ABSTRACT
SURROUNDTODAYS7ESTERNECONOMIESISCALLEDFOR'OVERNANCEMUSTATTENDTO SYSTEMIClELD LEVELISSUESMOREBROADLYINSTEADOFFOCUSINGONAPPARENTLYSTABLE ANDCONTROLLABLESUB SYSTEMS-YRESEARCHSUGGESTSTHATUNDERSTANDINGCAUSAL TEXTURESINTURBULENTlELDSAPPEARSTOBECRUCIALINDESIGNINGMOREEFFECTIVEPOLITICAL GOVERNANCE4HESEARGUMENTSARECONSISTENTWITH%MERYAND4RISTS CAUSAL TEXTURES THEORYWHICH SUGGESTS THAT SECOND ORDERUNINTENDEDCONSEQUENCES CREATINGTURBULENTENVIRONMENTALCAUSALTEXTURESEMERGEFROM@NORMALDECISION MAKINGANDACTING
)ARGUEINTHISCHAPTERTHATTURBULENCECALLSFORADIFFERENTFORMOFGOVERNANCE ANDTHATASPROPOSEDBY%MERYAND4RIST WITHOUTCHANGESINTHEVALUES DRIVINGHUMANACTIVITIESTHECONSEQUENCESOFREGULATIVEACTSWILLLEADENVIRONMENTS TOBECOMEEVENMORETURBULENT)FMEMBERSOFAlELDAREABLEANDWILLINGTOADAPT TOCHANGINGCONDITIONSBYRECALIBRATINGTRANSFORMINGOREVENREPLACINGTHEIR VALUESTURBULENCEWILLBEADDRESSEDANDMAYDISAPPEAR)FNOTTHElELDMAY PARTITIONITSELFINTOSMALLENCLAVESWHERESOMEAREABLETOADAPTWHILEOTHERSARE NOTWHICHMEANSTHATTURBULENCEISADDRESSEDONLYBYTHELUCKYFEW-C#ANN AND3ELSKY -YILLUSTRATIVECASEnTHEHEALTHCARElELDINA3WEDISHREGIONnWASINATURBULENT
CAUSALTEXTUREATTHEENDOFTHESASPOLITICALGOVERNANCEHADMADEADAPTATION TOAHIGHLYUNCERTAINCONTEXTUALENVIRONMENTIMPOSSIBLE)SHOWHOWTHISLEDTHE lELDTOFACETHERISKOFREACHINGHYPER TURBULENCEWHEREORGANIZATIONALFAILURE INCREASESRAPIDLYRENDERINGTURBULENCEENDEMIC-C#ANNAND3ELSKY -YMAINCONTRIBUTIONISTOILLUSTRATEANDPROPOSEANALTERNATIVEANDINMANY WAYSFORTHATlELD NEWCONCEPTIONOFHOWGOVERNANCEDESIGNCANBELINKEDTO POLICY MAKINGINORDERTOMOREEFFECTIVELYADDRESSTURBULENTENVIRONMENTS !FTERHAVINGINTRODUCEDTHEBACKGROUNDTOMYAPPROACHINTHEPREAMBLETHIS
CHAPTEREXPLORESTHEIDEASONGOVERNANCEDESIGNPRESENTEDABOVEINTHREESTEPS
&IRST)ARGUETHATTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURESMAKEITCRITICALTOBRINGASYSTEMIC MODELOFGOVERNANCETOTHEPOLICY MAKINGTABLEANDTOINVITESTAKEHOLDERS TOBECOMEINVOLVEDINREGULATORYAFFAIRSAROUNDTHATTABLE-YCASESHOWS THEBENElTSWHENACTORSAREENGAGEDASMORETHANJUSTVOTERSINDEMOCRATIC SYSTEMS)ARGUEINSTEADTHATSTAKEHOLDERSFULLYINVOLVEDINTHEEARLYSTAGESOF GOVERNANCEDIALOGUESLEADINGTONEWPOLICIESRULESANDLAWSISANEFFECTIVE WAYOFADDRESSINGTURBULENCE4HISHASTODONOTONLYWITHEFFECTIVENESS BUTALSOWITHFAIRNESSSEE#HAPTERINTHISVOLUME 4HESETTINGOFTHE GOVERNANCEMODELINTHISWAYISANECESSARYBUTINSUFlCIENTSTEPTOADDRESS TURBULENTCONDITIONS
.EXT)ARGUETHATGOVERNANCEDESIGNSRELYINGONAFUTUREORIENTATIONAREMORE CAPABLEOFADDRESSINGTURBULENCETHANGOVERNANCEDESIGNSUSINGCASE BASED HISTORICEXPERIENCESANDCURRENTCONVICTIONS4HISSETSAMOREINCLUSIVETHAN EXCLUSIVETONEFORATTRACTINGTHEMULTI STAKEHOLDERFORMATNEEDEDTOENHANCE FUTUREEFFECTIVENESS
4HEN)ILLUSTRATEASPECTSOFTHIS@NEW GOVERNANCEDESIGNTHATUSESENVIRON MENTALSCANNINGLINKEDTOTHECREATIONOFFUTUREIMAGESOFANIDEALHEALTHCARE SYSTEMTHATRESPONDSTOPLAUSIBLEFUTURECONTEXTUALCONDITIONSELICITEDTHROUGH SCENARIOSnTHEIDEALIZEDDESIGN!CKOFF nINTHEMOSTSOUTHERNREGION OF3WEDEN
!STHISBOOKEMPHASIZES TWOIMPORTANTTOOLSEMERGEDDURINGTHESTO EXPANDMANAGEMENTKNOWLEDGE4HElRSTSEEINGHOWINTURBULENTCAUSALTEXTURES THEENVIRONMENTBECOMESANACTORINITITSOWNRIGHTWASAWAYOFINCLUDINGWHAT HADBEENPREVIOUSLYEXCLUDED4HESECONDSCENARIOFORMATIONWASAMEANSOF NEGOTIATINGWITHFUTUREENVIRONMENTS"OTHADVANCEDTHEMEANSOFDEALINGWITH UNCERTAINCHANGE&RED%MERYAND%RIC4RISTARTICULATEDTHECLEARESTMODELOFTHE lRST%MERYAND4RIST WHILE7ACKAB 3CHWARTZ AND VANDER(EIJDEN SUCCESSFULLYDEVELOPEDANDAPPLIEDTHESECOND 4HElRSTCONCEPTUALIZEDWHATHADNOTPREVIOUSLYBEENSEENWHILETHESECOND CLARIlEDHOWITSROLEINTHEFUTUREWOULDHELPTHEPRESENT"OTHWEREINSTRUMENTS FORNEGOTIATINGWITHFUTUREREALITIESINTHEPRESENT%ACHWASTYPICALLYUSEDALONE WHICHMAYBEWHYBOTHFELLSHORTINDELIVERINGONTHEIRPROMISES )THINKTHATJOININGTHEMTOGETHERASTHISBOOKDOESGIVESTHECAUSALTEXTURE
