ABSTRACT
EHIRUHÀQDOO\REWDLQLQJD OLYLQJRIKLVRZQZLWKLQ WKH&KXUFKRI (QJODQG+HKDGDOUHDG\SURYHGDGHWHUPLQHGVXLWRUVLPSO\UHIXVLQJ DWDQ\WLPHWRDFFHSWWKDWKLVHQJDJHPHQWWR(OVLHZDVRYHU,QGHHG KLVOHWWHUVWRKHUWKURXJKRXWWKHZDUEHFDPHYHU\SDVVLRQDWH6KH HYHQWXDOO\ZDVSHUVXDGHGWRPDUU\KLPRQFRQGLWLRQWKDWKHKDG ÀUVWREWDLQHGKLVRZQEHQHÀFHDQGWKXVDFTXLUHGDVWDWXVZKLFK ZRXOGPHHWDWOHDVWVRPHRIKHUPRWKHU·VUHVHUYDWLRQV(OVLHGLGZDQW WRPDUU\DQGWRKDYHFKLOGUHQRIKHURZQEXW-RKQ·VHQGHDYRXUVWR ÀQGDSDULVKKDGUHVXOWHGLQUHEXIIVDQGIUXVWUDWLRQVDWHYHU\WXUQ
+DYLQJVHUYHGKLVÀUVWFXUDF\DW6W0DUWLQ·V&KXUFK.HQVDO5LVH LQQRUWK/RQGRQ²KHKDGWKHQPRYHGDVKDVEHHQQRWHGWR KLVVHFRQGFXUDF\DW6W0DU\$EERWV.HQVLQJWRQ²$VKLVWLPH DW.HQVLQJWRQZDVGUDZLQJWRDFORVHDQGDIWHUDOPRVWQLQH\HDUVDV DFXUDWHKHKDGDSSOLHGZLWKRXWVXFFHVVWREHFRPHWKHLQFXPEHQWLQ SDULVKHVDVIDUDÀHOGDV*XHUQVH\)DOPRXWK'XQPRZ%LUPLQJKDP &KHVWHU6KUHZVEXU\&DQWHUEXU\DQG*ORXFHVWHU:LWKWKHPRXQWLQJ QXPEHURIUHMHFWLRQVKHKDGEHFRPHLQFUHDVLQJO\GHVSHUDWHERWKLQ KLVIRUORUQVHDUFKIRUDSDULVKDQGLQWKHWKZDUWLQJRIKLVKRSHVWR PDUU\(OVLH ,Q DGDULQJ HIIRUW WR HDVH KLV SDWK VKHKHUVHOIPDGH DGLUHFW
DSSURDFKLQZULWLQJWRWKH%LVKRSRI/RQGRQ-RKQ:LOOLDP:DQG ²ZKR KDG UHSODFHG*HRIIUH\ )LVKHU RQ WKH ODWWHU·V HOHYDWLRQWR&DQWHUEXU\LQHDUO\6KHZHQWVRIDUDVWRDVVXUH :DQGWKDWVKHZDVZLOOLQJWRUHVLJQKHUSDVWRUDWHDIWHUWKHLUPDUULDJH DQGWKDWVKHZRXOGHYHQDFFHSWFRQÀUPDWLRQIURPWKHELVKRS/HWWHUV EHWZHHQWKHPZHUHH[FKDQJHGRQDZHHNO\EDVLVVRPHWLPHVZLWKLQ DIHZGD\V7KHELVKRSZDVXQPRYHGE\DOO(OVLH·VGHFODUDWLRQVDQG VXSSOLFDWLRQVEHFDXVH DVKHZURWH LQ2FWREHU FRQÀUPDWLRQ UHTXLUHV¶DFRPSOHWHUHDGLQHVVWRDFFHSWZKDWHYHULVLQYROYHGLQWKH VHUYLFHZLWKWKHKHDUWDVZHOODVZLWKWKHPLQGDQGWKHUHLVVXFKD WKLQJDVDQ$QJOLFDQHWKRV·ZLWKZKLFKVKHZRXOGQHHGWREHFRPH IDPLOLDU+HGLGFRQFHGHWKDWVKHZRXOGKDYHKDG¶IDUJUHDWHULQWHOOHFWXDOJUDVSWKDQ·RIWKHFDQGLGDWHVIRUFRQÀUPDWLRQDWWKDWWLPH EXWIHOWWKDWVKHODFNHGWKHDSSURSULDWH¶GLVSRVLWLRQ· 8QGHWHUUHG VKHSUHVVHGKHU FDVH DJDLQ RQO\ WREH DGYLVHGE\
