ABSTRACT
Indigenous peoples number over 350 million AROUND THE GLOBE ANDPOSSIBLYMANYMOREDEPENDINGONHOWONEDElNESindigenous.4HISNUMBERISCOMPRISEDOFMOREINDIVIDUALSTHANTHEENTIREPOPULATIONOFTHE5NITED 3TATESORABOUTTHEEQUIVALENTOFTHE%UROPEAN5NION)TINCLUDESONTHEORDER OFDIFFERENTCULTURES4HUSINDIGENOUSPEOPLESCONSTITUTEABOUTPERCENT OFTHEWORLDSPOPULATIONˆBUTMORESIGNIlCANTLYTHEYACCOUNTFORASMUCHAS PERCENTOFTHEWORLDSCULTURALDIVERSITY3TILLMANYWRITERSHAVEPREDICTEDTHE DEMISEOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLESESPECIALLYFORNATIVENATIONSIN.ORTH!MERICA&OR INSTANCEINTHELATENINETEENTHCENTURY4HOMAS*EFFERSON-ORGANTHECOMMIS SIONEROF)NDIAN!FFAIRSCLAIMEDh4HEGREATBODYOF)NDIANSWILLBECOMEMERGED INTHEINDISTINGUISHABLEMASSOFOURPOPULATIONvQUOTEDIN)VERSONn SEEALSO#ADWALADERAND$ELORIAONENVISIONEDDISAPPEARANCE (OWEVER
.ATIVE!MERICANSARENOTONLYhSTILLHEREvBUTALSOONEOFTHEFASTEST GROWING SEGMENTSOFTHE53POPULATION3NIPP.AGEL 4HISIS ALSOTRUEFORINDIGENOUSPEOPLESINMUCHOFTHERESTOFTHEWORLD
#ONFRONTATIONSANDCONmICTSBETWEENSTATESANDINDIGENOUSPEOPLESAREAS OLDASSTATESTHEMSELVES#HASE $UNNAND(ALL #LEARLYSTATESHAVEBEEN UNILATERALLYSUCCESSFULINDISPLACINGABSORBINGINCORPORATINGASSIMILATINGOR DESTROYINGINDIGENOUSPEOPLESOVERTHEPASTYEARS9ETDESPITEMYRIADDIRE PREDICTIONSˆANDMOREIMPORTANTLYREPEATEDMILITARYANDSOCIALACTIONSDIRECTED AGAINSTTHEMBYSTATESˆMANYINDIGENOUSPEOPLESHAVERESISTEDSTEADFASTLYAND SURVIVEDATTEMPTSATTOTALANNIHILATION#ERTAINLYONEMIGHTRESPONDh.OTYET BUTSOONv"UThSOONvISNOWMANYCENTURIESOLD4HUSTHEQUESTIONREMAINSAS TOHOWORWHYINDIGENOUSPEOPLESHAVESURVIVEDTHEONSLAUGHTSAGAINSTTHEM )NPARTICULARHOWHAVETHEYSURVIVEDINTOTHEEARLYTWENTY lRSTCENTURYWHEN THEREARENOMOREREGIONSOUTSIDETHEREACHOFGLOBALCAPITALISMANDNOREGIONS THATARENOTCLAIMEDBYONEORMORESTATES
7EBEGINBYSKETCHINGAFEWOFTHEWAYSINDIGENOUSPEOPLESHAVESURVIVED 4HEEXAMPLESWILLILLUSTRATEAMONGMANYOTHERTHINGSTHENEEDTOINCREASETHE PRECISIONOFCONCEPTSWEUSETODISCUSSINDIGENOUSSURVIVAL4HISINTURNREQUIRES REEXAMINATIONOFTHEORETICAL ISSUES INCLUDINGNOTONLYINDIGENOUSPEOPLESBUT ALSOQUESTIONSABOUTTHEORIGINANDPROCESSESOFGLOBALIZATION"ERGERAND(UN TINGTON#HASE $UNN#HASE $UNNETAL&EATHERSTONE &EATHERSTONEETAL'ILLS(OLTON+ING-ANNING 0ODOBNIK2OBERTSON2OBINSON3KLAIR 3MITHAND*OHNSTON /UREXPLORATIONOFTHEPUZZLEOFHOWPEOPLEWITHOUT MASSIVERESOURCESNUMBERSORWEAPONSCANRESISTTHETRANSFORMATIVEANDOFTEN DESTRUCTIVEEFFECTSOFGLOBALIZATIONWILLSHEDSOMELIGHTONTHEGENERALPROCESSES OFGLOBALIZATIONANDRESISTANCETOIT
4HESUBJECTOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLESINAGLOBALCONTEXTISAVERYLARGEAND VERYCOMPLEXTOPIC!CTUALLYITISASETOFDISCUSSIONSFRAUGHTWITHCONTROVERSIES ANDCONTENTIONSINCLUDINGOVERTHEBASICCONCEPTSANDTERMINOLOGIESUSED-ANY SCHOLARSUSEACOMMONGLOSSFORINDIGENOUSPEOPLES!MERICAN)NDIANSORPEOPLES LIKETHEM4HEREAREMYRIADPROBLEMSINTHISLIMITEDGLOSSTHATAROSEFROMSOME OFTHESOCIALSCIENCESTHEMSELVES9ETTHISGLOSSHOWEVERPROBLEMATICDOESPERMIT THEBEGINNINGSOFACONVERSATION7EWILLRElNETHISDESCRIPTIONASWEPROCEEDIN THISCHAPTERTOBEMORECOMPREHENSIVEOFTHEINTERNATIONALANDGLOBALNATUREOF INDIGENOUSPEOPLESASBASEDONTHEEXAMPLESWEEXAMINEINTHISBOOK
$ElNINGglobalizationISARGUABLYASCOMPLEX!GAINMANYSCHOLARSUSEA COMMONGLOSSTHEINTENSESPEEDINGUPOFCOMMUNICATIONTRAVELCOMMERCEAND INTERCONNECTIONSACROSSTHEPLANET%ARTHINTHELATETWENTIETHANDEARLYTWENTY lRSTCENTURIESPRIMARILYBUILTONCAPITALISTSYSTEMSINRICHCOUNTRIESTHATEXPLOIT MARKETSTRUCTURES'IVENTHISREFERENCETOTHECAPITALISTMODEOFPRODUCTIONIT MAYBEMOREINSTRUCTIVETOTHINKOFGLOBALIZATIONASDIVIDEDINTOTHREEGENERAL CATEGORIES OF ECONOMICPOLITICAL AND CULTURALPATTERNS THAT ARE INVOLVED IN A CLOSEANDCOMPLEXPROCESSOFINTERACTION4HESAMECOULDBESAIDFORANYPERIOD