CONCEPTUALIZATIONAPRACTICALIMPLICATIONANDMAKESTHEPRACTICEOFFUTUREANALYSIS MORECONCEPTUALLYRIGOROUSANDROBUST4OACHIEVETHISINMYCHAPTER)DESCRIBE ILLUSTRATEANDDISCUSSHOWASCENARIO BASEDMETHODOLOGYLEADINGTOANIDEALIZED DESIGNOFAFUTUREREGIONALHEALTHCARElELDWASUSEDTODEBATEANALYSEANDIMPROVE THECURRENTlELDWHENFACINGTHERISKSOFBECOMINGHYPER TURBULENT)NTERESTINGLY SOMEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANTMANIFESTATIONSOFTHECHANGEDSYSTEMWEREMANIFESTED INNEWVALUESANDSTANDPOINTSREGARDINGCRITICALCOMPONENTSTHATSHAPEDBEHAVIOUR 4HENEWVALUESENABLEDTHESYSTEMTOTACKLEHYPER TURBULENCE 3CENARIOSANDSCANNINGFORTURBULENTUNCERTAINTIESCANBEDESCRIBEDASAMEANS
OFACCOMPLISHINGTWODISTINCTYETCOMPLEMENTARYAGENDASINSYSTEMGOVERNANCE &IRSTTHEYACTTOINVOLVETHEPEOPLEWHOARETOCHANGETHEIRBEHAVIOURTHUS REALIZINGTHEINTENTIONOFTRANSFORMATIONINTHESTRATEGY MAKINGLEARNINGPROCESS 4HISNOTONLYIMPROVESTHECHANCEOFACHIEVINGTHEINTENTBUTALSOENGAGESTHE KNOWLEDGEEXPERIENCEANDINTERESTSOFTHESEINDIVIDUALSnENRICHINGTHEQUALITY OFTHEOUTPUT3ECONDTHEYSTRETCHINTOANDPROBEFUTUREDEVELOPMENTSTHATARE UNKNOWNBUTSEEMAMBIGUOUSLYKNOWABLETHEREBYAVOIDINGMYOPICLEARNING ,EVINTHALAND-ARCH !VERYINTRIGUINGASPECTOFTHECAUSALTEXTUREVIEWOFENVIRONMENTALSENSING
WHICH)RELYONHEREISTHATITADDRESSESTHERISKOFMYOPICLEARNINGBYCAPTURING lELD DRIVINGFORCESTHATWEREINITIATEDBYOURPASTACTIONSSEE#HAPTERINTHIS VOLUME /THERAPPROACHESTOENHANCINGTHETHINKINGABOUTTHEFUTUREnSUCH ASTHE$ELPHIMETHODDIALECTICREASONINGANDFORECASTINGnHAVENOTPROVEN TOBEASSTRONGINTHISREGARDSINCETHEYFOCUSMUCHLESSONUSINGDIFFERENCES OFOPINIONONTHEFUTURETOBETTERUNDERSTANDTHEPRESENT)THEREFOREWANTTO STRESSTHEBENElTSOFUSINGFUTUREANALYSISBASEDONCONTEXTUALANALYSISENGAGINGA MULTITUDEOFSTAKEHOLDERS)TSMAINADVANTAGESLIEINITSABILITYTOIDENTIFYSTRATEGIC ISSUESSYSTEMATICALLYITSBROADAPPROACHTOPROBLEM SCOPINGASWELLASITSFOCUS
ONEXPLORINGUNCERTAINTY3CHOEMAKER 4HEIDEALIZEDDESIGNEXEMPLIlED BYSCENARIOSINTHEHEALTHCARECASEPRESENTEDINTHISCHAPTERTRANSPIREDASARESULT OFAPPRECIATINGTHEIMPORTANCEOFSIGNALSFROMTHEFUTURE ) FIND THAT THIS APPROACH CAN REINSTATE A FIELDS LOST ABILITY TO ADAPT TO
TURBULENCEANDTHEREBYAVOIDHYPER TURBULENCESINCEITPROVIDESARESPONSETO POLITICALGOVERNANCETHATAVOIDSKEYTRAPSINGROUPPROCESSESSUCHASTHERISKS OFANALYTICALBLINDSPOTSANDMYOPICTHINKINGFRAMES3CHOEMAKER 4HE APPROACHSTRIVESTOFRAMEPOLITICALGOVERNANCEOPERATIONSWITHAFOCUSONTHE LONG TERMEFFECTIVENESSOFTHEGOVERNEDSYSTEMITSELFANDDOESSOBYREALIZING CHANGEOFSUPPORTINGVALUES
4HEPRACTICEOFGOVERNANCEMANIFESTEDINPOLICIESANDREGULATIONSHASGONEFROM ITSORIGINSASASOCIETALSAFETYNETDURINGTHELATETHCENTURY%WALD TOBECOMINGALESS THAN IDEALARENAFORSTIMULATINGBEHAVIOURALCHANGEINOUR SOCIETIES4HORNGATE ,AWSWIDELYDEBATEDANDNARROWLYPASSEDALLTOO OFTENENDUPWITHUNINTENDEDRESULTSTHATFAILTOBESEENASSOCIALLYLEGITIMATE 'ANGL 4HISISLARGELYDUETOHOWTHELARGERlELDINWHICHREGULATIONIS EMBEDDEDINCLUDINGTHEDOMAINOFGOVERNANCECONTINUESTOBEDEEPLYSHAKEN BYUNEXPECTEDCONTEXTUALEVENTS(UMANAFFAIRSCANBEARGUEDTOHAVEMOVED BEYONDTHEDREAMSOF'REEKCAUSALITY!NDTHEDEPENDABLEHIERARCHYOFCHAINSOF COMMANDHASBECOMESUSPECTBYNON GOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONS.'/S AS WELLASBYYOUNGERGENERATIONSINMANYSOCIETIES0ARADOXICALLYINDIVIDUALSNOW HAVEPOWERSNEVERSEENBEFOREINHUMANHISTORYDUETOHIGHEREDUCATIONAND ACCESSTOGLOBALINFORMATIONASWELLASGLOBALMEDIASPACE !S REGIONAL INTEGRATION ANDGLOBALIZATIONGROW LAWS FORMULATEDBY AND
EMANATINGFROMNATIONSTATESNOLONGERALLOWFORGOVERNANCEOF ISSUESTOBE BOUNDEDBYA SINGLENATIONSOR REGIONS INTERESTS%NVIRONMENTALPOLLUTION RESOURCEMANAGEMENTINTHEENERGYlELDANDLABOURMARKETREGULATIONASWELL ASHEALTHCARESYSTEMNEEDSREQUIREPOLITICALGOVERNANCETHATACKNOWLEDGESSUPRA NATIONALINTERESTSANDORGANICCHANGE/NAGENERALLEVELPOLICY MAKINGISTODAY OFTENSTRETCHEDTOTHEPOINTWHERETHEBENElTSOFCENTRALCONTROLnPREDICTABILITY ANDACCOUNTABILITYnDONOTEXCEEDTHECOSTSOFLITTLEORINCORRECTINFORMATIONOR OFSOCIETALRESISTANCETOACCEPTTHEIMPLICATIONSOFPOLICIES-C#AFFREYETAL 4HEREISTHUSPOTENTIALVALUEINMOREPARTICIPATIVEAPPROACHESTOPOLICY MAKING INTURBULENTENVIRONMENTSnSOMETIMESALSOSPANNINGNATIONALANDINDUSTRY DElNITIONS)NOURCASE THISMEANSTHATTHEPROJECTDElNEDTHEPARTICIPANTS NOTBYTHEIRINDUSTRIALLINKSnEGPHARMACEUTICALINDUSTRYBIOTECHORAPUBLIC MUNICIPALITYnBUTRATHERFROMTHEFACTTHATTHEYINSOMEWAYCONTRIBUTEDTO CREATINGBETTERHEALTHFORLOCALCITIZENS