:DQG LQ'HFHPEHU LQTXLWHH[SOLFLW WHUPV WKDW LWZRXOGEH ¶LPSRVVLEOH·IRU-RKQ*DUULQJWRQWRÀQGDFKXUFKZKLOHVKHZDVVWLOO VHUYLQJD¶)UHH&KXUFK3DVWRUDWH·7KHELVKRSEHWUD\HGWKHGHSWKRI KLVIHHOLQJVRQWKLVDIIDLURIWKHKHDUWZKHQKHZDVUHSRUWHGDVKDYLQJ FRPPHQWHGWKDW*DUULQJWRQFRXOG¶JRDQGEHDEXWFKHU·VER\LIKH ZDQWVWRPDUU\WKLVZHOIDUHZRUNHU·5HGXFHGWRXWWHUGHVSRQGHQF\ (OVLHDFFXVHG'U:DQGRI¶$QJOLFDQDXWRFUDF\·DQG¶KRO\EODFNPDLO· UHDOL]LQJWKDWDQ\KRSHVVKHPLJKWRQFHKDYHKDGRIEHDULQJFKLOGUHQ ZHUHUHFHGLQJUDSLGO\2
Bishop Wand
-RKQ:LOOLDP&KDUOHV:DQGZDVDVFKRODUO\$QJOR&DWKROLFIURP DPRGHVWEDFNJURXQGLQ*UDQWKDPLQ/LQFROQVKLUHDQGDOWKRXJK KLVSDUHQWVKDGERWKEHHQFRQÀUPHGLQWKH&KXUFKRI(QJODQGKLV IDWKHUKDGEHFRPH WKHRUJDQLVW IRU VHUYLFHV DW D&DOYLQLVW FKDSHO QHDUWKHIDPLO\KRPHDQGSOD\HGWKHKDUPRQLXPWKHUHRQ6XQGD\ PRUQLQJV+HUHJXODUO\WRRNKLVWKUHHVRQVZLWKKLP$VWKHELVKRS ODWHUUHFDOOHGKLVIDWKHUKDG¶EHORQJHGWRWKHPRVWGHÀQLWHO\&DOYLQLVW VHFWLRQRIWKHHYDQJHOLFDOVWKHFKDSHOZDVKDQG\DQGKHHQMR\HGKLV MREDVRUJDQLVW·7KHFKDSHOVHUYLFHVZHUHQRWZHOFRPHWRWKHIXWXUH ELVKRSDQGOHIWDGHHSO\XQSOHDVDQWLPSUHVVLRQRQKLPVRWKDWKH QHYHUIRUJRWWKHVHER\KRRGH[SHULHQFHVRI¶XQGLOXWHG&DOYLQLVPIURP WKHLQVLGH·DVKHFDOOHGLW,QGHHGKHZDVVXUHWKDWLQKLVHDUO\\HDUV KHKDG¶KHDUGDJUHDWGHDOPRUHDERXWIUHHZLOODQGSUHGHVWLQDWLRQ WKDQPRVW·RIKLV¶FROOHDJXHVLQODWHUOLIH·,QUHDFWLRQKHEHFDPHD FRQÀUPHG$QJOLFDQDW VFKRRO+LVPRWKHUKDGQRW DFFRPSDQLHG KHUKXVEDQGWRWKHFKDSHOEXWKDGUHPDLQHG¶IDLWKIXOWRWKHSDULVK FKXUFK·7KHUHVXOWZDVLQ:DQG·VYLHZWKDW¶WKHVHSDUDWLRQPDGH DQXQFRPIRUWDEOHEUHDFKEHWZHHQWKHPMXVWZKHUHWZRWKRURXJKO\ UHOLJLRXVSHRSOHZRXOGIHHOLWPRVW· ,W VHHPVSUREDEOH WKDW WKHSHUVRQDOGLVWDVWH:DQG IHOW IRU WKH
UHOLJLRQRI KLV IDWKHU DQG IRU WKH DXVWHUH FKDSHOZRUVKLSRI KLV FKLOGKRRGLQÁ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ÀHGUHODWLRQVZLWKKLVFOHUJ\\HWLQWKLVPDWWHU KHZDV VXSSRUWHGE\$UFKELVKRS)LVKHUZKRKDG IRUPHUO\EHHQ *DUULQJWRQ·VELVKRSLQ/RQGRQLQKLVRSSRVLWLRQWR-RKQDQG(OVLH·V XQLRQDV)LVKHUKLPVHOIIUHHO\DGPLWWHGWRWKHPERWKRQDODWHUEXW KDSSLHURFFDVLRQ