OFMODERNCAPITALISMHOWEVERTHEDIFFERENCESLIEINTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENA WORLDECONOMYANDAGLOBALECONOMYWHEREASTHEFORMERECONOMICPATTERNOC CURREDONANINTERNATIONALSCALEWHEREPRODUCTIONEXCHANGEANDCONSUMPTION TOOKPLACEBETWEENSTATESINTHELATTERECONOMICPATTERNPRODUCTIONEXCHANGE ANDCONSUMPTIONTAKEPLACEONATRANSNATIONALSCALE
)NTHISECONOMICPATTERNOFGLOBALIZATIONTHEREISAFUNDAMENTALNOTIONOF EXPANSIONBUTITISNOTTHETYPEOFEXPANSIONTHATOCCURREDDURINGTHERISEOFTHE INTERNATIONALECONOMY2OBINSON DESCRIBESTHISEXPANSIONASTWOFOLDTHE lRSTIShEXTENSIVEENLARGEMENTvWHERETHEhCOMMODIlCATIONOFSOCIALRELATIONSv REACHEDLOCATIONSTHATWEREONCEBEYONDTHESTRUCTUREOFhCOMMODITYPRODUC TIONvTHESECONDIShINTENSIVEENLARGEMENTvWHERETHISCOMMODIlCATIONOFSOCIAL RELATIONSISBECOMINGINCREASINGLYPRIVATIZEDPPn !SGLOBALCAPITALISMHAS REACHED INTO ALL REGIONSOF THEWORLD hEXTENSIVE ENLARGEMENTvHASGROWN LESS APPARENT!CCORDINGTO2OBINSONLATE TWENTIETH CENTURYCAPITALISMSEXPANSION ISINTENSIVEWITHAhDEEPENINGRATHERTHANTHEENLARGINGOFTHESYSTEMSDOMAIN INVADINGANDCOMMODIFYINGALLTHOSEPUBLICANDPRIVATESPHERESTHATPREVIOUSLY REMAINEDOUTSIDEITSREACHv
/NEEXAMPLEOFTHIShINTENSIVEENLARGEMENTvISTHEPRIVATIZATIONOFEDUCA TION"ASEDUPONNEOLIBERALIDEOLOGIESMULTILATERALAGENCIESSUCHASTHE)NTERNA TIONAL-ONETARY&UNDANDTHE7ORLD"ANKOFTENIMPOSESTRUCTURALADJUSTMENT PROGRAMSTHATCOMPROMISETHEAUTONOMYOFLOCALCOMMUNITIES/PERATINGON GUIDELINESOFhCONDITIONALITYvTHESESTRUCTURALADJUSTMENTPROGRAMSCANMEAN DIRECTCUTBACKSTOEDUCATION(OLTON !SANALREADYDElCIENTDETERIORAT INGANDNEGLECTEDINSTITUTIONINMUCHOFTHEDEVELOPINGWORLDEDUCATIONCANNOT WITHSTANDSUCHPRIVATIZATIONESPECIALLYATTHEEXPENSEOFINDIGENOUSTRADITIONSOF INSTRUCTIONTHATHAVEALREADYBEENMARGINALIZEDWITHINALARGERMODERNCONTEXT
/NEEXAMPLETHATISPARTICULARLYSIGNIlCANTTOOURDISCUSSIONOFINDIGENE ITYRESISTANCEANDREVITALIZATIONINANERAOFGLOBALIZATIONISTHECASEOFTHE NATURALGASEXPLOITATIONIN"OLIVIA#IVILSOCIETYUNRAVELEDWHENTHENEOLIBERAL ADMINISTRATIONOF FORMERPRESIDENT'ONZALO3ANCHEZDE,OZADAPROPOSED THE BUILDINGOFAGASPIPELINETOTRANSPORT"OLIVIANNATURALGASTHROUGH#HILEAND ONTO-EXICOANDTHE5NITED3TATES)NTHISINSTANCEINDIGENOUS!YMARACOM MUNITIESJOINEDFORCESWITHMINERSTEACHERSSTUDENTSANDPEASANTSINASHOW OFANhUNLIKELYALLIANCEvTORESISTTHEEFFECTSOFGLOBALCAPITALISMINTHEFORMOF NATURALRESOURCEEXPLOITATIONSDEPENDENCEON#HILEANACCESSTOSHIPPINGPORTS AND53INmUENCEOVERTHEREGION0OSTEROn %NCOMPASSINGONEOF THELARGESTINDIGENOUSPOPULATIONSONEARTH"OLIVIAISAPRIMEEXAMPLEOFHOW NATIVEPEOPLESCANRESISTUNJUSTINVASIONSOFGLOBALCAPITALISM
7ITHINRECENTPOLITICALPATTERNSOFGLOBALIZATIONNOSINGLEEVENTHASDONE MORETOALTERWORLDSENTIMENTANDRECOGNITIONTOWARDTHEBROADERSENSEOFINDIG ENOUSPEOPLESTHANTHEELECTIONOF%VO-ORALESIN!STHElRSTINDIGENOUS PRESIDENTOF"OLIVIATOASSUMEOFlCE-ORALESSVICTORYEXEMPLIlESTHECHANGING SOCIOPOLITICALSCENESINCOUNTRIESWHEREINDIGENOUSMOVEMENTSHAVEEFFECTIVELY TAKENHOLD)TNOTONLYDEMONSTRATESTHEGLOBALIMPORTANCEOFTHESESUCCESSESBUT
ALSOADDSTOAPATTERNOFRESISTANCEINOPPOSITIONTOGLOBALNEOLIBERALHEGEMONY -OREOVER THE ACCEPTANCE OF INDIGENOUS POLITICS INTO A BROADERMOVEMENT OF RESISTANCETOGLOBALCAPITALISMISDEMONSTRATEDBYTHEESTABLISHMENTOFCLOSETIES WITHOTHER,ATIN!MERICANLEADERS