)UNDERSTANDTHATPOLICY MAKERSHAVEARESPONSIBILITYTOCREATEEFFECTIVEPOLICIES WHICHGOVERNSOCIALBEHAVIOURINADESIREDDIRECTION3OMEBEHAVIOURSANDACTIONS SHOULDBESTIMULATEDWHILEOTHERSARETOBEAVOIDED)NORDERTOACHIEVETHISTHE POLICYANALYSTMAYTAKEDIFFERENTANDCOMPLEMENTARYSTANCES4HORNGATE SUGGESTEDAMOSTCHERISHEDSTANCEISTHATOFTHEPOLICYANALYSTASNEUTRALAND RATIONALPROVIDINGINSIGHTFULANALYSESANDPOLICYRECOMMENDATIONSBASEDON RELIABLEANDVALIDINFORMATION!SECONDPOSSIBLESTANCEISFORPOLICY MAKERSTO TAKEONTHEROLEOFADOCTORPRESCRIBINGHOWPOLICYSHOULDBEFORMULATEDAND IMPLEMENTED3UCHPOLICY MAKINGACTSMOREASDECISION MAKINGTHANASPROVIDING INFORMATIONTOBEUSEDWHENFORMULATINGDECISIONS4HORNGATES THIRD STANCEISTHATPOLICY MAKERSMAYINSTEADCHOOSETOACTASMERCENARIESGUIDEDBY AHIGHERVISIONORUNDERSTANDINGWHERETHEIRMAINRESPONSIBILITYISTOCONVINCE OTHERSTOFOLLOWAGIVENPATHORIDEAL4HISTHIRDSTANCEISPARTICULARLYFREQUENT WHENPOLICY MAKERSHAVEAVESTEDINTERESTINTHEMATTERATHAND*ENKINS 3MITH AND7EIMER0ETTIGREW-AAK 4HEULTIMATEOBJECTIVEFOR ALLTHREESTANCESHOWEVERISTOIMPROVEPOLICYWHERETHEBESTWAYTOMEASURE THESUCCESSOFPOLICYANALYSISISAFUNCTIONOFHOWMUCHATTITUDESINSOCIETYARE FORMEDORCHANGED3ABATIERAND*ENKINS 3MITH 4OFURTHERADISCUSSION OFEFFECTIVEPOLITICALGOVERNANCE)PROPOSEAWAYOFCOMBININGTHESETHREESTANCES ANDTHEREBYPROPOSEAFOURTH 7HICHEVERSTANCEANALYSTSTAKEISCONDITIONEDBYTHEFACTTHATPOLICYANALYSTS
ANDPOLICY MAKERSTHINKANDBEHAVELIKEMOSTPEOPLEnANDARESUBJECTTOTHE SAMESOCIALANDPSYCHOLOGICALLIMITATIONS4HORNGATE !NALYSTSTOOARE NOTPERFECTLYRATIONALNORFREEFROMBIASES4HEIRMOTIVESMAYSHIFTDURINGTHE ANALYTICPROCESSANDMAYINCLUDEPERSONALAMBITIONSASWELLASOFlCIALOBJECTIVES 4HEYMAYBEINmUENCEDBYSOCIALPRESSURESTOCONFORMTOWHATTHEYBELIEVEOTHERS WANT-ILGRAM ESPECIALLYWHENINFORMATIONABOUTTHESUBJECTMATTERAT HANDISSCARCE&ESTINGER !NALYSTSANDDECISION MAKERSAREOFTENTREATEDAS ANELITEGROUPINSOCIETYWHICHUNDERPINSTHEIRPERCEPTIONOFTHEMSELVESASASMALL ANDPRIVILEGEDGROUPINCREASINGTHEPROBABILITYOFHARMFULGROUPTHINK*ANIS /THERSOCIALFACTORSSUCHASPERSUASIONANDFATIGUEMAYALSOIMPACTUPON POLICYFORMULATION@3OCIALPSYCHOLOGYPERSPECTIVESONPOLICY MAKINGLEADTOTHE CONCLUSIONTHATPOLICYANALYSESUSUALLYFORMAVERYSMALLPARTOFPOLICY MAKING PROCESSES)TMAYBETHEMOSTRATIONALPART"UTSOCIALANDPSYCHOLOGICALFACTORS STILLSEEMTOPLAYAFARMOREDOMINANTROLEINPOLICY MAKING4HORNGATE P &ROMAVAILABLERESEARCH)CANTHUSCONCLUDETHATGOVERNANCEWILLTENDTO BECOMEMOREBIASEDBYSINGLELOBBYISTGROUPSINTERESTSANDINDIVIDUALPREFERENCES IFTHEINFORMATION SEEKINGANDDECISION MAKINGPROCESSESUSEDEXCLUDEIMPORTANT STAKEHOLDERS)NTHECASEOFHEALTHCAREITMAYBEPHARMACEUTICALCOMPANIESTHAT PERFORMSUCHAROLE3OLOGICALLY)BELIEVEINTHEFOURTHSTANCEONGOVERNANCE WHEREPOLICYANALYSTSANDDECISION MAKERSACTASDESIGNERSPROVIDERSANDOPERATORS OFAGOVERNANCESYSTEMORPROCESS)TISTHISFOURTHSTANCETHAT)ELABORATEUPON INTHISCHAPTER
7HENTHOSEWHOARETOBEGOVERNEDBYPOLICIESAREEXCLUDEDFROMTHEGOVERNANCE MAKINGPROCESSADHERENCETOITSOUTCOMEISPROBLEMATIC-VUNGIETAL 6IDEIRAETAL3TEYAERTETAL &OREXAMPLEINASTUDYOFCOMMERCIAL lSHERMENS RESPONSES TOCHANGES INlSHERIESPOLICIES ITWAS FOUNDTHATHOW PERCEPTIONSOFPOLICY MAKINGPROCESSESAREMANAGEDISANIMPORTANTFACTORIN EXPLAININGRESILIENCETOCHANGE3OCIALRESILIENCEWASIMPROVED-ARSHALL IF
s SOCIALKNOWLEDGEWASCO PRODUCEDTHROUGHINVOLVEMENT INTHEDECISION MAKINGPROCESS
s ASENSEOFEQUITYORFAIRNESSSEE#HAPTERINTHISVOLUME WASSECUREDAND IF
s ANABILITYTOINmUENCETHESPEEDOFIMPLEMENTATIONWASACKNOWLEDGEDINTHE FORMATIONOFPOLICIES-ARSHALL
4HEIMPORTANCEOFPROCEDURALJUSTICEFORESTABLISHINGLAW MAKINGLEGITIMACYWAS ALSOFOUNDBY'ANGL INASTUDYOF53#ONGRESSLAW MAKING4HESESTUDIES INDICATETHEIMPORTANCEOFSTAKEHOLDERENGAGEMENTWHENREALIZINGTHEINTENDED OBJECTIVESFROMPOLICY MAKINGINANUMBEROFDIFFERENTlELDSnARGUABLYALSOIN THElELDOFHEALTHCAREWHICHWEDISCUSSINDEPTHLATER )NADDITIONlNALOUTCOMESAREIMPROVEDBYSTAKEHOLDERENGAGEMENT)NA