+RZHYHUDVZHKDYHVHHQ(OVLHKDGDFTXLUHGLQÁXHQWLDOIULHQGV 7KHVHRQFHDOHUWHGWR*DUULQJWRQ·VSLWLIXOVLWXDWLRQPDGHDFUXFLDO LQWHUYHQWLRQ,Q/DG\6WDQVJDWHLQIRUPHGKHUKXVEDQGRIWKH LPSDVVHLQZKLFK(OVLHDQG-RKQIRXQGWKHPVHOYHV7KHQRUPDOO\ HTXDEOH/RUG6WDQVJDWHVRKDSS\LQKLVRZQPDUULDJHEHFDPH¶YHU\ DQJU\·DWWKHQHZVDQGDFWHGLPPHGLDWHO\WREULQJDERXWWKHSRVLWLYH FKDQJHQHHGHGE\WKHFRXSOH+HEURNHWKHGHDGORFNE\HQOLVWLQJWKH KHOSRIKLVJRYHUQPHQWFROOHDJXHWKH/RUG&KDQFHOORU/RUG-RZLWW ZKRKDGZLWKLQKLVJLIWFHUWDLQ&KXUFKRI(QJODQGEHQHÀFHV-RZLWW KDGJDLQHGWKHXQHQYLDEOHUHSXWDWLRQLQSROLWLFDOOLIHRIKDYLQJIHZ UHDOSULQFLSOHV\HW LQ WKLV LQVWDQFHKH VHL]HGKLV FKDQFH WR VKDUH 6WDQVJDWH·VPRUDORXWUDJH/RUG-RZLWWZKRZDVERUQLQ6WHYHQDJH 5HFWRU\DQGZDVWKHRQO\VRQRID&KXUFKRI(QJODQGFOHUJ\PDQ RIIHUHG*DUULQJWRQ WKH OLYLQJ RI$OO 6DLQWV&KXUFK+DPSWRQ 0LGGOHVH[ZLWKLQDPDWWHURIGD\V7KHORJMDPZDVEXUVWDQGZLWK HQRUPRXVUHOLHI-RKQSURPSWO\DFFHSWHG+HZDVIRUPDOO\LQVWLWXWHG WKHUHLQ0D\ /DWHUWKDWVDPH\HDUDVKDVEHHQVWDWHG6TXDGURQ2IÀFHU(OVLH
&KDPEHUODLQZDVGLDJQRVHGDVVXIIHULQJIURPDUWKULWLV\HWLQVSLWH RIKHULOOQHVVVKHDQG-RKQIHOWDEOHDWODVWWRSODQIRUWKHLUZHGGLQJ ZKLFKÀQDOO\RFFXUUHG LQ -XO\ 7KH VKHHU UHOLHI RFFDVLRQHG E\-RKQ·VDSSRLQWPHQWDQGWKHSURVSHFWRIPDUULDJHKDVWHQHGKHU UHFRYHU\IURPLOOQHVVDOWKRXJKVKHZDVRQO\DEOHWRKREEOHGRZQWKH DLVOH7KH\KDGEHHQHQJDJHGRQDQGRIIIRUWHQ\HDUV7KHZHGGLQJ ZDVKHOGDW6W-RKQ·V)ULHUQ%DUQHWWKHSDULVKFKXUFKVLWXDWHGDVKRUW GLVWDQFHIURP&KULVW&KXUFK&RQJUHJDWLRQDODOVRLQ)ULHUQ%DUQHW 5RDGDQGZDVZLGHO\UHSRUWHGLQWKHQHZVSDSHUVERWKQDWLRQDODQG ORFDO,WKDGDQREYLRXVDWWUDFWLRQIRUMRXUQDOLVWVDQGHYHQDSSHDUHG ZLWKDSKRWRJUDSK LQWKH6RXWK$XVWUDOLDQSUHVV+RZFRXOGWKH PDUULDJHRIDQ$QJOLFDQSULHVWWRD&RQJUHJDWLRQDOPLQLVWHUWKHÀUVW ZRPDQFKDSODLQLQWKH%ULWLVKIRUFHVEHLJQRUHG" 7KHKRQH\PRRQ FRQVLVWHGRI DZHHN LQ WKHYLFDUDJHRI -RKQ·V
EHVWPDQ5REHUW:DOO\+RUWKLQWKHYLOODJHRI6KDOIRUGVRXWKRI *XLOGIRUGLQ6XUUH\DQGDVHFRQGZHHNDWDKRWHOLQ7RUTXD\LQ 'HYRQSDLGIRUE\-LP&KDPEHUODLQ(OVLH·VIDWKHU$OZD\VOR\DOWR