#ULTURALPATTERNSOFGLOBALIZATIONAREPERHAPSTHEMOSTSUBJECTIVEOFTHE THREE CATEGORIES )N A TELLINGDESCRIPTION ABOUT CULTURAL GLOBALIZATION,EONOR !MARANTE CAPTURED A SCENARIO INDICATIVEOF THIS SUBJECTIVITYWHEN SHE REPORTEDONTHEUSEOFVIDEOPRODUCTIONAMONGTHE+AYAPO)NDIANSOF"RAZIL"Y USINGVIDEO TECHNOLOGYINANATTEMPTTODOCUMENTANDPRESERVETHISCULTUREA +AYAPOLEADERREMARKEDh'IVENTHATTHEWHITEMANHASLITTLEINTERESTINUSWE HAVETOACTONOUROWNv!MARANTE !PARADOXARISESHEREONTHEONE HANDTHEINmUENCESOFMODERNTECHNOLOGYCANBESEENASALTERINGTRADITIONAL CUSTOMSOFCULTURALPRESERVATIONANDONTHEOTHERTHEREAPPEARSTOBEATLEAST SOMENOTIONOFAGENCYPROVIDEDBYTHEAVAILABILITYOFTHISMEDIATINGPRODUCT .ONETHELESSINORDERTOBETRUETOTHEPHENOMENONATHANDTHEINTERACTIONOF CULTUREONAGLOBALLEVELISOCCURRINGANDMUSTBEINTERPRETEDASSUCH
0ETER"ERGER OUTLINEDWHATHEDESCRIBEDAShFOURDISTINCTPROCESSESOF CULTURALGLOBALIZATIONvINCLUDINGTHEh$AVOSvCULTUREWHICHILLUSTRATESBEHAVIOR ATTUNEDTOGLOBALBUSINESSANDENTREPRENEURSHIPTHEh&ACULTY#LUB)NTERNATIONALv CULTUREWHICHDESCRIBESTHEEXPANSIONOF7ESTERNKNOWLEDGETHEh-C7ORLDv CULTUREWHICHENCOMPASSESAWESTERNIZATIONOFPOPULARCULTUREANDTHECULTURE OFh%VANGELICAL0ROTESTANTISMvEMBODIEDINANEXPLOSIONOFRELIGIOUSPROSELYTIZ INGPPn )NADDITIONTOTHESEPROCESSES"ERGERALSOMAKESREFERENCETO THEFOLLOWINGFOURPOTENTIALADAPTATIONSTHATOCCURWHENINDIGENOUSCULTURES are FACEDWITHTHESEENCROACHINGGLOBALIZATIONS THEREPLACEMENTOFLOCALCULTURE COEXISTENCEBETWEENGLOBALAND LOCALCULTURES SYNTHESISOFGLOBALAND LOCALCULTURESAND REJECTIONOFGLOBALCULTUREBYLOCALCULTURES(SIAO ORINDIGENOUSNATIONS
%VIDENCEOFTHESEANDOFEVENMOREADAPTATIONSWITHINTHEGLOBALCULTURAL COMMUNITIESOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLESISQUITEPREVALENT3INCETHEENDOFTHElF TEENTHCENTURYTHEREHASBEENNOSHORTAGEOFINSTANCESWHEREFORCESMOTIVATEDBY CAPITALISTACCUMULATIONTHROUGHEXPLOITATIONHAVEREPLACEDORTRIEDTOELIMINATE LOCALCULTURESINTHE!MERICAS,IKEWISETHECONCERTEDEFFORTTOCOEXISTCANBE SEENINTHELATE TWENTIETH CENTURYATTEMPTTOCREATEADEMOCRATICPLURALSTATEIN %CUADOR 3ELVERSTON 4HEADAPTATIONOF SYNTHESIS ALSOCANBE FOUND IN THEAGRO INDUSTRIALPRODUCTIONANDMARKETINGOFANCIENT!NDEANFOODS(EALY ˆESPECIALLYINCONTRASTTOTRENDSINTHEPROLIFERATIONOFFASTFOODSINmUENCED BYTHERIGIDRATIONALIZATIONFROMTHE7EST!NDlNALLYTHEADAPTATIONOFREJECT INGVARIOUSCULTURALPATTERNSOFGLOBALIZATIONISDEMONSTRATEDBYTHE+ALIMANTAN $AYAKSOF )NDONESIAAND THEIR STRUGGLE TOPROTECT THEIR FORESTS FROM INVESTORS WHOATTEMPTTOPROlTFROMTHEDEMANDFORNATURALRESOURCESWITHINTHEGLOBAL ECONOMY&RIED )TISTHISADAPTATIONOFREJECTIONANDTHESUBSEQUENTCASES OFRESISTANCEONTHEPARTOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLESAROUNDTHEWORLDTHATCONTRIBUTE TOTHEFOCUSOFTHISBOOK
'LOBALIZATIONASWEDISCUSSITACCOMPANIESTHEEXPANSIONOFTHEMODERN WORLD SYSTEMANDTHEREFORETHESPREADANDDIFFUSIONOFCAPITALISMAROUNDTHE GLOBE!NDRE'UNDER&RANK )MMANUEL7ALLERSTEIN ANDOTHERSHAVEIDENTIlEDMUCHOFTHISASEMERGINGATTHESAMETIMEANDINTANDEM WITHCOLONIALISMANDTHEYHAVEFURTHERIDENTIlEDMUCHOFWHATOTHERSHAVECALLED underdevelopmentASAPURPOSEFULWAYOFCONSTRUCTINGANDCONTROLLINGWORLDMAR KETS&RANK USESTHETERMhTHEDEVELOPMENTOFUNDER DEVELOPMENTvWHEREAS OTHERSEG7ALLERSTEIN CALLTHIShNEO IMPERIALISMBYCORESTATESv
4HISUNDERSTANDINGISESSENTIALTOANALYZINGINDIGENOUSPEOPLESFORTWO REASONS&IRST THE!MERICAN )NDIANNATIONS ANDOTHER INDIGENOUS PEOPLES IN THE7ESTERN(EMISPHEREˆESPECIALLY IN.ORTH!MERICAˆARE SUBSUMED IN THISPROCESSOFhDEVELOPMENTvINTERMSOFCONQUESTCOERCIVEASSIMILATIONAND NATION BUILDING3ECONDTHOSEWHOSURVIVETHESEPROCESSESAREFURTHEROPPRESSED ANDMARGINALIZEDTHROUGHFORMSOFINTERNALCOLONIALISM4HESEPOPULATIONSARE RELATIVELYSMALLINCORESTATESSUCHASTHE5NITED3TATESAND#ANADAANDRELA TIVELYLARGEBUTDIFFUSEIN,ATIN!MERICANSTATESWHERETHEYALSOARETYPICALLY LESShDEVELOPEDv2ECENTCONmICTSIN-EXICO.ICARAGUA'UATEMALA%CUADOR #HILE0ERUANDESPECIALLY"OLIVIAUNDERSCORETHESERELATIONSHIPSOFINDIGENOUS PEOPLESRESISTANCEANDTHELARGERGLOBALIZATIONPROCESSES