STUDYOFASTAKEHOLDERAPPROACHTOPOLICY MAKINGFORWATERSHEDMANAGEMENT ,EACHETAL FOUNDTHATTHEOPENANDCOLLABORATIVEPROCESSHADSIGNIlCANT EFFECTSONTHElNALOUTCOMEPARTICULARLYINADDRESSINGPROBLEMSONALOCALOR REGIONAL SCALE SUCHASWHICHPROJECTSWILLBEPURSUEDANDHOWTHEYWILLBE MONITORED!STHEYPUTIT@PARTNERSHIPSAPPARENTLYHAVETHEMOSTPOSITIVEEFFECT ONTHEMOSTSERIOUSPROBLEMSINTHEWATERSHEDWHICHSUGGESTSTHATPARTNERSHIPS DEVOTEMOREEFFORTSTOSERIOUSPROBLEMS,EACHETALP )TWASSHOWN THATPARTNERSHIPSANDTHECOLLABORATIVEPROCESSHELPEDPOLITICALGOVERNANCEIN TERMSOFSOLVINGIMMINENTPROBLEMSINTHEREGIONALCONTEXT4HESERESULTSWERE STRONGERTHELONGERTHEPARTNERSHIPSHADEXISTED 4HEIMPORTANCEOFSTAKEHOLDERINVOLVEMENTANDSOCIETALDEVELOPMENTISALSO
MANIFESTEDTHROUGHTHEDEPLOYMENTANDREINFORCEMENTOFSOCIALCAPITAL0UTNAM 7HENACTORSMEETANDWORKTOGETHERTHEYDEVELOPRELATIONSHIPSTHAT BUILDSOCIALCAPITALWHICHSTIMULATESTHECREATIONOFNEWKNOWLEDGE.AHAPIET AND'HOSHAL 4HISDOESNOTHAPPENBYITSELF)TREQUIRESDESIGNINGFOR INSTITUTIONALANDLEADERSHIPINVOLVEMENTnTHETYPEOFGOVERNANCETHATTHEFOURTH TYPE)MENTIONEDABOVEENTAILS2ESPONSIBLELEADERSHIPIEFOCUSINGONRELATIONS ANDMORALE INAGLOBALSTAKEHOLDERSOCIETYHELPSTOCREATESOCIALCAPITALAMONG
STAKEHOLDERS-AAK nWHICHRETRO FEEDSBACKINTOTHEMOREEFFECTIVEPOLICY MAKINGLOOPANDPRODUCESBETTERGOVERNANCE0UTNAM 4HEENGAGEMENT BYSTAKEHOLDERSINPOLITICALGOVERNANCECONSEQUENTLYNOTONLYIMPROVESACCESSTO INFORMATIONBUTALSOCREATESASOCIALPLATFORMFORFUTURELEARNING (OWEVERSTAKEHOLDERPARTICIPATIONPERSEDOESNOTADDRESSTURBULENCE)ARGUE
THATITISMOREIMPORTANTTHATPARTICIPATIONRESTSUPONACTIVEENGAGEMENTWHICH MOBILIZESTHESTAKEHOLDERSCAPABILITIESANDINTERESTSTOCO PRODUCEKNOWLEDGE 4HISCO PRODUCTIONOFKNOWLEDGEHASMADEAREALDIFFERENCEINNATURALRESOURCE MANAGEMENT3TEYAERTETAL ASWELLASINIRRIGATIONAGRICULTURE-VUNGIET AL 4HEIMPORTANCEOFEFFECTIVEKNOWLEDGECO PRODUCTIONDESIGNWASALSO SEENINASTUDYOFSTAKEHOLDERPARTICIPATIONINTHEREFORMOF%UROPEANWATERPOLICY 6IDEIRAETAL 7HILEKNOWLEDGECO PRODUCTIONWASIMPORTANTINALLOFTHESE CASESMANYPOTENTIALLYIMPORTANTSTAKEHOLDERSWERENOTINVOLVED)TWASPRIMARILY REPRESENTATIVESOFTHESTATEORLOCALAUTHORITIESASWELLAS.'/SWHOPARTICIPATED ANDTHEISSUESDISCUSSEDWERELARGELYOFATECHNICALNATURE-OREOVERTHEACTUAL PROCESSESUSEDTOCREATEPARTICIPATIONIEPUBLICHEARINGSANDPUBLICCOMMENTS WEREFOUNDTOBEINADEQUATEASTHEYPRIMARILYAIMEDTOCONFORMTOTHE%UROPEAN 5NIONS%5S PARTICIPATORYPRINCIPLEBUTDIDNOTALLOWACTIVEENGAGEMENTOF CONCERNEDSTAKEHOLDERS6IDEIRAETAL 4HUSIFSTAKEHOLDERINVOLVEMENTIS TOBEEFFECTIVEINTERMSOFINmUENCINGlNALPOLICY MAKINGDISTANCEDPARTICIPATION BYONLYAFEWACTORSISNOTENOUGH4HEPROCESSANDAMBITIONSOFBROADERAND DEEPERPARTICIPATIONASWELLASTHETYPESOFPARTICIPANTSAREOFVITALIMPORTANCE nESPECIALLYINTURBULENTlELDS!SOCIO ECOLOGICALGOVERNANCEAPPROACHTO53 HEALTHCAREBASEDONAlELD FOCUSEDHOLISTICANDCOLLABORATIVEAPPROACHPROVED TOBEANIMPORTANTWAYOFMANAGINGHYPER TURBULENCE3ELSKYETAL !S POINTEDOUTBY"EIERLEAND#AYFORD THECHOICEORDESIGNOFPOLICY MAKING METHODOLOGYMAYCREATEPOSITIVESIDE EFFECTSINTERMSOFSTRONGSOCIALCAPITALAND IMPROVEDOPPORTUNITIESFOREFFECTIVEPARTNERSHIPSINFUTUREPOLICY MAKING4AVITS FOUNDTHATSOCIALCAPITALINCREASESTHELEVELOFPOLITICALSOPHISTICATIONAND FACILITATESCOOPERATIONWITHINSOCIETYHELPINGPEOPLETOVOICETHEIRPOLICYDEMANDS BETTERTHUSIMPROVINGPOLITICALGOVERNANCEINTURBULENTSITUATIONS 3TAKEHOLDERENGAGEMENTINPOLICYANALYSISANDDECISION MAKINGADDSMORE
PERSPECTIVESINGOVERNANCE MAKINGPROCESSES!NEARLIERWIDERANDMOREACTIVE ENGAGEMENTOFSTAKEHOLDERSPROVIDESMOREINFORMATIONANDREDUCESTHERISKOF SINGLE ACTORBIASES9ETTHERISKREMAINSTHATPOLICY MAKINGWHICHINCLUDESMORE INTERESTSWILLTURNINTOAPOLITICALPOWERSTRUGGLEWHERETHEVESTEDINTERESTSOFEACH PARTYINVOLVEDMAYLEADTOFORMINGCOALITIONSANDTOASTRONGLYPOLITICIZEDPROCESS 4HISISWHERETHEREISANOBVIOUSNEEDFORDESIGNINGGOVERNANCEMECHANISMSTHAT CANOPENLYCHALLENGEPOWERFULINTERESTSnFORINSTANCEPHARMACEUTICALCOMPANIES ORPOLITICALACTORSnOVERTHELONGRUNSEEFOREXAMPLE0ETTIGREW 4OAVOID SUCHPOLITICIZEDRISKS)ARGUETHATDESIGNINGFORTHEINCLUSIONOFMORESTAKEHOLDER GROUPSWITHDIVERSEINTERESTSENGAGEDASACTIVECO PRODUCERSOFTHEGOVERNANCE
STRUCTUREANDPROCESSESINGOVERNANCEGUIDEDBYTHEFUTURECONTRIBUTESMORE EFFECTIVELYTOTACKLINGTURBULENCE
