ABSTRACT
CALLEDTHE@TURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURE4HISTHEORYWASPRODUCEDBY&RED%MERY AND%RIC4RISTANDTHEIRCOLLEAGUESINTHE4AVISTOCK)NSTITUTEIN,ONDONDURINGTHE S7EFOCUSONTHEORIGINALFORMULATIONASWELLASSUBSEQUENTDEVELOPMENTS UPTOTHEPRESENT)NTHESECONDSECTIONWEREVIEWTHENATUREANDHISTORYOF SCENARIOPRACTICES4HISOFFERSACOMPARATIVERENDITIONOFHOWSCENARIOPRACTICES DEVELOPEDONBOTHSIDESOFTHE!TLANTICAGAINFROMTHESTOTHEPRESENT)N THElNALSECTIONOFTHISCHAPTERWEOUTLINEHOWSCENARIOWORKAND#44INFORM ANDENRICHEACHOTHER
)NTHEYEARSSPANNINGTHEENDOF7ORLD7AR))ANDTHEPUBLICATIONOF%MERY AND4RISTSSEMINALPAPER@4HECAUSALTEXTUREOFORGANIZATIONALENVIRONMENTSIN (UMAN2ELATIONSINTHElELDOFSOCIALPSYCHOLOGYHADBEENMOSTATTENTIVE TODEVELOPMENTSINBIOLOGY&ROMTHATDISCIPLINEANDPARTICULARLYFROMTHEWORK
OFVON"ERTALANFFY AND!SHBY ONHOWORGANISMSRELATETOTHEIR CONTEXTSSOCIALPSYCHOLOGYSCHOLARSHADIMPORTEDANDTHENADAPTEDTHEIDEA THATSYSTEMSSHOULDBETREATEDAS@OPENnTHATISASlTTINGINDERIVINGFORM ANDSUSTENANCEFROMANDCONTRIBUTINGTOANENVIRONMENTAROUNDTHEM4HIS PERSPECTIVEWHICHBECAMEKNOWNAS@OPENSYSTEMSTHINKINGTHENINmUENCED THINKINGINORGANIZATIONSWHERESTRATEGICPLANNERSBECAMEINCREASINGLYINTERESTED INTHEBUSINESSENVIRONMENTSETTINGPARAMETERSFORSTRATEGICDECISION MAKING /PENSYSTEMSTHINKINGWOULDBEANESSENTIALPARTOF%MERYAND4RISTSWORKAND ACENTRALCOMPONENTOFHOWTHEIRWORKWOULDCOMETOENLIGHTENFUTURESCHOLARS ANDPRACTITIONERS !SECONDIMPORTANTINPUTINTO%MERYAND4RISTSTHINKINGCAMEFROMTHEIR
COLLEAGUE+URT,EWIN )NHISWORK,EWINFOUNDTHAT TOUNDERSTAND SOMETHINGINTHESOCIALWORLDASOCIALSCIENTISTENGAGESWITHITANDTHATTHE INEVITABLECHANGESCAUSEDBYTHEENGAGEMENTHELPTHESCIENTISTTOEXPLAINTHE SYSTEMBETTER4HISIDEAWASTHEFOUNDATIONOFTHEMETHODOFACTIONRESEARCH %MERYAND4RISTADOPTEDTHISAPPROACHOF@ENGAGINGWITHWHICHTHEYSTUDIED INTHEIRVARIOUSlELDRESEARCHES4RISTLATERHIGHLIGHTEDTHISPRINCIPLEINTHETITLE OFHISTHREE VOLUMETRILOGYOF4AVISTOCKWORKPUBLISHEDBYTHE5NIVERSITYOF 0ENNSYLVANIA0RESSBETWEENANDNAMINGIT4HE3OCIAL%NGAGEMENTOF 3OCIAL3CIENCE /PENSYSTEMSANDENGAGEMENTWEREDECISIVEELEMENTSINHOWTHEIR WORKEVOLVEDNOTONLYAFFECTINGWHATTHEYRESEARCHEDBUTALSODElNINGTHEROLE THEYDEVELOPEDASRESEARCHERSRELATINGTOCLIENTSORSUBJECTS !LLTHISWORKTHENLEDTOTHEDEVELOPMENTOFCAUSALTEXTURETHEORY#44
WHICH%MERYAND4RISTLAUNCHEDFORTHElRSTTIMEINTHEIRSEMINALPAPER WHICHWEDISCUSSBELOW)NITTHEYDEVELOPEDATAXONOMYOFCAUSALTEXTURESOF ENVIRONMENTSWITHINWHICHORGANIZATIONSAIMTOSURVIVEANDTHRIVE4HEONE THEYDREWPARTICULARATTENTIONTOWASCALLEDTHE@TURBULENTlELD4URBULENCEIN COLLOQUIAL%NGLISHDESCRIBESCONDITIONSTHATAREUNCERTAINCOMPLEXANDCHANGING UNPREDICTABLYANDOFTENQUICKLY)NTHEIRPAPER%MERYAND4RIST DElNED @TURBULENCE IN AMUCHMOREPRECISEWAY THAT COULD REFER TOORGANIZATIONAL ENVIRONMENTS)NTHISVOLUMETHEWORD@TURBULENCEISUSEDINITSMORERESTRICTED ANDTECHNICALMEANINGASDESCRIBEDINDETAILBELOW2EADERSNEEDTOHANGONTO THISPOINTINORDERTOUNDERSTANDTHELINEOFARGUMENTONWHYSCENARIOSWORK ANDWHYTHEYHAVEGROWNASINCREASINGLYTURBULENTCONDITIONSHAVEEMERGED)N THENEXTSECTIONWERETURNTOTHEPRECISEUNDERSTANDINGOFTURBULENCEOFFEREDBY #44
