ABSTRACT
FUTUREITCANAPPEARTHATEVERYTHINGUNDERINVESTIGATIONISINTERCONNECTED)NA COMPLEXWORLDTHISINTERCONNECTEDNESSCANGENERATEASENSEOFUNCERTAINTY/NCE THISCONNECTEDNESSISPERCEIVEDITBECOMESDIFlCULTTOAPPLYSIMPLECAUSE AND EFFECTLOGICANDTOlNDEASY@SOLUTIONSORPATHWAYS3YSTEMSTHINKINGCANPROVIDE PROCESSESANDMETHODSTOCOPEWITHTHISCOMPLEXITY 4OBEA@SYSTEMSTHINKERISTORECOGNIZETHENEEDTOGIVEANACCOUNTOFTHE
WORLDASAPERCEIVEDHIERARCHYOFSYSTEMS)TISALSOTO@SETSOMECONSTRUCTEDABSTRACT WHOLESOFTENCALLEDhSYSTEMSMODELSv AGAINSTTHEPERCEIVEDREALWORLDINORDERTO LEARNABOUTIT#HECKLANDAND3CHOLESP 3YSTEMSTHINKINGISFAMILIARTOMANYSCENARIOPRACTITIONERSPARTICULARLYIN
THEIRQUESTTOUNDERSTANDDEEPSYSTEMICCHANGESINTHEENVIRONMENT(OWEVERTO DATEMUCHOFTHEUSEFULNESSOFASYSTEMSAPPROACHTOSCENARIOPRACTICEHASCOME FROMA@HARDPERSPECTIVETHATASSUMESSYSTEMSEXISTINTHEREALWORLDANDTHATTHEY CANBEDESCRIBEDOBJECTIVELY(ARDSYSTEMSTOOLSUSEDBYSCENARIOPRACTITIONERS INCLUDECAUSALLOOPDIAGRAMSTHATAREUSEDTOEXPLOREDRIVINGFORCESOFCHANGEAND SCENARIOLOGICSSEEFOREXAMPLEVANDER(EIJDEN
7HILE@HARDSYSTEMSTHINKINGTOOLSHAVETHEIRVALUEA@SOFTSYSTEMSPERSPECTIVE MAKESANOTHERCONTRIBUTIONBYPROPOSINGTHATHUMANACTIVITYSYSTEMSASERIES OFPURPOSEFULACTIVITIESTHATEXHIBITSEMERGENCE MAYEXISTINTHEREALWORLDBUT THEYEXISTONLYAS@NOTIONALSYSTEMSnTHATISTHEYONLYMAKESENSETHROUGHTHE PERSPECTIVESINTHESENSEOFWORLDVIEWSOR7ELTANSCHAUUNGEN OFTHEPERSONS DESCRIBINGTHEM4HEREFOREBYFOCUSINGONPERSPECTIVESORWORLDVIEWS33- OFFERSAN@ORGANIZEDWAYOFTACKLINGPERCEIVEDPROBLEMATICALSOCIAL SITUATIONS THROUGH LEARNING#HECKLANDAND0OULTERPXVnXVII ,EARNINGOCCURS WHENINDIVIDUALSBRINGTHEIRDIFFERENTWORLDVIEWSTOTHETABLECOMETOAPPRECIATE THOSEDIFFERENCESANDDEVELOPANEWSHAREDMEANINGANDAGREEONWAYSFORWARD THROUGHWHAT#HECKLANDCALLS@ACCOMMODATION#HECKLAND SUGGESTSTHAT THEENQUIRYPROCESSITSELFCANBEORGANIZEDASALEARNINGSYSTEM 4HEREISEVIDENCETHATSCENARIOPRACTICEANDTHE33-DEVELOPEDINPARALLEL
OVERTHELASTFOURDECADES(OWEVERWEARGUETHATTHEOPPORTUNITIESPRESENTED BYA@SOFTSYSTEMSPERSPECTIVEFORENHANCINGSCENARIOPRACTICEHAVENOTBEEN SUFlCIENTLYEXPLORED !SARESULTOFWORKINGTOGETHERONASCENARIOPROJECTWEREALIZEDTHEPOTENTIAL