3CENARIOSCREATEAPROCESSTHATISCONDUCTEDBYANALYSISANDSHAREDUNDERSTANDING OFCONTEXTUALFACTORANALYSES3CHOEMAKER !BASICPRINCIPLEOFSCENARIO PLANNINGISTHATITINVOLVESALEARNINGPROCESSBASEDONCOOPERATIONANDDISAGREEMENT BETWEENINDIVIDUALSLEADINGTOCO PRODUCINGANDINTERNALIZINGASHAREDMEANING ANDUNDERSTANDINGASWELLASARTICULATIONOFPOTENTIALDIFFERENCESINOPINION 3CHWARTZVANDER(EIJDEN )FDONEPROPERLYTHEPROCESSTENDSTO FORCETHECOLLABORATIVEANALYSISTOREDElNEORREFRAMEPOLITICALARGUMENTSBASEDON SHAREDUNDERSTANDINGOFCONTEXTUALINFORMATION4HEFOCUSONCONTEXTUALFACTORS IESOCIALECONOMICPOLITICALTECHNOLOGICALENVIRONMENTALANDLEGALFORCES AIMS TOPREVENTANDSUPERSEDESHORT TERMPRIVATEINTERESTSANDAMBITIONSOFINVOLVED PARTNERS)FSEARCHINGFORANUNDERSTANDINGOFHOWNEWPOLICIESFORENERGYSYSTEMS MAYBEFORMEDANDREALIZEDONEWOULDBEGUIDEDBYUSINGSCENARIOSASCONTEXTUAL FACTORSSUCHASGREENTECHNOLOGIESTHEGREENHOUSEEFFECTEMISSIONSREGULATION GLOBALTRANSPORTATIONANDTRAVELLINGSOCIETALVALUESANDGLOBALPOLITICSAROUND THE+YOTO0ROTOCOL4HISOUTSIDE INAPPROACHIMPROVESTHEGOVERNANCEPROCESS ASCONTEXTUALFACTORSAREBEYONDTHECONTROLOFEACHINDIVIDUALSTAKEHOLDERAND CONSIDERINGTHEMJOINTLYINTHISWAYAVOIDSMANYPSYCHOLOGICALTRAPSnSUCH ASOVERCONlDENCEANDTUNNELVISION3CHOEMAKER nINDECISION MAKING PROCESSES)NTHECASEOFTHE3K»NEREGIONINTHISCHAPTERTHEOUTSIDE INAPPROACH CAMEINTHEFORMOFPATIENTnORRATHERCUSTOMERnFOCUS &ORMANYPEOPLEADRAWBACKWHENUSINGSCENARIOSISTHATTHEYINCREASEANXIETY
SINCETHEYUNDERLINETHATTHEREARENOEASYANSWERSTOACONTENTIOUS2ITTELAND 7EBBER ORCOMPLICATED!CKOFF SITUATIONINATURBULENTCONTEXT 3INCESCENARIOSMAYNOTSINGLEOUTONE IDEALANDPREFERABLEPOLICYCREATING INSTEADALEARNINGPROCESSTHROUGHWHICHIMPROVEDPOLICY MAKINGMAYEMERGE THEYDOCAUSEANXIETY&ORPOLICYANALYSISANDDECISION MAKINGTHISANXIETYIS POSITIVEASITPROVIDESANOPPORTUNITYTOTESTDIFFERENTCONCLUSIONSANDCALLSFOR ACTIONINTHEPSYCHOLOGICALSAFETYTHATLONG TERMFUTURESPROVIDE3CENARIOSWILL HELPTHEPROCESSBYPROVIDINGRELEVANTNOVELCHALLENGINGCOHERENTANDPLAUSIBLE ALTERNATIVESTORIESOFHOWTHEFUTURECONTEXTMAYLOOK4HESESTORIESAREINTURN USEDTOINFORMGOVERNANCEWITHREGARDTOPOLICYANALYSISANDCURRENTDECISION MAKING )ARGUETHATFUTURE ORIENTEDSTAKEHOLDERENGAGEMENTMAYIMPROVEPOLITICAL
GOVERNANCESABILITYTORESPONDTO/STROMSP CALLFORSTUDIESTHAT@ADDRESS THEQUESTIONOFHOWTOENHANCETHECAPABILITIESOFTHOSE INVOLVEDTOCHANGE THECONSTRAININGRULESOFTHEGAMETOLEADTOOUTCOMESOTHERTHANREMORSELESS
TRAGEDIES)NSTEADOFBEINGSTUCKINAPRISONERSDILEMMAWHEREASUPERIORPOWER nWHETHERITISTHEDISTRICTATTORNEYORTHEPOLICY MAKERnSETSTHERULESOFTHEGAME MYCHAPTERAIMSTODESCRIBEAPOLICYAPPROACHINWHICHCONCERNEDINDIVIDUALS MAYACTUALLYCO CREATETHERULESOFTHEGAMEBEFOREORSIMULTANEOUSLY PLAYINGIT )NSTEADOFRULESSETBYDETACHEDPOLITICIANSANDINmUENTIALLOBBYINGGROUPSTHERE ISCOLLABORATIONBETWEENAMULTITUDEOFLARGEANDSMALLSTAKEHOLDERSWHOSETRULES ANDPLAYTHEGAMEINTHISWAYPOTENTIALLYAVOIDING/STROMS REMORSELESS TRAGEDIES 4OILLUSTRATEHOWAFUTURE ORIENTEDSTAKEHOLDER INTENSIVEAPPROACHMAYCHANGE
THESCENEINAHEAVILYPOLITICIZEDANDTRADITIONALINDUSTRY)NOWTURNTOTHECASE OFHEALTHCAREINSOUTHERN3WEDEN
$URINGTHELATESTHE3WEDISHHEALTHCARElELDWASINASTATEOFTURBULENCE DUE TO ITS INABILITY TO ADAPT TO CHANGES IN THEHIGHLYUNCERTAIN CONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENT!GOVERNMENTREPORTWARNEDTHATTHE3WEDISHHEALTHCARESYSTEM WOULDNOTMEETITSRESPONSIBILITIESWITHOUTSTRUCTURALRENEWAL3/5 BUT THESOLUTIONSTHATWERECALLEDFOREGNEWFORMSOFOWNERSHIPPROlT DRIVEN INCENTIVESANDINCREASEDCOMPETITION3/5 DIDNOTMATERIALIZE#OSTS FORHEALTHCAREIN3WEDENINCREASEDBYMORETHANPERCENTANNUALLYBETWEEN ANDWHILEPRODUCTIVITYDETERIORATED*šNSSONETAL WHICHWAS DEALTWITHTHROUGHINADEQUATERATIONALIZATIONANDDOWNSIZING4URBULENCEWAS SEEMINGLYDRIVENBYTHELACKOFSTRUCTURALRENEWALTHATHADBEENCALLEDFOR )NADDITIONSIGNIlCANTDEGREESOFINNOVATIONINFORINSTANCEINFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY)4 BIOTECHNOLOGYMEDICALEQUIPMENTANDPHARMACEUTICALSHAD OPENEDUPANEWSCENEOFOPPORTUNITIESANDDEMOGRAPHICCHANGESWITHALARGE PROPORTIONOFPEOPLEBORNDURINGTHESAPPROACHINGRETIREMENT4HESEFORCES