0ERHAPSTHEMOSTCOMPELLINGOBSERVATIONISTHATEVENINCORESTATESWITH CAPITALISMSOCIALMOVEMENTSBYINDIGENOUSPEOPLESSUCHASTHE!MERICAN)NDIAN -OVEMENTANDMANYSOVEREIGNTYMOVEMENTSSUGGESTPARALLELSTOOTHERPROCESSES OFHISTORICALDOMINATIONANDINJUSTICE4HESEMOVEMENTSTHENANDNOWSEEKTO MAINTAIN CLOSENESS TO THE LAND TO RETAIN IFNOT REVITALIZE TRADITIONAL CULTURES ANDTOOPPOSECAPITALISTSOCIALSTRUCTURES4HESEPARALLELSAREFOUNDINTHE,ATIN !MERICANSOCIALMOVEMENTSASWELLANDBEARREMARKABLESIMILARITYTOINDIGENOUS PEOPLESSTRUGGLESAROUNDTHEGLOBE
4HISISONEREASONWHYWEUSESPECIlCLANDEDEXAMPLESANDDISCUSSIONSOF INDIGENOUSPEOPLESINTHEFOLLOWINGCHAPTERS)TISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATSOCIAL SYSTEMS OF GOVERNANCE COMMUNITY LOCAL ECONOMY AND LAND TENURE BECOME ARENASOFCONmICTWITHININDIVIDUALSTATES4HEYAREOFTENSITESOFRESISTANCETO CAPITALISTDOMINATIONANDTHEIMPOSITIONOFPRIVATEPROPERTYANDPROlT DRIVEN VALUESYSTEMS"ESIDESDEVELOPINGNEWCONSUMPTIVEPATTERNSGLOBALIZATIONAT TEMPTSTOPRIVATIZEANDCORPORATIZEALLTHESOCIALSYSTEMSITDOMINATES%XAMPLES OFSUCHRESISTANCEINCLUDETHEREMOTEAREASOF#HIAPAS-EXICOTHATGAVERISETO THE:APATISTAS!YMARACOCA LEAFGROWERSINTHE"OLIVIANHIGHLANDSCOLLECTIVIZING ANDORGANIZINGWITHUNIONSTHE)NUITIN.UNAVUTTHE-OHAWKIN1UEBECTHE .AVAJOINTHE533OUTHWESTANDTHE,AKOTAINTHENORTHERN53PLAINSSTATES REORGANIZINGUNDERCOLLECTIVESYSTEMSTHATSTRIVETOMAINTAINTRADITIONALLIFESTYLES 4HESEAREALLCASESWHEREGLOBALIZATIONCOMESINTOCONmICTWITHINDIGENOUSPEOPLES INTHE!MERICASWITHPOWERFULCONGRUENCEOVEREVENLONGERPERIODSAMONGTHE !DEVASIIN)NDIAORTHE-AORIIN.EW:EALAND
'LOBALIZATIONISUSUALLYREFERREDTOASASYSTEMTHATPRODUCEShDEPENDENCYv ANDhUNDERDEVELOPMENTvINDEVELOPINGECONOMIESCOMMONIN,ATIN!MERICAAND
WHERECORPORATEPROlTSGOTOOTHERCOUNTRIESUSUALLYINCOREAREAS$ELLO"UONO AND,ARA &ORINDIGENOUSPEOPLESTHISMEANSSOCIOECONOMICDEPRESSION ANDCONTINUINGCULTURALREPRESSION3EVERALPROCESSESWITHINTHELARGERPHENOM ENONOFGLOBALIZATIONINCLUDESIGNIlCANTCOMPONENTSOFOPPRESSIONANDCULTURAL DOMINATIONˆATTIMESOVERTANDINTENTIONALATOTHERSCOVERTANDLESSINTENTIONAL ANDMANYTIMESUNFORESEEN&URTHERMOREMANYCRITICSOFGLOBALIZATIONADMITIT ISSOMETHINGOFAMIXEDBAGCAUSINGWHATMANYSEEAShPOSITIVEvCHANGESEVEN WHILEITCREATESOTHERPROBLEMS#LEARLYGLOBALIZATIONNEEDSFURTHERANALYSISIN RELATIONTOINDIGENOUSPEOPLES
7HATDOWEMEANBYRESISTANCETOGLOBALIZATION)NDIGENOUSRESISTANCETOGLOBAL CAPITALISM ISWORLDWIDE DIVERSE AND LOOSELY INTERCONNECTED-ANY FORMSOF RESISTANCEARECOVERTECHOING3COTTSCONCEPTOFhWEAPONSOFTHEWEAKv THEYOFTENTRANSMUTEANDORMASQUERADEASSOMETHINGELSE/THERFORMSWHILE APPEARINGCLASSICALLYREVOLUTIONARYDEFYANYEASYDESCRIPTION&ORINSTANCETHE EVENTSIN#HIAPASHAVESOMETIMESBEENSEENASPARTOFAREGIONALORAPEASANT ANDHENCEACLASS ORAcaudillo-DRIVENREBELLION4HEYARELESSOFTENDISCUSSED ASANINDIGENOUS-AYANREBELLION-OVEMENTSINTHE5NITED3TATESSUCHAS THE!MERICAN )NDIAN-OVEMENT ARE OFTEN SEEN SOLELY IN TERMS OF LOCALIZED ETHNICURBANORRACIALREBELLIONS)NDIGENOUSRESISTERSAREOFTENCONNECTEDVIA INTERNATIONALNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS).'/S THE5NITED.ATIONSA LARGEVARIETYOFTHEIROWNORGANIZATIONSANDTHE)NTERNET,ANGMANETAL 3MITHAND7ARD
)NOTHERCASESTRADITIONALCULTUREANDORGANIZATIONITSELFISARESOURCETHAT FACILITATESRESISTANCEANDSURVIVAL#ALLIOU#HAMPAGNE &ENELON )NDIGENOUSRESISTANCESTRUGGLESAREOCCURRINGALLOVERTHE WORLDEVENIN%UROPEASFOREXAMPLEAMONGTHE3AAMI%IDHEIM +URD ISHACTIVITIESIN7EST!SIAAND-ISKITORESISTANCEIN.ICARAGUAHAVELONGBEEN NOTEDAS INDIGENOUSMOVEMENTS(ARFFAND'URR 'URRS Minorities at Risk IS A CATALOG OF SUCHMOVEMENTS AND,INDA3MITHS Decolonizing MethodologiesISITSELFANACTOFRESISTANCEAGAINSTTHEHEGEMONYOF %UROPEAN ROOTEDSOCIALSCIENCECONCEPTS(ERWORKISROOTEDINHER-AORICOM MUNITYANDHERACADEMICEXPERIENCES
