ABSTRACT

It is said that among the advantages of the doctrine are the following: • it gives certainty to the law; • it is a curb on arbitrary decisions; • it is based on a notion of justice which maintains equality; • it provides a rational base for decision making. As is to be expected, many argue there are disadvantages of the doctrine: • it makes the law inflexible; • change is slow and convoluted; • it encourages a tedious hairsplitting tendency in legal argument. In addition, to understand the relationship between cases and legislation and the theory and practice of the doctrine of precedent it is also essential to understand the importance of accurate reporting of legal cases

The importance of cases and the extent of the legal rule developed only become apparent after the case, and one needs good reports. If you cannot trust the reporting, then you cannot trust the law.