TOGETHERHADCREATEDANEEDFORSYSTEMICTRANSFORMATION,EVINAND.ORMANN 4HEPOLITICALGOVERNANCEnORRATHERLACKTHEREOFnHADATTHESAMETIME NOTINSTILLEDANEFFECTIVEABILITYENABLINGTHElELDTOADAPTTOTHESECHANGESBYTHE MUCHNEEDEDSTRUCTURALRENEWALTHATHADBEENCALLEDFOR4HElELDSGOVERNANCE WASACTUALLYREINFORCINGITSOWNSTATEOFTURBULENCEANDWASINNEEDOFRENEWAL 4WOCONSULTANTS"ERT,EVINAND2ICHARD.ORMANNTHEREFOREDESIGNEDAND LAUNCHEDACOLLABORATIVEPROJECTFORASOUTHERNREGIONWITHIN3WEDENn3K»NE nTHATCOULDHELPTHElELDTOADAPT TO THETURBULENCETHATPOORGOVERNANCE ANDUNEXPECTEDCHANGEHADCREATED)NPOLITICALREFORMSATTHENATIONAL LEVELHADALSOGIVENMOREPOLITICAL FREEDOMTO THE REGION TOADDRESS ITOWN PROBLEMS-YROLEINRELATIONTOTHISWORKWASTOCO EDITABOOKONHEALTHCARE SYSTEMSINWHICHTHE3K»NECASEISACENTRALCOMPONENT.ORMANNAND!RVIDSSON 4HECLIENTSINTHISWORKCONSISTEDOFANUMBEROFPUBLICANDPRIVATEACTORS
SEEBELOW WHOSHAREDANINTERESTINAWELL FUNCTIONINGHEALTHCARESYSTEMIN 3K»NE 4HE3K»NEHEALTHCAREPROJECTSTARTEDOUTBYACCEPTINGTHATSYSTEMSRESULTFROM
ALONGHISTORYANDWITHTHEINSIGHTTHATIFONEWANTSTOCHALLENGETHECURRENT FEATURESOFTHESYSTEMITISDIFlCULTTODOITFROMWITHINTHESYSTEMSOWNPREMISES 4HESYSTEMCHARACTERISTICSINTHEMSELVESTENDTOREINFORCETHESTATUSQUOAND HINDERRADICALCHANGE)NORDERTOCOUNTERTHESEARTICULATEDSYSTEMICPROBLEMS THEPROJECTSTARTEDBYANALYSINGTHECONTEXTUALDRIVERSOFCHANGEONTHESYSTEM FROMAHISTORICPERSPECTIVETOENABLEANINSIGHTFULDIALOGUEONTHEPOSSIBLEFUTURE DEVELOPMENTOFTHEREGIONALHEALTHCARESYSTEM4HISPROCESSIDENTIlEDCRITICAL KEYUNCERTAINTIESANDCREATEDANOPPORTUNITYFORSCENARIOANALYSISMANIFESTED FORINSTANCEINDISCUSSIONSREGARDINGFUTUREHEALTHCARENEEDSBYPATIENTS4HE SCENARIOSDIALOGUEALSOCREATEDACONVERSATIONONWHICHCRITICALCOMPONENTSA WELL FUNCTIONINGFUTUREHEALTHCARESYSTEMHADTOINCORPORATE4HEANALYSESAND DISCUSSIONOFKEYUNCERTAINTIESINSCENARIOSTHUSBECAMEATOOLTHATFRAMEDAND PRODUCEDANIDEALIZEDDESIGNOFAREGIONALHEALTHCARESYSTEMIN3K»NE 4HEIDEALIZEDDESIGNDELIBERATELYDISREGARDEDTHEADMINISTRATIVEORGANIZATION
INPLACEATTHATTIME4HISMEANTFOREXAMPLETHATTHEPROJECTGROUPINTENTIONALLY DISREGARDEDCIRCUMSTANCESFUNDAMENTALTOSOMESUB SYSTEMSSUCHASDISTRIBUTION OFWORKBETWEENTHELAW MAKINGNATIONALSTATETHEREGIONCOUNTYCOUNCILWITH RESPONSIBILITYFORCAREOFTHEILLANDTHEMUNICIPALITIESWITHRESPONSIBILITYFOR HOMENURSINGANDOLD AGECARE!NOTHERSYNERGISTICOBJECTIVEWASTHATTHEWORKING PROCESSINITSELFCOUNTEREDRISKSOFALACKOFSTAKEHOLDERENGAGEMENTINEXISTING COLLABORATIVEPROCESSES 4HE3K»NEREGIONWASDURINGTHELATESRESPONSIBLEFORTHEHEALTHCARE
OFMILLION3WEDISHCITIZENSWHERERESPONSIBILITYFORDIFFERENTACTIVITIESSUCH ASOLDAGEHEALTHCAREANDlNANCINGWEREDISTRIBUTEDBETWEENLOCALREGIONALAND NATIONALAUTHORITIES4HEPROJECTCONSTITUTEDACOLLABORATIVEAPPROACHINCLUDING REPRESENTATIVESnPOLITICIANSADMINISTRATORSANDPROFESSIONALSnFROMMUNICIPALITIES ANDREGIONALANDNATIONALAUTHORITIESASWELLASTRADEUNIONSCOMPANIESANDOTHER ORGANIZATIONSINTHElELDOFHEALTHCARE0ARTICIPATINGORGANIZATIONSIETHEGROUP OFACTORSWHOJOINTLYSERVEDASCLIENTSANDCO PRODUCERSOFNEWINSIGHTS INCLUDED !STRA:ENECAAPHARMACEUTICALCOMPANY 0RAKTIKERTJØNST!"APRIVATEHEALTHCARE PROVIDER &šRSØKRINGSKASSAN3K»NEASTATE OWNEDLABOURANDHEALTHMARKET INSURANCECOMPANY 2EGION3K»NETHEREGIONALMUNICIPALITY +&"USINESS $EVELOPMENT(EALTHACOOPERATIVELYOWNEDFOODRETAILER +OMMUNFšRBUNDET 3K»NETHECOUNTYMUNICIPALITY ,ANDSTINGSFšRBUNDETTHEREGIONALMUNICIPALITY MANAGINGHEALTHCARE ,ØKARFšRBUNDETATRADEORGANIZATIONFORPHYSICIANS AND ,ØNSFšRSØKRINGAR3K»NEAPRIVATEINSURANCECOMPANY 4HEPARTICIPANTSWEREHEAVILYENGAGEDINTHESEPROJECTSFROMTHEIRINCEPTION
INSPRINGASWELLASDURINGTHEPOST PROJECTREALIZATIONOFTHESYSTEMICIDEAS WHICHISSTILLONGOINGASOF)TISFORINSTANCEMANIFESTEDINTHEAMBITIONOF