THATLAYINTHEINTERSECTIONOFTHESETWOlELDSANDINVITED0ROFESSOR+EESVANDER (EIJDENAGLOBALLEADERINSCENARIOS0ROFESSOR0ETER#HECKLANDTHECREATOROFTHE SOFTSYSTEMSMETHODOLOGYAND*AAP,EEMHUIS'LOBAL"USINESS.ETWORK'". %UROPEANEXPERIENCEDPRACTITIONERWITHBOTHMETHODOLOGIESTOPARTICIPATEIN A$EEP#ONVERSATIONIN!USTRALIAINFULLDETAILSOFTHE$EEP#ONVERSATION CANBEFOUNDATWWWCBSCURTINEDUAUlLES$EEP#ONVERSATIONPDF 4HEAIMOF THECONVERSATIONWASTOEXPLORETHESYNERGIESASWELLASTHECOMMONALITIESAND DIFFERENCESBETWEENTHE33-ANDTHESCENARIOMETHODOLOGY-ANYOFTHEPOINTS DISCUSSEDINTHISCHAPTERDRAWINSPIRATIONFROMTHATMEETING )NEXPLORINGTHEBEARINGOF33-ONSCENARIOSINTHISCHAPTEROURCENTRAL
ARGUMENTISTHATASOFTSYSTEMSAPPROACHCONTRIBUTESTOSCENARIOPRACTICENOTBY TRYINGTODETERMINEHOWHUMANACTIVITYSYSTEMSOPERATEINTHEREALWORLDBUTBY APPLYINGSYSTEMSPRINCIPLESTOTHEWAYINWHICHWESTUDYTHEFUTUREWHILETAKING THEMULTIPLEPERSPECTIVESONTHATFUTUREASANOPPORTUNITYTOGENERATEALTERNATIVE PERCEPTIONSANDWAYSFORWARD 7ECOMMENCETHISCHAPTERBYOUTLININGTHEPARALLELEMERGENCEOFSCENARIO
PRACTICEANDSOFTSYSTEMSTHINKINGINPARTICULARTHE33-7ETHENPROCEEDTO OUTLINEAKEYOBSERVATIONFROMTHE$EEP#ONVERSATIONTHATPROVIDEDTHEIMPETUS FORTHEMOREDETAILEDEXPLORATIONOFHOWASOFTSYSTEMSPERSPECTIVECANINFORM SCENARIOPRACTICE7ETHENDISCUSSTHESEIDEASUNDERTHEHEADINGSOFSYSTEMS CONCEPTSANDTHEAPPLICATIONOF33-PROCESSESTOSCENARIOS&INALLYWESUMMARIZE THEINSIGHTSGENERATEDINRELATIONTOEACHPHASEOFASCENARIOPROJECT
4WOMAJORDEVELOPMENTSINTHElELDOFMANAGEMENTOCCURREDDURINGTHES ANDEARLYSTHATLEDTOASHIFTINTHEWAYINWHICHLONG TERMPLANNINGAND GENERALPROBLEM SOLVINGWEREAPPROACHED
Scenario practice and long-term business planning
4HElRSTDEVELOPMENTWASRELATEDTOTHEPERCEPTIONOFINCREASINGUNCERTAINTYAND COMPLEXITYINTHEENVIRONMENT7HENHIGHLEVELSOFUNCERTAINTYANDCOMPLEXITY PERSIST%MERYAND4RIST CHARACTERIZEDSUCHENVIRONMENTSASTURBULENT lELDSONEOFTHEFOUR@CAUSALTEXTURESOFTHEENVIRONMENTASDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTER 4HEEFFECTOFTURBULENCEFORMANAGERSISASENSETHATTHE@GROUNDISINMOTION WHICHISCAUSEDBYINTERACTIONSOFORGANIZATIONSASTHEYCOMPETEWITHEACHOTHER ANDFROMDEVELOPMENTSINTHEENVIRONMENTITSELFDRIVENBYINNOVATIONINTER DEPENDENCIESBETWEENECONOMICANDOTHERASPECTSOFSOCIETYETC -ANAGERS THEREFOREEXPERIENCEAGROSSINCREASEINTHEIRAREAOF@RELEVANTUNCERTAINTY%MERY AND4RIST )NSUCHASITUATIONSINGLE LINEFORECASTSWITHUNIQUEEND POINTPREDICTIONS