4HESEMOVEMENTS ARE SO DIVERSE SO mUID IN ORGANIZATION GOALS AND METHODSTHEYALLBUTDEFYSUMMARY0ROBABLYTHEMOSTSALIENTDIFFERENCEFOR INDIGENOUSMOVEMENTS IS THEEMPHASISON LOCALCOMMUNITY IDENTITYPOLITICS LANDCLAIMSANDRIGHTSTOAVARIETYOFTRADITIONALPRACTICES4HELATTERINCLUDE ALTERNATIVE FAMILYORGANIZATIONS SUCHASEXTENDEDKINSHIPMATRILINEALITYAND ORPOLYGYNYCOMMUNALOWNERSHIPOFRESOURCESSUCHASLANDTHEUSEOFLANDFOR SACREDCEREMONIESLESSORNONHIERARCHICALDECISIONMAKINGCULTURALMEMBERSHIP
INCOMMUNITYANDINDIGENOUSKNOWLEDGETHATMAYINCLUDEUSEOFPLANT LIFEFOR MEDICINEANDPSYCHICTREATMENT-ANYOFTHESEPRACTICESCONTRADICTCHALLENGE OR THREATENDEEPLYHELDVALUES IN STATE BASED SYSTEMS4HEMOST FUNDAMENTAL CHALLENGETOCAPITALISMTHOUGHCOMESFROMCOMMUNALOWNERSHIPOFRESOURCES BECAUSEITDENIESTHEOVERARCHINGDOMINANCEOFPRIVATEPROPERTYRIGHTS#ONTRARY TOWHATMANYEARLYEXPLORERSMISSIONARIESANDCOLONIZERSTHOUGHTANDUNFORTU NATELYMANYSO CALLEDDEVELOPMENTEXPERTSTODAYCONTINUETOTHINKITISNOTTHAT INDIGENOUSPEOPLEDONOTUNDERSTANDINDIVIDUALOWNERSHIP2ATHERTHEYHAVE LONGRECOGNIZEDWHATMANYENVIRONMENTALMOVEMENTSAREBEGINNINGTOFORCE CAPITALISTSTOACCEPTMOSTRESOURCESAREPARTIALLYIFNOTWHOLLYhPUBLICGOODSvTO USETHETERMINOLOGYOFECONOMISTS ANDARETHEREBYSITESOFPOLITICALECONOMIC OR SOCIAL CONTESTATION4HE INTERACTIONS OF ENVIRONMENTALISTS AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLESHAVEBEENSOMETHINGOFAMIXEDBAGALTHOUGHINTHElRSTDECADEOFTHE TWENTY lRSTCENTURYALLIANCESHAVEBECOMEMORECOMMON
!NOTHERFORMOFRESISTANCEHASBEENOVERTCONSCIOUSEFFORTSTOMAINTAIN hTRADITIONALCULTUREv7ETHINKOFTRADITIONALCULTURENOTASSTATICANDUNCHANG INGBUTRATHERASEVOLVINGACCORDINGTOTHEDESIRESOFGROUPMEMBERSRESISTING DOMINATIONRATHERTHANINACCORDWITHDESIRESORDIRECTIONSOFOUTSIDERS4HATIS TRADITIONALCULTURELIKEALLOTHERSOCIALFORMSANDSTRUCTURESEVOLVESANDCHANGES CONTINUOUSLYIFSPORADICALLYANDUNEVENLY&ENELONn3MITHAND 7ARD 7EHAVEOBSERVEDTHESEPROCESSESIN.ORTH!MERICATAKINGPLACE OVERSOMEYEARSRANGINGFROM)NUITTO,AKOTATO:APOTECS4HEYAREEVEN OLDERINOTHERPARTSOFTHEWORLDSUCHASAMONGTHE!DEVASIIN)NDIAWHOHAVE KEPTTRADITIONALCULTURESANDLANGUAGESALIVEFORTHOUSANDSOFYEARS
#ULTURE BUILDINGCANBEANOTHERFORMOFRESISTANCE&ORINSTANCETHEREARE NEARLYTHREEDOZENTRIBALCOLLEGESINTHE5NITED3TATES!MERICAN)NDIAN(IGHER %DUCATION#ONSORTIUM"OYER 4HESE ARE INSTITUTIONSOFHIGHER EDUCATIONTYPICALLYEQUIVALENTSOFCOMMUNITYCOLLEGESRUNBYVARIOUS.ATIVE !MERICANGROUPS4HEYDIFFERFROMTHETYPICAL53COMMUNITYCOLLEGEINTHAT MANY COURSES PROMOTE TRADITIONAL CULTURE LANGUAGE CRAFTS AND CUSTOMS )N SOMECASESLANGUAGEPROGRAMSHAVEBEENAIMEDATREVIVINGORREINVIGORATINGA LANGUAGETHATHASFALLENINTODISUSE)NDEEDLANGUAGEEDUCATIONISOFTENAPRI MARYMISSIONOFTHESECOLLEGES4HUSTRIBALCOLLEGESAREANINSTITUTIONALMEANSOF PRESERVINGANDENHANCINGhTRADITIONALCULTURESv3OMEINROADSHAVERECENTLYBEEN MADEINCOLLEGESANDUNIVERSITIESAROUNDTHEWORLDALTHOUGHTHESEINSTITUTIONS CONTINUETOREMAINPURVEYORSOFHEGEMONICIDEOLOGIESANDHISTORY#HAMPAGNE AND!BU 3AAD7OLF
2ESISTANCECANALSOTAKETHEFORMOFBUILDINGOTHERLOCALIZEDINSTITUTIONS THAT CONFORM TO TRADITIONAL CULTURAL VALUES4HE$IN£ .AVAJO HAVE SEVERAL SUCHINSTITUTIONS4HETRIBALPOLICEFORCEWHILEACTINGMUCHLIKEANYOTHERRURAL POLICEFORCEINTHE5NITED3TATESISALSOCULTURALLYSENSITIVETO.AVAJOTRADITIONS ANDWORKSWITHINTHEM-OREDIRECTARETHEhPEACEMAKERCOURTSvWHICHAVOID ADVERSARIALTECHNIQUESOF!NGLOCOURTSBYPURSUINGRESOLUTIONOFDISPUTESAMONG .AVAJOSTHROUGHMEANSTHATAREINACCORDWITH.AVAJOCONCEPTSOFHARMONY7E