REALIZING@3K»NSK,IVSKRAFTTHE,IVING3TRENGTHOF3K»NE WHICHDESCRIBESHOW HEALTHCAREINTHEREGIONISREORGANIZEDAROUNDTHENEEDSOF@CUSTOMERSANDTHE ORGANIZATIONALSTRUCTUREOFEACHPARTICULARFORMOFCARE4HEIDEALIZEDDESIGNWAS DEVELOPEDINWITHATEN YEARPERSPECTIVEANDASYSTEMICLEVELWHICHMEANT THATITHADTOBEREALISTICALLYTRUEIN!TEN YEARTIMEFRAMEWASCHOSENSINCE POLITICALELECTIONSWEREHELDEVERYFOURTHYEARANDTHEPROJECTWANTEDTOSPANTWO ELECTIONCYCLES4HEQUALITYOFTHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNWASJUDGEDTOBEACCEPTABLE THROUGHCRITERIADEVELOPEDBY,EVINAND.ORMANN IE IN TERMSOF USEFULNESSACCURACYAVOIDANCEOFMINIMALCRITICALDENOMINATORSANDINSIGHT 4HEPROJECTSTRIVEDTOMAKETHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNACTIONABLEANDREALISTICINTERNALLY CONSISTENTANDREALISTICALLYDIFFERENTFROMTHECURRENTSTATEOFAFFAIRS)TWASMEANT TOBEINFERREDFROMDISAGREEMENTANDNOTBASEDONLYONANARROWCOMMONGROUND THATEVERYBODYCOULDAGREEUPONENABLINGPARTICIPANTSTODEDUCENEWINSIGHTS ONHEALTHCARESYSTEMSINORDERTOLESSENRELEVANTUNCERTAINTIESFORALLINVOLVED STAKEHOLDERS4HEOVERRIDINGAMBITIONWASTOPREVENTTHESYSTEMICDESIGNFROM BEINGSUBJECTTOHYPER TURBULENCE 4HEPROJECTDESIGNEDANDCONVENEDOPENDISCUSSIONSOFMANY IDEASAND
QUESTIONEDTAKEN FOR GRANTEDOPINIONSnWHICHINMANYCASESHADNOTBEFORE BEENARTICULATEDANDORHADREMAINEDSUBCONSCIOUS4HISAPPROACHPRODUCEDA SETOFCHARACTERISTICSTHATTHEPARTICIPANTSAGREEDSHOULDBEAFEATUREOFHEALTHCARE SYSTEMSSEE.ORMANNAND!RVIDSSON 4HECHARACTERISTICSDESCRIBETHE EXTENTTOWHICHTHEPARTICIPANTSnSTAKEHOLDERSINTHEHEALTHCARESYSTEMnMANAGED TOCHALLENGETHEIROWNPRECONCEIVEDIDEASOFHEALTHCARETHATPRIORTOTHEPROJECT WERETAKENFORGRANTED-ONETIZATIONOFHEALTHCAREWASFORINSTANCEALMOST IMPOSSIBLETODISCUSSDURINGTHESIN3WEDEN"UTTHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNPROJECT HELPEDEVERYONETOSEEITASINEVITABLE4HEPOSSIBILITYOFPRIVATEOWNERSHIPOF HEALTHCAREPROVIDERSWASALSOALLOFASUDDENPOSSIBLETODISCUSS.EVERTHELESS SOMECHARACTERISTICSSUCHASFAIRNESSANDOPENACCESSTOHEALTHCAREFORALLWERENOT DISCARDEDINSTEADPARTICIPANTSNOTEDTHATMONETIZATIONANDFAIRNESSWERENOTnA PRIORInINCOMPATIBLEBUTCOULDBECHARACTERISTICSTOBEHARMONIZEDWITHEACH OTHER!NOTHERCHARACTERISTICnLABOURMARKETREGULATIONFORPEOPLEOLDERTHAN nHADPREVIOUSLYNOTBEENSEENASANINTEGRATEDCOMPONENTOFTHEHEALTHCARE SYSTEMBUTTHEPARTICIPATINGACTORSNOWSTARTEDTOREGARDITASANIMPORTANTFACTOR INANEFFECTIVEHEALTHCARESYSTEM4HUSAMAJORCONTRIBUTIONOFTHEPROJECTWASITS EFFECTIVENESSINCO PRODUCINGNEWVALUESAMONGTHESTAKEHOLDERSVIS Í VISCRITICAL CONTEXTUALFACTORS 4HE COLLABORATIVE PROJECT ALSO FREED STAKEHOLDERS THINKING AND HELPED
PARTICIPANTSTOIDENTIFYANDRECOGNIZETWONEWCHARACTERISTICSTHATTHEYBELIEVED HADTOBECENTRALINANIDEALHEALTHCARESYSTEM&IRSTTHEMAINPRODUCERSOFHEALTH AREINDIVIDUALSTHEMSELVESnNOTPHYSICIANSANDNURSES!TTHATTIMEINDIVIDUALS REPRESENTEDASLEEPINGRESOURCEIN3K»NETHATCOULDMAKETHEENTIREHEALTHlELD MOREEFlCIENTIEBYUSINGLESSERAMOUNTSOFPUBLICRESOURCES ANDMOREEFFECTIVE
IEBYINCREASINGTHEHEALTHOFCITIZENSATTHESAMETIME 3ECONDASACUTECARE ELECTIVECAREANDBASICCAREDIFFERINTERMSOFWHICHROLESINDIVIDUALSAREABLETO PLAYWHERETHECAREIDEALLYISDONEWHOCANPERFORMTHECAREANDWHOSHOULD lNANCEITPARTICIPANTSFOUNDITADVISABLETOACKNOWLEDGETHESEDIFFERENCESIN ORDERTOENSUREEFFECTIVENESS4HEYREALIZEDTHATEACHFORMOFCARENEEDEDITS OWNPARTICULARFORMOFLOGICINORDERTOFUNCTIONEFlCIENTLY4HESEDIFFERENCES WEREIDENTIlEDINTHEDIALECTICANDCOLLABORATIVEFUTURE ORIENTEDWORKPROJECT THAT,EVINAND.ORMANN DESIGNEDANDFACILITATEDLEADINGTOTHEIDEALIZED DESIGNOFTHE3K»NEHEALTHCARElELD $ESPITETHEPOSITIVERESULTSONHOWTOIMPROVETHESYSTEMPARTICIPANTSWERE
FRUSTRATEDDURINGTHEWORK4HISCANBEEXPECTEDGIVENTHEAMBITIONTOCRITICALLY DEBATECONTEXTUALFACTORSTHATEARLIERHADBEENTAKENFORGRANTEDORIGNOREDAND MAYEVENBEINTERPRETEDASAPOSITIVESIGNOFALEARNINGSTRUGGLERATHERTHANAS SOMETHINGTOBEAVOIDED4HEIDEABEHINDTHEPROJECTTHAT,EVINAND.ORMANN DESIGNEDANDDEPLOYEDWASTOACKNOWLEDGEUNCERTAINTYINSTEADOFHIDING ANDIGNORINGIT)NMYEXPERIENCEANXIETYISPARTOFTHEGAMEWHENOBJECTIVES INCLUDECHALLENGINGWHATISTAKENFORGRANTEDANDSELDOMDISCUSSEDSOMETIMES EVENNOTARTICULATEDATALL 4HEAMBITIONOFSCENARIOANALYSISnINTHISCASEULTIMATELYMANIFESTEDINAN