WKH&KXUFKRI(QJODQGQHYHUWKHOHVV-RKQVDZWKDWWKHLUPDUULDJH ZDV D WULXPSK DJDLQVW HQWUHQFKHG$QJOLFDQSUHMXGLFH DQG OLNH (OVLHWKRXJKWWKDWWKH\ZHUH¶UHDOO\SLRQHHUVLQWKHPDWWHURIFKXUFK XQLW\·<HWWKLVPDUULDJHKDGRQO\RFFXUUHGDV-RKQKLPVHOIDGPLWWHG ¶LQ WKH WHHWKRIDXWKRULW\·ZKLFKKDGEHHQKRVWLOHDQGREVWUXFWLYH WKURXJKRXW
A New Life Together
7KHFOHULFDOFRXSOHVHWXSWKHLUÀUVWKRPHWRJHWKHULQ-RKQ·VYLFDUDJH DW+DPSWRQ7ZRPRQWKVDIWHUWKHLUZHGGLQJLQ6HSWHPEHU (OVLH KHUVHOI IROORZLQJKHU KXVEDQG·V H[DPSOHZDV WR EHJLQ D QHZPLQLVWU\ 6KHZDV WR EHFRPH WKHPLQLVWHU RI WKH9LQH\DUG &RQJUHJDWLRQDO &KXUFK 5LFKPRQGXSRQ7KDPHVZKHUH VKH KDGÀUVWSUHDFKHGLQ-XQHWKDW\HDUVKRUWO\DIWHU-RKQ·VPRYHWR +DPSWRQVRPHÀYHPLOHVVRXWKZHVWRI5LFKPRQGEXWVWLOODVWULGH WKHULYHU6 ,Q(OVLHZDV\HDUVROG 6KHKDG IDLWKIXOO\SXUVXHGKHU
FDOOLQJ WR WKHPLQLVWU\ DQG LQ GRLQJ VR DV DZRPDQ VKH KDG HQFRXQWHUHGGLIÀ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
KHU FULWLFVZLWKKHU LQGXVWU\ VW\OH JRRG VSLULWVG\QDPLVP DQG VKHHUIRUFHRIFKDUDFWHU,QFRQWUDVWWRWKHGHSULYDWLRQVRIWKH6HFRQG :RUOG:DUDQGWKHEOHDNQHVVRIWKHODWHVWKURXJKRXWZKLFK
WKHFKXUFKHVVXIIHUHGQXPHULFDOGHFOLQHDQGORVVRIFRQÀGHQFH(OVLH EURXJKWH[FLWHPHQWDQGIXQ$VDPLQLVWHUVKHZRXOGFRQVLVWHQWO\EH SHUFHLYHGDVDJUHDWEOHVVLQJWRKHUFKXUFKHV²DVSUHDFKHUSDVWRU PXVLFLDQ\RXWKZRUNHUDQGLQVSLUHU+HUVZDVDOZD\VDQXSOLIWLQJ SUHVHQFH %\ RI FRXUVH VKHKDGPDGHDQDPH IRUKHUVHOI 6KHKDG
FRQIURQWHGWKHREVWDFOHVWRKHUEHFRPLQJDIRUFHV·FKDSODLQDQGVKH KDGRYHUFRPHWKHPDOEHLWDWVRPHFRVWWRKHUKHDOWK7KHSULQFLSOH RIDZRPDQFKDSODLQLQWKHDUPHGIRUFHVKDGEHHQODLGGRZQHYHQLI WKHRSSRVLWLRQKDGEHHQDQGUHPDLQHG¶LPSODFDEOH·6KHKDGVKRZQ VLPLODUUHVROXWLRQDQGIRUWLWXGHLQKHUGHDOLQJVZLWKWKH&KXUFKRI (QJODQGDXWKRULWLHVZKRKDGRSSRVHGKHUPDUULDJHWR-RKQIRUVR ORQJ,QWKLVWRRVKHKDGDWODVWJDLQHGWKHYLFWRU\DQGLQWKHSURFHVV VKHKDGVXUUHQGHUHGQRQHRIKHUVFUXSOHV6LJQLÀFDQWO\VKHKDGDOVR DVVHUWHGKHUVHOIDJDLQVWKHUGRPLQDWLQJPRWKHUZKRKDGQRWZDQWHG KHUWRPDUU\-RKQ*DUULQJWRQ6KHZDVVWLOODFWLYHO\HPSOR\HGDVD &RQJUHJDWLRQDOPLQLVWHUDQGVKHKDGJDLQHGDPHDVXUHRIUHFRJQLWLRQ LQDQGEH\RQGFKXUFKFLUFOHV +RZHYHUKHUURXWHWRWKDWUHFRJQLWLRQKDGHQWDLOHGVXFKGHÀDQFH