#44DEALSWITHSYSTEMSTRYINGTOSURVIVEANDTHRIVEINTHEIRENVIRONMENTSINA SUSTAINABLEWAY4HEINSIDEASYSTEM ANDTHEOUTSIDETHEENVIRONMENTOFTHAT SYSTEM @CO EVOLVEINTHESENSETHATSYSTEMSANDTHEIRENVIRONMENTSMUTUALLY
ANDSYSTEMATICALLYINmUENCEEACHOTHERANDTHEYPROCEEDINTOTHEFUTURETOGETHER 3ELSKYETAL 3YSTEMANDENVIRONMENTBOTHHAVELINKSBETWEENVARIABLES THATEXISTWITHINTHEMANDLINKSWITHEACHOTHER3EVERALINTERACTINGSYSTEMSTHEIR SHAREDENVIRONMENTSANDTHELINKSTHATCONNECTSTHEMTOGETHERAREDElNEDASA @lELD #AUSALTEXTUREISANEMERGENTPROPERTYOFTHEWHOLElELDANDCONCERNSTHE
BEHAVIOUROFALLSYSTEMSWITHINIT4HECAUSALTEXTUREOFAlELDSETSCONDITIONSON HOWTHESESYSTEMSANDTHEIRSHAREDENVIRONMENTSTRANSACT3ELSKYETAL P )NTHEIRPAPER%MERYAND4RISTIDENTIlEDFOURDISTINCTTYPESOFCAUSAL
TEXTURE4HESEWERE@IDEALTYPESIN'ERMANSOCIOLOGIST-AX7EBERS SENSE nTHATISALOGICALLYDERIVEDHYPOTHETICAL@PURECATEGORYOFEXISTENCEUNSULLIEDBY THECLUTTEROFTHE@REALWORLD)DEALTYPESCANHELPPRACTITIONERSTOIDENTIFYHOW CLOSEAGIVENSITUATIONISTOTHE@TEXTBOOKCASETHATTHEIDEALTYPEDESCRIBES&OR EXAMPLE7EBERUSED@BUREAUCRACYWHICHHEDISTINGUISHEDFROMCHARISMATICAND FROMTRADITIONALORGANIZATIONALIDEALTYPES ASTHEPERFECTFORMFORHIS@RATIONAL IDEALTYPEOFORGANIZATIONnYETEVERYONEKNOWSHOWIRRATIONALBUREAUCRACIESCAN ACTUALLYBEINREALLIFE 4HEDIFFERENCESAMONGTHEFOUR IDEAL TYPESTHAT%MERYAND4RIST
DEVELOPEDDEPENDEDUPONHOWSYSTEMSINTHElELDSYSTEMSTHEYTERMED@ ANDTHEIRSURROUNDINGENVIRONMENTWHICHTHEYTERMED@ ARELINKED4HEY WEREPARTICULARLYINTERESTEDINLINKSTHEYCALLED@LAW LIKEIELINKSDRIVENBYA LOGICTHATPERTAINSOVERAPERIODOFTIME &OURPOSSIBLELINKSBETWEENSYSTEMAND ENVIRONMENTEXIST
,READAS@%LONEONENOTAS@,ELEVEN DENOTESLINKSTHATREMAININTERNAL TOASYSTEM
,LINKSTHESYSTEMTOITSENVIRONMENTnSYSTEMOUTPUTSRELATEDTOTHE PLANNINGFUNCTION
,LINKSTHEENVIRONMENTTOTHESYSTEMnSYSTEMINPUTSRELATEDTOTHE LEARNINGFUNCTION
,DENOTESLINKSBETWEENELEMENTSINTHEENVIRONMENTITSELFANDWHICH OCCURINDEPENDENTLYOFTHESYSTEM
$ISTINCTIONSAMONGTHECAUSALTEXTURESAREMOSTHELPFULLYCHARACTERIZEDBYWHICH OFTHE,,,AND,LINKSAREMOSTSALIENTINTHESITUATIONSTUDIEDAS WESHOWIN4ABLEnTHATIS%MERYAND4RISTWORKEDOUTTHECAUSALTEXTURES LOGICALLYINTERMSOFlELDSTRUCTUREANDTHETYPEOFCOPINGORRESPONSESTRATEGY THATWOULDENABLEASYSTEMTODOWELLINTHATCAUSALSITUATIONAMOREELABORATE VERSIONOF4ABLEISFOUNDIN#HAPTERAS4ABLE )NDEVELOPINGTHEFOURCAUSALTEXTURES%MERYAND4RISTS REASONINGWAS
LOGICALANDDEDUCTIVE4HEDISTINCTIVECONTRIBUTIONWASTOARTICULATEFORTHElRST TIMETHENATUREANDPROPERTIESOFTHEENVIRONMENTALRELATIONSHIPS,
4ABLE 4HEFOURCAUSALTEXTURES
4HENAMESTHEYGAVEEACHCAUSALTEXTUREWERERATHERINCIDENTAL INTENDEDTO MAKETHETYPESMOREACCESSIBLE %RIC4RIST TOLD2AMIREZAND3ELSKYTHAT THE LABEL@TURBULENTOCCURREDTOTHEMWHILEONAVERYUNSTABLEAEROPLANEmIGHT 4HEDEPICTION@TURBULENTHASSUBSEQUENTLYCAPTUREDTHEIMAGINATIONOFMANY SCHOLARSANDMANAGERS)NPICKINGUPONTHELABEL@TURBULENCETHEYHAVEMADE THATARTICLEONEOFTHEMOSTWIDELYCITEDINTHELITERATUREONMANAGEMENT ANDORGANIZATIONS !SONEPROGRESSESFROMTYPE)TOTYPE)6CAUSALTEXTUREINCREASINGCOMPLEXITY