IDEALIZEDDESIGNTHATCOULDBETTERADDRESSPLAUSIBLEFUTURECONTEXTUALCONDITIONS nWASNOTTOGETEXISTINGAUTHORIZEDINSTITUTIONSTOIMPLEMENTTHEDESIGNASSUCH 4HEMODELINSTEADPROVIDEDASYSTEMICFOUNDATIONFORFUTURECOLLABORATIVEWORK ENABLINGSTRATEGICCONVERSATIONVANDER(EIJDEN TOBECARRIEDOUTFROMA SYSTEMICPERSPECTIVEANDAHOLISTICVIEW/NEOFTHEMAINRESULTSWASTHEREFOREA NEWWAYOFSTRUCTURINGACOLLABORATIVELEARNINGPROCESSBEHINDPOLITICALGOVERNANCE WHERETHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNBECAMEATOOLTOSTIMULATEANDDEBATEIDEAS $URINGTHISCHANGEPROJECTTHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNATTEMPTEDTOPROVIDEAGUIDING
VISIONDEVELOPINGKNOWLEDGEABOUTTHEFUTUREINORDERTOPRODUCEEVENBETTER VISIONS!LOGICALNEXTSTEPONCETHEIDEALIZEDDESIGNHADBEENESTABLISHEDWAS TOIDENTIFYEXISTINGRESTRICTIONSBETWEENTHESYSTEMOFTHATTIMEANDTHEIDEALIZED DESIGNINORDERTOSEEWHICHCOULDBEOVERCOMEINORDERTOREVISETHEDESIGN ACCORDINGLY4HEREVISEDDESIGNTHENTURNEDINTOANAMBITIOUSBUTATTAINABLE MODELFORHEALTHCAREANDOLD AGECAREFORTHEYEAR)TBECAMEALONGGOAL ANDSTARTINGFROMTHISGOALAPROGRAMMEOFACTIONSWASTHENELABORATEDUPONAND IMPLEMENTED4HEWORKINTHE3K»NEREGIONHASMANIFESTEDITSELFINSEVERALWAYS INCLUDINGEFFORTSTOSTRUCTUREDIFFERENTTYPESOFHEALTHCAREAROUNDSPECIlCCARE LOGICSASWELLASEFFORTSTOMAKECITIZENSACTIVELYENGAGEDINTHECREATIONOFTHEIR OWNHEALTHSEEFOREXAMPLE.54%+ 4HE3K»NECASEILLUSTRATESTHEIMPORTANCEOFDESIGNGOVERNANCETOUNDERSTAND
HOWAFUTUREHEALTHCARESYSTEMAIMSTOPROVIDEVALUETOITSSTAKEHOLDERSAND TOEFFECTIVELYCHALLENGEWHATPREVIOUSLYWASTAKENFORGRANTED&URTHERMORE ASTHECASESHOWSGOVERNANCEDESIGNSTHATENSURETHESYSTEMISINVESTEDWITH
SELF DEVELOPINGANDSELF REGULATORYPROPERTIESASCERTAININGLONG TERMINNOVATION AND RECONFIGURATION CAPABILITIES ,EVIN AND.ORMANN IMPLIES THAT GOVERNANCEISSUBJECTEDTOCOMPETITIVEPRESSURES)NSUCHGOVERNANCEDESIGNSIT BECOMESPOSSIBLETOQUESTIONANDCHALLENGEGOVERNANCESTRUCTUREFUNCTIONING ANDEFFECTIVENESS4HEPROPOSEDIDEALIZEDDESIGNOFTHE3K»NEREGIONMANIFESTED ANIMPORTANTCHANGEINTHISDIRECTIONBYARGUINGTHATCAREPURCHASESSHOULDBE ALLOCATEDTOTHECITIZENSANDNOTASHADBEENTHECASEUNTILTHENTOMEDICAL EXPERTISEANDPUBLICADMINISTRATORS)NTERESTINGLYAPARADOXSEEMSTOBETHATTHE GOVERNANCEPRINCIPLESOFAlELDTHATREDUCESTURBULENCEMUSTENSURETHEIROWN SURVIVALBYALLOWINGANDSTIMULATINGPRESSUREONTHEMFROMOUTSIDETHATSYSTEM )FSUCHPRESSUREDOESNOTEXISTTHEGOVERNANCESYSTEMWILLAVOIDUNCERTAINTY PRETENDTHATITDOESNOTEXISTANDACTTOCO PRODUCEMOREOFITCAUSINGTHElELD INWHICHITISEMBEDDEDTOBECOMETURBULENT
)HAVESHOWNTHATTHEREAREINHERENTBIASESINSOCIALPROCESSESAIMINGTOGOVERN POLITICALSYSTEMSBYIMPLEMENTINGPOLICIESANDREGULATION4HISISESPECIALLYRISKY WHENFACINGATURBULENTSITUATIONTHATMAYTRANSFORMITSELFINTOHYPER TURBULENCE DUETOINAPPROPRIATEAPPROACHESOFITSPOLITICALGOVERNANCE)NORDERTOMINIMIZE THISRISK)SUGGESTTHATADIFFERENTMOREINCLUSIVEGOVERNANCESTANCEBASEDUPONA DESIGNFOCUSWHICHCOUNTERACTSANDAVOIDSSOMEOFTHETRAPSISWORTHDEPLOYING 4HEAPPROACH)SUGGESTRESTSONTWOSTEPS&IRSTPOLITICALGOVERNANCEISDESIGNED
TOINCLUDESTAKEHOLDERSANDTHEIRCOMPETENCESASWELLASTHEIRVESTEDINTERESTS 0ARADOXICALLYTHEEXCLUSIONOFAMULTITUDEOFSTAKEHOLDERSWILLINCREASETHERISK THATGOVERNANCEHOLDERSFOCUSONAPARTICULARVESTEDINTERESTSINCETHEPOTENTIAL FORASINGLESTAKEHOLDERTOMONOPOLISTICALLYINmUENCETHEINFORMATIONPROCESS INCREASES!SINCREASINGNUMBERSOFSTAKEHOLDERSAREINCLUDEDINTHEGOVERNANCE PROCESSMOREANDDIVERSEINFORMATIONWILLBEUSEDANDVESTEDINTERESTSWILL COUNTEREACHOTHERMOREEFFECTIVELY3ECONDAFUTURE ORIENTEDAPPROACHINCLUDED INGOVERNANCEDESIGNAPPEARSTOCONTRIBUTETOAVOIDINGTHERISKTHATVESTEDINTERESTS INTHESTATUSQUOWILLMONOPOLIZEANDHARMTHEGOVERNANCEPROCESS"YUSING LONG TERMPOSSIBILITIESANDUNDERSTANDINGDRIVERSFORCHANGEINTHECONTEXTUAL ENVIRONMENT)ARGUETHATAMOREEFFECTIVEGOVERNANCEMODELEADINGTOCHANGED SOCIETALVALUESANDBEHAVIOURISREALIZED 4OILLUSTRATETHIS)PROVIDETHECASEOFHOWASCENARIO BASEDPROJECTLEADING
TOANIDEALIZEDDESIGNOFAHEALTHCARESYSTEMIN3WEDENCHANGEDTHEPRINCIPLES UNDERLYINGPOLITICALGOVERNANCE)TLEDTHESTAKEHOLDERSTOOVERCOMEPSYCHOLOGICAL BARRIERSANDRELUCTANCETOCHANGETHATWASACTUALLYCO CREATINGTURBULENCE"Y ADOPTINGAFUTUREANALYSISMANIFESTEDINANIDEALIZEDDESIGNOFAHEALTHCARESYSTEM POLITICALGOVERNANCEDESIGNEDTOADDRESSTURBULENTlELDSCANENGAGEPARTICIPATIVE
STAKEHOLDERSASWELLASAFUTUREORIENTATIONOFTHELARGERSYSTEMTOMAKEAN EFFECTIVEDIFFERENCE
