chapter  4
Athlete Development, Athlete Rights and Athlete Welfare: A European Union Perspective
Ian Henry
Pages 18

OEL/&E58E&$ 16FL1LOL186F 8))&E&% &S&5:L186 8E E&%O"L186 8) LO1L186 )&&F> 6%&E L/& 8OEF& )8E 1)& E8.E55& 4O6"/&% 16 NVVN$ O61Q&EF1L1&F "86LE"L&% L8 &S&5:L 86&(L/E&& .1)L&% T8O6. F:8ELF5&6JF:8ELFR85&6 E&"855&6%&% T L/& )E85 :T16. LO1L186 )&&F 6% L8 E&%O"& L/& )&&F 16 E&F:&"L 8) 8L/&E T8O6. F:8ELF:&EF86FD LO1L186>

61Q&EF1L1&F 4F8 8))&E &41L& L/4&L&F ,&S1141LT 16 E&4L186 L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L& F&6"&$ 6% L/&1E FLO%T 6% &S516L186 L15&L4&> /&F& EE6.&5&6LF ::4T 864T L8 T8O6. F:8ELF:&EF86F R/8 E& &6&*"1E1&F 8) L/& .E&&5&6L &LR&&6 L/& O6.E16 4T5:1" 8551LL&& ;< 6% "844&.&FJO61Q&EF1L1&F> /&F& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F /Q& L/& 8::8ELO61LT L8 :OEFO& L/&1E FLO%1&F ""8E%16. L8 16%1Q1%O4 FLO%T 6% &S516L186 L15&L4&F>

1644T$ 5861L8E16. 8)$ 6% LOL8E14 FF1FL6"& )8E$ &41L& L/4&L&F 16 E&F:&"L 8) "%&51" FLO%1&F 1F :E8Q1%&%> LO%T "L1Q1L1&F E& F"/&%O4&% L8 ""8558%L& L/& 6&&%F 8) LE1616.$ 6% "85:&L1L186$ L&SL883F$ /6%883F$ 56O4F$ F:&"14 41L&ELOE& 6% 8L/&E OS141ET &%O"L1864 5L&E14F E& :E8Q1%&% R1L/ L/& 15 8) :E858L16. L/& 8::8ELO61LT L8 FLO%T %OE16. :&E18%F 8) F&6"& )8E LE1616. 8E "85:&L1L186>

1,(,2, )#& 6 "F& 8) :16 4F8$ L/&E& 1F 4&.1F4L186 ;8T4 &"E&& 9-IHJ977H$ 97 &:L&5&E< E&?O1E16. O61Q&EF1L1&F L8 E&F&EQ& M= 8) L/& L8L4 :4"&F :E8Q1%&% )8E ""E&%1L&% /1./0:&E)8E56"& F:8ELF5&6 6%R85&6R/8/Q&L 4&FL L/&51615O5"%&51" E&?O1E&5&6LF> 6 %%1L186$ L/& 16FL1LOL186F L/L :E8Q1%& %&.E&&F 16 L/& E& 8) :/TF1"4 "L1Q1LT 6% F:8EL FLO%1&F 6% L/& L1864 6FL1LOL&F 8) /TF1"4 %O"L186 E& E&?O1E&% T 4R L8 E&F&EQ& 6 %%1L1864 6O5&E ;&?O1Q4&6L L8 += 8) L/&1E 16L3&< 8) :4"&F )8E /1./0:&E)8E56"& F:8ELF5&6 6% R85&6>

E&F1%&6"&F$ ,&S14& L15&L4&F 6% ,&S14& F"/&%O4&F )8E L/& F1LL16. 8) &S5F E& 8))&E&% L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F>

85& O61Q&EF1L1&F 6% /1./&E &%O"L186 16FL1LOL186F :E8Q1%& %%1L1864 FLO%&6L0L/4&L& FO::8EL> /& 61Q&EF1LT 8) Q1&%8$ )8E &S5:4&$ 16 NVV-/% +V &41L& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F L L/& O61Q&EF1LT$ 58FL 8) R/85 R&E& .E6L&%# E&.1FLEL186 F"/84EF/1:FG L/&1E 8R6 F"/84EF/1: 8) L/& 61Q&EF1LT 8) Q1&%8G 6%$ R/&E& 6&"&FFET$ F"/84EF/1: )8E ""8558%L186 16 /44 8) E&F1%&6"&> /&T 4F8 E&"&1Q&% 6 448"L186 8) )E&& &4&"L1Q& "E&%1LF ::41&% L8 L/& "%&51" :E8.E55& L/&T E& FLO%T16.$ %&F1.6&% )8E L/4&L&F>

,%-% ++ $"!)"( "( 0)+ )+) "! ( ))/ )+"! /& F&"86% LT:& 8) ::E8"/ 1F 86& 16 R/1"/ L/&E& 1F )8E54 FTFL&5 )8E "368R4&%.16. FLO%&6L0L/4&L&FD 6&&%F$ R/1"/ FL8:F F/8EL 8) 4&.4 E&?O1E&5&6L OL R/&E& :&E51FF1Q& 4&.1F4L186 8E E&.O4L186F &S1FL$ OL/8E1F16. OL 68L E&?O1E16. O61Q&EF1L1&F L8 53& F:&"14 :E8Q1F186 )8E &41L& F:8ELF:&EF86F> ;S5:4&F /&E& 16"4O%& &4.1O5 ;46%&EF<$ &65E3$ FL861$ 1646%$ &E56T$ LQ1$ 1L/O61 6% R&%&6><

1,2,(, $ #3% *$&./+ 6413& L/& &S5:4&F 8) O6.ET 6% :16$ 16 R/1"/ FLL& 4&.1F4L186 E&?O1E&F "&EL16 LT:&F 8) E&F:86F&$ L/& FLL&0/)'&/'. ::E8"/ 16Q84Q&F L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 8) :&E51FF1Q& 4&.1F4L186 6%J8E )8E54 .E&&5&6LF &LR&&6 L/& FLL& 6% F&4&"L&% &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL186F> O"/ 6 ::E8"/ 1F &S&5:41*&% T L/& 4&51F/ 855O61LT 8) &4.1O5 L/L 16 NVVM 16LE8%O"&% 6 .E&&5&6L$ L/& ')/)'.0'&4&&0$ R/1"/ RF 161L1L&% T L/& 161FLET 8) :8EL 8) L/& 4&51F/ 855O61LT 16 "88:&EL186 R1L/ L/& L/E&& 16%&:&6%&6L &%O"L1864 6&LR8E3F$ L/& &4.16 4T5:1" 6% 6L&E0&%&E4 8551LL&& ; < 6% L/& F:8ELF %5161FLEL186 8%T ;< 8) L/& 4&51F/ "855O61LT>99

/& ')/)'.0'&4&&0 16LE8%O"&% LR8 161L1L1Q&F 15&% L FO::8EL16. T8O6. F:8ELF:&EF86F 16 /1./&E &%O"L186> 1EFL$ )8E L/& "%&51" T&E NVVMJNVV-$ L/& F:8ELF .8Q&E616. %5161FLEL186 6% L/& RE%&% L/8F& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F R/8 R&E& E63&% 86 L/& 4T5:1" 41FLF "86LE"L ;HV= 8) )O440L15& :E8)&FF1864 "86LE"L< L/L 448R&% L/&5 L8 "8516& &41L& F:8EL 6% FLO%1&F 16 /1./&E &%O"L186> /1F 16"4O%&% F"/84EF/1: 8) NV$VVV &6416. L/&F& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F L8 :T )8E F:&"1*" "8FLF 16"OEE&% 16 "851616. &41L& F:8EL 6% FLO%T F R&44 F F:8EL0F:&"1*" FO::8EL> /& F"/&5& FLEL&% R1L/ 58%&FL 6O5&EF> 6 L/& *EFL T&E 8) 8:&EL186$ *Q& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F R&E& RE%&% "86LE"L ( )8OE 16 /1./&E &%O"L186 8OLF1%& 8) L/& O61Q&EF1LT FTFL&5 6% 86& O61Q&EF1LT FLO%&6L ;L L/& E12& 61Q&EF1L&1L EOFF&4<>

