |3 pages

Flitcroft'S Case

21 L.R. Ch. 519 (1882) Court of Appeal

chapter |5 pages

In Re Alexandra Palace Company

21 L.R. Ch.149 (1882) Chancery

chapter |3 pages

Lambert v. The Neuchatel Asphalte Company (Limited)

51 L.J. Ch.882 (1882) Vice Chancellor — Chancery

chapter |4 pages

In Re Prank Mills Mining Company

L.R. 23 Ch. 52 (1883) Court of Appeal

chapter |15 pages

In Re Oxford Benefit Building and Investment Society

35 L.R. Ch. 502 (1886) Chancery

chapter |2 pages

Midland Land and Investment Corporation, Limited

Unreported (Shorthand Reporter's notes in Palmer, Company Precedents, 1912, pp. 904–906), (1886), Chancery

chapter |14 pages

Leeds Estate, Building and Investment Company v. Shepherd

36 L.R. Ch. 787 (1887) Chancery

chapter |6 pages

Kehoe v. The Waterford and Limerick Railway Company

L.R. 21 (Ire.) Ch. 221 (1888) Master of the Rolls — Chancery