RIHVWDEOLVKHGRUGHUWKDWLWPXVWKDYHEHHQGLIÀFXOWIRUKHUWRDFFHSW WKDWVRPHWLPHVWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOZD\WKHZHOOWURGGHQSDWKZDVWKH ULJKWFRXUVHWRWDNH+HUH[SHULHQFHKDGRQO\UHLQIRUFHGKHULQGLYLGXDOLVP:RXOGVXFKZD\ZDUGQHVVDOZD\VEHDYLUWXH"+DYLQJEHHQ IRUFHGWRWDNHKHURZQVLQJXODUSDWKZRXOGVKHEHDEOHWRRIIHUZHOO EDODQFHGDGYLFHWRRWKHUV"+RZZRXOGVKHHYHUNQRZZKHQLWZDV ULJKWWRFRQIRUP"6XFKTXHVWLRQVUHPDLQHGVWLOOWREHDQVZHUHGEXW LQIRUWKLVEULJKWVWDUDV6LGQH\%HUU\KDGSURSKHVLHGDQRWKHU ELJMREDQGDEULJKWIXWXUHEHFNRQHG
<HDUVRI)XOÀOPHQW$1HZ+RPHDQG)XWXUH
$IWHU KHUPDUULDJH WR -RKQ*DUULQJWRQ D YLFWRU\ RYHU$QJOLFDQ EXOO\LQJDQG VWXIÀQHVV DV WKH\ERWKXQGHUVWRRG LW DQG WKURXJK KHUVHUYLFHLQWKH5$)(OVLH&KDPEHUODLQKDGDFTXLUHGDQDWLRQDO FHOHEULW\UDUHLQD&RQJUHJDWLRQDOPLQLVWHULIQRWXQLTXHLQWKHODWH V6XFKIDPHPDGHKHUVHWWOLQJGRZQDVWKHPLQLVWHURI9LQH\DUG &RQJUHJDWLRQDO&KXUFK5LFKPRQGXSRQ7KDPHV DZNZDUGERWK IRUKHU DQG IRUKHU FKXUFKPHPEHUV 6KHZDVQRWRQO\ LQ DQHZ
SDVWRUDWHDQGQHZO\PDUULHGEXWLQDGGLWLRQVKHKDGWRFRSHZLWK WKHGHPDQGVLPSRVHGXSRQKHUDVWKHZLIHRIWKHYLFDURI$OO6DLQWV· &KXUFK+DPSWRQZKRLQKDGSDULVKLRQHUVLQKLVFDUH 6KHKDG HQFRXQWHUHG FRQVLGHUDEOHGLIÀFXOWLHV LQ KHU OLIH DQG
PLQLVWU\ VR IDU DW OHDVWSDUWLDOO\ EHFDXVH VKHZDV VXFK D WRXJK XQFRPSURPLVLQJZRPDQ\HWWKRVHYHU\TXDOLWLHVRIWRXJKQHVVDQG HQGXUDQFHKDGHQDEOHGKHUWRVXUYLYHDQGWULXPSK7KHVHH[SHULHQFHV ZHUHQHFHVVDULO\WRLQÁXHQFHKHUODWHUGHFLVLRQVEXWKHUVWURQJZLOO DQGVHOIFRQÀGHQFHJDYHKHUDUHVLOLHQFHDQGWKHSRZHUWRRYHUFRPH YLFLVVLWXGHVDQGWRWDNHKHURZQOLQHDJDLQVWWKHYRLFHVRIIULHQGDQG IRHDOLNH6KHZRXOGQRWEHFRZHGLQWRVXEPLVVLRQQRPDWWHUZKDW WKHFDXVH
/LIHDW+DPSWRQ
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ÀFDOWKRXJKLQWKHODWHVDQGVWKH YROXPHRIWUDIÀFWKRXJKKHDY\E\FRQWHPSRUDU\VWDQGDUGVZRXOG KDYHEHHQOHVVRIDQXLVDQFHWKDQLWZRXOGODWHUEHFRPH $OO6DLQW·V&KXUFKWRZKLFK-RKQKDGEHHQDSSRLQWHGLVQRWWKH