PREVALENT IN PLANNINGDURING THE S BECAMEPROBLEMATIC BECAUSE THEY PRESUMEDTHEENVIRONMENTWASCHARACTERIZEDBYAHIGHDEGREEOFCERTAINTYAND STABILITY4HISREALIZATIONASWELLASEMPIRICALEXPERIENCELEDTOTHEINTRODUCTION OFSCENARIOPRACTICESORIGINALLYDEVELOPEDBY+AHNANDOTHERSATTHE2!.$ CORPORATIONINTHE53ANDBY'ASTON"ERGERFORTHE&RENCHGOVERNMENT INTOALL KINDSOFORGANIZATIONSBYPEOPLESUCHAS7ACKAB )NTHISCONTEXT SCENARIOSPROVIDEDAWAYOFDEALINGMORECOMPREHENSIVELYWITHUNCERTAINTY /VERTIMEANUMBEROFSCENARIOPROCESSESANDSCHOOLSEVOLVED"RADlELDET
AL 4HETYPEOFSCENARIOPRACTICEREFERREDTOINTHISCHAPTERISPARTOFTHE SO CALLED@INTUITIVELOGICSSCHOOLBESTKNOWNTHROUGHTHEWORKOF2OYAL$UTCH 3HELLANDTHEWRITINGSOF7ACKAB VANDER(EIJDEN AND3CHWARTZ 4HEINTUITIVELOGICSAPPROACHEMPHASIZESTHEPARTICIPANTS OFTENMANAGERS ASTHEONESTODEVELOPTHESCENARIOSTENDSNOTTOUSEDETAILED COMPUTERMODELLINGANDWORKSWITHALLSCENARIOSTHATAREREGARDEDASEQUALLY PROBABLE"RADlELDETAL /NEOFTHEEARLIESTlNDINGSOF0IERRE7ACKINHISPIONEERINGWORKAT2OYAL
$UTCH3HELLWASTHATSCENARIOSHADTOCONNECTWITHMANAGERSASSUMPTIONSBELIEFS ANDCONCERNSFORTHEFUTUREINORDERTOBEOFREALUSETOTHEM)NOTHERWORDS SCENARIOPRACTICEHADTOIMPACTUPONTHEMENTALMODELSOFDECISION MAKERS!S HE7ACKAP WRITES
4HEMAINPOINTWEWANTTOMAKEINTHISCHAPTER ISTHATTHISCONCEPTOFTHE @MICROCOSMOFDECISION MAKERSINOURVIEWPARALLELEDTHEEMERGINGWORKOF0ETER #HECKLANDINHIGHLIGHTINGTHECONCEPTOFWORLDVIEWOR7ELTANSCHAUUNG INTHE 33-#HECKLANDDREWATTENTIONTOTHEFACTTHATMANAGERSACTFROMTHEIRMENTAL IMAGEORVIEWOFTHEWORLD&OREXAMPLETHEREMAYBEAPRISONINTHEREALWORLD BUTTOONESETOFCORRECTIONALOFlCIALSITISANINSTRUMENTOFRETRIBUTIONWHILE TOANOTHERITISAPLACEREDOLENTWITHPOTENTIALFORREHABILITATION%ACHSETOF OFlCIALSWILLMANAGETHEPRISONBASEDONTHEIRPARTICULARWORLDVIEW3IMILARLY 7ACKARGUEDTHATTHEMENTALIMAGETHATMANAGERSHOLDOFTHEFUTURESHAPESTHE STRATEGICDECISIONSTHEYMAKEANDTHATACORPORATESTRATEGICVIEWPOINTISESSENTIALLY THEIRSHAREDMENTALMODELS)TISTHUSCLEARTHATTHEINTUITIVELOGICSAPPROACHTO SCENARIOSWITHITSFOCUSONPERCEPTIONSANDTHESUBJECTIVEANDTACITKNOWLEDGEOF THEPARTICIPANTSPROVIDESMANYPHILOSOPHICALLINKSWITHSOFTSYSTEMSTHINKING
Soft systems thinking and problem structuring
!NOTHERMAJORDEVELOPMENTTHATOCCURREDINTHElELDOFMANAGEMENTDURING THESANDSWASTHEREALIZATIONTHATMANYORGANIZATIONALINDUSTRYAND POLICYISSUESWERE@WICKED2ITTELAND7EBBER @ILLSTRUCTURED-ITROFF AND%MSHOFF OR@MESSES!CKOFF )NTHESESITUATIONSSOLUTIONS CANNOTBEEASILYFOUNDBECAUSETHEREISALACKOFAGREEMENTABOUTTHENATUREOF THEPROBLEMLETALONETHESOLUTIONS)TISWITHINTHISCONTEXTTHATSOFTSYSTEMS THINKINGEMERGED 3OFTSYSTEMSTHINKINGWASPARTOFASECONDWAVEOFSYSTEMSTHINKINGTHAT