/& F&"86% 161L1L1Q& &.6 16 L/& NVV-JNVV+ "%&51" T&E 6% RF LE.&L&% L T8O6. 4T5:1" L/4&L&F F&4&"L&% )8E L/& &4.16 8OL/ 4T5:1" &5 R/8 E&.1FL&E&% L O61Q&EF1LT 8E 8L/&E /1./&E &%O"L186> 6 L/& *EFL T&EF 8) 8:&EL186$ NV(MV T8O6. 4T5:1" L/4&L&F R&E& L8 & &41.14& )8E FO::8EL> 6413& L/& L/4&L&F 86 L/& 8)*"14 &4.16 4T5:1" E6316. 41FL$ L/& 5&5&EF 8) L/& 8OL/ 4T5:1" L&5 R&E& 68L RE%&% "86LE"LF$ OL E&"&1Q&% *66"14 FO::8EL 448R16. L/&5 L8 "8516& /1./&E &%O"L186 6% &41L& F:8EL>

/& E12& 61Q&EF1L&1L EOFF&4 RF L/& *EFL /1./&E &%O"L186 16FL1LOL186 L8 E&F:86% L8 L/&F& 161L1L1Q&F$ %&Q&48:16. 1LF CLO%T 6% 4&6L %O"L186 E8.E55&D ;< L8 :E8Q1%& "85:4&5&6LET F&EQ1"&F )8E &41L& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F> 16"4O%&% R8E3F/8:F 6% :E&F&6LL186F 86 L15& 56.&5&6L$ "855O61"L186 F3144F$ *66"14 56.&5&6L$ 162OET :E&Q&6L186 6% E&/141LL186> 6 %%1L186$ FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F "8O4% E&?O&FL L8 F:E&% L/&

/1F E&?O&FL /F L8 & 5%& L8 L/& 16FL1LOL186 O:86 E&.1FLEL186> 4&S1141LT 5T 4F8 & 8))&E&% L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F 16 E&.E% L8 &S5 L15&L4&F>

1,2,2, .%&7 6 L/& "F& 8) &E56T$ "86LE"L &LR&&6 L/& &OLF"/&E :8ELO6%$ L1864 :8EL &%&EL186F$ L/& 61Q&EF1LT :8ELF FF8"1L186 6% /1./&E &%O"L186 16FL1LOL186F 448RF FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F LL&6%16. 86& 8) L/& -' &41L& F:8ELF O61Q&EF1L1&F L8 /Q& ""&FF L8 E6.& 8) F&EQ1"&F 6% &6&*LF> /&F& 16"4O%& E&%O"&% &6LET "E1L&E1 )8E L/4&L&F$ ,&S14& L15&L416.$ ,&S14& &S516L186 L15&L4&$ 4L&E6L1Q& 5&6F 8) "85:4&L16. "8OEF& E&?O1E&5&6LF FO"/ F %1F"E&L186 6% ,&S1141LT )8E LL&6%6"& L "85:O4F8ET F&516EFJ 4&"LOE&F$ 6% LOL8E 5861L8E16.$ R1L/ FLO%&6LF 8))&E&% :&EF864 LOL8EF 6% FLO%T "8O6F&4416.> L RF &FL15L&% L/L ::E8S15L&4T '+V 6L1864 F?O% 5&5&EF ;0$ 0 6% 0F?O%F< E& &6E844&% L L/&F& O61Q&EF1L1&F L 6T 86& L15&>

6 %%1L186$ L/& &E56 :8ELF 1% 8O6%L186 8))&EF L&5:8EET OEFE1&F 8) O: L8 L/E&& T&EF L8 :E8)&FF1864 L/4&L&F R/8 /Q& &6E844&% 86 O61Q&EF1LT :E8.E55& 6% L/&6 E&L1E& )E85 "85:&L1L1Q& F:8EL>

,%,% $()!++"! " ++) .+"! !+()+) 0 $"(+! ") /& L/1E% LT:& 8) ::E8"/ 1F 86& 16 R/1"/ L/& L/4&L1" %&Q&48:5&6L 6&&%F 8) L/& 16%1Q1%O4 E& "L&E&% )8E T L/& F:8EL16. 16FL1LOL186F 6% R/&E& F:8EL16. %Q8"L&F "L 86 &/4) 8) L/& FLO%&6L$ L8 6&.8L1L& ,&S14& EE6.&5&6LF R1L/ L/& O61Q&EF1LT>

1,1,(, . E&&"& 1F 6 &S5:4& 8) FLL& L/L :E8Q1%&F F85& 4151L&% E1./LF L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F$ 6% L/OF &S/11LF F85& )&LOE&F 8) L/& :E&Q18OF LT:&$ OL R/1"/ O4L15L&4T E&41&F 86 6&.8L1L186 &LR&&6 L/& L/4&L&$ 8E L1864 :8EL &%&EL186 FL)) 8E "8"/&F "L16. 86 &/4) 8) L/& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&$ 6% O61Q&EF1LT FL)) L8 )"141LL& L/4&L&FD "85:4&L186 8) L/&1E "%&51" :E8.E55&> L/4&L&F R1L/ %1FL16.O1F/&% F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"& "6 & .1Q&6 &S&5:L186 )E85 &6LE6"& &S516L186F L8 6T O61Q&EF1LT %&:EL5&6L 8) L/&1E "/81"& ;R1L/ 68 4151LF 86 L/& 6O5&E 8) L/& L/4&L&F %51LL&% L8 &"/ %&:EL5&6L<> 8E 6L1864 "/5:186F L F&618E 8E T8OL/J2O618E 4&Q&4$ &6LET "6 & 8))&E&% L8 86& 8) L/& *Q& &:EL5&6LF 8) /TF1"4 %O"L186 6% :8EL "1&6"&F ;O: L8 MV= 8) L/& L8L4 %51FF186 6O5&E 8) L/& %&:EL5&6L< ; 161FLET 8) :8EL$ R NHN+J9777<>

/& .8Q&E65&6L 4F8 8))&EF LR8 LT:&F 8) F"/84EF/1:> /& *EFL 1F 6 66O4 F"/84EF/1: )8E FLO%&6LF 8) 6T &%O"L1864 4&Q&4 O: L8 O6%&E.E%OL& FLO%1&F> /& F&"86% FO::8ELF L/4&L&F )8E .E%OL& FLO%1&F L E&&3 61Q&EF1L1&F 8E E8%$ 16 F:8EL0E&4L&% %1F"1:416&F ;&:OLT 161FLET 8) :8EL$ R NHN+J9777<>9N

LO%&6L0L/4&L&F 16 E&&3 O61Q&EF1L1&F E& :&E51LL&% L8 516L16 L/&1E FLO%&6L FLLOF )8E 6 O64151L&% 4&6.L/ 8) L15&$ 1EE&F:&"L1Q& 8) L/&1E "%&51" "/1&Q&5&6L> /OF$ FLO%&6L 5T E&516 E&.1FL&E&% F "6%1%L& )8E "/&48EDF %&.E&& )8E ' 8E 9V T&EF> /1F 448RF &41L& L/4&L&F L8 F&L F1%& L/&1E FLO%1&F L8 LE16 16L&6F1Q&4T 6% L3& :EL 16 "85:&L1L186> L L/& &6% 8) L/&1E F:8EL16. "E&&E$ L/& L/4&L& "6 E&LOE6 L8 /1FJ/&E O61Q&EF1LT L8 "85:4&L& /1FJ /&E FLO%1&F> O"/ 6 ::E8"/ 1F 68L R1L/8OL %1)*"O4L1&F$ F16"& E&LOE616. L8 "%&51" FLO%1&F :&E18%1"44T )L&E &SL&6%&% F&6"& "6 :E8Q& :E84&5L1">

8R&Q&E$ 4L/8O./ L/&F& 5&FOE&F R&E& 16 :4"&$ 16 :E"L1"&$ ,&S1141LT 16 FLO%T L8

:&"14 LE&L5&6L 1F 5LL&E 8) :&EF864 6&.8L1L186 R1L/ L/& /8FL16. %&:EL5&6L 6% 68L 44 E& FT5:L/&L1"> L/4&L&F E&:8EL /Q16. /% L8 E&4T 86 L/& 16L&E"&FF186 8) L/&1E "8"/&F 8E L/&1E L1864 &%&EL186F R1L/ L/& O61Q&EF1LT 6% L/L L/1F /% :E8Q&% L8 & 8) QE14& &))&"L1Q&6&FF>