OFTRANSACTIONSINAlELDLEADSTOANAGGREGATEBEHAVIOUROFTHATlELDTHATBECOMES LESSANDLESSSTABLE4HECAUSALTEXTUREISAMANIFESTATIONOFTHISRELATIVEINSTABILITY &ROMTHEPOINTOFVIEWOFANYSYSTEMINTHEENVIRONMENTSUCHASANORGANIZATION THISMEANSTHATITSENVIRONMENTBECOMESLESSSTABLEASTHETEXTURESPROCEEDnTHAT ISTHEINCREASINGINSTABILITYOFTHElELDASAWHOLEMANIFESTSITSELFASA@RELEVANT INSTABILITYOFTHEENVIRONMENTOFINDIVIDUALSYSTEMSORORGANIZATIONS
)N%MERYAND4RISTTERMSASEXPRESSEDINTHEPAPERTHE,LINKSARE RELEVANTTOALLSYSTEMSINAlELD&ORANYSYSTEMINTHISlELDTHESE LINKSARE PERCEIVEDASTHEWIDERCONTEXTINWHICHITlNDSITSELF4HISINITIALLYCREATEDA DEGREEOFCONFUSIONASITWASLESSTHANCLEARHOWTODISTINGUISH,FROM, LINKS4HISDILEMMAWASSUBSEQUENTLYPOST RESOLVEDBYTHEDElNITIONOF THETRANSACTIONALANDCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTS%ACHSYSTEMORGANIZATION IN THElELDHASITSOWNCOMPETITIVEANDCOLLABORATIVEOPERATIONSANDRELATIONSWITH OTHERSWHICHAREDElNEDASTHE,AND,LINKS4HISISTHETRANSACTIONAL ENVIRONMENTDElNEDBYTHEACTIONSOFTHEACTORSINIT4OGETHERTHESETRANSACTIONS INAGGREGATEBECOMEPARTOFTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT4HELATTERISDElNED BYTHERELEVANT,LINKSEXPRESSEDNOTASAGENTACTIONSBUTINTERMSOFMACRO FACTORS)FANINDIVIDUALACTORCANINmUENCETHESITUATIONSHEISINTHETRANSACTIONAL ENVIRONMENTDElNEDBY,AND,LINKS)FANINDIVIDUALACTORISLOOKINGAT MACRO PHENOMENATHATSHECANNOTINmUENCESHEISLOOKINGATTHECONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTDElNEDBY,LINKS )NTHElRSTTWOTYPESOFCAUSALTEXTURETHEENVIRONMENTISRECOGNIZEDTOBE
STABLEBYTHEMAJORITYOFTHEACTORSINIT)NTYPE)))WITHMOREINTERCONNECTIONS THElELDBECOMESMOREDYNAMICOR@DISTURBED"UTEVENIFCOMPETITIONMAYBE SEVEREANDSOMEORGANIZATIONSWILLPERISHTHESEEVENTSHAPPENINAMUTUALLY ACKNOWLEDGEDANDLEGITIMATEWAY&ORTHISREASONTHOSEINATYPE)))ENVIRONMENT RECOGNIZE THAT THE @PLAYINGlELD IE THE TRANSACTIONAL ENVIRONMENT IS STILL RELATIVELYSTABLE3YSTEMSINTHISENVIRONMENTALTEXTUREOPERATEACCORDINGTOAND SUPPORTASETOFINSTITUTIONALRULESOFTHEGAMEVANDE6ENAND(ARGRAVE THATCHARACTERIZETHElELDTHEYCONSTITUTEANDINHABIT 5PTOANDINCLUDINGATYPE)))CASUALTEXTURECHANGEOCCURSBETWEENANDAMONG
SYSTEMSENCOMPASSEDINASTABLEANDRELATIVELYPREDICTABLESHAREDENVIRONMENT EVENIFLIFEISNOTALWAYSTOTALLYAGREEABLEANDHASITSUPSANDDOWNS(OWEVERIN THETURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURETHEINSTITUTIONALARRANGEMENTSGOVERNINGTHElELDAS AWHOLESTARTTOBREAKDOWNANDTHEWHOLEOFTHElELDINCLUDINGTHECONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTOF,LINKSBECOMESASOURCEOFINSTABILITY4HESUDDEN INSTABILITY INTHE,RELATIONSHIPSSIGNALSTODECISION MAKERSTHATTHEYCANTRELYONIT ANYMORE4HISMAKESTHE@RELEVANTUNCERTAINTYSALIENTINANEWWAYFORTHEMAS THEIRORGANIZATIONSTRYTOSURVIVEANDTHRIVEINTHATENVIRONMENT (OWMIGHTTHISHAPPEN#HARLES0ERROW INHISBOOK.ORMAL!CCIDENTS
