ABSTRACT
Z@[,<P >* BW 1@N '@>P@>>VP( * H 1 D 0 >* 3 B , ' = ( E + - ; . /G
9V7 1,[ ,\',DV9@>P V7, 1@<<@[9>6 9=D@NV>V '@NN,PD@>*,>', 7@<*P
#,V[,,> <,VV,NP >* D7@>,=,P 9> 'N,1Y<<] DN@>@Y>',* V>*N* 9>>9P7
ED7@>,=,P N, P@Y>*P V7@Y67V @1 P V]D,P) 9NN,PD,'V9Z, @1 P<967V ZN98
V9@>P 9> V7, PD,,'7 @1 V7, P=, D,NP@> @N #,V[,,> *911,N,>V D,@D<,FG
%7 <+TT+M %@MM+NC@>)N T@ @>+ >) T7+ N=+ C7@>+=+' >) +%7
C7@>+=+ %@MM+NC@>)N T@ @>+ >) T7+ N=+ <+TT+MF
@V, V7, 1@<<@[9>6 DN@>Y>'9V9@> *,V9<P(
& 7, Z@[,< '@NN,PD@>*9>6 V@ V7, <,VV,N 9P > @D,> Y>N@Y>*,*
1N@>V Z@[,< E'1G V7, P7@NV Z@[,<P 9> N9V9P7 >6<9P7 LP7<<) NVM) >*
V7, <@>6 Z@[,< 9> [,*9P7 4 L#,NN]MFG
& 7, Z@[,< '@NN,PD@>*9>6 V@ V7, <,VV,N H 9P '<@P, N@Y>*,* 1N@>V
Z@[,< E'1G ,N=> <4FG
& 7, Z@[,< '@NN,PD@>*9>6 V@ V7, <,VV,N 1 9P 7<18'<@P, N@Y>*,*
,G6G ; /'= LV9N,MG
& 7, <,VV,N / #,1@N, , 9P DN@>@Y>',* P 19N<] <@>6 $% P@Y>* P
9> -=*/,* $7,<P9;9% E'1G >6<9P7 L*N9>;MFG
& 7,> <,>6V7 9P YP,* V@ *911,N,>V9V, =,>9>6P) P7@NV D7@>,=,P N,
[N9VV,> [9V7 @>, <,VV,N >* <@>6 D7@>,=,P [9V7 V[@) P 9> BD-* L2N,M
/ BDD-* L[9>*M / BD--* L'YPV@=PMQ ,/= LD,@D<,M / ,/== LEV@6,V7,NF
[9V7MQ .DB L=Y*M E>@=9>V9Z, 'P,F / .DB@ L=Y*M EDNV9V9Z,
'P,FG
& =,P @1 [,*9P7 @N969> =] '@>V9> V7, <,VV,N 45 P 9> 0
E9>>G D;,D) D<', >=,F) , E=<, >=,F) E;B ED<', >=,FG
@N*P @1 1@N,96> @N969> =] '@>V9> @V7,N <,VV,NP V7> V7@P,
=,>V9@>,* #@Z,) 1@N ,\=D<, % = F G J J P 9> //*
L#>>M) %;0 L7N@7M) = ,,* L^,'7 ,DY#<9'M) .(;J
L=7N:7MG
& 7, <D7#,V9'< @N*,N @1 <,VV,NP 9P % ' ( * + , - . / 0 3 7 ; = B
D E F G H J 1G
& 7, DN@>Y>'9V9@> @1 V7, ,Z,N]*] PD@;,> <>6Y6, *911,NP 9>
P,Z,N< N,PD,'VP 1N@= V7V @1 V7, PV>*N* PD@;,> >@N= EP,,
7DV,N XXFG 7, PVN9'V '@NN,PD@>*,>', #,V[,,> <,VV,NP >*
D7@>,=,P *@,P >@V 7@<* 9> ,Z,N]*] PD@;,> <>6Y6,G