ROG+DPSWRQSDULVKFKXUFK6W0DU\·VZKLFKVWDQGVKLJKXSLQWKH FHQWUHRIWKHYLOODJH5DWKHULWLVDPRUHPRGHUQEXLOGLQJRQO\EHJXQ LQ<HWWKLVZDVWRSURYLGH(OVLHDQG-RKQZLWKWKHLUÀUVWKRPH WRJHWKHURIZKLFKWKH\KDGGUHDPHGDQGIRUZKLFKWKH\KDGZDLWHG SDWLHQWO\:LWKDFRQVWDQWÁRZRIYLVLWRUVWRWKHYLOODJHHVSHFLDOO\LQ VXPPHUDQGERRNVHOOHUVDQGDQWLTXHVKRSVDSOHQW\(OVLHDQG-RKQ VHWWOHGKDSSLO\LQWRWKHYLFDUDJHDGHWDFKHGGRXEOHIURQWHGKRXVH
ZLWKDODUJHJDUGHQ-RKQRIFRXUVHZDVIDPLOLDUZLWKWKHDUHDKDYLQJ OLYHGWKHUHIRUDOPRVWD\HDUEHIRUHWKHLUPDUULDJH (OVLHZDVQRW D QDWXUDO KRXVHZLIH DQGGLGQRW HDVLO\ WDNH WR
KRXVHZRUN6KHKDGQHYHUQHHGHGWRGRLWDQGDW+DPSWRQ-RKQ RYHUFDPHWKLVSUREOHPE\DUUDQJLQJIRUDSDULVKLRQHUWRFRPHLQWR FOHDQWKHKRXVH$VDUHVXOW-RKQ·VVWXG\DQGWKHORXQJHRUPXVLF URRPZHUHDOZD\VNHSWLQLPPDFXODWHFRQGLWLRQIRUWKHUHFHSWLRQRI YLVLWRUV-RKQDQG(OVLHGLGWKHLUEHVWWRVXSSRUWHDFKRWKHU·VPLQLVWU\ DQGRQRFFDVLRQVWKH\HYHQSUHDFKHGLQHDFKRWKHU·VFKXUFKHV$W OHDVWRQRQHRFFDVLRQWKH9LQH\DUG&RQJUHJDWLRQDO&KXUFKGHDFRQV KHOGDIRUPDOPHHWLQJDW$OO6DLQWV·YLFDUDJH $V VKHKDG DVVXUHG%LVKRS:DQG WKDW VKHZRXOG (OVLH WRRN
VHULRXVO\KHU UROH DV WKHYLFDU·VZLIH FDULQJ IRU -RKQ·V FKXUFKDV ZHOODVIRUKHURZQ+HU¶WHUULÀFHQWKXVLDVPDQGYLWDOLW\·PDGHKHU DIRUFHLQWKHSDULVKHVSHFLDOO\RQ6XQGD\V$OWKRXJK(OVLHDQG-RKQ ZHUHVRGLIIHUHQW²VKHZDVWHHWRWDOKHOLNHGDOFRKROVKHZDVWDOO KHZDVVKRUWHUVKHZDVD&RQJUHJDWLRQDOLVWKHD+LJK$QJOLFDQ² WKHLUVSURYHGWREH¶DVWURQJDQGPXWXDOO\VXSSRUWLYHUHODWLRQVKLS· ZKLFKZDVWREULQJWKHPERWKODVWLQJKDSSLQHVV2QHFORVHIULHQG GHVFULEHGWKHLU¶LPSUREDEOHPDUULDJH·DVLOOXVWUDWLQJ¶E\WKHLUPXWXDO XQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHWUXHHFXPHQLFDOVSLULW·&HUWDLQO\-RKQDQG(OVLH ZRXOGKDYHOLNHGWKDWGHVFULSWLRQ$W$OO6DLQWVDQGLQWKHSDULVKDV DZKROH(OVLHGLGQRWUHVLVWEHLQJNQRZQDVWKHYLFDU·VZLIH,QGHHG VKHZDVKDSS\WREH0UV*DUULQJWRQ 2XWVLGHWKHSDULVKKRZHYHUVKHZDVXQLYHUVDOO\NQRZQDV(OVLH