NOWSEENEWSOCIALFORMSARISEAMONGINDIGENOUSRESISTANCESUCHASTHEh junta del buen gobiernovLOCALJUSTICEOFTHE:APATISTASTHECOCAGROWERSIN"OLIVIAWITH %VO-ORALESOREVENTHEAUTONOMOUSYET)SLAMICJUSTICEOFTHE+URDS
/THERFORMSOFRESISTANCEARELESSINSTITUTIONALIZEDBUTNONETHELESSIMPOR TANT7ARDETALAND"AIRD /LSENAND7ARD ANALYZEHOWWOMEN AMONGTHENORTHERN#HEYENNEHAVEADAPTEDCONVENTIONAL STEPPROGRAMSTHAT ADDRESSALCOHOLABUSEORSPOUSEABUSETO#HEYENNECULTUREPROMOTING#HEYENNE FAMILY VALUES!NOTHER COMMON INSTITUTION AMONG.ATIVE!MERICANS IN THE 5NITED3TATESISMAINTENANCEOFMATRILINEALFAMILYSYSTEMSESPECIALLYTHROUGH THEOWNERSHIPOFPROPERTY4HISOFTENCOMESATAGREATPRICEASMISSIONARIESAND BUREAUCRATICFUNCTIONARIESHAVEREPEATEDLYATTACKEDMATRILINEALITYAShBARBARICv hUNCHRISTIANvORCHAOTIC.ATIVE!MERICANFEMINISTSOFTENORGANIZEINWAYSTHAT OPPOSEMOREMAINSTREAMFEMINISTMOVEMENTS4YPICALLYINDIGENOUSFEMINISTS FOCUSONISSUESOFIDENTITYANDCULTURALPRESERVATIONPRIORTOMORENARROWLYFO CUSEDFEMINISTCONCERNS#HISTE*AIMESAND(ALSEY-ARCOS -ILLER3HOEMAKER 2IGOBERTU-ENCHU HASDOCUMENTEDTHE OPPRESSIONANDRESISTANCEBY-AYANWOMENANDFAMILIESIN'UATEMALAAS'LORIA -U®OZ2AM¤REZ HASDONEFOR:APATISTAWOMEN
2ELIGIONCANBEYETANOTHERFORMOFRESISTANCEEG#HAMPAGNEB -AINTENANCEOFRELIGIOUSPRACTICESDESPITEMASSIVEATTEMPTSTODESTROYTHEMAS SERTSANENTIRELYDIFFERENTWAYOFAPPROACHINGTHESUPERNATURALANDTHESACRED !MONGTHEMOSTCRITICALOFTHESEPRACTICESARELANDSTHATARESACREDANDNECESSARY FORRELIGIOUSCEREMONIES4HISLEADSTOCONmICTSOVERUSEOFTHELANDFORSACRED FUNCTIONSVERSUShPRODUCTIVEvANDORhRECREATIONALvUSE-C,EOD 4ODAY ASh.EW!GERSvHAVEPRACTICEDVARIOUSFORMSOFSHAMANISM)NDIANGROUPSHAVE PROTESTEDATTEMPTSTOAPPROPRIATENATIVETRADITIONS&ENELONn2OSE .ATIVESCHOLARSSEETHESEMULTIFARIOUSINTRUSIONSINTOTRADITIONALCULTURE ASALASTARENAOFCONmICTWHERETHEHOLISTICKNOWLEDGEOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLES COULDONCEAGAINBEEXPLOITEDBYWESTERNMARKETSTHATHAVEADIFFERENTORIENTATION TOWARDPEOPLEANDLANDANDOFKNOWLEDGEITSELF$ELORIA
4HEREVIVALOFOLDER TRADITIONS SUCHAS THE3UN$ANCE SEE FOREXAMPLE *ORGENSEN&ENELONn CANBEANOTHERFORMOFRELIGIOUS RESISTANCE4HESE REVIVALS HARK BACK TOMANY REVITALIZATIONMOVEMENTS THE ,ONGHOUSERELIGIONOFTHE)ROQUOIS7ALLACE THE'HOST$ANCEMOVEMENT "ROWN#HAMPAGNE$E-ALLIE,ANDSMAN4HORNTON ANDTHE.ATIVE!MERICAN#HURCH,A"ARRE!BERLE 3TEWART TONAMEA FEW4HESEMOVEMENTS ALL OFWHICHARE SOMEWHAT SYNCRETICPRESERVEMANYTRADITIONALVALUESANDHAVEMETWITHSOMESUCCESSIN COMBATINGTHEDESTRUCTIVENESSOFINCORPORATIONINTOTHECAPITALISTWORLD SYSTEM 4HE,ONGHOUSERELIGIONHASBEENASOURCEOFSTRENGTHAMONG)ROQUOIS2USSELL 4HORNTON ARGUESPERSUASIVELYTHATADOPTIONOFTHE'HOST$ANCERELIGION HELPEDMANYSMALLGROUPSTHATHADSUFFEREDSEVEREDEMOGRAPHICLOSSESDUETO DISEASETORECOVERBOTHDEMOGRAPHICALLYANDCULTURALLY-ORERECENTLYTHE.A TIVE!MERICAN#HURCH.!#ALSOKNOWNASTHEPEYOTERELIGION HASBEENVERY
SUCCESSFULINHELPINGINDIVIDUALSRECOVERFROMALCOHOLISM.!#HASWONSEVERAL COURTBATTLESTHATALLOWMEMBERSTOUSEPEYOTE)VERSONn
!LLOFTHESERELIGIOUSTRADITIONSAREVASTLYDIFFERENTFROMTHEVARIOUSMONOTHE ISMSFOUNDINTHESTATESOFTHEMODERNWORLD SYSTEM4HEIRSURVIVALANDGROWTH AREIMPORTANTFORMSOFRESISTANCETOTHEIDEOLOGIESOFTHEMODERNWORLD SYSTEM ANDTOPRESSURESFORINCREASINGHOMOGENEITYOFCULTUREDUETOVARIOUSGLOBALIZA TIONPROCESSES$UANE#HAMPAGNEARGUESh.ATIVESDONOTSEETHEWORLDASONE WHEREONLYHUMANSHAVEAGENCYORSOUL4HE.ATIVEWORLDISFULLOFFORCESTHAT HAVEAGENCYSOULORSPIRIT(UMANSHAVEAROLETOPLAYINTHE#OSMICDRAMA BUTNOTNECESSARILYACENTRALROLEORANEXCLUSIVEROLEv 4HUSMANYIN DIGENOUSRELIGIONSNOTONLYOPPOSECAPITALISTPHILOSOPHIESBUTALSOCHALLENGETHE UNDERPINNINGSOFENLIGHTENMENTPHILOSOPHY)NDEEDTHISCHALLENGEISTHEBASISOF AMBIVALENTRELATIONSWITHECOLOGISTSh,ANDISGIVENASASACREDGIFTANDASACRED STEWARDSHIP0EOPLEDONOTOWNLANDBUTMUSTCAREFORTHELANDASPARTOFTHEIR SACREDTASKWITHINTHEPURPOSEANDDIRECTIONOFTHECOSMICORDERv#HAMPAGNE 4HESECOREVALUESAREINSEPARABLEFROMTRADITIONALCULTUREANDAREOFTENA VERYIMPORTANTCOMPONENTOFCONTINUINGRESISTANCETOHEGEMONICDOMINATION