RDR =V)9J ;' $=;J=;;PJ
9>>9P7 EDNV 1N@= [@N*P @1 1@N,96> @N969>F 7P ,967V Z@[,< >* BW
'@>P@>>V D7@>,=,P( * H 1 D 0 >* 3 B , = ( E + - ; . / G
<< Z@[,<P >* <=@PV << '@>P@>>VP '> @''YN P ,9V7,N P7@NV @N <@>6
P@Y>*P ED7@>,=,PFG 7, D7@>,V9' *,2>9V9@>P @1 V7, 9>>9P7 Z@[,<P >*
'@>P@>>VP N, P 1@<<@[P E[9V7 ,\=D<,P @1 >,N8,HY9Z<,>V N9V9P7
>6<9P7 P@Y>*PF(
6 %<@N+ 1M@>T W>M@W>)+) N<++C
) 7<18%<@N+ 1M@>T W>M@W>)+) "+)
@C+> 1M@>T W>M@W>)+) ">;
X %<@N+ 1M@>T M@W>)+)
? 7<18%<@N+ 1M@>T M@W>)+)
S %<@N+ "%; M@W>)+) "@@;
= 7<18%<@N+ "%; M@W>)+) )@%;
R
M@>W>%98
T9@> >)
N@W>)
NTMW%TWM+
D,'9< VV,>V9@> P7@Y<* #, D9* V@ V7, 1@<<@[9>6 *,V9<PG
& 7,N, 9P >@ *911,N,>', 9> HY<9V] #,V[,,> V7, '@NN,PD@>*9>6 <@>6
>* P7@NV Z@[,<P ** # *) # ) # ) HH # H) 11 # 1) DD # D) 00 # 0)
# G
& << <@>6 Z@[,<P N, DN@>@Y>',* P DYN, <@>6 Z@[,<P) >@V P 91 V7,]
[,N, *9D7V7@>6P @N P 91 V7,] ,>*,* 9> )+ @N )FG
& 7, Z@[,< H $]% 9P NV9'Y<V,* [9V7 PVN@>6<] DN@VNY*,* <9DP >*
P=<< @D,>9>6 #,V[,,> V7,=G
& 7, HY<9V] @1 V7, <@>6 Z@[,< 11 9P $C(% >* V7V @1 V7, P7@NV 1 9P
$C%) '1G =*/T,18 L]@YIM) 31--1 L@[<M) .1;,1 L6@#<9>M) ;3*1@1/ LV@
ND9AM E9<<V9Z, 'P,FG 7, <9DP N, DN@VNY*,* >* 7<18'<@P,*G
& 7, Z@[,<P >* ) >* <P@ >* N, *911,N,>V9V,* 9> <<
D@P9V9@>P 9> [@N*) 9>'<Y*9>6 #,1@N, ; >* 9> Y>PVN,PP,* P]<<#<,PG
1G B L]@YM / B LV,M) . @*@-- LV@ YPM # . @*@-- L JVK YPM E V @YN
7@YP,F) B @-- L[9V7 V,M / B-- L7,N,M) 3*=B LD@9>VM / 3*=B$
LPV9>60M) E / @/ L@1 V7, #@VM / / /@/ L9>V@ TV7, >@P,M) - (B*
L<,1M / -(B@* LEP7,T7,F <,1VM) E ;* L#<@@*M / E;* L'@<@YNM) 3 ;, -
L*,Z9<M) . ;,,* L=N;M) E* E=<, >=,F) E; L[N@>6MG
& 7, '@>P@>>VP 3 B , N, DN@>@Y>',* [9V7@YV PD9NV9@>) 9G,G
[9V7@YV #N,V7] L7M P@Y>* 1V,N V7,=G
& 7, '@>P@>>V = 9P @1V,> DN@>@Y>',* P NV7,N *N;) V79'; P@Y>*