CHALLENGEDTHENOTIONTHATMODELSWERE@REPRESENTATIONSOFREALITYRATHERTHAN ASAIDSFORTHEDEVELOPMENTOFINTER SUBJECTIVEUNDERSTANDING-IDGLEY P 3OFTSYSTEMSTHINKERSSUCHAS#HECKLANDDECLAREDTHATSUCHAREDUCTIONIST SCIENTIlCAPPROACHTODEALINGWITHHUMANACTIVITYWASLESSTHANADEQUATEBECAUSE EACHINDIVIDUALHADTHEIROWNVIEWONWHATCONSTITUTESAPROBLEMSITUATION POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS ANDBARRIERS TO RESOLUTION4HEREFORE SYSTEMS AND THEIR OBJECTIVESCOULDNOTBETAKENASGIVEN/VERMANYYEARSTHROUGHWORKINGWITH HIS-ASTERSSTUDENTSINREAL LIFESITUATIONSININDUSTRYHEDEVELOPEDTHE33- PUBLISHINGEXTENSIVELYFROMTHESUPTOTHEPRESENTDAY
#HECKLANDALSOCHALLENGEDTHEASSUMPTIONTHATHUMANACTIVITYISGOAL SEEKING )NmUENCEDBY'EOFFREY6ICKERSSWORKHEADOPTEDTHEPREMISETHATTHEMAINTENANCE ANDCONSTANTBALANCINGOFRELATIONSHIPSINASYSTEMWASAMOREFRUITFULBASISFOR EXAMININGPROBLEM SOLVINGBEHAVIOURINORGANIZATIONS#HECKLANDGREATLYADMIRES 6ICKERSSWORKESPECIALLYHISIDEASONTHETHEORYOFAPPRECIATIVESYSTEMS6ICKERS CITEDIN#HECKLANDP EXPLAINSAPPRECIATIONAS@AMENTALEVALUATIVE ACTINWHICHCONmICTINGNORMSANDVALUESDETERMINEWHAThFACTSvARERELEVANT WHILSThFACTSvPERCEIVEDORENVISAGEDDEMANDATTENTIONBECAUSETHEYARESEENTO BERELEVANTTOPARTICULARNORMSANDVALUES4HUS33-PROVIDESWHAT#HECKLAND P CALLS@APRACTICALORCHESTRATIONOFTHEPROCESSOFAPPRECIATION 4HE33-ASSISTSWITHADDRESSING@WICKEDOR @ILL STRUCTUREDSITUATIONSBY
PLACINGDIFFERENTACTORSPERCEPTIONSORWORLDVIEWSABOUTTHEISSUEATTHEHEART OFITSENQUIRYANDWORKINGWITHTHESETHROUGHAPROCESSOFAPPRECIATION TO GENERATELEARNINGABOUTTHESITUATION)FANYTHINGAWARENESSOFTHE@WICKEDNESSOF MANYORGANIZATIONALANDPUBLICPOLICYCHALLENGESHASINCREASEDOVERTHEDECADES "OTHSCENARIOPRACTICEANDTHE33-OFFERWAYSOFADDRESSINGUNCERTAINTYTHEREBY ASSISTINGMANAGERSTODEALWITH@WICKEDISSUES
4HEOUTCOMEOFTHE$EEP#ONVERSATIONMENTIONEDINTHEINTRODUCTIONWASTHE IDENTIlCATIONOFCOMMONALITIESANDDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHEMETHODOLOGIESAS WELLASCHALLENGESTHATCOULDBEADDRESSEDBYUSINGTHEMTOGETHER)NPARTICULAR VANDER(EIJDENAND#HECKLANDUNDATED SUGGESTEDTHATSCENARIOSAREAPARTICULAR TYPEOFHUMANACTIVITYSYSTEMTHEPURPOSEOFWHICHISTOGENERATELEARNINGWHAT THEYCALLED@AhKNOWLEDGEMOBILIZINGvPROCESS6ANDER(EIJDENUNDATED ALSO