1,1,2, &#0 #& '% 6O5&E 8) O61Q&EF1L1&F 16 L/& /Q& LE%1L18644T 16)8E544T 8))&E&% &41L& FLO%&6L0 L/4&L&F F:&"14 "86"&FF186F 16 L&E5F 8) &S5 %L&F$ 48"L186 )8E /84%16. &S516L186F$ FF1.65&6L %&%416&F$ R1Q16. 8) LL&6%6"& E&?O1E&5&6LF 6% ,&S14& %OEL186 8) :E8.E55&F 8) FLO%T> 8R&Q&E$ L L/& &41L& 4&Q&4$ L/8F& L/4&L&F R/8 E& 86 L/& :8EL 8E4% 4FF &E)8E56"& E8.E55& ;< /Q& ""&FF L8 L/& F&EQ1"&F 8) C&E)8E56"& 1)&FLT4& %Q1F8ED &5:48T&% T 86& 8) L/& L1864 6FL1LOL&F 8) :8EL 16 L/& $ 6% R/&E& 6&"&FFET L/1F 16%1Q1%O4 R144 6&.8L1L& %1E&"L4T R1L/ L&"/16. FL)) 86 &/4) 8) L/& FLO%&6L0L/4&L&>

/14& L/& FTFL&5 /F L/OF LE%1L18644T /% 6 16)8E54 &4&5&6L 8) 6&.8L1L186 ;8)L&6 T L/& L1864 :8ELF &%&EL186 8E L/& &E)8E56"& 1)&FLT4& %Q1F8E< F :E&:EL186F )8E L/& /8FL16. 8) L/& 86%86 NV9N 5&F 16L&6F1*&%$ .8Q&E65&6L "L1Q1LT 16 L/1F E& /% 16"E&F&% F16"& L/& NVV-FOEQ&T>

/& 4&6L&% L/4&L& "/84EF/1: "/&5& ;< 16LE8%O"&% 16 NVV-/F &&6 )OEL/&E )8E541F&% 6% &SL&6%&%> /1F F"/&5& F&EQ&F L/4&L&F &48R L/& > /& :E8.E55& :E8Q1%&F .8Q&E65&6L )O6%16. L/L 1F %&F1.6&% L8 :E858L& :EL6&EF/1: &LR&&6 L1864 8Q&E616. 8%1&F 8) :8EL ;F< 6% /1./&E &%O"L186J)OEL/&E &%O"L186 16FL1LOL186F> LF FLL&% 15F E& L8 :E858L& 46"& &LR&&6 "%&51" 41)& 6% LE1616. F :&E)8E56"& L/4&L&$ L/OF E&%O"16. L/& %E8:8OL 8) L4&6L&% L/4&L&F )E85 F:8EL %O& L8 "%&51" 6% *66"14 :E&FFOE&F> /& )8"OF 1F L/OF 86 516L1616. F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"&$ 6% L/& F"/84EF/1:F L/L 58O6L L8 O: L8 KM+VV :&E T&E E& .&6&E44T 16L&6%&% )8E FO::8EL16. F:8EL16. &S:&6%1LOE& 86 F&EQ1"&F FO"/ F "8"/16.$ :/TF18L/&E:T$ F:8ELF F"1&6"&$ 6OLE1L1864 %Q1"& 6% F:8ELF :FT"/848.T$ EL/&E L/6 86 &%O"L1864 F&EQ1"&F 8E 5L&E14F>

6 %%1L186 L8 L/& F"/&5& 16 NVV7 R&E& NV9N F"/84EF/1:F 15&% L L/8F& R1L/ :8L&6L14 L8 :E8.E&FF L8RE%F L/& > /1F :E8Q1%&F 66O4 .E6LF 8) O: L8 K9V3$ OL .16 L/&F& E& 16L&6%&% )8E F:8ELF FO::8EL F&EQ1"&F EL/&E L/6 &%O"L1864 F&EQ1"&F> &Q&EL/&4&FF$ %Q1F8EF 5T 6&.8L1L& R1L/ O61Q&EF1LT FL)) 86 &/4) 8) L/&1E FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F L8 "/1&Q& F85& ,&S1141LT 16 E&?O1E&5&6LF>

/& L8: L1&E 8) &41L& L/4&L&F 86 L/& E&"&1Q&F L/& F&EQ1"&F 8) :&E)8E56"& 41)&FLT4& %Q1F8E R/8 R144 :E8Q1%& %Q1"& 6% FO::8EL )8E 44 6860F:8EL16. F:&"LF 8) 41)&FLT4& 16"4O%16. &%O"L1864 6% Q8"L1864 :E&:EL186 FO::8EL> /& 1F %1Q1%&% 16L8 L/E&& "L&.8E1&F 8) L/4&L&F$ 65&4T$ C8%1O5D$ L/8F& R1L/ .&6O16& :8L&6L14 L8 R16 4T5:1"J8E4% /5:186F/1: 5&%4FG C&Q&48:5&6LD$ L/8F& R/8 R144 & "85:&L1L1Q& )8E 5&%4F 16 NV9I$ 6% C4&6L&%D$ L/4&L&F 1%&6L1*&% F L/8F& 413&4T L8 :E8.E&FF L/E8O./ L/& 8E4% 4FF :L/RT> L8L4 8) 9NVV L/4&L&F 16 L/& L8: LR8 "L&.8E1&F /Q& &6&*L&% )E85 .8Q&E65&6L 16Q&FL5&6L 8) K9VV 5144186 :&E T&E )8E F:8ELF :&E)8E56"& FO::8EL>

,%% 0$ &))((' " "( +(.+.() /& )8OEL/ ::E8"/ 1F 86& R/&E& L/&E& E& )&R 8E 68 )8E54 FLEO"LOE&F$ 6% 6T EE6.&5&6LF )44 "3 86 16%1Q1%O44T 6&.8L1L&% .E&&5&6LF R/&E& L/&F& :E8Q& :8FF14&> /1F "L&.8ET 1F Q&ET E8% &"OF& L/&E& E& 16FL1LOL186F L/L /Q& &&6 Q&ET :E8"L1Q& 16 16

T:EOF$ OL L/&E& E& 4F8 L/8F& "8O6LE1&F R/8F& FTFL&5F /Q& LE%1L18644T &&6 ?O1L& E1.1% 16 6LOE& 16 E&4L186 L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L&FD 6&&%F$ FO"/ F L4T 6% 4L> ;L/&E &S5:4&F 16 L/1F LT:& 16"4O%& OFLE1$ U&"/ &:O41"$ E&46%$ 48Q31 6% 48Q&61><

1,,(, 0$7 /& FTFL&5 8) F:8EL &%O"L186 16 L4T "/6.&% L L/& &6% 8) L/& 977VF> 6 L/& 84% FTFL&5$ L/&E& /% &&6 9+ 16FL1LOL&F 8) :/TF1"4 &%O"L186$ R/14& L L/& L15& 8) L/& *&4%R8E3$ L/&E& R&E& ::E8S15L&4T MV O61Q&EF1L1&F 8))&E16. F:8EL0E&4L&% "8OEF&F> 8FL 8) L/&F& "8OEF&F R&E& :E8Q1%&% R1L/16 )"O4L1&F 8) 5&%1"16&$ R/1"/ /Q& L&6%&% L8 & "86F&EQL1Q& 16 L&E5F 8) 448R16. %:LL186F L8 "8OEF&F$ FF&FF5&6L 8E LL&6%6"& E&?O1E&5&6LF L8 & 5%& )8E L/4&L&F 8E 8L/&E .E8O:F>

4&S1141LT 8) "8OEF& E&?O1E&5&6LF )8E FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F 1F 58E& ::E&6L 16 F85& :E1QL& O61Q&EF1L1&F$ OL 16 L/& :O41" O61Q&EF1L1&F$ E&?O1E&5&6LF "6 & E1.1%$ 6% 6T E&?O&FL )8E ,&S1141LT 1F F&&6 F 5LL&E &LR&&6 L/& FLO%&6L0L/4&L& 6% L&"/16. FL))>

85& 8) L/& O61Q&EF1L1&F %8 /Q& 4163F R1L/ F:8EL )&%&EL186F$ OL L/&F& E& 68L :EL1"O4E4T FLE86. 8E "86F1FL&6L$ 6% 4L/8O./ F85& F:8EL )&%&EL186F .1Q& 8OL OEFE1&F L8 FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F L8 )OEL/&E L/&1E &%O"L186 L O61Q&EF1L1&F$ L/1F :E"L1"& 1F 4151L&%> LO%&6L0 L/4&L&F 5T$ /8R&Q&E$ 6&.8L1L& 16%1Q1%O44T R1L/ O61Q&EF1LT FL))>

