ABSTRACT
J.T. Turner presents a provocative alternative to the traditionalist soul options in the history of Christian thought. In fact, he is something of an outsider in this context. Ironically, although he might be reticent to admit this, his view departs significantly from the majority view within Christian thought and inclines toward modern-day materialism. Whatever implied benefits of body-to-person relation on his hylomorphist-materialism, there are significant philosophical and theological worries. I will briefly respond to one of his challenges, then move to consider the philosophical and theological challenges through the lens of the Tradition.