&KDPEHUODLQDQGVKHFRQWLQXHGWRXVHKHUPDLGHQQDPHIRUPRVW SXUSRVHVIRUWKHUHVWRIKHUOLIH7KLVZDVLQPDUNHGFRQWUDVWWRDW OHDVW RQH RWKHU RUGDLQHG&RQJUHJDWLRQDOZRPDQZKR EDVHG LQ /DQFDVKLUHZDVH[SHFWHGDIWHUPDUULDJHWRIRUJRKHUPDLGHQQDPH DQGWKHUHDIWHU WRXVHKHUKXVEDQG·V$OWKRXJKZLOOLQJ WRFRPSO\ VKHODWHUZRQGHUHGZK\WKHUXOHVKDGEHHQGLIIHUHQWIRU(OVLH:DV (OVLHVHHQDVDVSHFLDOFDVH":HUHWKRVHLQRUQHDU/RQGRQWUHDWHG GLIIHUHQWO\IURPWKRVHLQWKHQRUWK"(OVLHZDVDIWHUDOODIULHQGRI 6LGQH\%HUU\WKHVHFUHWDU\RIWKH&RQJUHJDWLRQDO8QLRQRI(QJODQG DQG:DOHV,IKHXVHGKHUPDLGHQQDPHWKHQIHZ&RQJUHJDWLRQDOLVWV
ZRXOGTXHVWLRQLW3HUKDSVDIWHUWKHZDULWZDVGHHPHGWKDWVRFLDO FRQYHQWLRQVKDG HDVHG VRPHZKDW DQG(OVLH XVLQJ WKH VXUQDPH &KDPEHUODLQKDGDOUHDG\DFTXLUHGVRPHGLVWLQFWLRQ
A Family
6RRQDIWHUPDUULDJH(OVLHDW\HDUVDQG-RKQDWGHFLGHGWR DGRSWDFKLOGUDWKHUWKDQWU\WRKDYHFKLOGUHQRIWKHLURZQ(OVLH·VVWLOO GHOLFDWHKHDOWKDQGKHUGHGLFDWLRQWRKHUFDOOLQJZHUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQV 7KH\FKRVHWRDGRSWDFKLOGRIDQDJHDSSUR[LPDWHWRDQ\FKLOGZKR PLJKWKDYHEHHQERUQ WR WKHPKDG WKH\PDUULHGZKHQ WKH\KDG RULJLQDOO\KRSHGWR-DQHWWHZDVLQWKH%ULWLVK/HJLRQFKLOGUHQ·VKRPH DW5LFKPRQGXSRQ7KDPHVFORVHWR(OVLH·VFKXUFKLQWKH9LQH\DUG 7KHFKLOGUHQRIWKHKRPHH[VHUYLFHPHQ·VFKLOGUHQZHUHVHQWWRWKH &RQJUHJDWLRQDOFKXUFKZKHUH-DQHWWHZDVLQWKH%URZQLHV2QDYLVLW WR9LQH\DUGRQHGD\-RKQWRRNDQLPPHGLDWHVKLQHWRKHUDQGVKH ZDVIRVWHUHGZLWKWKHP(OVLHZDVDOLWWOHUHOXFWDQWMXGJLQJ-DQHWWH WREH¶DPRXVH·EXW-RKQZDVNHHQDQGWKHIRVWHULQJLQWLPHOHGWR KHUIXOODGRSWLRQ /LNHPDQ\RIKHUJHQHUDWLRQ(OVLHZDVWKULIW\ÀQGLQJLWGLIÀFXOW
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·VORYHRIPXVLFOHGKHUWRGLUHFWDQGFRQGXFWRUDWRULRVDW$OO
6DLQWV+DPSWRQWRZKLFKDPRQJRWKHUVVKHZRXOGLQYLWHPHPEHUV DQGIULHQGVRI9LQH\DUG,QVLPLODUIDVKLRQEXWRQDVPDOOHUVFDOH