1,,2, $0 4L 1F :&E/:F LT:1"4 8) 6O5&E 8) 51"E8FLL&F> L /F F544 &%O"L186 FTFL&5 ;16"4O%16. F16.4& O61Q&EF1LT<> 1L/ F544 O61Q&EF1LT FTFL&5$ 1L 1F :&E/:F 58E& %1)*"O4L L8 %:L :E8Q1F186 L8 ""8558%L& L/& 6&&%F 8) L/4&L&F> :8EL16. &S"&44&6"& 6% L/& 6&&%F 8) L/4&L&F E& L/OF 68L "368R4&%.&% L L/& O61Q&EF1LT 8E L 6T 8L/&E "%&51" 16FL1LOL186> /& 864T "86"&FF186 L/L 1F 8))&E&% "5& 16L8 &))&"L 16 NVVM R/&6 T8O6. L/4&L&F :EL1"1:L16. 16 16L&E6L1864 "85:&L1L186F R&E& .1Q&6 L/& 8::8ELO61LT L8 :8FL:86& L/&1E O61Q&EF1LT &S5F>

F 1F &Q1%&6L )E85 L/& 8Q& "855&6LET$ &"/ 8) L/& ::E8"/&F %&F"E1&% "EE1&F R1L/ 1L "8FLF 6% &6&*LF 16 L&E5F 8) 5&&L16. L/& &%O"L1864 6% F:8EL16. 6&&%F 8) T8O6. FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F> 8R&Q&E$ &)8E& .816. 86 L8 "86F1%&E L/&F& "8FLF 6% &6&*LF 16 E&4L186 L8 L/& 15:41"L186F 8) L/&F& ::E8"/&F )8E "86F1%&EL186 8) L/& E84&F$ E1./LF 6% E&F:86F1141L1&F 8) FL3&/84%&EF$ R& R144 "86F1%&E L/& 1FFO& 8) &%O"L1864 :E8Q1F186 )8E FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F R/8 E& 5&5&EF 8) L/& :4T&E "%&51&F 8) :E8)&FF1864 F:8ELF "4OF>

- %4$('0"$*0 49' 4" 44 ' /(00$('% *(/4 &$0 $' %4$(' 4( 4"%4 74$(' 6 L/& F5& RT F L/& E&4L186F/1: &LR&&6 L/& FLL& 6% &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL186F 16 E&F:&"L 8) L/4&L&F E1./LF E6.&F 486. "86L16OO5 )E85 %1E&"L 16L&EQ&6L186 L8 $#//8" #.$ F8 16 L/& "F& 8) L/& 6LOE& 8) .8Q&E65&6L "86LE84 8) :E8)&FF1864 F:8EL16. "%&51&F$ L/&E& 1F E6.& 8) ::E8"/&F> 6 L4T$ )8E &S5:4&$ .8Q&E65&6L 8))&EF Q&ET 41LL4& 5861L8E16. 8E "86LE84 8) :E8)&FF1864 F:8EL16. &6L1L1&F 16 L&E5F 8) L/& %&41Q&ET 8) &%O"L1864 8::8ELO61L1&F> 6 L/& $ /8R&Q&E$ 16 NVVM$ 3144F "L1Q& ;R/1"/ 1F L/& &"L8E 3144F 8O6"14 ;<9M E&F:86F14& )8E F:8EL 6% *L6&FF< %&Q&48:&% ?O41*"L186$ L/& %Q6"&% ::E&6L1"&F/1: 16 :8EL16. S"&44&6"&$ :E8.E55& 8) FLO%T 6% ?O41*"L186 %&F1.6&% L8 5&&L L/& 6&&%F 8) L/4&L&F R/8 E& LE1616. :E8)&FF18644T 16$ )8E &S5:4&$ 16

F:8ELF$ L/OF %1FEO:L16. L/&1E ""&FF L8 516FLE&5 F"/88416.>9-8R&Q&E$ &6..&5&6L R1L/ L/& ::E&6L1"&F/1: F"/&5& 1F Q84O6LET EL/&E L/6 56%L8ET )8E F:8ELF 8E :EL1"O4E "4OF$ 6% L/& :E8Q1F186 8) F16.4& :E8.E55& L :EL1"O4E 4&Q&4 1F O6413&4T L8 :E8Q1%& .88% C*LD .1Q&6 L/& E6.& 8) &%O"L1864JQ8"L1864 LE1616. 6&&%F 16 L/1F %1F:EL& :8:O4L186>

6 L/& "F& 8) E6"&$ /8R&Q&E$ 41Q1&E 1&E$9+ 16 6 O6:O41F/&% E&:8EL )8E L/& NVVFLO%T /1./41./L&% RTF 16 R/1"/ L/& E&6"/ FLL& :E858L&F .88% :E"L1"& 16 L/& *&4% 8) :E8)&FF1864 "%&51&F T OF16. FTFL&5 8) 16%1Q1%O4 "86LE"LF &LR&&6 T8O6. :4T&EF 6% L/&1E "4OJ"%&5T R1L/ *66"14 F6"L186F )8E )1416. L8 "/1&Q& L/& "86LE"L&% .84F .E&&%> L 1F R8EL/ /1./41./L16. 1&EDF ""8O6L 8) L/& "F& 8) L/& "%&51&F 8) :E8)&FF1864 E&6"/ EO.T "4OF 16 F85& %&L14>

F16. %L )E85 L/& &E4T NVVVF$ 1&E F&&3F L8 144OFLEL& /8R L/& "4OF R&E& 58E& &))&"L1Q&4T 16,O&6"&% L8 "8551L L/&5F&4Q&F F&E18OF4T L8 /&4: :4T&EF L8 F&L 6% "/1&Q& E&41FL1" 6% 5&616.)O4 &%O"L1864 .84F> "%&5T :4T&EF E&:E&F&6L 5E.164 :4T16. E&F8OE"&> ) L/& MH7 "%&5T :4T&EF E&.1FL&E&% L :E8)&FF1864 "4OF 16 L/& L8: LR8 %1Q1F186F 16 NVVMJNVV-$ IN :4T&% )8E L/& :E8)&FF1864 L&5 %OE16. L/& F&F86$ 6 Q&E.& 8) M :4T&EF :&E "%&5TJLE1616. "&6LE&$ :4T16. 6 Q&E.& 8) 9+ 5L"/&F$ R1L/ -H ;9N= 8) "%&5T :4T&EF< .1616. :E8)&FF1864 "86LE"LF L L/& &6% 8) L/& F&F86> /1F /1./41./LF L/& 15:8EL6"& 8) LR8 "86LE1OL186F 8) L/& "%&51&FJLE1616. "&6LE&F# *EFL L/&1E *66"14 "86LE1OL186 L8 L/& :E8)&FF1864 "4OF$ F16"& :4T&EF 16 L/& "%&5T E& OF&% R1L/8OL F&E18OF4T 15:16.16. 86 L/& F4ET "8FLFG 6% F&"86% L/& 15:8EL6"& 8) L/& &%O"L1864 "86LE1OL186 L8 L/& :4T&EF$ R/1"/ 1F :EL1"O4E4T "EO"14 )8E L/& ''= R/8 %8 68L E&"&1Q& :E8)&FF1864 EO.T "86LE"LF>

/& &"86851"F 8) :E8)&FF1864 EO.T 16 E6"& 53& L/& *66"14 "86LE1OL186 :8L&6L144T "E1L1"4> 4L/8O./ E1./LF 16"85& .E&R T -I= )E85 977' L8 NVVH ;)E85 ++>H 5144186 L8 H'>N 5144186<$ 16 L/& L8: %1Q1F186 ;8: 9I<$ "4O &S:&6%1LOE& .E&R T +I= 16 L/& :&E18% )E85 977' L8 NVVM 486& ;N>9M(M>MN 5144186<$ 6% :4T&EFD F4E1&F .E&R T HV= )E85 977' L8 NVV9 ;NNVV(M'VV :&E 586L/< F8 L/L T NVVN F4E1&F E&:E&F&6L&% +'= 8) 44 "4O &S:&6%1LOE&> /& FLL& O%1L8E /8R&Q&E 15:8F&% 4151L 8) IV= F L/& :E8:8EL186 8) "4O &S:&6%1LOE&$ R/1"/ "8O4% & 448"L&% L8 F4E1&F> /OF$ 4L/8O./ "%&5T :4T&EF R&E& 5E.164 :4T16. E&F8OE"&$ L/&T R&E& "/&: 6% "8O4% 53& L/& %1))&E&6"& 16 L&E5F 8) 68L .816. 8Q&E O%.&L>