V7V '> #, '<@P, V@ =) ,PD,'9<<] 9> V7, ,>Z9N@>=,>V @1 DG 1G 3D==*
P W>X@9%+) W>NC9MT+) <X+@<M NT@C "9T
8 W>X@9%+) W>NC9MT+) X+<M NT@C M@%;
' X@9%+) <Z <X+@<M NT@C )@Y>
J W>X@9%+) <X+@<M N9"9<>T N@W>)
4 6<@TT< 1M9%T9X+ @M 6<9)+ 7@>+[
U X@9%+) <"9@)+>T< 1M9%T9X+ @M 6<9)+ X@9%+
7 X@9%+) C<T< 6<9)+ [@W>6
9 X@9%+) <X+@<M <T+M< @>)@>
I X@9%+) <X+@<M TM9<< M@W>)
: X@9%+) "9<"9< >N< =+T<
; X@9%+) <X+@<M >N< >@9N+
X@9%+) X+<M >N< M9>6
@Y+<N >)
%@>N@>>TN
DN@8
>@Y>',* [,;<]G V '> <P@ '@8@''YN [9V7 '@>P@>>VP) >* 9P V7,>
PVN@>6,N P@Y>*) DNV9'Y<N<] 91 V7, 1@<<@[9>6 '@>P@>>V 9P B
@N ,G 1G (D0/0 L#*M) .* ( @/ L@1 TV7, =>M) 3( L,Z9<M) *(.*/ /
LD,NP@>M) E;(*/ L,N<]M) E/( L@<*M) E*(,0 L>@V,#@@;M) E*(B
L#Y>'7 @1 #9N'7 V[96PM) =(,1 L,<,'VN9'9V]M) BD(, LP7MG
& 7, '@>P@>>V - 9P DN@>@Y>',* P NV7,N V79'; P@Y>* [7,> 9V
@''YNP #,V[,,> V7, Z@[,<P D >* 0G 1G 3D--0 L#@VV<,M) (D--D L=*M)
,D-B L6@<*M) 3- L#9VM) E*--* L[9<*MG
& 7, '@>P@>>V ; 9P <[]P VN9<<,* [9V7 V7, V9D @1 V7, V@>6Y,) ,G6G
3H1; L[7,,<M) 0;* EV@[>F) D;,D EV@[>F) E*;;@== L9> V7, PVN,=M)
,* ;;@/ L VYN>MG
& !84 ',NV9> 6N==V9'< 1@N=P V7, 9>9V9< '@>P@>>V @1 V7,
1@<<@[9>6 [@N* @N DNV9'<, )+#8$+5G 7,P, 1@N=P N, =9><]
>@=9><P ,>*9>6 9> ) <9;, 3 ;( L1=9<]M EP,'V9@> 3GWF) V7, DN,P,>V
9>*9'V9Z, >,6V9Z,) ,G6G / BD-L = >@V '@=9>6M EP,'V9@> RGWF) V7,
P,'@>* D,NP@> P9>6Y<N 9=D,NV9Z,) ,G6G BD-$ L'@=,0M EP,'V9@>
B3GWF) >* V7, 2NPV 9>2>9V9Z, E 9>2>9V9Z,F) ,G6G BD-@- LEV@F '@=,M
EP,'V9@> BRGXFG
\=D<,P(
/4!>D+H! ?!10 47 ?(7 :);) A=6J-":);)AA=6J#
#6@ Y[0$
=9) 4697- "=9)44697#
#"+ GW9+T0$
PS9) P;;)- "PS9)PP;;)#
#%@=+ 7+M+0$
1/+0D+H! +0 5) U);) PS9N6 "U);)PPS96#
#T7+ "@T %=+$
U);)N86; "U);)886;#
#T7+ "@T' T@@$
9668):6)J "9668)::6)J#
#"WN9>+NN=>$
>!?7 +0+7 0!(D+H! ); PS9) SI8SNS; ");PS9)PPSI8SS;#