STUDIEDTHESETOFCONDITIONSTHATLEDTOTHE4HREE-ILE)SLANDNUCLEARPOWER INCIDENT(EFOUNDTHATTHENUCLEARREACTOROPERATORSTACITLYANDMISTAKENLY THOUGHTTHATWHATWASGOINGONHADBEENPREDICTEDINADVANCEANDTHATWAYSTO DEALWITHITHADBEENSPECIlEDINTHEIROPERATINGMANUALS9ETTHESITUATIONTHAT ACTUALLYAROSEHADNOTBEENPREDICTEDANDANTICIPATEDINTHEMANUALS3OINDOING WHATTHEMANUALSSAIDSHOULDBEDONEOPERATORSACTUALLYCONTRIBUTEDTOMAKING THEACCIDENTHAPPENANDMADEITWORSE3OTOOWITHTURBULENCEnITMAYBECAUSED BYANAGGREGATEOFACTORSWHOAREUNAWARETHATTHEYAREINFACTCO PRODUCING
THETURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURE&OREXAMPLEIFACTORSINADISTURBEDnREACTIVECAUSAL TEXTUREDONOT INAGGREGATEATTENDTOTHEEXTERNALITIES THEYPRODUCE INTHEIR NORMALCOMPETITIVEACTIONSINCLUDINGFAILURETOATTENDTOAPPROPRIATEREGULATORY FRAMEWORKS THEYMAYUNWITTINGLYCO PRODUCEATURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURE3ELSKY ETALPSEEALSO#HAPTERSANDINTHISVOLUME &ORAGIVENOBSERVERTHETYPE)6CAUSALTEXTUREREmECTSCONDITIONSINTHElELD
THATHAVEBEENCALLED@WICKEDPROBLEMS2ITTELAND7EBBER @MESSESOR SYSTEMSOFPROBLEMS!CKOFF AND@META PROBLEMS4RIST3ELSKYAND 0ARKER 4RISTCLARIlEDLATER THATTHE,CONTEXTUALLINKSSUPPLYTHEBOUNDARY
CONDITIONSFORANYONESYSTEMSTRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTITS,AND, RELATIONSWITHWHICH IT TRANSACTSWITH OTHERS (OW THE NATURE OF THE, RELATIONSHIPSSHAPESTHESETRANSACTIONSWASTHEKEYCONTRIBUTIONINTHEORIGINAL ANALYSIS4RISTP 4HISISANIMPORTANTINSIGHTFORTHEPURPOSESOF THISBOOKASITCLARIlESHOWANDWHYSCENARIOSHELPDECISION MAKERSnSPECIlCALLY INTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURES)NTHElRSTTHREETYPESOFCAUSALTEXTUREACTORSIN AGGREGATEMAINTAINADEGREEOFCONTROLOVERTHElELD"UTINTHETURBULENTCAUSAL TEXTURETHE,AND,TRANSACTIONSAMONGSYSTEMSBECOMEAFFECTEDBYHIGHLY UNCERTAIN,MACRO RELATIONSHIPSDUETOUNCERTAINCAUSALITY7ITHTHESOURCEOF UNCERTAINTYNOLONGERPREDICTABLESCENARIOSBECOMEHIGHLYRELEVANTMETHODS)N THISRESPECTITISCRUCIALTHATTHEMETHODSUPONWHICHSCENARIOWORKRESTSNEITHER DEPENDUPONNORDEPLOYPROBABILITYANDPREDICTABILITYASAIDSINASSESSINGHOWTHE TURBULENCEMAYPLAYOUT7EEXPANDONTHISIMPORTANTPOINTIN#HAPTER 7E SUBSCRIBE TO THE @SOCIO ECOLOGICAL POSITIONPROPOSEDBY%MERY AND
4RIST ANDFURTHERDEVELOPEDIN#44(ERETURBULENCEISUNDERSTOODASA DISTINCTIVElELD BASEDENVIRONMENTALTEXTURENOTONLYASANASPECTOFANINDIVIDUAL ORGANIZATIONSENVIRONMENT3ELSKYETALP ASSERTTHAT @4OCONSTRUE TURBULENCEASAPROPERTYOFAPARTICULARlRMSENVIRONMENTxISTOCONmATEITWITH THECOMMERCIALCHALLENGESROUTINELYFACEDBYEVERYlRM#ONmATINGTURBULENCE WITHINTENSECOMPETITIVECHALLENGESREmECTSTHEWAYINWHICHTHEWORD@TURBULENCE ISUSEDINEVERYDAYLANGUAGEANDHASARATHERDIFFERENTMEANINGFROMITSUSAGE IN#444HEEVERYDAYVIEWOFTURBULENCEIMPLIESTHATSTRATEGIZINGINTHElNAL ANALYSISISCOMPETINGnAPOSITIONMOREAPPROPRIATETOTHEDISTURBEDnREACTIVE TYPE)))TEXTURE CONDITIONSTHANTOTHETURBULENTlELDIN%MERYAND4RISTS SENSE4HETECHNICALVIEWOFTURBULENCEUSEDIN#44SUGGESTSTHATCOMPETITIVE ACTIONSMAYNOTALWAYSBEAPPROPRIATEIFTHEYCO PRODUCEATURBULENTlELDTHAT LEADSTOTHECOLLAPSEOFSYSTEMSINSTITUTIONSANDlRMS INIT)NEFFECTDIRECT EFFECTSOFCOMPETITIVEACTIONSANDUNINTENDEDHIGHER ORDERCONSEQUENCESMAYNOT BECONlNEDTOOTHERINDUSTRYACTORSWITHWHOMONEISCOMPETING4HELOGICAL CONCLUSIONOFCONmATINGTURBULENCEWITHCOMPETITIVECHALLENGESISTHAT@THEMORE TURBULENTTHEENVIRONMENTTHEMOREAGGRESSIVEMUSTBETHElRMSRESPONSE !NSOFFP #44ONTHEOTHERHANDSUGGESTSTHAT@SUCHhPROACTIVEv