F1.61*"6L F8OE"& 8) 16"85& L8 L/& "4O RF .8Q&E65&6L .E6L L1&% L8 :&E)8E56"& 16 E&F:&"L 8) &"/ "%&5T :4T&E> L L/& &.16616. 8) L/& T&E$ L/& &%O"L186 8)*"&E .E&&F F&L 8) .84F R1L/ &"/ :4T&E> /1F 5T & "/1&Q&5&6L 8) 6 &6% ?O41*"L186 8E :E8.E&FF186 16 L/& FTFL&5 ;&>.> )E85 T&E 9 L8 T&E N 8) 6 O6%&E.E%OL& :E8.E55&<> 1.OE& 9 16%1"L&F L/& E6.& 8) ?O41*"L186F F8O./L T "%&5T :4T&EF 16 NVVMJNVV-;R/1"/ 1F 5O"/ R1%&E L/6 L/& F16.4& %Q6"&% ::E&6L1"&F/1: F"/&5& %&41Q&E&% 16 58FL "F&F L8 "%&5T :4T&EF 16 )88L44 6% EO.T "%&51&F 16 6.46%<> 8R&Q&E$ O64&FF L/& :4T&EF 5&&L L/&1E &%O"L1864 .84F$ L/& "4O 48F&F 7V= 8) 1LF )O6%16. )8E :4T&EDF &%O"L186> /& 6&L E&FO4L 1F L/L "4OF E& 5O"/ 58E& 413&4T L8 & "86"&E6&% 8OL "%&51" :&E)8E56"& F16"& )14OE& L8 :&E)8E5 E&FO4LF 16 *66"14 :&64L1&F$ 6% L/& FL6%E% 8) "%&51" :&E)8E56"& 16 5O"/ R1%&E E6.& 8) ?O41*"L186F$ L/8O./ )E )E85 :&E)&"L$ 1F 15:E&FF1Q& "85:E&% R1L/ L/& 6.41F/ "F&$ R/&E& &%O"L1864

- " "$4 */ (' *(/4 6;;1 ' (&&$00$('$'! ( 4" ('07%4$'!3 +.0 "! (!! " ".! $"(+) !*" ! ! .("$ 8448R16. L/& NVV-FLO%T$ L/& :8EL 61LDF :E18E1L1&F R&E& %E1Q&6 T L/& :E&:EL186F )8E 16"4OF186 8) 6 EL1"4& 86 F:8EL 16 L/& 6&R 86FL1LOL186 )8E OE8:& F1.6&% 16 NVV-6% EL1*&% 16 NVV+ T 9' &5&E LL&F ;OL 4L&E 6%86&% )L&E E&)&E&6% 16 E6"& 6% L/& &L/&E46%F E&2&"L&% L/& E&LT< 6% L/& FOF&?O&6L %8:L186 8) L/& E&LT 8) 1F86 16 NVVH$ "8516. 16L8 )8E"& 16 &"&5&E NVV7> /&F& :E&:EL186F 16"4O%&% !#0 ). '& )'.0$9I 6% L/& "8551FF18616. 8) 6&R FLO%T 86 LE1616. FTFL&5F )8E T8O6. :&8:4& 16 F:8EL 16 L/& >

/14& L/& /1L& :&E :E&%L&% L/& "8516. 16L8 )8E"& 8) L/& 6&R LE&LT R1L/ 1LF EL1"4& 16"8E:8EL16. F:8ELF "85:&L&6"&$ 1L 6&Q&EL/&4&FF F1.644&% L/& "86L16O&% :E18E1L1F16. 8)

:841"T %&Q&48:5&6L 16 L/1F E&$ 6% 5%& &S:41"1L L/& OE8:&6 8551FF186DF LR16 "86"&E6F L/L E&4L& L8 16F&EL186 16 L/& 48OE 5E3&L L L/& &6% 8) &41L& F:8ELF "E&&EF 6% L/& LE&L5&6L 8) L/4&L&F$ :EL1"O4E4T L/& T8O6.$ R1L/16 LE1616. "&6LE&F>

/& FLO%T 8) L/& LE1616. FTFL&5F 16 OE8:& 16Q&FL1.L&% 9+ F:8ELF :E"L1F&% L/E8O./8OL OE8:& E&,&"L16. L/& QE1&LT 8) F:8ELF ;5L&OEJ:E8)&FF1864$ 16%1Q1%O4JL&5$ FO55&EJ R16L&E$ &L"><$ 6% L/& .&6%&E :E&%85166"& 6% F:8ELF :E"L1F&% T %1F4&% :&EF86F R&E& "86F1%&E&%> /& FLO%T 16"8E:8EL&% LT:848.1"4 %&F"E1:L186 8) L/& %1))&E&6L 5&"/61F5F 6% FTFL&5F )8E L/& LE1616. 8) T8O6. L/4&L&F$ 6% 64TF1F 8) ?O41LT "E1L&E1 ::41&% T8OL/ &41L& F:8ELF LE1616. FTFL&5F$ L8.&L/&E R1L/ 6L1864 6% OE8:&6 4&.4 6% :841L1"4 )E5&R8E3F E&4L16. L8 L/& LE1616. 8) T8O6. L/4&L&F>

6 E&4L186 L8 L/& LT:848.T 8) 5&"/61F5F 6% FTFL&5F )8E F:8ELF LE1616.$ L/& OL/8EF 1%&6L1)T 6O5&E 8) )"L8EF L/L 15:"L 86 L/& 6LOE& 8) :E8Q1F186 )8E &%O"L186 T 16%1Q1%O4 F:8EL> /&F& 16"4O%&# R/&L/&E L/& F:8EL 1F :E8)&FF1864G L&5 8E 16%1Q1%O4 F:8ELG 1F F:8EL R1L/ &E4TJ51%%4&J4L& C5LOE1LTD 16 L&E5F 8) L/& .& 8) L/4&L&F L L/& 86F&L 8) 16L&6F1Q& LE1616. 6% 8) &41L& "85:&L1L186G L/& FTFL&5 8) LE1616. "&6LE&FG 6% L/& F:&"1*" EO4&F 6% ?O41LT FL6%E%F 16 E&F:&"L 8) L/4&L& &%O"L186 L/L E& E&?O1E&% T L/& FLL& 8E T L/& F:8ELF )&%&EL186>

1.OE& M 144OFLEL&F L/& )"L8EF 16,O&6"16. L/& :816L L R/1"/ L/& L/4&L&DF F"/88416. 1F 16L&EEO:L&%>

/& E&:8EL .8&F 86 L8 1%&6L1)T L/& 4&Q&4 8) %1FEO:L186 8) &%O"L186 &Q1%&6L )8E %1))&E&6L F:8ELF$ %1))&E&6L1L16. :E8)&FF1864 L&5 F:8ELF$ 16%1Q1%O4 :E8)&FF1864 F:8ELF 6%

C6860:E8)&FF1864D F:8ELF> 8E :E8)&FF1864 L&5 F:8ELF$ )88L44 OFO44T 16Q84Q&F F1.616. )O44 :E8)&FF1864 "86LE"L L 9'$ 6% L/OF &%O"L186 &T86% L/1F .& 1F &SLE&5&4T EE&> F3&L44 )8448RF F1514E :LL&E6$ R/&E&F )8E EO.T L/& "E1L1"4 .& ::&EF L8 & N9$ L/8O./ .E&L&E ,&S1141LT ::&EF L8 &S1FL 16 L/1F "F&> 6 L&E5F 8) 16%1Q1%O4 F:8ELF$ L&661F E&?O1E&F 16L&6F1Q& %&Q&48:5&6L )E85 6 &E41&E .&$ 6% 1F F:8EL L/L 1F /1./4T %&Q&48:&% 16 *66"14 L&E5F$ 6% L/& .& 8) L&E516L186 8) FLO%1&F L&6%F L8 & 9I 8E 4&FF> T"416. E&:8ELF :E84&5F 16 L/8F& "8O6LE1&F$ FO"/ F &4.1O5$ R/1"/ /Q& FLE86. LE%1L186$ R1L/ T8O6. L/4&L&F %&F:1L& L/& &S1FL&6"& 8) C8: :8ELD F"/884F$ *6%16. 1L 16"E&F16.4T %1)*"O4L L8 "8516& /1./0F"/884 FLO%T 6% F:8ELF LE1616.> 6 E&4L186 L8 6860:E8)&FF1864 F:8ELF$ L/4&L1"F 6% FR15516. E&:E&F&6L F:8ELF$ R/&E& Q&ET )&R L/4&L&F "6 41Q& )E85 L/&1E F:8EL16. &E616.F$ 6% &%O"L186 6% F:8EL16. :E&:EL186 "6 & "8516&%>

