ABSTRACT
In an uncanny way, "The Concrete Sumo" demands a response. At the heart of the essay is an account of the author's first day of practice as a civil engineer. Describing what went on inside his head as he figured out what to do, the author reveals some of the springs of his action, as well as what he did, and how it turned out. It becomes clear why Broome has set aside Aristotle and his emphasis on good moral habits. The latter are useful, but to bring them to bear in an exigent situation, the agent uses a personal guide in imagination. Interestingly, the account encompasses emotional aspects, aspects that are commonly neglected. Broome seems to hold that doing what the person of good character would approve is right no matter what the outcome for anyone. This claim requires taking a great deal for granted.