3OMEOFTHEMOSTSIGNIlCANTFORMSOFRESISTANCEARETHEVARIOUSWAYSTHAT RESOURCES AREMANAGED COLLECTIVELY FOR COLLECTIVE GOOD0HRASED ALTERNATIVELY THEREAREVARIOUSWAYSOFPURSUINGCOLLECTIVERATIONALITY(EREONEMUSTBECARE FULNOTTOREADTHISSOLELYASCONVENTIONALhPUBLICGOODSvADMINISTRATION4HIS GOESMUCHFURTHERINCOLLECTIVEOWNERSHIPOFGOODSˆLANDANDLIVESTOCKMOST COMMONLYˆTHATARETYPICALLYINDIVIDUALLYPRIVATELYOWNEDCOMMODITIESINTHE CAPITALISTWORLD SYSTEM!S#HAMPAGNESUGGESTSMANYINDIGENOUSPEOPLESSEE THEIRROLESPRIMARILYASSTEWARDSWHOAREAPARTOFNATURENOTASITSCONTROLLERS OROWNERS
/NEOFTHEMOREDRAMATICEXAMPLESOFSUCHRESISTANCEISTHECONTINUINGEF FORTOF,AKOTAPEOPLESTOREGAINCONTROLOFTHE"LACK(ILLS3EVERALCOURTDECISIONS INCLUDINGONEBYTHE533UPREME#OURTHAVEDETERMINEDTHATTHETERRITORY OFTHE"LACK(ILLSINWHATISNOW3OUTH$AKOTA WASILLEGALLYTAKENFROMTHE ,AKOTAPEOPLES,AZARUS)VERSON#HURCHILLn )N ACCORDWITHCAPITALISTVALUESAND53JURISPRUDENCETHESETTLEMENTOFTHISCLAIM HASBEENMONETARY4HE,AKOTAPEOPLESHOWEVERHAVESTEADFASTLYREFUSEDSUCH COMMODIlEDSETTLEMENTSANDHAVEINSISTEDONTHERETURNOFTHELANDTHATTHEY CONSIDERSACRED4HEINTENSITYOFTHISCOMMITMENTISUNDERSCOREDBYTHERELATIVE POVERTYOF,AKOTAPEOPLE3HANNON#OUNTYWHERETHE0INE2IDGE2ESERVATION ISLOCATEDTHERESERVATIONCLOSESTTOTHE"LACK(ILLS HASBEENSINCETHE POORESTCOUNTY IN THE5NITED3TATES$ESPITE THE TEMPTATION TO TAKE THECASH SETTLEMENTTHE,AKOTASHAVECONTINUEDTOREJECTSUCHASETTLEMENTANDTOSTRUGGLE FORTHERETURNOFTHEIRLAND
2UNNING THROUGH ALL THESE DISCUSSIONS CONCERNING INDIGENOUS PEOPLES INTHE5NITED3TATESHASBEENTHEISSUEOFSOVEREIGNTY"ECAUSEOFINITIALTREATY AGREEMENTSINDIGENOUSPEOPLESINTHE5NITED3TATESHAVEASPECIALRELATIONSHIP DIRECTLYWITHTHE53FEDERALGOVERNMENT$ELORIAAND7ILKINS&ENELON
)T ISONTHIS LEGALSTATUSTHATMANYACTIONSOF.ATIVE!MERICANGROUPS REST)NDEEDSOVEREIGNTYISSUESAREOFTENTHEBASISOFCHALLENGESTOSTATESAROUND THEWORLDANDCUTTOTHEHEARTOFTHEINTERSTATESYSTEMBUILTONTHE0EACEOF 7ESTPHALIA7ILMER
!LTHOUGHNATIVEPEOPLESHAVEMETWITHSOMESUCCESSINMAINTAININGSOV EREIGNTYTHEYHAVEHADTOlGHTON%UROPEANGROUNDSˆWITHIN%UROPEANLAW FORDETAILEDEXAMPLESFROMNORTHERN.EW3PAINSEE#UTTERAB 7E WILLDISCUSSTHESOVEREIGNTYISSUEINMOREDETAILLATER2ECENTLYONEOFTHEMORE OUTSTANDINGSUCCESSESHASBEENTOUSETHEDOCTRINEOFSOVEREIGNTYTOBUILDVARIOUS GAMINGOPERATIONS-ULLISAND+AMPER&ENELON "YEXPLOITINGTHE CONTRADICTORYDESIRESFORACCESSTOGAMBLINGANDADESIRETOFORBIDIT!MERICAN )NDIANSHAVEBEGUNTOTURNCONSIDERABLEPROlTS"UTFORSOMEOTHERGROUPSSUCH ASTHE#HOCTAWTHISSUCCESSISFRAGILEANDVOLATILEANDSUBJECTTOFEDERALREDElNI TION&AIMAN 3ILVA
4HEQUESTIONREMAINS(OWMUCHHAVETHEYHADTOGIVEUPTOWINTHESE VICTORIES"YlGHTING%UROPEANCIVILIZATIONONITSOWNTURFINDIGENOUSPEOPLES HAVEHADTOACCEPTSOMEOFTHEPREMISESOFTHATTURF4HOMAS"IOLSIARGUESTHATTHE LAWIShAFUNDAMENTALCONSTITUTINGAXISOFMODERNSOCIALLIFEˆNOTJUSTAPOLITICAL RESOURCEORANINSTITUTIONBUTACONSTITUENTOFALLSOCIALRELATIONSOFDOMINATIONv "IOLSI 4HUS COURTS HAVE BEEN A LEADING INSTITUTIONALMEANS OF COMMODIFYINGEVERYTHINGESPECIALLYLAND"IOLSI 3TILLINDIGENOUS PEOPLESCONTINUETOUSELEGALSYSTEMSTORESISTINCORPORATIONANDGLOBALCAPITALISM WHENTHEYAREAVAILABLEWITHDIRECTACCESS(EREWEMUSTNOTEANIMPORTANTDIF FERENCEBETWEENINDIGENOUSSTRUGGLESINTHECOREORhlRSTvWORLDORGLOBALNORTH ANDTHOSEINTHEhTHIRDWORLDvORPERIPHERALAREASORGLOBALSOUTH4HERULEOF LAWCARRIESMUCHMOREFORCEINTHElRSTWORLDANDSOISAMOREUSEFULTOOLTHERE !LTHOUGHTHISISGENERALLYTHECASETHEREAREEXCEPTIONSINBOTHDIRECTIONS
