ABSTRACT

Most eighteenth-century converts were, of course, baptized members of the established church. Indeed, the Church of England could claim the nominal allegiance of over 90 per cent of the population of England throughout most of the century. Consequently, most evangelicals described their experience in terms of passing from nominal adherence to earnest faith, rather than in terms of proselyte conversion. As Sarah Middleton looked back on her life before conversion she was scathing: ‘We went to church and did all the outward things [but] we were but baptized heathens.’8 So often the convert used the metaphor of being woken from a deep sleep to describe their experience, so much so that to be ‘awakened’ was almost a cliché. Margaret Austin summarized her experience in stark terms when she signed off a letter to Charles Wesley: ‘Margaret Austin, awakened by the Reverend Mr Whitefield: Convicted by the Reverend Mr John Wesley: Converted by the Reverend Mr Charles.’9 The other term that converts often used was ‘serious’ – as when describing someone as a ‘serious professor’ to indicate that their religion was more than public observance, more than ‘going constantly to church and sacrament’.