POSITEDTHATASCENARIOPROJECTCANBEDESIGNEDASAPURPOSEFULHUMANACTIVITY SYSTEMUSING33-"YDOINGSOHESAYSTHEQUESTIONOFPURPOSEISPLACEDONTHE TABLEENABLINGMANAGERSANDPRACTITIONERSTOSEETHATASCENARIOPROJECTNEVER EXISTSONITSOWNANDTHEREFOREDOESNOTHAVEANINHERENTPURPOSE BUTALWAYSAS APARTOFABIGGERPROJECTSUCHASSTRATEGIZINGWHICHHASABUILT INPURPOSESUCH ASSURVIVALANDGROWTH 4HESEINSIGHTSHADNOTBEENPREVIOUSLYEXPRESSED4HEYREPRESENTEDAUSEFUL
CONCEPTUALDEVELOPMENTTHATCOULDLINKTWOIMPORTANTMANAGERIALINTERVENTIONS FORCOPINGWITHWICKEDISSUES"ASEDONTHESEINSIGHTSANDFURTHERRESEARCHWE WENTONTOEXAMINETHEAPPLICATIONOFSOFTSYSTEMSTHINKINGAND33-PROCESSES TOSCENARIOPRACTICE"ELOWWEDISCUSSTHESEFOCUSINGlRSTONINSIGHTSABOUT SYSTEMS
Systems concepts
)NTHISSECTIONWEDISCUSSTWOKEYSOFTSYSTEMSCONCEPTSTHATWEBELIEVECANINFORM SCENARIOPRACTICE4HESEARETHEIMPLICATIONSOFSEEINGBOUNDARIESASJUDGEMENTS ANDVIEWINGTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTASASUBJECTDOMAIN
Boundaries as judgements 3CENARIOPRACTITIONERSDISTINGUISHBETWEENTWOLEVELSOFTHEENVIRONMENT4HE lRSTISCALLEDTHETRANSACTIONALANDISTHATASPECTOFTHEENVIRONMENTTHATMANAGERS FEELTHEORGANIZATIONHASINmUENCEOVERANDINWHICHITCANBEASIGNIlCANTPLAYER 4HESECONDTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTISTHATPARTOFTHEENVIRONMENTTHAT MANAGERSBELIEVETHEORGANIZATIONHASNOINmUENCEOVERANDWHICHCONTAINS THE@REFEREESTHATSETTHERULESFORTHEWAYINWHICHTHEORGANIZATIONCAN@PLAY IN THETRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTVANDER(EIJDENP /RTOUSE 4RISTSP PHRASETHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTPROVIDES@THEBOUNDARY CONDITIONSFORTRANSACTIONALRELATIONS3CENARIOSTHENFOCUSONAPPRECIATINGAND ILLUMINATINGPOSSIBLEDEVELOPMENTSINTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTBYMAPPING THEMAJORDRIVINGFORCESOFCHANGETHATCOULDINmUENCETHEFUTURETRANSACTIONAL ENVIRONMENT 4HUSSCENARIOPRACTITIONERSMUSTMAKEDECISIONSABOUTWHERETODRAWTHE
BOUNDARYBETWEENTHECONTEXTUALANDTRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTSBEFORETHEYCAN DEVELOPSCENARIOS4HISBOUNDARYDECISIONISOFTENDETERMINEDINCONSULTATION WITHTHECLIENTANDISDEPENDENTUPONTHETOPICANDPURPOSEOFTHEENQUIRY4HE VALUEOFASOFTSYSTEMSPERSPECTIVEINTHISREGARDISTOREMINDSCENARIOPRACTITIONERS ANDMANAGERSTHATDRAWINGTHESEBOUNDARIESISAJUDGEMENT!SSUCHTHEYAREFREED UPTO@SHIFTTHEMTOEXPERIMENTCONCEPTUALLYWITHPERSONALGROUPCOMMUNITY ANDOTHERSTAKEHOLDERPERCEPTIONSOFTHEIRORGANIZATIONALFUTURES !NEXAMPLEOFTHISISPROVIDEDBY2AM¤REZANDVANDER(EIJDENP
