Nursing Theory, Postmodernism, Post-structuralism, and Foucault critiques mainstream American nursing theory and its use of post-structural theory, comparing and contrasting how postmodern and post-structural ideas have been used fruitfully in nursing research and theorizing elsewhere.

In the late 1980s, references to post-structuralism and Michel Foucault started to appear in nursing journals. Since then, hundreds of nursing publications have cited postmodernism and key post-structural ideas such as power/knowledge, discourse, and de-centring the human subject. In Nursing Theory, Postmodernism, Post-structuralism, and Foucault, Olga Petrovskaya argues that the application of these ideas is markedly different in American nursing theory scholarship compared to nursing theoretical scholarship generated outside the canon of "unique" nursing theory. Analysing relevant literature from the late 1980s through 2010s, she demonstrates this difference, arguing that American nursing theory calcified into a matrix of dogmas built on logical positivism, wary of "borrowed" theory, and loyal to a "unique nursing science." Post-structural ideas that fit the matrix, such as criticism of medicine, are sanctioned, whereas ideas sceptical of humanistic agendas including those that challenge American nursing theory are rendered meaningless. In contrast, other nurse scholars from Britain, Australia, Canada, and what the author calls the American enclave group engaged with postmodern and post-structural perspectives to enrich their research and invite readers to rethink nursing practice. The book showcases examples of their intelligent, creative theorizing. Arguing that American nursing theory enervated nursing theorizing, Petrovskaya calls for opening this matrix to theoretical and methodological creativity, less rigid categories of scholarship, and healthy self-examination.

Making the case that post-structural ideas are vital for nurses’ ability to critically reflect on their discipline and profession, this is a necessary read for all those interested in nursing theory, philosophy, and praxis.

Chapter 1 of this book is available for free in PDF format as Open Access from the individual product page at www.routledge.com. It has been made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 license.

chapter 1|19 pages

Early 21st-Century Canadian Nursing at a Theoretical Crossroads

Between American Nursing Theory and British-Australian Post-structural Theorizing 1
Size: 0.58 MB

chapter 2|18 pages

Establishing the Field of Study

Postmodern, Post-structural, and Foucauldian Nursing Scholarship

chapter 3|20 pages

American Nursing Science and Discipline-Specific Theory

In the Grips of Logical Positivism

chapter 4|24 pages

Postmodern and Post-structural Ideas in American Nursing Texts I

Gortner, Dzurec, Reed, Watson, and Nursing Science Quarterly

chapter 5|20 pages

Postmodern and Post-Structural Ideas in American Nursing Texts II

Advances in Nursing Science and the Enclave Group

chapter 6|18 pages

Postmodern and Post-structural Ideas in Non-American Nursing Literature

Examining Nurse-Patient Relationships and the Holistic Nurse

chapter 7|19 pages

It's Not About Being Comfortable Bedfellows

Why Postmodern and Post-structural Literacy Matters in Nursing