This chapter explores the question of how to care for scholarly accounts, expanding one of the central concerns that shaped ANT as an intellectual practice: Where and how to study agency and how this relates to knowledge politics. Drawing on ethnographic observations on prostate cancer screening practices, I show how attending to ‘(not) knowing and (not) moving/being moved by an other’ helps to understand the difference speculative commitment to neglected things can make in our scholarly accounts. I suggest that ‘motile not-knowing an “other”’ and going along with ‘neglected things’ and seeing where such going along leads us in our scholarly accounts comes with fostering ‘caring obligations.’ Such obligations to reciprocate attentiveness to others happen asymmetrically and dare to keep the question of ‘how to care’ through our scholarly accounts open. Starting from the tension between agency as ‘an unanticipated gift from the “dispositif,”’ this chapter is thereby attending to both: ANT concerns about decentring human agency, while also focusing on what humans do, once agency has become a gift from the dispositif.