ABSTRACT

If you say ‘murder is wrong’, one question to ask is: why is it wrong? Come up with as many explanations as you can of why murder is wrong.

In philosophy of religion there is a classical problem called the Euthyphro dilemma that comes from the writings of Plato. The crunch point of the dilemma is a question that Socrates raises about how goodness is defined:

Is an action ‘good’ because:

1 God commands it, or 2 God commands what is good?