L= >@T %@=9>6 T@ WM;W
)::) PS9)N8; ")::)PS9)88;#
+LM+ >@T %@=9>6 1T+M <<
); =9) J6IJ ");=9)JJ6IJ#
R
M@>W>%98
T9@> >)
N@W>)
NTMW%TWM+
RDQ 4=IP ;' 9=;3 J=S;'J
7, *911,N,>', #,V[,,> P7@NV >* <@>6 P@Y>*P 9P YP,* Z,N] [9*,<] 9>
9>>9P7 V@ *9PV9>6Y9P7 *911,N,>V [@N*PG @>6 P@Y>*P '> @''YN 9> <=@PV
>] D@P9V9@> 9> [@N*) >* V7,N, N, 1,[ N,PVN9'V9@>P @> D,N=9PP9#<,
'@=#9>V9@>P @1 <@>6 >* P7@NV P@Y>*PG 79P 9P '<,N 1N@= V7, 1@<<@[9>6
,\=D<,PG
<=@PV << V7, D@PP9#<, '@=#9>V9@>P @1 P7@NV >* <@>6 P@Y>*P @''YN(
P7@NV8P7@NV8P7@NV) P7@NV8<@>68P7@NV) <@>68P7@NV8<@>6) <@>68<@>68P7@NV)
P7@NV8<@>68<@>6) <@>68<@>68<@>6) ,V'G @V, 9> DNV9'Y<N V7, 1@<<@[9>6
V7N,, D@9>VP(
7+M+ 9N )911+M+>%+ "+TY++> N7@MT >) <@>6 X@Y+< "+1@M+ N7@MT
>) <@>6 %@>N@>>TF
\=D<,P(
+>?D +0%0+D+H! 49SN; =9N9 P99 "49S;=99PP99#
Y>T T@ "+ 7+M+
49SN; 94P)N A=6J "49S;94P)AA=6J#
Y>T T@ 6@ Y[
F. P;;)- 1/! 7+M+0
98=; )6 CFF. 8 WTN9)+ +D +? 01D I+0KF
98=; )6 CFF.R. 8 WTN9)+ +D +? 4>1.K 01D I+0KF
98=; CFF. R F WTN9)+ +D +? I+0KF
96; CF. R F <9> 1/!?F
96; CF.R. R F <9> I+.. 4>1.K 1/!F
98=; CFF.R. R F WTN9)+ +D +? 4>1.K I+0KF
P696 %%@W>T P6696 "M9%; P6996 )9<<
PS96 2M+ PSS96 Y9>) PS996 %WNT@=N
:SPP "WT :SSPPN DT@E %7>6+ :SSNP @T7+M DCMT9T9X+
%N+E
:S; +66 :SSN; @T7+M
:SS;;- TM>N1@M=0
7@MT >)
<@>6
N@W>)N
*9PV9>'V
=,>9>6P(
7+M+ 9N )9NT9>%T9@> "+TY++> N7@MT >) <@>6 A' P' 8 @M J Y7+> 9T
@%%WMN 1T+M 9'I':'; @M F+1@M+ N7@MT A'P'8 @M J T7+ %@>N@>>TN 9'I'
:' ; >) M+ 19M<[ <@>6F
\=D<,P(
7YP) ,/== LV@6,V7,N [9V7M 9P DN@>@Y>',* [9V7 P7@NV $>%8P@Y>* >*
<@>6 $P%8P@Y>*) [79<, ,/= LD,@D<,M 9P DN@>@Y>',* [9V7 P7@NV $P%8
P@Y>* >* P7@NV @N 7<18<@>6 $>%8P@Y>*G
7, =9> PVN,PP 9P <[]P @> V7, 2NPV P]<<#<, @1 V7, [@N* EP,'V9@>
XGSFG @>6 Z@[,<P ,<P,[7,N, V7> 9> V7, 2NPV P]<<#<, N, DN@>@Y>',*
