ABSTRACT

Evaluation has come of age. Today most social and political observers would have difficulty imagining a society where evaluation is not a fixture of daily life, from individual programs to local authorities to parliamentary committees. While university researchers, grant makers and public servants may think there are too many types of evaluation, rankings and reviews, evaluation is nonetheless viewed positively by the public. It is perceived as a tool for improvement and evaluators are seen as dedicated to using their knowledge for the benefit of society.

The book examines the degree to which evaluators seek power for their own interests. This perspective is based on a simple assumption: If you are in possession of an asset that can give you power, why not use it for your own interests? Can we really trust evaluation to be a force for the good? To what degree can we talk about self-interest in evaluation, and is this self-interest something that contradicts other interests such as "the benefit of society?" Such questions and others are addressed in this brilliant, innovative, international collection of pioneering contributions.

chapter 1|38 pages

Evaluation

For Public Good or Professional Power?

section I|52 pages

“Do unto Ourselves....”

chapter 2|16 pages

Policy and Evaluation

Many Powers, Many Truths

chapter 3|20 pages

Sharing Power among Evaluation Players

Mission Possible?

section II|83 pages

Game Frontiers: Political and Administrative Players

chapter 5|20 pages

PART

Program Assessment or Power Grab?

chapter 6|20 pages

Co-Ordination of Social Policies at the EU Level

An Ambiguous Relationship between Evaluation and Politics

chapter 7|18 pages

The Power of Illusion

Evaluative Information and Political Steering in Valais

section III|59 pages

To Have and to Hold ... Power

chapter 9|24 pages

Using Their Discretion

How State Audit Institutions Determine Which Performance Audits to Undertake

chapter 10|28 pages

Power Asymmetries and Performance Audits

The Canadian Human Rights Commission and the Auditor General of Canada

chapter |4 pages

Postscript

Evaluators in the Land of Oz—Dealing with Hard and Soft Power