ABSTRACT
Abstract Charles A. Beard resigned from Columbia University on October 8, 1917 at a
time when modern universities were emerging as significant institutions in the economic
and political development of the United States. Thus, Beard’s highly publicized resignation
came at a time when universities were under exceptional scrutiny by economic and
political elites, who increasingly viewed higher education institutions as either private
corporations which they owned or as extensions of the modern state apparatus. Moreover,
Beard’s resignation came after a long string of dismissals, resignations, and censures at
American universities that progressive historians have ironically chronicled as a history of
the development of academic freedom in the United States. In fact, the early “academic
freedom” cases were successful acts of academic repression and, in this context, Charles A.
Beard’s resignation opened a window onto the realpolitik of American universities, which
have never been ivory towers, but have always been fundamentally political institutions,
where groups and individuals engage in contests for power, authority, and resources
within the framework of even larger social conflicts.