4HEREHAVEBEENMANYFORMSOFSYMBOLICRESISTANCE&ORINSTANCEPOLITICAL PRESSUREHASLEDTOSEVERALNATIONALANDORSTATEPARKSRESERVINGSOMEAREASFOR TRADITIONAL.ATIVE!MERICANCEREMONIES SUCHAS"EAR"UTTE$EVILS0OSTPILE AND-EDICINE7HEEL-C,EOD ALTHOUGHTHESEHAVEBEENLIMITEDINSCOPE !NOTHEREXAMPLEHASBEENTHEMOVEMENTAGAINSTTHEUSEOF.ATIVE!MERICAN IMAGES AS SPORTSMASCOTS &ENELON ALONGWITHNATIONALMOVEMENTS TO REMOVETHEINJURIOUSTERMsquawFROMMANYPLACENAMES4HEEXPANSIONOFTHE POWWOWCIRCUITISALSOAVITALFORMOFASSERTING)NDIAN NESSTHATBOTHREINFORCES )NDIANIDENTITYANDPRESENTS)NDIANCULTURETOAGENERALAUDIENCE-ATTERN ,ASSITER
)NRECENTDECADESTHEREHAVEBEENINDIGENOUSMOVEMENTSTHATHAVECHAL LENGEDGLOBALIZINGCAPITALISM7ILMER#HAMPAGNEA !MONGTHESE MOVEMENTS ARE THOSEBY ).'/S SUCH AS#ULTURAL 3URVIVAL THE )NTERNATIONAL 7ORK'ROUPON)NDIGENOUS!FFAIRSTHE#ENTERFOR7ORLD)NDIGENOUS3TUDIES ANDTHE5NITED.ATIONS7ORKING'ROUPON)NDIGENOUS0OPULATIONS4HEREARE ALSOSEVERAL INDIGENOUSORGANIZATIONSSEE7ILMERn3MITHAND 7ARD -OSTOFTHESEMOVEMENTSANDORGANIZATIONSREPRESENTINDIGENOUS
PEOPLESONBOTHTHESOCIALGROUPLEVELANDCOLLECTIVELYWITHGREATVARIATIONIN THEIRAPPROACHESTOWARDISSUESTHENATUREOFRESISTANCEANDTHEAMOUNTOFTHEIR PARTICIPATIONINPOLITICALSPHERES
4HE:APATISTAMOVEMENTˆ%J£RCITO:APATISTADE,IBERACI˜N.ACIONALOR THE:APATISTA!RMYOF.ATIONAL,IBERATION%:,. CENTEREDIN#HIAPASˆHAS BEENONEOFTHEMOSTDRAMATIC4HE:APATISTAIDEOLOGYCONTRADICTSTHELOGICOF CAPITALISMSOTOODOSOME:APATISTAPRACTICES-EMBERSREJECTMODERNIZATIONAND SO CALLEDDEVELOPMENT2OSS+ATZENBERGER#OLLIERAND1UARATIELLO -ATTIACE -IGNOLO ARGUES THAT THE:APATISTAMOVEMENT CONSTITUTESANALTERNATIVETO'RECO 2OMANLEGACIESOFSTATE MAKING4HE:AP ATISTASSEEKTOMAINTAINTRADITIONALLIFEWAYSINTHEFACEOFOVERWHELMINGPRESSURE TOASSIMILATEINTOTHECAPITALISTCULTUREANDPRACTICEANDARETHUSOPPOSEDTOTHE .ORTH!MERICAN&REE4RADE!GREEMENT .!&4! AND THE&REE4RADE IN THE !MERICAS!GREEMENT&4!! 4HEMARCHTO-EXICO#ITYANDTHEDEMONSTRA TIONSINTHE:OCALO-ARCH ACCOMPANIEDBYAHUGEOUTPOURINGOFCIVIL SOCIETYINSUPPORTOFTHE:APATISTASARESOMEINDICATIONOFTHEGROWINGIMPACT OFSUCHMOVEMENTS7EDISCUSSTHE:APATISTASINMOREDETAILIN#HAPTER3EE THEPHOTOONTHEBACKCOVER
!LTHOUGHTHISCATALOGOFINDIGENOUSRESISTANCESOVERTORIMPLICITTOGLOBAL CAPITALISMANDTOTHEINTERNATIONALSTATESYSTEMISLARGEITISBUTASMALLSAMPLE OFSUCHMOVEMENTS7EARGUETHATTHESEMOVEMENTSAREMORETHANOPPOSITIONS TOTHESTATESWITHINWHICHVARIOUSINDIGENOUSGROUPSAREEMBEDDED4HEYARE ALLCLAIMSTOACONTINUEDRIGHTTOEXISTASSEPARATEENTITIESACLAIMTOHAVETHE RIGHTTOPRESERVETHEIROWNCULTURESASTHEYSEElT)NSHORTTHEYARECLAIMSTO AUTONOMYFROMTHESTATEANDFROMTHEMANYFORMSOFGLOBALIZATION4HELATTER CLAIMFORSOMEDEGREEOFAUTONOMYFROMGLOBALIZATIONISWHATLINKSINDIGENOUS MOVEMENTSTOOTHERSOCIALMOVEMENTS)TISA LSOWHYTHESEQUINTESSENTIALLYLOCAL MOVEMENTSARESIMULTANEOUSLYPARTOFAGLOBALPROCESS
"UTWHYDOWEINSISTONAGLOBALAPPROACH
)TISIMPORTANTTHATWEBECLEARABOUTWHATWEARETRYINGTODOINTHISBOOKAND WHATWEARENOTTRYINGTODO)NTHEBRIEFESTTERMSOURARGUMENTISTHATINDIG ENOUSPEOPLESANDTHEIRMYRIADREACTIONSTOGLOBALIZATIONMUSTBEUNDERSTOOD FROMGLOBALPERSPECTIVESASWELLASFROMLOCALREGIONALANDNATIONALPERSPECTIVES 4ODOTHISWEUSEANDMODIFYWORLD SYSTEMSANALYSIS7EDOnotCLAIMTHATA WORLD SYSTEMSANALYTICAPPROACHISTHEONLYAPPROACHOREVENTHEMOSTIMPORTANT APPROACHTOAGLOBALEXAMINATIONOFINDIGENOUSPEOPLES2ATHERWEADVANCEA MOREMODESTCLAIMTHATITISAUSEFULTOOLBUTONETHATMUSTBEMODIlEDAND HONEDFORTHESEPURPOSES7HATWEdoARGUEVIGOROUSLYISTHATANYEXAMINATION OF INDIGENOUSPEOPLES IS INCOMPLETE IF ITDOESNOT INCLUDEONEORMOREGLOBAL perspectives.