4HEAUTHORSARGUETHATEXTENDINGTHEBOUNDARYOFTHETRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENT INTOTHEPERCEIVEDCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTINCREASESTHEAREAOFTHEENVIRONMENT OVERWHICHMANAGERSBELIEVETHEYHAVEINmUENCETHUSREVEALINGNEWOPTIONSAND OPPORTUNITIESFORACTIONTHATMIGHTNOTOTHERWISEHAVEBEENPERCEIVED4HEY OFFERTHEEXAMPLEOFTHE6)3!CORPORATIONWHOBOUGHTTOGETHERBANKSRETAILERS CONSUMERSANDTECHNOLOGYPROVIDERSTOCONVERTTHETECHNOLOGICALANDOTHERSFORCES OFTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT@INTOEFFECTIVEPROCESSESSTANDARDSANDPROTOCOLS THEREBYOPENINGUPNEWBUSINESSOPPORTUNITIESFORTHEBANKSINPARTICULAR
Conceptualizing the contextual environment as a subject domain 4HE CONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENT IN SCENARIO PRACTICE IS BY DEFINITION A SHARED ENVIRONMENTAMONGASETOFORGANIZATIONSTHATISDELINEATEDBYANISSUEORSUBJECT EGSUPERANNUATION 7EWOULDLIKETOSUGGESTTHATTHEREARETIMESWHENITIS USEFULFORORGANIZATIONSTOTHINKOFTHEIRCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTASASUBJECT DOMAINANDTODEVELOPSCENARIOSINREFERENCETOTHISDOMAINRATHERTHANMORE
DIRECTLYTOTHEORGANIZATION/NETIMEINPARTICULARWOULDBEDEVELOPINGSCENARIOS FORWHAT-ORGAN REFERSTOAS@EGOCENTRICORGANIZATIONS 3UCHORGANIZATIONSSAYS-ORGANP HAVEA@lXEDNOTIONOFWHO
THEYAREORWHATTHEYCANBEANDAREDETERMINEDTOIMPOSEORSUSTAINTHATIDENTITY ATALLCOSTS4HISLEADSTHEMTOOVEREMPHASIZETHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEMSELVESWHILE UNDERPLAYINGTHESIGNIlCANCEOFTHEWIDERSYSTEMOFRELATIONSINWHICHTHEY EXIST4HISMEANSAS-ORGANPOINTSOUTTHATTHEYPOTENTIALLYMISSIMPORTANT ENVIRONMENTALCHANGES !NEXAMPLEISPROVIDEDBY#LAUS WHOSUGGESTSTHATTRADITIONALMUSIC
COMPANIESDIDNOTSUCCESSFULLYANTICIPATETHEIMPACTOFDIGITALPROVIDERSSUCHAS .APSTERANDI4UNESBECAUSETHEIDENTITYOFTHESECOMPANIESWASDElNEDMORE AS @SELLING#$S THAN @PROVIDINGHOMEENTERTAINMENT4HUS THE TRADITIONAL COMPANIESKEPTTAKINGACTIONSTHATWERECONGRUENTWITHTHEIRIDENTITYSUCHAS PROGRAMMING#$SSOTHATTHEYCOULDNTBEPLAYEDORCOPIEDONCOMPUTERS EVEN THOUGH@THEENVIRONMENTINDICATEDSOMETHINGDIFFERENTWASNEEDED!NOTHER EXAMPLEISIFLIBRARIESHADALWAYSSEENTHEMSELVESASCOLLECTORSOFBOOKSTHEN THEYWOULDNOTHAVETHOUGHTOFNEWINFORMATIONSTORAGEFORMATSASPARTOFTHEIR ACTIVITIES 7EBELIEVE THEREFORE THAT ENCOURAGINGMANAGERS INORGANIZATIONSWITH