) "8OEF&$ R1L/16 L/& F5& F:8EL$ %1))&E&6"&F &LR&&6 %1))&E&6L &5&E LL&F &S1FL F E&FO4L 8) QET16. ::E8"/&F L8 4&.4 :E8L&"L186 8) ""&FF L8 &%O"L186 ;F &S&5:41*&% 16 L/& %1F"OFF186 8Q& 8) L/& E&6"/ EO.T FTFL&5<$ 6% L/& E&:8EL "86"OEF R1L/ L/& "86"4OF186F 8) 5E &L 4> ;NVV-< L/L L/& /F F1.61*"6L E84& L8 :4T 16 :E8L&"L16. T8O6. L/4&L&F 16L&E&FLF 16 L/1F *&4%>

2-" 04%$0"$'! ( 7$%$'0 $' 0*4 ( 4"%40. 7% //0 /& F&E1&F 8) E&:8ELF "8551FF186&% T L/& :8ELF 61L 8) L/& OE8:&6 8551FF186$ L8.&L/&E R1L/ R8E3 O6%&EL3&6 T 8L/&E 16L&E&FL&% FL3&/84%&EF$9' 4&% L8 L/& %E)L16. 8) F&L 8) MI E&"855&6%&% .O1%&416&F 86 %O4 "E&&EF>97NI 1Q&6 L/L L/& "85:&L&6"& :E8Q1%&% T L/& 1F86 E&LT 16 E&F:&"L 8) F:8EL RF F/E&% ;8E CF8)LD< "85:&L&6"&$ 86& 16 R/1"/ L/& RF 68L .1Q&6 :E15"T 8Q&E 6L1864 :841"T 6% 4&.1F4L186$ 1L 1F 68L FOE:E1F16. L/L L/& .O1%&416&F :E8%O"&% 4E.&4T L3& L/& )8E5 8) &S/8ELL186 6% &6"8OE.&5&6L 8) :O41" OL/8E1L1&F 6% 8L/&E FL3&/84%&EF$ FO"/ F LE1616. "&6LE&F$ &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL186F 6% F:8EL16. 8%1&F$ L8 R8E3 L8.&L/&E L8 %&Q&48: 6% FOFL16 5&FOE&F R/1"/ R144 :E858L& %O40"E&&E 8::8ELO61L1&F>

1S 8) L/& MI .O1%&416&F$ /8R&Q&E$ E&4L& %1E&"L4T L8 L/& E84& L/L L/& OE8:&6 8551FF186 51./L :4T> & /Q& E.O&% &4F&R/&E& L/L L/& E&F:86F1141L1&F 8) L/& 16 E&4L186 L8 %O4 "E&&EF E& L/8F& 8) C6/6"16. L/& 368R4&%.& F& 8) &5&E LL&F 6% /1./41./L16. 16&?O1L1&FG :E8L&"L186 8) L/& 16%1Q1%O4DF E1./LF .16FL L/& &5&E LL& ; <D>NV 6 :EL1"O4E$ L/& E84& 8) L/& 8551FF186 E&4L&F 68L 864T L8 L/& "L1Q1L1&F 8) 16%1Q1%O4 FLL&F ;&S"&:L 16 L&E5F 8) &S/8ELL186<$ OL 4F8 L8 0.&/&0#'&$ "L1Q1LT> /OF$ L/& F1S .O1%&416&F %1E&"L4T E&4L&% L8 L/& OE8:&6 8551FF186 )8"OF 86 L/& )8448R16. LE6F6L1864 "86LE1OL186F#

L15O4L16. "88:&EL186 &LR&&6 6L1864 LE1616. "&6LE&F 6% &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL&F )E85 %1))&E&6L &5&E LL&F L8 FO::8EL L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 6% Q14141LT 8) %O40 "E&&E :841"1&F )8E FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F )E85 8L/&E &5&E LL&F ;O1%&416& NH<G

"E&L16. 8::8ELO61L1&F R1L/16 1LF :E8.E55& )8E &%O"L186 6% LE1616. L8 :E8Q1%& *66"14 6% 8E.61FL1864 FO::8EL )8E L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 6% 15:4&5&6LL186 8) %O40"E&&E 58141LT 6&LR8E3F 8) "88:&EL16. F:8ELF 8E.61FL186F 6% &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL&F 86 &/4) 8) FLO%&6L0L/4&L&F R/8 58Q& )E85 86& &5&E LL& L8 68L/&E ;O1%&416& N'<G

&6"8OE.16. 6% FO::8EL16. L/& 4&%16. &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL186F 6% O61Q&EF1L1&F 16 &5&E LL&F$ 16 :EL6&EF/1: R1L/ F:8EL FL3&/84%&EF$ L8 :EL1"1:L& 16 LE6F6L1864 "86F8EL1 L8 %&Q&48: F/E&% "OEE1"O4 6% &%O"L1864 :E8.E55&F

:E8.E55&F$ "85586 58%O4&F R1L/16 %&.E&& :E8.E55&F 8E F/E&% "OEE1"O4O5 E&F8OE"&F ;O1%&416& N7<G

FO::8EL16. OE8:&6 %O40"E&&E 6&LR8E3F E16.16. L8.&L/&E FL3&/84%&EF R/8 E&:E&F&6L16. L/4&L&F$ F:8ELF 8E.61FL186F$ &%O"L1864 16FL1LOL186F$ FO::8EL16. F&EQ1"&F$ 6L1864 OL/8E1L1&F$ "8"/&F 6% OF16&FF&F$ L8 )OEL/&E L/& %1FF&516L186 6% 15:4&5&6LL186 8) L/&F& O1%&416&F ;O1%&416& MM<G

FO::8EL16. E&F&E"/ E&.E%16. L/& 16L&E6L1864 %15&6F186 8) %O40"E&&E :E8.E55&F$ 16 :EL1"O4E E&.E%16. L/& &))&"LF 8) LE6F1L186F 16 L/4&L&FD 41Q&F$ L/& F)&.OE%16. 8) L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 8) T8O6. L/4&L&F 16 &E4T F:&"141FL186 F:8ELF$ L/& &))&"L1Q&6&FF 8) 5&FOE&F 6% FO::8EL16. F&EQ1"&F 16 L/& &5&E LL&F$ 6% L/& E&0&6LET :E8"&FF 8) OE8:&6 L/4&L&F 16L8 L/& 48OE 5E3&L ;O1%&416& M+<G

5861L8E16. 3&T %&Q&48:5&6LF 16 L/& *&4% 8) %O4 "E&&EF 8) L/4&L&F L 6L1864 6% OE8:&6 4&Q&4 6% L8 &Q4OL& L/& 15:4&5&6LL186 8) L/&F& O1%&416&F ;O1%&416& MI<>

1-" 8%(*&'4 ( (' 4$('% (/ /(44$'! 4"%40. 00 4( 74$(' L 1F "4&E )E85 L/& 8Q& %1F"OFF186 LE"16. L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 8) :841"T L/16316. 16 E&4L186 L8 L/1F 1FFO& L/L L/& "86"&E6 L8 :E8L&"L ""&FF L8 &%O"L186 ;6% 8L/&E F:&"LF 8) %O4 "E&&E< /F &&6 FF8"1L&% R1L/ %1F"8OEF& E&4L16. L8 L/4&L&FD E1./LF 16 F1LOL186 16 R/1"/ L/4&L&F 5T & :E&FFOE&% L8 "L .16FL L/&1E 486.0L&E5 &"86851" 6% &5:48T5&6L 16L&E&FLF> 8"/&F 5T E&F1FL L/& :E8L&"L186 8) L/4&L&FD E1./LF 16 L/1F E& R/&E& L/&T )&&4 L/L )8"OF16. 86 &%O"L186 R144 %1FLE"L 6 L/4&L& 6% 4&% L8 FO08:L154 :&E)8E56"&> 8R&Q&E$ R/14& L/& :OEFO1L 8) .84F 16 LR8 %1))&E&6L *&4%F L L/& F5& L15& 51./L & E&.E%&% T F85& F L &FL "85:E851F&$ 6% L R8EFL F .&6&EL16. "86,1"L16. :E18E1L1&F R/1"/ O6%&E516& :&E)8E56"& 16 8L/ &%O"L186 6% &41L& F:8EL$ L/&E& 1F 4F8 F85& &Q1%&6"& L/L L/&F& %O4 :E18E1L1&F "6 & 68L F15:4T 5OLO44T "85:L14& OL 16%&&% "85:4&5&6LET>

