ABSTRACT

The murder of James Standsfield by his son Philip resulted in a high-profile trial that captured the Scottish public’s imagination for several centuries. During the trial, it emerged that Philip was the classic prodigal son, who had left home and behaved immorally, before returning chastened to the family home. He had resented his father’s authority however, causing the father significant grief, before – or so it was alleged – finally killing him and covering up the murder. The trial contained both sentimental moments, including descriptions by James’ friends of his anxiety and grief about his son’s behaviour, and the supernatural – the body bled when touched by Philip and he was haunted by a ghost. To modern eyes, some events appear unbelievable but they capture the horror of parricide for seventeenth-century Scots, a crime that disrupted natural hierarchies within the family as well as normative ideals of the parent-child relationship.