Skip to main content
Taylor & Francis Group Logo
    Advanced Search

    Click here to search products using title name,author name and keywords.

    • Login
    • Hi, User  
      • Your Account
      • Logout
      Advanced Search

      Click here to search products using title name,author name and keywords.

      Breadcrumbs Section. Click here to navigate to respective pages.

      Chapter

      Iliadic Refraction
      loading

      Chapter

      Iliadic Refraction

      DOI link for Iliadic Refraction

      Iliadic Refraction book

      Iliadic Refraction

      DOI link for Iliadic Refraction

      Iliadic Refraction book

      ByEdan Dekel
      BookVirgil's Homeric Lens

      Click here to navigate to parent product.

      Edition 1st Edition
      First Published 2011
      Imprint Routledge
      Pages 34
      eBook ISBN 9780203806227
      Share
      Share

      ABSTRACT

      If the reputation of the Aeneid relative to the Homeric poems has fl uctuated greatly in the history of literary criticism, that of the Odyssey has consistently suffered by comparison to the Iliad.1 For many centuries, conventional wisdom viewed the Iliad as a profound poem about heroism, honor, and death, while the Odyssey was often seen as a more disparate collection of character studies and domestic vignettes. In antiquity, the difference between the poems is fi rst described explicitly by Aristotle (Poet. 1459b13-15):

      The pathos of the Iliad is linked to its simple construction, while the complexity of the Odyssey is associated with its emphasis on “recognitions” and êthos.2 On the face of it, this dichotomy does not seem to embody any actual value judgment, only an analytical description of the structure and primary thematic mode of each poem. At a much later stage of the commentary tradition, the twelfth-century Byzantine scholar Eustathius transforms the Aristotelean distinction into a more direct comparison in his discussion of the proem of the Iliad (Comm. ad Il. 1.7.5-7):

      While this certainly implies that the Iliad contains more of the qualities that we commonly associate with epic, there is still a clear attempt to weigh the relative merits of the two poems without explicitly privileging one over the other. The greater solemnity and heroism of the Iliad are balanced by the Odyssey’s superior clarity and character interest. Furthermore, Eustathius seems to contradict Aristotle directly in describing the Odyssey as the clearer (saphesteron) of the two poems.

      T&F logoTaylor & Francis Group logo
      • Policies
        • Privacy Policy
        • Terms & Conditions
        • Cookie Policy
        • Privacy Policy
        • Terms & Conditions
        • Cookie Policy
      • Journals
        • Taylor & Francis Online
        • CogentOA
        • Taylor & Francis Online
        • CogentOA
      • Corporate
        • Taylor & Francis Group
        • Taylor & Francis Group
        • Taylor & Francis Group
        • Taylor & Francis Group
      • Help & Contact
        • Students/Researchers
        • Librarians/Institutions
        • Students/Researchers
        • Librarians/Institutions
      • Connect with us

      Connect with us

      Registered in England & Wales No. 3099067
      5 Howick Place | London | SW1P 1WG © 2022 Informa UK Limited