ABSTRACT
In this chapter, the author (re)examines the linkages between State discourse and social movement advocacy efforts that have emerged in conjunction with the legislative struggles concerning ‘gay marriage’ and the repeal of ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’. Drawing on data gathered from United States Department of Justice policy briefs related to same-sex marriage and LGBTQ service in the military, the author identifies key three themes: 1) neoliberal constructions of citizenship, 2) U.S. nationalism, and finally, 3) the construction of a neutral government with a historical foundation of justice. The text then focuses on the implications of these discursive assemblages and their unlikely marriage with LGBT advocacy efforts by the Human Rights Campaign that – despite intentions – renders some LGBT bodies as worthy of State-given rights and others as undeserving. The chapter concludes by placing the policy briefs and rights-based claims in conversation with the contemporary political climate that increasingly poses threats to marginalized populations. This is done to shed light on both the pitfalls of neoliberal social movement strategies and potential examples of equitable social justice in trying times.
