ABSTRACT
Charges of inconsistency are frequently made against opponents of abortion for failing to “live out” their beliefs. One such popular charge is that opponents of abortion are inconsistent for failing to “adopt the babies they don’t want aborted”; in this chapter, I will focus on a slightly broader version of this charge. I will understand adoption broadly to include adopting and/or fostering children, as well as concretely supporting the systems involved in facilitating adoption and foster care through financial means, volunteering, and/or advocacy. I will argue that opponents of abortion do not have special obligations to adopt* for the reasons often presumed, and thus are not inconsistent for failing to do so. However, I will go on to argue that they nevertheless have compelling reasons to do so—to decrease future abortions and oppose abortion with integrity.