6 E&F&E"/ L/L )8448R&% 86 )E85 L/& NVV-FLO%T T 5E &L 4>$ ?O1416N9 F8O./L L8 %%E&FF L/1F 1FFO& T 16Q&FL1.L16. F:8EL16. 6% &%O"L1864 &S:&E1&6"&F 8) &41L& :&E)8E5&EF R/8 R&E& 8E /% &&6 O61Q&EF1LT FLO%&6LF$ %ER6 )E85 L/E&& OE8:&6 "8O6LE1&F# E6"& ;6 &S5:4& 8) R/L L/& NVV-FLO%T /% 4&44&% LL&0&6LE1" TFL&5 8) &*6&% &.4 41.L186<$ 1646% ; LL&0:86F8E&% 8E54 TFL&5 FL41F/&% 86 &E51FF1Q& &.1F4L186< 6% L/& ;6 &S5:4& 8) &:E&F&6LL186 8) L/4&L&F %O"L1864 6L&E&FLF 4E.&4T T :8EL16. 8%1&F<> 6 &"/ "F&$ L/4&L&F ;F1S :&E "8O6LET< R&E& F&4&"L&%$ R/8 R&E& 5&6 6% R85&6 %ER6 )E85 4T5:1" 6%J8E :E8)&FF18641F&% F:8ELFG R&E& 41FL&% F &41L& L/4&L&F 8E R&E& )O44 L15& :E8)&FF1864FG R&E& L "E&&E FL.& E6.16. )E85 L/& &.16616. 8) L/&1E 16L&E6L1864 "E&&E L8 155&%1L& :8FL0E&L1E&5&6LG R&E& "OEE&6L 8E )8E5&E FLO%&6LF R/8 /% 8:L&% L8 FLO%T %OE16. L/&1E &41L& F:8EL "E&&EG 6% R/8 F:83& 6.41F/ ;16 LR8 "F&F R1L/ L/& 1% 8) 6 16L&E:E&L&E<> ?O1416 F8O./L L8 1%&6L1)T L/& 6LOE& 8) L/& L/4&L&FD &S:&E1&6"& 8) L/& LR8 %8516F 6% /8R L/4&L&F 6&.8L1L&% L/& :E&FFOE&F E&FO4L16. )E85 8L/ FTFL&5F>

/& E&F&E"/ 5&L/8% %8:L&% 16Q84Q&% L/& L316. 8) %&L14&% 41)& /1FL8E1&FNN L/L .&6&EL&% 6 &SLE&5&4T E1"/ ?O41LL1Q& %L F&L> L R8O4% 68L & :8FF14& L8 %8 2OFL1"& L8 L/1F FLO%T 16 L/& 4151L&% F:"& 448LL&% /&E& 6% F8 R& E&FLE1"L 8OEF&4Q&F L8 /1./41./L16. 6O5&E 8) L/& L/&5&F$ R/1"/ &5&E.&% )E85 L/&F& 9' 41)& /1FL8E1&F>

"/ 8) L/& &41L& F:8ELF:&EF86F 1%&6L1*&% /% "/8F&6 L8 &6L&E 16L8 6% E&516 R1L/16

86& "6 E&.E% F &16. :8F1L1Q& 8OL O6%&EL316. &%O"L186 16 L6%&5 R1L/ L/&1E &41L& F:8EL LE1616.> /&F& L/E&& 6L1864 FTFL&5F R&E& 16 &))&"L "/8F&6 &"OF& 8) L/&1E %1))&E&6"&F> /& FLL& 16 E6"& :E8Q1%&F F:&"141FL 16FL1LOL186F 16 :EL1"O4E ;- &/0#030 &0#'&$ 3 /)'.0 $-6).0#/ 0 $ ).'.%& 16 E1F< L8 )"141LL& 8L/ F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"& 6% &%O"L1864JQ8"L1864 :E&:EL186 8) L/4&L&F> 6 1646%$ :&E51FF1Q& 4&.1F4L186 448RF )8E L/& FO::8EL 8) L/4&L&F 16 %O4 F:8EL16.(&%O"L1864 "E&&E$ R/1"/ L8.&L/&E R1L/ FLL& *66"14 FO::8EL :&E51LF &41L& L/4&L&F L8 "86L16O& L/&1E &%O"L1864 %&Q&48:5&6L> 6 L/& $ FTFL&5 8) *66"14 FO::8EL )8E F:8EL16. %&Q&48:5&6L 1F ""85:61&% T C48"4D EE6.&5&6LF 5%&$ :EL1"O4E4T T O61Q&EF1L1&F F:&"141F16. 16 F:8ELF F"1&6"& FO"/ F 8O./8E8O./ 6% L/ 61Q&EF1L1&F$ L8 )"141LL& &41L& L/4&L&FD )O4*45&6L 8) &%O"L1864 E&?O1E&5&6LF> 6 44 L/E&& FTFL&5F$ L/4&L&F E&:8EL&% :8F1L1Q& LL1LO%& L8 L/& &6&*LF 8) "86L16O16. R1L/ %O4 &%O"L186(F:8EL "E&&E> %O"L1864 &S:&E1&6"& )"141LL&% F:8EL16. %&Q&48:5&6L$ 6% F3144F %&Q&48:&% 16 L/& F:8EL16. "86L&SL R&E& F&&6 L8 & LE6F)&E4& L8 L/& R8E4%F 8) &%O"L186 6% 8) R8E3>

/& &6&*LF "1L&% 16"4O%&%$ )8E &S5:4&#

/& 6&&% L8 )8"OF 86 58E& L/6 86& F:&"L 8) 41)& R/1"/ E&41&Q&% L/& 16L&6F1LT 8) :E&FFOE& &56L16. )E85 8L/ F:8EL 6% &%O"L1864 :&E)8E56"& /&4:16. L8 C:OL L/16.F 16 :&EF:&"L1Q&DG

&41&) L/L F3144F 4&E6&% 16 86& E& R&E& LE6F)&E4& 6% Q4O&%> 6L&EQ1&R&&F "1L&% F:&"LF FO"/ F# :46616. 6% 8E.61FL186 F3144FG L&5 R8E3G 16L&E:&EF864 F3144FG L/& 141LT L8 F&L .84F$ :E18E1L1F& 6% 5861L8E "/1&Q&5&6LG 516L1616. "8551L5&6LG %&Q&48:5&6L 8) $ 6O5&E"T 6% 41L&E"T$ 6% 64TL1"4 F3144F R/1"/ "6 )"141LL& O6%&EFL6%16. 6% "855O61"L186 16 "8"/16. "86L&SLFG 4&%&EF/1:G 6&LR8E316. 6% OF16&FF RE&6&FFG

)EOFLEL186 R1L/ L/& &S:&E1&6"& 8) /Q16. %&%1"L&% L15& &S"4OF1Q&4T L8 &41L& F:8EL 16 L/& :FL$ 6&.4&"L16. &%O"L186$ OL R/1"/ /% E&FO4L&% 16 516154 15:E8Q&5&6L 16 F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"&G

16L&44&"LO4 FL15O4L186 L8 ""85:6T L/& :/TF1"4 "/44&6.&F 8) LE1616. 6% :&E)8E56"&$ /&4:16. L8 516L16 16L&E&FL 6% "8551L5&6LG

F15:4T :&E)8E516. &LL&E 16 F:8EL 16 6 "%&51" &6Q1E865&6L R/1"/ 1F F:8EL0 )E1&6%4TG

)&&416. 58E& F&"OE& 6% /&6"& :&E)8E516. &LL&E R1L/ L/& CF)&LT 6&LD 8) .1616. ::E8:E1L& ?O41*"L186F$ :E&:E16. )8E )OLOE& 41)& FL.&F 6% 16 :EL1"O4E )8E :8FL0 L/4&L1" "E&&EFG