EGOCENTRIC TENDENCIES TO THINKOF THEIR CONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTASA SUBJECT DOMAINANDTODEVELOPSCENARIOSINREFERENCETOTHISDOMAINCANHELPTHEMBETTER UNDERSTANDTHEINTERDEPENDENCIESOFTHESYSTEMSTOWHICHTHEYBELONGANDAVOID BECOMINGWEDDEDTOOUTDATEDIDENTITIES #HECKLANDS EXPERIENCEINDEVELOPINGTASK ANDISSUE BASEDMODELS
ORHOLONSWITHIN33-ISHELPFULHERE4ASK BASEDMODELSHESAYS@MAPEXISTING ORGANISATIONALSTRUCTURESWHILETHELATTERFOCUSONTHEISSUE(ESAYSTHEBENElTOF ISSUE BASEDHOLONSISTHATTHEY@LIFTTHETHINKINGINTHESITUATIONOUTOFITSNORMAL UNNOTICEDCOMFORTABLEGROOVES#HECKLANDP! 7EBELIEVETHATTHESAMECOGNITIVEBENElTSCANBEACHIEVEDFORORGANIZATIONS
WITHEGOCENTRICTENDENCIES4HEORGANIZATIONWOULDSTILLBETHECLIENTWITHTHEIR TRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTBUTINSTEADOFTHINKINGOFTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT AS@OURENVIRONMENT"URTETAL THEMANAGERSOFTHEORGANIZATIONWOULD BEENCOURAGEDTOTHINKOFITASASUBJECTDOMAINANDTOREFERENCETHESCENARIOSTO THISDOMAIN"YDOINGSOTHEYWOULDBELOOSENEDUPTOPERCEIVETHEIRCONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTMORE@ACCURATELY4HISPROPOSALISCONSISTENTWITHSOMESCENARIO SCHOLARSWHOHAVEPOINTEDTOTHENEEDTODEVELOPALTERNATIVEWAYSOFDEPLOYING SCENARIOSTODEALWITHORGANIZATIONSWITHEGOCENTRICTENDENCIES,ANG
Application of SSM processes to scenarios
)NTHISSECTIONWEFOCUSONWHATWESEEASlVEMAINCONTRIBUTIONSOFTHE33-TO SCENARIOPRACTICE
Conceptual modelling 4HELINKBETWEENTHEDEVELOPEDSCENARIOSANDACTIONISNOTALWAYSCLEARWITHIN SCENARIOPRACTICE3OMETIMESGROUPSCANSTRUGGLE IN TAKINGTHEOUTCOMESOF SCENARIOSFORWARD4HISDOESNOTOCCURTOTHESAMEDEGREEWITHTHE33-BECAUSE ANUMBEROFTOOLSHAVEBEENDESIGNEDSPECIlCALLYWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKTOENABLE ACTION7EBELIEVETHESETOOLSCOULDPROVIDEASTRUCTUREDWAYFORSCENARIOGROUPS TOTAKETHEOUTCOMESOFTHEIRSCENARIOSFORWARDINTOACTION 4HEPARTICULARTOOLWEHAVEINMINDHEREISCONCEPTUALMODELSOR@HOLONS