[9V7@YV =9> PVN,PP) '1G B-0@0/ L9>V@ V7, 7@YP,M) (I33@/ L :Y=DM)
,33*@*/ L9>V@ V7, 'YD#@N*M) ;E*/B0-@/ L9>V@ V7, N,PVYN>VM) B-0@
==@/ L9> 7,NT79P 7@YP,M) !-=*/'*@== L9> ,<P9>;9MG
P88 2M+C<%+
P88 "WM)+>
P88N 2M+C<%+ DCMT9T9X+ %N+E
P88N "WM)+> DCMT9T9X+ %N+E
P8 "%;
P8 1M@= "+79>)
8IP- X@9)0 / 8IPP =C
8=IA6 Y9<)+M>+NN / 8=IAA6 MX+>
I86 Y++;)[ / I886 M;
8;J C+@C<+ / 8;JJ DT@6+T7+ME Y9T7
A)98= 1+M / A9886 "+=
9:A6 C@>) / 9:AAS <=C
U9P C@Y+M / U9PP6 TMW=C
J;8 NC+%T%<+ 1M=+ / J;88 )+>N+
R
M@>W>%98
T9@> >)
N@W>)
NTMW%TWM+
RD2 6A4P4=;3J
9>>9P7 7P BS '@==@> *9D7V7@>6P) 9G,G '@=#9>V9@>P @1 V[@ Z@[,<P
@''YNN9>6 9> V7, P=, P]<<#<,G 9D7V7@>6P '> #, *9Z9*,* 9>V@ 1@YN
6N@YDP ''@N*9>6 V@ V7, 2>< Z@[,<G
@V, DNV9'Y<N<] V7, *911,N,>',P #,V[,,> V7, D9NP * / *) 1* / 1H) H /
1H) * / D >* H / DG 9>>9P7 <P@ 7P @V7,N ;9>*P @1 Z@[,< '@=8
#9>V9@>P) #YV V7,P, @V7,NP *@ >@V 1@N= *9D7V7@>6PG ,V[,,> V7,P,
Z@[,<P V7,N, 9P <=@PV <[]P P]<<#<, #@Y>*N]) 7,N, 9>*9'V,* #]
*@V) LGMG \=D<,P(
J;=DN DT@E N[ ISA)DN; "+69>
6;=D @><[ PA4PSDN DT@E 7CC+>
U68)D )912%W<T 86I)D T+>N+
J996DN DT@E <<@Y )PJ6DN DT@E <@@; 1@M
9C7T7@>6N
RD0 X99!9)J
]<<#92'V9@> 9> 9>>9P7 9P 9> =@PV 'P,P *,V,N=9>,* #] V7, 1@<<@[9>6
#P9' NY<,G
7+M+ 9N N[<<"<+ "@W>)M[ "+1@M+ +X+M[ N+GW+>%+ @1 N9>6<+ %@>8
N@>>T 1@<<@Y+) "[ X@Y+<F
> V7, 1@<<@[9>6 ,\=D<,P V7, P]<<#<, #@Y>*N] 9P 9>*9'V,* #]
*@V) LGM(
P V7, ,\=D<,P P7@[) =@ND7@<@69'< >* P]<<#<, #@Y>*N9,P @1V,>
'@9>'9*,) P 9> /*=6@B6@,*/G YV V79P 9P '@9>'9*,>V<G ,N] @1V,> =@N8
D7@<@69'< #@Y>*N9,P @''YN [9V79> P]<<#<,P) >* V7,N, =] ,Z,> #,
V[@ =@ND7@<@69'< #@Y>*N9,P [9V79> V7, P=, P]<<#<,) P 9> V7, 2NPV
P]<<#<, @1 3D@*@=6=G 7,N, 9P <P@ P]<<#<, #@Y>*N] 9> V7, =9**<, @1
',NV9> Z@[,< D9NP PY'7 P V7@P, V V7, ,>* @1 P,'V9@> XG5) ,G6G =6/06@