F&6F& 8) C46"&D 16 E&"8.61F16. L/L L/&E& 1F 58E& L8 41)& L/6 F:8EL$ F8"14 "85)8EL 16 51S16. R1L/ :&&EF>

&6LE4 L8 L/& "86"&E6F &S:E&FF&% 16 E6.& 8) 1FFO&F E1F&% T 16L&EQ1&R&&F 16 L/& "8OEF& 8) 16L&EQ1&RF RF L/& ?O&FL186 8) C46"&D$ "86"&:L 68L )O44T 8:&EL18641F&% 16 L/& 41L&ELOE& ;4& N<> ?O1416DF ::E8"/ L8 .1616. F85& :OE"/F& 86 L/& E&4L1Q& 15:8EL6"& 8E Q4O& :4"&% 86 %1))&E&6L 41)& %8516F ;F:8EL16.$ &%O"L186 8E R8E3$ 6% F8"14< RF L8 F3 FO2&"LF L8 R&1./L L/& Q4O& L/&T :4"&% 86 L/&F& 41)& %8516F> /1F :E8Q1%&F F15:4& OL 6&Q&EL/&4&FF FO..&FL1Q& F&L 8) E&F:86F&F> L 1F 68L "4&E R/&L/&E E&F:86%&6LF 16 L/&1E 6FR&EF R&E& E&)&EE16. L8 L/& Q4O&$ F 8::8F&% L8 L/& L15&J&))8EL .1Q&6 L8 "L1Q1L1&F 16 L/&F& 41)& %8516F> 8R&Q&E$ L/8O./ L/&F& :EL1"O4E %L E& "EO%&$ L/&T 144OFLEL& L/& E&4L1Q& R&1./L16. 16 L&E5F 8) Q4O& 8E &))8EL :4"&% 86 F:8EL F 8::8F&% L8 8L/&E E&F 8) 41)&> /& 68L186 8) R8E3(41)& 46"& RF 86& R/1"/ /F .16&% .E8R16. 1F

E1F&% 16 E&4L186 L8 :FT"/8F8"14 /&4L/> L /F &.O6 L8 LLE"L E&F&E"/ LL&6L186 16 E&4L186 L8 L/& RTF 16 R/1"/ 6860F:8EL16. "L1Q1L1&F 15:16.& 86 F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"&>NM

L F&&5F "4&E L/L )8E F85& L/4&L&F L 4&FL$ F1.61*"6L )"L8E 16 E&51616. )8"OF&% 86 F:8EL16. .84F /% &&6 L/& 8::8ELO61LT L8 46"& F:8EL16. E&?O1E&5&6LF R1L/ 8L/&E %&56%F 8E FL15O41> 6 L/&F& 9' "F& FLO%1&F 8) &41L& L/4&L&F R/8 /% "/8F&6 L8 .8 16L8 /1./&E &%O"L186 R/14& :OEFO16. L/&1E L/4&L1" "E&&E$ &%O"L186 :E8Q1F186 )8E FO"/ L/4&L&F /% &S&EL&% :8F1L1Q& 16,O&6"& 86 F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"&> L 51./L & E.O&% L/L :E44&4 FLO%T 8) L/4&L&F R/8 /% %&"1%&% &'0 L8 :OEFO& %O40"E&&E LE"3$ OL /% :OL L/&1E "%&51" 8E Q8"L1864 "L1Q1L1&F L8 86& F1%& R/14& "85:&L16. L L/& /1./&FL 4&Q&4$ F/8O4% & O6%&EL3&6 L8 &FL41F/ L/& &SL&6L L8 R/1"/ L/& F16.4&0LE"3 ::E8"/ %8:L&% T L/8F& 16%1Q1%O4F 15:"L&% :8F1L1Q&4T 8E 6&.L1Q&4T 86 L/&1E :&E)8E56"&> 8E L/& LT:& 8) L/4&L& 16 ?O1416DF F5:4&$ /8R&Q&E$ L/&E& RF 68 L&6F186 &LR&&6 L/& %O4 "E&&EF$ 6% 16 6O5&E 8) 16FL6"&F L/1F RF E&"8.61F&% T L/&1E "8"/&F F :E8Q1%16. F1.61*"6L .16 16 L&E5F 8) :&E)8E56"&>

/L L/& E&FO4LF 8) L/1F ?O41LL1Q& FLO%T FO..&FL 1F L/L &Q&6 )8E F85& :E8)&FF1864 L&5 F:8ELF ;)88L44 16 L/& "F& 8) 1661F/ L/4&L&$ EO.T 16 L/& "F& 8) E1L1F/ L/4&L& 6% /6%44 16 L/& "F& 8) E&6"/ L/4&L&<$ 1L RF :8FF14& L8 :OEFO& /1./&E &%O"L186 8:L186F &Q&6 L/8O./ L/1F /F &"85& 16"E&F16.4T O6OFO4 16 F8""&E 16 :EL1"O4E ;6% 58E& %1)*"O4L 16 FTFL&5F 58E& "855&E"141F&% L/6 F8""&E 16 1646%<> 85& 8) L/& E&F:86F1141LT )8E )14OE& 8) F:8ELF L8 :E8Q1%& ::E8:E1L& &%O"L1864 8::8ELO61L1&F L8 &41L& F:8ELF:&EF86F 1F LLE1OL&% L8 "8"/&F 6% :&E/:F 8L/&E FL3&/84%&EF R/8 E&.E% &6..16. 16 6T F1.61*"6L "L1Q1LT 8L/&E L/6 LE1616. F %5.16. L8 6 L/4&L&DF :8L&6L14 L8 :&E)8E5>

- ('%70$('0 6 L/1F E&Q1&R$ R& /Q& LE"&% L/& %&Q&48:5&6L 8) :841"T 16 L/& %O40"E&&E %8516 6% F:&"1*"44T L/& E84& 8) L/& > /& EL1864& %8:L&% L L/& 4&Q&4 1F 86& 8) /O56 ;L/4&L&FD< E1./LF 6% L/& :E8L&"L186$ 16 :EL1"O4E$ 8)5168EF> /&F& E1./LF /Q& 68L &&6 )O44T E&F:&"L&% R/&E&$ )8E &S5:4&$ "8"/&F 8E 8L/&E 5&5&EF 8) L/& L/4&L&DF &6L8OE.& /Q& :4"&% :E&FFOE& 86 L/& L/4&L& L8 :OEFO& F:8EL16. :&E)8E56"& .84F L L/& "8FL 8) :E&2O%1"16. 8E &Q&6 6%8616. "L1Q1L1&F 16 L/& *&4% 8) &%O"L186 8E Q8"L1864 :E&:EL186 R/1"/ ;5T< EO6 "8O6L&E L8 L/& L/4&L&DF 486.0L&E5 16L&E&FLF> 8R&Q&E$ F ?O1416DF FLO%T 144OFLEL&F L/&E& 1F .88% &Q1%&6"& L/L )8E F85& ;16%&&% R/&6 R& Q1&R L/& 6O5&E 8) "OEE&6L 6% )8E5&E FLO%&6L(L/4&L&F 16 4T5:1" L&5F )8E &S5:4&$ R& "6 "415 )8E 56T< L/4&L&F$ L/&E& 1F :8F1L1Q& EL/&E L/6 16Q&EF& E&4L186F/1: &LR&&6 &%O"L1864 8::8ELO61L1&F 6% "8551L5&6L 6% F:8EL16. FO""&FF> /14& L/1F 5T 68L & L/& "F& )8E &Q&ET L/4&L& 6% L/& "O4LOE& 6% :E"L1"4 "86L&SLF 8) "&EL16 F:8ELF 5T /Q& LE%1L18644T 5141LL&% .16FL ""8558%L16. &%O"L186 6% Q8"L1864 LE1616.$ L/&E& 1F .88% E.O5&6L )8E FO..&FL16. L/L L/& 5OLO44T E&16)8E"16. E&4L186F/1: &LR&&6 &%O"L186 6% F:8ELF :&E)8E56"& 1F 6 F:&"L L/L "8O4% & 58E& )O44T %%E&FF&% 16 "8"/ &%O"L186> 4L/8O./ L/& EL1864& )8E 16L&EQ&6L186 16 L/1F *&4% 5T & E1./LF F&%$ FO::8EL )8E E&F&E"/ F& L8 /1./41./L$ 68L F15:4T L/& 486.&E0L&E5"8FLF 8) )1416. L8 :E858L& &%O"L1864 6% Q8"L1864 8::8ELO61L1&F$ OL 4F8 L/& "86%1L186F O6%&E R/1"/ 5OLO4 E&16)8E"&5&6L 8) L/&F& .84F 15F "/1&Q&%$ 1F 6 E& 16 R/1"/ :841"T 16L&EQ&6L186 F/8O4% & R&4"85&%>