4HESEAREPURPOSEFULHUMANACTIVITYSYSTEMSDElNEDAS@THEABSTRACTIDEAOFAWHOLE HAVINGEMERGENTPROPERTIESALAYEREDSTRUCTUREANDPROCESSESOFCOMMUNICATION ANDCONTROLWHICHINPRINCIPLEENABLEITTOSURVIVEINACHANGINGENVIRONMENT #HECKLANDP 4HEHOLONSARENOTREPRESENTATIONSOFTHEREALWORLD BUTARESIMPLIlEDDEVICESORTRANSITIONALOBJECTS7INNICOTT TOENCOURAGE DISCUSSIONANDLEARNINGABOUTPATHWAYSFORWARD&OREXAMPLEANYPRODUCTION SYSTEMCANBEMODELLEDASAHOLONCONSISTINGOFASETOFACTIVITIESTHATTRANSFORMS RESOURCES INTOAlNISHEDPRODUCTAND ISCONTROLLEDBYPROCESSES THAT SUSTAIN ONGOINGPRODUCTION !BASISFORDEVELOPINGTHECONCEPTUALMODELSISTHE#!47/%MNEMONIC
#HECKLAND EXPLAINSTHAT#!47/%STANDSFORCUSTOMERSTHEBENElCIARIES ORVICTIMSOFTHESYSTEM ACTORSTHEPERSONORPERSONSWHOCARRYOUTTHEACTIVITIES INTHESYSTEM TRANSFORMATIONPROCESSTHEPURPOSEFULACTIVITYUNDERTAKENWITHIN THESYSTEM 7ELTANSCHAUUNGTHEWORLDVIEWWHICHMAKESTHISPURPOSEFULACTIVITY MEANINGFUL OWNERTHEPERSONORPERSONSWHOCOULDPREVENTTHEACTIVITIESFROM OCCURRING ANDENVIRONMENTALCONSTRAINTSTHINGSWHICHTHESYSTEMMUSTTAKEAS GIVEN #HECKLANDP! SUGGESTSUSINGTHESETOFORMA@ROOTDElNITION INTHEFORMOFASENTENCETHATANSWERSTHREEQUESTIONS7HATTODO(OWTO DOIT7HYDOIT!FTERTHESEAREDElNEDTHEELEMENTSOFTHEHOLONSARETHEN DEVELOPEDBYLISTINGANDMAPPINGOUTTHENECESSARYACTIVITIESTOACHIEVETHESTATED TRANSFORMATIONS 4HEDIFFERENCEBETWEENHOLONSANDSCENARIOSISTHATHOLONSDIRECTLYINCORPORATE
THEACTIONSTHATTHECLIENTORGANIZATIONWOULDTAKEASIMPLIEDBYTHESCENARIOS !TTHE$EEP#ONVERSATIONITWASSUGGESTEDTHATTHESTRATEGIESSUGGESTEDBYEACH SCENARIOCOULDBEMODELLED4HESEMODELSORHOLONSWOULDTHENHELPSTRUCTUREA DISCUSSIONTOASSISTMANAGERSPROGRESSTHEOUTCOMESOFTHESCENARIOS
CATWOE and scenario narratives $EVELOPINGSCENARIONARRATIVESISNOTEASY7HILEMANYTEXTSOFFERGUIDELINES TOASSISTWRITERSINDEVELOPINGSCENARIONARRATIVESWEFEELTHATTHE#!47/% MNEMONICASDISCUSSEDABOVE PROVIDESASPECIlC@TECHNOLOGYFORTHISTASK)N STRUCTURINGTHESCENARIONARRATIVE#!47/%HELPSUSERSTOPROVIDEIDENTIFY RESPONSESTOTHEFOLLOWINGQUESTIONSTHE#!47/%ORDERHASBEENREARRANGED TOREmECTTHESCENARIOCONTEXT
s 7HATISTHENATUREOFTHEACTIVITYESPECIALLYTHEDRIVINGFORCESBEINGDESCRIBED INTHESCENARIOTHETRANSFORMATIONIN33-LANGUAGE 7HATISTHEPLOTOFTHE TALETHECONmICTANDRESOLUTIONWITHINTHESCENARIO4
s 7HATISTHEDECLAREDWORLDVIEWORPOINTOFVIEWFROMWHICHTHESCENARIOIS BEINGTOLD7HOSHOULDBETHENARRATORANDWHYARETHEPLOTANDACTIVITIESIN THESCENARIOIMPORTANT7
s 7HOARETHEVICTIMSORBENElCIARIESOFTHEMAINACTIVITYBEINGPURSUEDINTHE SCENARIOANDWHATARETHEIRPERSPECTIVES#
s 7HOARETHEMAINACTORSOFTHISPOINTOFVIEWWHOWOULDUNDERTAKETHE ACTIVITYWITHINTHESCENARIO7HATARETHERELATIONSHIPSBETWEENTHEM!