LEV@F P]M) ,*6; 6 LV,>P,MG
RDM PI)JJ ;' 6;P=;P6=;
9>>9P7 [@N* PVN,PP 1@<<@[P V79P 9=D@NV>V NY<,(
7+ =9> NTM+NN 9N <Y[N @> T7+ 2MNT N[<<"<+ @1 T7+ Y@M)F
@[,<P ,<P,[7,N, V7> 9> V7, 2NPV P]<<#<, V7,N,1@N, *@ >@V N,',9Z,
8D9 RT7+ 2N7 7=D86D;); +X+M[
8S6DP);DN86; 7@Y+X+M J6PDP); T7+>
A6DU RT7+ )[ 9D8N DT@E "+69>
ASID86NJDJ 9> RT7+ :M ASI8D86N6; 9>T@ RT7+ :M
;DP6N; @1 >TT9 ;DP6N9D9) T@ >TT9
)9DJ6;D86N6; T@ +<N9>;9 )9DJ6;D36NJDJDN86; 9> +<N9>;9' T@@
ASN6NJDJ 9> DT7+E TM++N ;6JDNPDN86; <N@ RT7+ Y@=>
DCMT9T9X+ %N+E
R
M@>W>%98
T9@> >)
N@W>)
NTMW%TWM+
\=D<,P(
9>>9P7 P,>V,>', 9>V@>V9@> 9P 6,>,N<<] 1<<9>6) #YV V7, 2NPV P]<<#<, @1
V7, 2>< [@N* @1 P,>V,>', '> >,Z,NV7,<,PP #, DN@>@Y>',* [9V7
N9P9>6 9>V@>V9@> [9V7@YV V7, [@N* #,9>6 69Z,> PVN@>6 PVN,PPG >
V7, 1@<<@[9>6 ,\=D<,P V7, 9>V@>V9@> '@>V@YN 9P P7@[> #@Z, V7,
P,>V,>',G
7,> [@N* >,,*P V@ #, 69Z,> DNV9'Y<N<] PVN@>6 ,=D7P9P V79P 9P *@>,
#] =,>P @1 9>V@>V9@>G > **9V9@>) PY'7 [@N* 9P @1V,> =@Z,* V@ V7,
#,69>>9>6 @1 V7, P,>V,>',G
TM+NN >)
9>T@>T9@>
RDL =V)9 4I:=;X
>] ,>*9>6P @''YN 9> V[@ 1@N=P [9V7 <V,N>V9Z, Z@[,<P) ,G6G )==
)== L9>M) ),0 ),1 E9>V,NN@6V9Z,F) )/DB )/HB EDPV DNV9'9D<,FG 7,P,
Z@[,< <V,N>V9@>P 1@N= V7N,, D9NPQ ,'7 D9N 7P @>, #'; Z@[,< >*
@>, 1N@>V Z@[,<G
1 69Z,> ,>*9>6 '@>V9>P @>, @1 V7,P, P9\ Z@[,<P) V7,N, [9<< <P@ ,\9PV
DN<<,< ,>*9>6 [9V7 V7, @V7,N Z@[,< @1 V7, D9NG 1 [, 7Z, V7, ,>*9>6
)(/ L,=D7P9PM) V7,N, [9<< <P@ #, )(/Q 91 ),0@0/ EV79N* DG P6G 9=DGF)
V7,> <P@ ),1@1/ ,V'G 7, Z@[,<P @1 V7, PV,= *,V,N=9>, [79'7 ,>*9>6 @1
V7, D9N 9P V@ #, '7@P,>G
1 T7+ NT+= %@>T9>N @>+ @M =@M+ @1 T7+ X@Y+<N S' =' ' T7+ +>)9>6 <N@
7N T@ 7X+ "%; X@Y+< DS' =' EF 1 T7+ NT+= 7N >@ "%; X@Y+<N' T7+
+>)9>6 7N T@ 7X+ 1M@>T X@Y+< DX' ?' EF
( ;,<) 5,+9 ;,<) =*-)
5JJ 5JJ
= ? 58= 58?
