ABSTRACT
Germline editing has a promising potential to prevent not only much human suffering but also animal suffering. There are thus special reasons why a virtuous person would support the advancement of such research. Nevertheless, genome-editing research is often pursued in a vicious manner, demonstrating not only a lack of moral virtue but also a deficiency of intellectual virtue. In this chapter, three germline editing studies that were recently conducted on animals will be evaluated through a virtue ethics framework. It will be shown that these studies, like most other kinds of animal research, are rife with not only moral failings, such as a lack of compassion for laboratory animals, but also intellectual failing, such as a failure to calculate the right means to the end of human health. It will conclude by suggesting some systematic changes that must be made in the animal research community before animal germline research can be characterized as truly virtuous.
