ABSTRACT

This irregular sonnet was first published in the Original Poetry section of Leigh Hunt’s The Literary Pocket-Book for 1823 (LPB) 115, where it is entitled To —— and signed with the Gk capital letter sigma Σ. Hunt appears to have printed it from a fair copy in S.’s hand, originally in Harvard Nbk 1 but torn from it (no doubt to allow him to make a copy for the press), and now in Box 1 f. 75r: see headnote to To —— [Lines to a Critic]. S. transcribed the fair copy himself from his draft of ll. 1–8 in Nbk 11 179–80 and of ll. 9–13 in Nbk 10 f. 28v rev. Neither draft is titled. In Harvard Nbk 1, the text is headed To ——, which is written with a different pen-point, probably (as MYRS v suggests) by Mary. In the list of Contents that she made at the end of Harvard Nbk 1, the poem is identified as To —— a sonnet, even though it contains only thirteen lines and lacks a sonnet’s rhyme-scheme. In 1824 it is called simply Sonnet III and is undated, only acquiring the title by which it has generally been known, Lines to a Reviewer, in 1839 (iv 48), where it is included among the Poems Written in 1820.