RESPONSESMAYPRODUCEHIGHLYPROBLEMATICUNINTENDEDCONSEQUENCESINEXTENDED SOCIALlELDS3ELSKYETALP
Perceiving turbulence in practice
7HILETHEIDEALTYPESTHAT%MERYAND4RIST IDENTIlEDWERECLEARINPRACTICE ITISNOTSOEASYTOESTABLISHTHATONEISINASITUATIONTHATAPPROXIMATESAGIVENIDEAL TYPEOFCAUSALTEXTUREANDNOTANOTHER4HISISWHATHAPPENSWHENIDEALTYPESARE USEDINREALWORLDINSTANCES)N#HAPTER4HOMASWRESTLESWITHTHISISSUEASHE ANALYSESTHECASEOF6ENEZUELAINTHEPERIOD 2ESEARCHBY-C#ANNAND3ELSKY AND"ABÓROG€LU SUGGESTS
THATPEOPLESEXPERIENCEOFTURBULENCEISMODERATEDBYTHEADAPTIVECAPACITIES THEYPERCEIVETHEYCANMOBILIZEBOTHINDIVIDUALLYINSIDEASINGLESYSTEM AND COLLECTIVELYAMONGTHEMEMBERSINHABITINGTHESAMElELD 4HISCONTRASTSWITH %MERYAND4RISTSSTANCEINTHEPAPERTHATCONSIDEREDTURBULENCEASANOBJECTIVE CONDITIONOFAlELDnTHROUGHWHICHITBECAMEADISTINCTIVETEXTURE)NSTEAD-C#ANN AND3ELSKY AND3ELSKYETAL PUTTHESUBJECTIVEPERCEIVEROFTURBULENCE EXPLICITLYINTOTHEPICTURESUGGESTINGTHATAGIVENlELDCONDITIONWILLBEEXPERIENCED DIFFERENTLYBYDIFFERENTACTORSANDTHEREFOREPERCEIVEDDIFFERENTLY)NOTHERWORDS SOMEMAYCONSIDERTHATTHEYAREOPERATINGINATURBULENTCAUSALTEXTUREWHILEOTHERS SEETHEMSELVESINADISTURBEDREACTIVEONE4HEREASONWHYTHEYEXPERIENCEAND PERCEIVETHEIRENVIRONMENTSDIFFERENTLYISTHATTHEYPERCEIVETHEIRADAPTIVECAPACITIES DIFFERENTLY3OMEMAYBELIEVETHEYHAVETHEADAPTIVECAPACITYTOMOBILIZEGREATEROR MOREVALUABLESTOCKSOFRESOURCESANDOTHERSMAYNOTHAVETHATPERCEPTION)NTHE lNALCHAPTERWEREVISITTHISDISTINCTIONBETWEENTHE@OBJECTIVE%MERYAND4RIST ANDTHE@SUBJECTIVE-C#ANNAND3ELSKY3ELSKYETAL NATUREOF CAUSALTEXTUREANDDRAWSOMEIMPLICATIONS4HISISELABORATEDUPONIN#HAPTERS TOOFTHISVOLUME
Coping with turbulence
3OHOWCANANYONERESPONDTOATURBULENTENVIRONMENTANDESCAPEFROMITS NEGATIVEORDAMAGINGEFFECTS%MERYAND4RIST ANDTHEIRFOLLOWERSSUGGESTED ONECOULDNOTDOITALONE3YSTEMSINAlELDTHATISCHARACTERIZEDBYTHETURBULENT CAUSALTEXTURECONDITIONSWOULDHAVETOCOMETOGETHERANDJOINTLYDETERMINE IDENTIFYUNCOVEROREVENCREATEGROUNDSTHATTHEYCOULDSHARETOACTTOGETHER @COMMONGROUND )NOTHERWORDSINAlELDWITHATURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURE DECISIONMAKERSAREADVISEDTOCOLLABORATEINORDERTOIDENTIFYASETOFVALUESTHAT THEYCANINSTITUTIONALIZETOCREATECOMMONGROUND!TALARGE SCALELEVELONECAN ARGUETHATTHISISWHATTHEPROCESSOFCIVILIZATIONHASSUCCESSFULLYDONETHROUGHOUT HISTORY!TA LOWER LEVEL ITENTAILSCREATINGINTER ORGANIZATIONALCOLLABORATIVE @ISLAND ARRANGEMENTS THAT CANKEEP TURBULENCEOUTSIDE EG.ORMANNAND