VKHZRXOGKROGPXVLFDOHYHQWVDW9LQH\DUG6KHDOVRUDQDFKLOGUHQ·V RUFKHVWUDLQWKHSDULVKDQGPDGHWKHYLFDUDJHDQGLWVJDUGHQDYDLODEOH IRUWKHVXPPHUIHWHHYHU\\HDU2QRQHRFFDVLRQWKH%LVKRSRI/RQGRQ VWD\HG IRUGLQQHU DIWHUSUHVLGLQJDW D FRQÀUPDWLRQ VHUYLFH DW$OO 6DLQWV(OVLHMRLQHGWKH0RWKHUV·8QLRQLQWKHSDULVKDQGLQ1RYHPEHU VKHIRXQGHGWKH<RXQJ:LYHV·&OXEZKLFKVKHFRQVFLHQWLRXVO\ DWWHQGHGHYHQZKHQVKHZDVZRUNLQJDWWKH%%&LQWKHV6KH UHDOL]HGWKDW\RXQJZLYHVHVSHFLDOO\QHHGHGDQLJKWRXWDQGDWWKH FOXEPHPEHUVZRXOGOLVWHQWRPXVLFKHDUWDONVKDYHVRFLDOVDQG HQMR\HDFKRWKHU·VFRPSDQ\LQDUHOD[HGVHWWLQJ(OVLHZRXOGWDNH IULHQGVIURPWKHSDULVKZLWKKHURQYLVLWVWRWKH&LW\FKXUFKHV,QWKH PLGVWKH:LYHV·&OXEVWLOOFRQWLQXHGDOWKRXJKDIWHU\HDUVLW QRORQJHUERUHWKHHSLWKHW\RXQJ(OVLHKHUVHOIFRQWLQXHGWRUXQWKH FOXEXSWRZKHQ-RKQOHIW+DPSWRQWRPRYHWRDOLYLQJLQ(VVH[ /LYLQJ LQ+DPSWRQ -DQHWWH DWWHQGHG -RKQ·V FKXUFKDQG MRLQHG
WKH FKRLU$V D WHHQDJHU VKH IRXQG -RKQ·V UHOD[HGYLHZ WRZDUGV VRFLDOJDWKHULQJVPRUHFRQJHQLDOWKDQ(OVLH·VVWULFWVDEEDWDULDQLVP ,QDFFRUGDQFHZLWKKHURZQXSEULQJLQJ(OVLHUHIXVHGWRDOORZKHU GDXJKWHU WRGRKRPHZRUNRUZDVKKHUKDLU RQ6XQGD\V DQG LQ DGGLWLRQVKHH[SHFWHGKHUWHHWRWDOSULQFLSOHVWREHUHVSHFWHG-RKQ·V PHPEHUVKLSRI WKH:RUNLQJ0DQ·V&OXE DQGRI WKH IUHHPDVRQV XQGHUOLQHGKRZPXFKKHGLIIHUHG IURPKLVZLIH7KHXQFRPSURPLVLQJ(OVLHDOVRGLVDSSURYHGRIPDNHXSWRKHUDIRUPRIIHPDOH YDQLW\ DQGXQQHFHVVDU\$V D UHVXOW -DQHWWHKDG VRPHDZNZDUG H[SHULHQFHVZKLOVWJURZLQJLQWRDGXOWKRRG :KLOH OLYLQJ DW+DPSWRQ -RKQ DQG(OVLH ERXJKW D FRWWDJH LQ
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·VDUGHQWWHHWRWDOLVPFRXOGFDXVHSDUWLFXODU
DZNZDUGQHVV DV DW -DQHWWH·VZHGGLQJ DIWHUZKLFK WKH JURRP·V IDPLO\ZLVKHGWRVHUYHVKHUU\DQGZLQH(OVLHH[HUFLVHGDYHWRRYHU WKLVVXJJHVWLRQ ,QWKH*DUULQJWRQIDPLO\PRYHGIURP+DPSWRQWRWKHUHFWRU\
DW*UHHQVWHGQHDU2QJDULQ(VVH[,QWKLVHDUO\QLQHWHHQWKFHQWXU\ KRXVHZLWKLWVZKLWHZDVKHGH[WHULRUDQGODUJHJDUGHQ(OVLHIHOWDW KRPHZKLOH-RKQZDVSURXGRIWKHDQFLHQWFKXUFKZKLFKKHVHUYHG +HZRXOGSHUVRQDOO\FRQGXFWYLVLWRUVDURXQGWKHFKXUFKEXLOGLQJ ZKLFKLV6D[RQLQRULJLQKDYLQJEHHQEXLOWWRPDUNWKHSODFHZKHUH6W (GPXQG·VERG\UHVWHGRQLWVZD\IURP/RQGRQWR%XU\6W(GPXQG·V LQ1HYHUWKHOHVV*UHHQVWHGSDULVKFKXUFKZLWKLWVGLVWLQFWLYH RDNWLPEHUZDOOVFXULRXVO\LVGHGLFDWHGWR6W$QGUHZDQGQRWWR6W (GPXQG
