Skip to main content
Taylor & Francis Group Logo
Advanced Search

Click here to search books using title name,author name and keywords.

  • Login
  • Hi, User  
    • Your Account
    • Logout
Advanced Search

Click here to search books using title name,author name and keywords.

Breadcrumbs Section. Click here to navigate to respective pages.

Chapter

Conclusions

Chapter

Conclusions

DOI link for Conclusions

Conclusions book

Comprehensive change and the limits and power of sectorial measures

Conclusions

DOI link for Conclusions

Conclusions book

Comprehensive change and the limits and power of sectorial measures
Edited ByAlessandro Bonanno, Kae Sekine, Hart N. Feuer
BookGeographical Indication and Global Agri-Food

Click here to navigate to parent product.

Edition 1st Edition
First Published 2019
Imprint Routledge
Pages 17
eBook ISBN 9780429470905
OA Funder Kyoto University

ABSTRACT

Based on, but also adding to, the arguments presented in the volume, this final chapter provides an answer to the book’s research question about the emancipatory power of geographical indication (GI) under globalization and neoliberalism. It opens with a brief summary of the overall conclusions derived from the book, which critically reflect on the potential for GI to transform and re-organize the agri-food sector, given the broader constraints at the societal level. Overcoming thorny agri-food constraints requires comprehensive approaches that involve the restructuring of current social arrangements. Following this analysis, the overarching conclusion reached is that GI does not offer solutions to structural problems highlighted by some classic and contemporary literature. However, while GI cannot structurally change the agri-food sector, it generates a number of consequences that can be relevant for emancipatory efforts. These outcomes are synthesized into six additional conclusions. First, the chapter concludes that the emancipatory role of GI depends on local social relations and socioeconomic conditions, which are in turn contingent on existing structural factors and the exercise of human agency. The second conclusion states that the success of GI depends on the way it is implemented. Implementation involves contradictory processes that may include the loss of heterogeneity, local identity and vernacular institutions. The third conclusion finds that GI does not necessarily represent a safeguard against the functioning of the free market, because emancipatory results are often endogenously countered by opposing consequences. The fourth conclusion underscores that GI represents a socially and politically aggregating force that is both necessary and beneficial but is often accompanied by episodes of distrust and conflict. The fifth conclusion rejects the claim that GI protects the environment and supports the sustainable use of natural resources because historical food systems upon which GIs are based do not consistently inhere ecological values. The sixth conclusion indicates that GI supports the desire of producers to remain in farming and food production despite adverse conditions. The chapter ends by contending that the emancipatory power of GI in all of its implementations is contradictory, because it contains elements that simultaneously promote and hamper its ability to improve the socioeconomic conditions of stakeholders and democratize the agri-food sector.

T&F logoTaylor & Francis Group logo
  • Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Cookie Policy
  • Journals
    • Taylor & Francis Online
    • CogentOA
    • Taylor & Francis Online
    • CogentOA
  • Corporate
    • Taylor & Francis Group
    • Taylor & Francis Group
    • Taylor & Francis Group
    • Taylor & Francis Group
  • Help & Contact
    • Students/Researchers
    • Librarians/Institutions
    • Students/Researchers
    • Librarians/Institutions
  • Connect with us

Connect with us

Registered in England & Wales No. 3099067
5 Howick Place | London | SW1P 1WG © 2021 Informa UK Limited