2AMIREZANDTHEIR@VALUECONSTELLATIONS )N#HAPTER!RVIDSSONSHOWS HOW3WEDISHHEALTHCAREISEXPLORINGHOWITMIGHTBEDONETHEREWHILEIN#HAPTER VANDER(EIJDENPRESENTSFOURSCENARIOSFOR)NDIANAGRICULTURETHATSUGGESTIT MIGHTBETHEPREFERREDFUTUREINTHATlELD )NTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURESATTENTIONMUSTSHIFTFROMUNDERSTANDINGTHE
COMPETITIVEOFTENONE TO ONEGAMESINTHEEXISTINGTRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENT TOUNDERSTANDINGHOWTHEFORCESFROMTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT, MAY SHAPETHETRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTINTHEFUTURE4HISISPRECISELYWHATSCENARIOS DOnTHEYATTENDTOANDWORKTHROUGHPLAUSIBLEPOSSIBILITIESINTHECONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTANDTHECONSEQUENCESFORTHETRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENT)NTHIS SECONDEDITIONWEHAVEADDEDANENTIRELYNEWCHAPTER THATEXPLORESHOWTHIS MIGHTWORKINTHECONTEXTOFTHERECENTlNANCIALCRISIS "UT PRIOR TO CONSTITUTING THESE INTER ORGANIZATIONAL CONSTELLATIONS ONE
MUSTAPPRECIATETHENATUREOFTHETURBULENTCAUSALTEXTUREANDTHENEWKINDS OFBEHAVIOURSTHATITREQUIRES4ODOSOINTHEMULTIPLEINASETOFSCENARIOS RATHERTHANTHESINGULARAFORECASTORREFERENCEPROJECTION HELPSMANAGERSTO ACKNOWLEDGERECOGNIZETHATTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTISBEYONDTHEIRCONTROL ORDIRECTINmUENCE3MITH INPREPARATIONFORCOMINGTOGETHERANDCO CREATINGANISLANDOFCOLLABORATIONTHATCANSHUTOUTTURBULENCEFORALLOFTHEM 4HISSTRATEGYISNOTENTIRELYUNPROBLEMATIC#REATINGNEWLYINSTITUTIONALIZED
RULESANDREGULATIONSMEANSRETURNINGTOHEAD TO HEADCOMPETITIONINTHETYPE )))@DISTURBEDREACTIVECAUSALTEXTURE$OMAINCREATIONTHROUGHSUCCESSFULINTER ORGANIZATIONALCONSTELLATIONSREQUIRESAMODEOFCONVERSATION INWHICHSUCH MULTIPLEPERSPECTIVESAREACKNOWLEDGEDAS LEGITIMATEANDHELPFUL3CENARIOS DO THAT IN A STRATEGIC CONVERSATION VANDER(EIJDEN 7HEN IN THIS PROCESSCOLLABORATIONSURMOUNTSCOMPETITIONTHENSCENARIOSAREEFFECTIVEWHEN COMPETITIONWINSINTHECONVERSATIONSCENARIOSFAILSEE#HAPTERINTHISVOLUME FORADEEPERANALYSISOFTHISASPECTOFSCENARIOWORK 7HETHERCOLLABORATIONISALLTHATISNEEDEDTOSOLVETHE@PROBLEMOFTURBULENCE
ISAMOOTPOINT0RIGOGINESEE#HAPTERINTHISVOLUME SUGGESTSTHATTHEREARE CRITICALPOINTSINTIMECALLEDBIFURCATIONSWHENTHEENTIREFUTUREOFASYSTEM DEPENDSUPONMINORmUCTUATIONSWITHINORWITHOUT)N#HAPTER2OGGEMA ARGUESCONVINCINGLYFROMEXAMPLESINSPATIALPLANNINGTHATATTHESESENSITIVE BIFURCATIONSTHECREATIVITYANDINNOVATIVEDRIVEOFONEINDIVIDUALACTORMAYBE ENOUGHTODETERMINETHESURVIVALORDEMISEOFTHElELDASAWHOLE )NSUMMARY%MERYAND4RIST CONSIDEREDTHATTOSTOPTHESNOWBALLING
EFFECT THATGIVES RISE TO FEEDSAND IS FEDBY TURBULENCE THE SALIENCEOF, RELATIONSHIPS IN THE CONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENTWOULD NEED TO BE REDUCED BY INSTITUTIONALIZINGNEWVALUES4HEIDEAISTHATSHAREDVALUESINTHESEINSTITUTIONS WOULDCREATEANENVIRONMENTOFLESSERUNCERTAINTYTHANTHETYPE)6CAUSALTEXTURE PUSHINGTURBULENCEBACKANDRECREATINGAMORESTABLEGROUNDFORDECISION MAKING ANDINVESTINGINTHEFUTURE(OWEVERATCRITICALBIFURCATIONPOINTSAKEYROLE
CONTINUESTOBEPLAYEDBYCREATIVEANDINNOVATIVEINDIVIDUALSWHOSHOWNEWWAYS OUTOFTHEMESSYANDWICKEDPROBLEMSCAUSEDBYTURBULENCE3CENARIOSAREAKEY METHODTOASSISTINTHISIMAGINATIVEANDCREATIVEPROCESS
3CENARIOSHAVEBEENUSEDINCOMPANIESFOROVERFOURDECADES,ESOURNEAND 3TOFFAESVANDER(EIJDEN ANDEVENLONGERBYMILITARYPLANNERS ANDPOLICY MAKERS"ECAUSEOFTHEIRORIGINSINMILITARYAPPLICATIONSGOINGBACKA LONGWAYTHEREARENOWMULTIPLEMETHODOLOGICALVERSIONSINTHEPUBLICDOMAIN DEPENDINGUPONHOWTHEYDEVELOPEDBOTHCONCEPTUALLYANDINPRACTICE4HEEARLY WORKIN2!.$THAT(ERMAN+AHN MADEFAMOUSALONGWITHTHEWORK AT32)ARECONSIDEREDPIONEERSINTHE!NGLO 3AXONWORLD)NTHE&RANCOPHONE WORLDTHESCHOOLOF,A0ROSPECTIVEDEVELOPEDBY"ERGER ANDFURTHEREDIN THENATIONALPLANNINGWORKOFTHE&RENCH$ELEGATIONFOR2EGIONAL!CTIONAND 3PACE0LANNING$!4!2 THE@FUTURIBLESMOVEMENTANDJOURNALFROM@FUTURS POSSIBLES THE@COMIT£SDELAPROSPECTIVETHATWEREFORMEDINPUBLICCOMPANIES SUCHAS%$&AND&RANCE4£LECOM,ESSOURNEAND3TOFFAES ANDTHEWORK OF-ICHEL'ODETANDHISCOLLEAGUESSHAPEDAWHOLECOMMUNITYOFPRACTICE !NIMPORTANTMILESTONEWASTHEINTRODUCTIONOFSCENARIOSAT2OYAL$UTCH3HELL
BY0IERRE7ACKYEARSAGO!LTHOUGHA&RENCHMAN0IERRE7ACKWASINmUENCED MOREBY'URDJIEFF S PHILOSOPHYHIGHLIGHTINGTHEESSENCEOF@SEEINGANEW RATHERTHANBYTHEHIGHLYTECHNICALANDQUANTIlEDMETHODSOFTHE&RENCHSCENARIO SCHOOL(EWASFOLLOWEDIN3HELLBY0ETER3CHWARTZWHOCAMEFROMTHE32) PRACTICEHAVINGWRITTENEARLYSCENARIOBOOKSSUCHAS3EVEN4OMORROWS4OWARDA 6OLUNTARY(ISTORY WITH0AUL(AWKENAND*AMES/GILVY4HE@3HELL3CHOOL BECAMEAPRIVATESECTORBENCHMARKNOTONLYBECAUSEOFTHEROLETHATSCENARIOS HADINHELPINGTHECOMPANYTOADDRESSTHElRSTOILSHOCK3CHWARTZVAN DER(EIJDEN BUTALSOBECAUSEITBECAMEANINTERWOVENPRACTICEACROSSTHE COMPANYTHATHASNOTBEENREPLICATEDELSEWHERETOTHESAMEDEGREE4HE'LOBAL "USINESS.ETWORK'". ORGANIZATIONFOUNDEDBY3CHWARTZTOGETHERWITHVAN DER(EIJDEN/GILVY#OLLYNSANDOTHERSWHENHELEFT3HELLCONTINUEDMOREIN THE32)TRADITIONTHANTHE3HELLONEJUSTASTHEWORKOF'ODETANDHISCOLLEAGUES CARRIEDONWITHTHE&RENCHTRADITIONINAWAYTHATPAIDLESSATTENTIONTOTHE53 CONTRIBUTIONTHAN3HELLDID "ECAUSEOFTHELEGACYOF0IERRE7ACKANDTHE3HELLSCHOOLTHECOREOFNON
MILITARYSCENARIOWORKHASMOVEDFROM(ERMAN+AHNSFAMOUSDICTUM@TOTHINK THEUNTHINKABLEINTHECONTEXTOFAPOSSIBLENUCLEARWAR TOFOCUSINGONSEEING ANEWREALITYBYIDENTIFYINGTHEDRIVINGFORCESINTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTTHAT DETERMINEPLAUSIBLEFUTURETRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENTSSEE#HAPTERINTHIS VOLUME
4HEBEST SELLINGBOOKBYVANDER(EIJDENP EXPLAINSSCENARIOWORK INWAYSTHATBUILDON%MERYAND4RISTS UNDERSTANDINGOFTRANSACTIONAL ANDCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTS3CENARIOSARECONSIDEREDTOBEMETHODSTOASSESS THECAUSALTEXTUREBYCONSIDERINGHOW,FORCESINTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENT INTERACTSYSTEMICALLYTOAFFECTASETOFTRANSACTIONALENVIRONMENT,AND, POSSIBILITIES4HIS ISTHEMETHODOLOGICAL FORMOFSCENARIOWORKTOWHICHTHE CHAPTERSINTHISBOOKREFER !SWENOTEDIN#HAPTERTHEUSEOFSCENARIOSINCORPORATEPLANNINGHAS
INCREASEDSUBSTANTIALLYSINCETHEEVENTSOF3EPTEMBER7EBELIEVETHATTHIS BOOKISTHElRSTPUBLICATIONTOPROPOSEACLEARLYARTICULATEDEXPLICITANDDEFENSIBLE REASONFORTHIS4HISISTHATDECISION MAKERSAREINCREASINGLYSEEINGTURBULENCEAS PARTANDPARCELOFTHEWORLDINWHICHTHEYLIVEMEANINGTHATTHEYCANNOTANY LONGERCOUNTONASTABLEFOUNDATIONFORTHEIRACTIVITIES!LONGANDGROWINGLIST OFLARGEANDUNANTICIPATEDEVENTSCRISESWARSANDOTHER@SURPRISESDISCUSSED IN#HAPTERDRIVESHOMETHEMESSAGETHATTHISISNOTSOMUCHAPROBLEMOF INSUFlCIENTANALYSISANDORRESEARCHORLACKOFDATAORINFORMATIONBUTOFTHE lELDITSELFHAVINGBECOMETURBULENTANDUNCERTAINREQUIRINGAFUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENTRESPONSE
7EHAVEPUTTOGETHERTHISBOOKTOEXPLAININASCHOLARLYANDPRACTICALMANNERHOW CAUSALTEXTURETHEORYHELPSDECISION MAKERSTOUNDERSTANDlRSTHOWSCENARIO ANALYSESHELPADDRESSTURBULENTENVIRONMENTSANDSECONDWHYSCENARIOANALYSIS ISINCREASINGASACONSEQUENCE5NDERSTANDINGHOWSCENARIOSADDRESSTURBULENCE HASMETHODOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS INTHAT ITCLARIlESTHEPURPOSEOFDEPLOYING SCENARIOSANDTHERESULTSONEMAYEXPECTFROMDOINGSO $URINGTHESITWASCUSTOMARYTOSAYTHATSCIENTISTSKNEWTHATBUMBLEBEES
mEWBUTTHATTHEYDIDNOTKNOWHOW-AGNAN OBSERVEDTHATTHETHEN KNOWN LAWSOFAERODYNAMICSCOULDNOTEXPLAINTHEIRABILITYTOmYDESPITETHEOBVIOUSFACT THATTHEYDID(EPOSTULATEDTHATNEWANDUNCONVENTIONALAERODYNAMICLAWSMUST BEINVOLVED3OMEYEARSLATERSCIENTISTSCANNOWEXPLAINTHESELAWSINDETAIL
4HUSWHILEBUMBLEBEESOBVIOUSLYmEW IT TOOK SOME TIME FOR SCIENTISTS TO UNDERSTANDWHY)NSOMEWAYSCENARIOWORKATTHEBEGINNINGOFTHESTCENTURY ISINTHESAMESITUATIONnITmIESBUTWEHAVELESSTHANROBUSTTHEORIESASTOWHY
)NSHORTTHECOREARGUMENTOFTHISBOOKISTHATASlELDSTAKEONTHECHARACTERISTICS OFATURBULENTENVIRONMENTCAUSALTEXTURETHEUSEOFMETHODSSUCHASSCENARIOS TOADDRESSTURBULENCEISBOUNDTORISE7EARGUETHATSCENARIOMETHODSWOULD NOTBE RELEVANT INOTHER THAN TYPE)6CAUSAL TEXTURECONDITIONSBECAUSE THE CONTEXTUALCOMPLEXITYDESCRIBEDBYTHE,RELATIONSHIPSISNOTSOSALIENTINSUCH ENVIRONMENTSANDSOSCENARIOSARENOTNEEDEDTOADDRESSIT7EHAVEIDENTIlED TWOMAINWAYSWHEREBYSCENARIOMETHODSHELPINCOPINGWITHTURBULENCE&IRST THEYHELPSTAKEHOLDERSTODEVELOPABETTERSYSTEMICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHECAUSAL TEXTUREOFTHECONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTANDTHESALIENT,RELATIONSHIPS7ITH SCENARIOSPEOPLERESPONSIBLEFORTHEIRORGANIZATIONSSURVIVALGAINNEWINSIGHTS ANDCLEARERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHESERELATIONSHIPSINTHEENVIRONMENTLEADINGTO AGROWINGAWARENESSOFPREDETERMINEDELEMENTSREDUCEDUNCERTAINTYANDBETTER INSIGHTSONHOWTHEREMAININGUNCERTAINTIESMAYPLAYOUT3ECONDSCENARIO METHODSHELPINBUILDINGCOMMONGROUNDAMONGDISPARATESTAKEHOLDERSBECAUSE THEYPROVIDESPACEFORMULTIPLEINTERPRETATIONSOFTHESITUATIONLEADINGACTORS TOUNDERSTANDEACHOTHERSPERSPECTIVEONHOWTHElELDTHEYHOLDINCOMMON MAYPLAYOUTUNDERDIFFERENTPLAUSIBLECONDITIONS4HISHELPSCREATETHECOMMON GROUNDTHATSHUTSTURBULENCEOUT )NTHECHAPTERSTHATFOLLOWTHEAUTHORSmESHOUTTHESETWOKEYLINKAGESIN
AVARIETYOFWAYSANDCONTEXTS
